Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
G. Aryee, M. Naim, C. Lalwani (2008)
Supply chain integration using a maturity scaleJournal of Manufacturing Technology Management, 19
Logistics scorecard (LSC) in Japan
Genevieve Jones (1967)
ForewordBritish Journal of Cancer, 101
G. Guizzardi, Nicola Guarino, P. Almeida (2016)
Business Process ManagementBusiness & Information Systems Engineering, 58
Jihyun Lee, Danhyung Lee, Sungwon Kang (2007)
An Overview of the Business Process Maturity Model (BPMM)
U. Kannengiesser (2008)
Subsuming the BPM Life Cycle in an Ontological Framework of Designing
R. Kaplan, D. Norton (2000)
The strategy-focused organizationStrategy & Leadership, 29
A. Propst (1996)
The New Economics: For Industry, Government, EducationTechnometrics, 38
Torbjørn Netland, Erlend Alfnes (2008)
A PRACTICAL TOOL FOR SUPPLY CHAIN IMPROVEMENT-EXPERIENCES WITH THE SUPPLY CHAIN MATURITY ASSESSMENT TEST ( SCMAT )
P. Petersen (1993)
The New Economics for Industry, Government, EducationAcademy of Management Perspectives, 7
J. CAMPBELLy, J. SANKARANz, yANZ Bank (2005)
An inductive framework for enhancing supply chain integrationInternational Journal of Production Research, 43
S. Sheard (2001)
Evolution of the Frameworks Quagmire
J. Brocke, M. Rosemann (2010)
Handbook on Business Process Management 1
M. Rosemann (2015)
The Service Portfolio of a BPM Center of Excellence
(2010)
EFQM/SPICE integrated model
(2000)
CGF CGF, Consumer Goods Forum (former GCI
Cmmi Team (2010)
CMMI for Development, Version 1.2
(2009)
Achieving the highest level of process culture maturity [online]. Available from: http://mysimpleprocesses
W. Burke, G. Litwin (1992)
A Causal Model of Organizational Performance and ChangeJournal of Management, 18
D. Mollenkopf, Peter Dapiran, G. Dapiran (2005)
The importance of developing logistics competencies: a study of Australian and New Zealand firmsInternational Journal of Logistics Research and Applications, 8
(2004)
Safety and security extensions for integrated capability maturity models [online]. Available from: http://www.faa.gov/ [Accessed 15
(2005)
CAM2 CAM-I, Consortium for Advanced ManagementInternational
W. Boswell, J. Boudreau (2001)
How leading companies create, measure and achieve strategic results through “line of sight”Management Decision, 39
M. Zairi (1997)
Business process management: a boundaryless approach to modern competitivenessBus. Process. Manag. J., 3
J. Pritchard, C. Armistead (1999)
Business process management - lessons from European businessBus. Process. Manag. J., 5
Towards process competence
T. Neubauer (2009)
An empirical study about the status of business process managementBus. Process. Manag. J., 15
(2004)
The BPM maturity model
Lei Chen, Chengfei Liu, Xiao Zhang, Shan Wang, Darijus Strasunskas, Stein Tomassen, Jinghai Rao, Wen-Syan Li, K. Candan, Dickson Chiu, Yi Zhuang, C. Ellis, Kwanghoon Kim (2009)
Advances in Web and Network Technologies, and Information Management, APWeb/WAIM 2009 International Workshops: WCMT 2009, RTBI 2009, DBIR-ENQOIR 2009, PAIS 2009, Suzhou, China, April 2-4, 2009, Revised Selected Papers, 5731
A. Maier, J. Moultrie, P. Clarkson (2009)
Developing maturity grids for assessing organisational capabilities: Practitioner guidance
(2008)
A practical application of supply chain management principles
M. Paulk (2004)
Surviving the Quagmire of Process Models, Integrated Models, and Standards
IDS BPM roadmap assessment
R. Hackney (2003)
Towards e-government business process changeBusiness Process Management Journal, 9
Jihyun Lee, Danhyung Lee, Sungwon Kang (2009)
vPMM: A Value Based Process Maturity Model
(2000)
The internet-enabled supply chain Achieving supply chain excellence through technology
R. Tapia, M. Daneva, P. Eck, R. Wieringa (2008)
Towards a business-IT aligned maturity model for collaborative networked organizations2008 12th Enterprise Distributed Object Computing Conference Workshops
W. Boswell, J. Bingham, Alexander Colvin (2006)
Aligning Employees Through Line of SightBusiness Horizons, 49
D. Schulz (1997)
What a wonderful world it could beQuality Progress, 30
Supply-chain council SCOR-mark survey
R. Silvestro, Charles Westley (2002)
Challenging the paradigm of the process enterprise : a case-study analysis of BPR implementationOmega-international Journal of Management Science, 30
Cmmi Team (2007)
CMMI for Acquisition, Version 1.2
Kevin McCormack, W. Johnson (2001)
Business Process Orientation: Gaining the E-Business Competitive Advantage
(2008)
Dimensions of business process change [online]. BPMInstitute. Available from: https://www.bpminstitute.org/uploads/media
Robert Gardner (2004)
The Process-Focused Organization: A Transition Strategy for Success
Michael Rohloff (2009)
Process Management Maturity Assessment
G. Aouad, R. Cooper, M. Kagioglou, J. Hinks, M. Sexton (1998)
A SYNCHRONISED PROCESS/IT MODEL TO SUPPORT THE CO- MATURATION OF PROCESSES AND IT IN THE CONSTRUCTION SECTOR.
(2008)
State of the business process management market 2008 [online]. Available from: http://www
(2007)
The IBM global business services 2007 Mainland China value chain study [online]. Available from: http://www-935.ibm.com/services/us/gbs/thoughtleadership/#Next
(2010)
BPM maturity check [online]. Available from: http://www.bpmmaturity. com
Shoshanah Cohen, Joseph Roussel (2005)
Strategic supply chain management : the five disciplines for top performance
(2004)
Mollenkopf and Dapiran 2005 NET Netland, Alfnes and Fauske SC maturity assessment test (SCMAT
P. Willaert, J. Bergh, Jurgen Willems, D. Deschoolmeester (2007)
The Process-Oriented Organisation: A Holistic View Developing a Framework for Business Process Orientation Maturity
Vaska Dimitrova, Jordanka Jovkova (2010)
A global supply chain framework
(2006)
Global supply chain benchmark report [online]. Available from: https:// www-935.ibm.com/services/us/igs/pdf/aberdeen-benchmark-report
G. Milligan, H. Romesburg (1984)
Cluster analysis for researchers
Michael Rohloff (2009)
Case Study and Maturity Model for Business Process Management Implementation
Rok Skrinjar, V. Bosilj-Vuksic, M. Stemberger (2008)
The impact of business process orientation on financial and non-financial performanceBus. Process. Manag. J., 14
Supply chain maturity monitor [online
Klara Palmberg (2009)
Exploring process management: are there any widespread models and definitions?The Tqm Journal, 21
Doe nu de online BPM-scan
Korrakot Yaibuathet, T. Enkawa, Sadami Suzuki (2008)
Influences of institutional environment toward the development of supply chain managementInternational Journal of Production Economics, 115
A. Borovik (2009)
The line of sight
G. Aouad, M. Kagioglou, R. Cooper, J. Hinks, M. Sexton (1999)
Technology management of IT in construction: a driver or an enabler?Logistics Information Management, 12
西口 敏宏 (1996)
Managing product development
Iker Soria, Juncal Alonso, Leire Orue-Echevarria, Mikel Vergara (2009)
Developing an enterprise collaboration maturity model: Research challenges and future directions2009 IEEE International Technology Management Conference (ICE)
D. Flarey (1994)
Reengineering the Corporation
The global scorecard
Gaby Doebeli, R. Fisher, R. Gapp, L. Sanzogni (2011)
Using BPM governance to align systems and practiceBus. Process. Manag. J., 17
(2010)
Available from: http://www.professor-scheer-bpm.com
(1980)
Discriminant analysis. California: Sage Publications
T. Simatupang, R. Sridharan (2005)
The collaboration index: a measure for supply chain collaborationInternational Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management, 35
T. McLaren (2006)
A Measurement Model for Web-enabled Supply Chain Integration
Tillmann Boehme (2009)
Supply Chain Integration: A Case-based Investigation of Status, Barriers, and Paths to Enhancement.
(2010)
Business motivation model, version 1.1 [online]. Available from: http://www. omg.org/ [Accessed 3
C. Poirier, M. Swink, F. Quinn (2010)
Ten traits of the best supply chainsSupply Chain Management Review, 14
(2007)
Supply chain management maturity Business process maturity: theory and application
A. Lockamy, Kevin McCormack (2004)
The development of a supply chain management process maturity model using the concepts of business process orientationSupply Chain Management, 9
C. Armistead, Simon Machin (1997)
Implications of business process management for operations managementInternational Journal of Operations & Production Management, 17
A. Scheer, M. Hoffmann (2015)
The Process of Business Process Management
John Jeston, J. Nelis (2006)
Business Process Management: Practical Guidelines to Successful Implementations
J. McGovern, S. Ambler, Michael Stevens, James Linn, Elias Jo, Vikas Sharan (2003)
A Practical Guide to Enterprise Architecture
Amy Looy, Manu Backer, G. Poels (2011)
Defining business process maturity. A journey towards excellenceTotal Quality Management & Business Excellence, 22
Alexander Colvin, W. Boswell (2007)
The Problem of Action and Interest Alignment: Beyond Job Requirements and Incentive CompensationHuman Resource Management Review, 17
(2009)
The GAIA supply chain sustainability maturity model [online]. Available from
Gartner EXP worldwide survey of more than 1,500 CIOs shows IT spending to be flat in
(2010)
Supply chain maturity self-assessment [online]. Available from: http://ayersconsulting
R. Handfield (2004)
How Mature Is your Supply Chain ?
Beyond process maturity to process competence
M. Muehlen, D. Ho (2005)
Risk Management in the BPM Lifecycle
R. Waterman, T. Peters, J. Phillips (1980)
Structure is not organizationBusiness Horizons, 23
T. Bruin, M. Rosemann (2007)
Using the Delphi Technique to Identify BPM Capability Areas
(2008)
Part 7: assessment of organizational maturity
P. Smart, H. Maddern, R. Maull (2009)
Understanding Business Process Management: Implications for Theory and PracticeInformation Systems & Economics eJournal
(2010)
How IT is managing new demands: McKinsey global survey results [online]. Available from: https://www.mckinseyquarterly.com
P. Fraser, C. Farrukh, M. Gregory (2003)
Managing product development collaborations—a process maturity approachProceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part B: Journal of Engineering Manufacture, 217
(1997)
How to stay flexible and elude fads
BPM market assessment survey
Narayan Ramasubbu, M. Krishnan, Prasad Kompalli (2005)
Leveraging global resources: a process maturity framework for managing distributed developmentIEEE Software, 22
T. Gulledge, Rainer Sommer (2002)
Business process management: public sector implicationsBus. Process. Manag. J., 8
M. Rosemann, T. Bruin (2004)
Application of a Holistic Model for Determining BPM Maturity
David Nave (2002)
How to compare six sigma, lean and the theory of constraintsQuality Progress, 35
P. Trkman (2010)
The critical success factors of business process managementInt. J. Inf. Manag., 30
M. Rosemann, J. Brocke (2015)
The Six Core Elements of Business Process Management
Richard Hull, Jan Mendling, Stefan Tai (2012)
Business Process ManagementInf. Syst., 37
Supa Waisayarat, Surapool Payomyam, S. Luangamornlert, P. Nilsook, Weerapong Kongsawas (2010)
A Causal Model of Organizational performance in Energy Sector: Stock Exchange of Thailand
FAA-iCMM
R. Lee, B. Dale (1998)
Business process management: a review and evaluationBus. Process. Manag. J., 4
(2003)
Part 2: performing an assessment
(1997)
Building supply chain communities [online
A. Magdaleno, C. Cappelli, F. Baião, F. Santoro, R. Araujo (2008)
Towards Collaboration Maturity in Business Processes: An Exploratory Study in Oil Production ProcessesInformation Systems Management, 25
Cmmi Team (2011)
CMMI for Services, Version 1.2
M. Stemberger, J. Jaklič (2007)
Towards E-government by business process change - A methodology for public sectorInt. J. Inf. Manag., 27
G. Stevens (1989)
Integrating the Supply ChainInternational Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management, 19
A. Atkinson, J. Waterhouse, R. Wells (1997)
A Stakeholder Approach to Strategic Performance MeasurementSloan Management Review, 38
M. Netjes, H. Reijers, Wil Aalst (2006)
Supporting the BPM life-cycle with FileNet
(2008)
Supply-chain operations reference-model. SCOR overview version 9.0 [online]. Available from: http://supply-chain.org/about/scor
M. Hammer (2007)
The process audit.Harvard business review, 85 4
Mary Lacity, M. Janson (1994)
Understanding Qualitative Data: A Framework of Text Analysis MethodsJ. Manag. Inf. Syst., 11
Paul Harmon (2004)
EVALUATING AN ORGANIZATIONS BUSINESS PROCESS MATURITY, 2
Narayan Ramasubbu, M. Krishnan (2005)
Leveraging Global Resources: A Process Maturity Framework for Managing Distributed Software Product Development
Ulrike Baumöl (2015)
Cultural Change in Process Management
The business process maturity model. A practical approach for identifying opportunities for optimization
Girish Punj, D. Stewart (1983)
Cluster Analysis in Marketing Research: Review and Suggestions for ApplicationJournal of Marketing Research, 20
R. Maull, D. Tranfield, W. Maull (2003)
Factors characterising the maturity of BPR programmesInternational Journal of Operations & Production Management, 23
(2010)
2010 BPM market assessment survey [online]. Available from: http://2010 stateofbpm.surveyconsole.com
J. Ayers (2003)
Supply Chain Project Management: A Structured Collaborative and Measurable Approach
(2010)
Het business maturity model [online]. Available from: http://www.deloitte.com/ view/nl_NL/nl/diensten/consulting
Standard CMMI appraisal method for process improvement (SCAMPI) A, version 1.2 [online
Peter Gyngell (1994)
Process Innovation: Reengineering Work through Information TechnologyEuropean Journal of Information Systems, 3
R. F. (1940)
Statistical Method from the Viewpoint of Quality ControlNature, 146
H. Harrington (2006)
Process management excellence
Pat Dowdle, Jerry Stevens, Bob McCarty, Dennis Daly (2005)
The process‐based management loopJournal of Corporate Accounting & Finance, 16
Sebastian Reiter, Glenn Stewart, C. Bruce, W. Bandara, M. Rosemann (2010)
The Phenomenon of Business Process Management: Practitioners' Emphasis
J. Brocke, Theresa Sinnl (2011)
Culture in business process management: a literature reviewBus. Process. Manag. J., 17
Josep Riverola (2001)
A general Approach to the Case Gathering Phase
M. Kohlbacher (2010)
The effects of process orientation: a literature reviewBus. Process. Manag. J., 16
K. Chang, Wei Wang, Lei Chen, C. Ellis, Ching-Hsien Hsu, A. Tsoi, Haixun Wang (2007)
Advances in Web and Network Technologies, and Information Management, APWeb/WAIM 2007 International Workshops: DBMAN 2007, WebETrends 2007, PAIS 2007 and ASWAN 2007, Huang Shan, China, June 16-18, 2007, Proceedings, 4537
(2006)
BPM maturity model identifies six phases for successful BPM adoption
P. Wognum, E. Faber (2002)
Infrastructures for collaboration in virtual organisationsInt. J. Netw. Virtual Organisations, 1
Anil Jain, M. Murty, P. Flynn (1999)
Data clustering: a reviewACM Comput. Surv., 31
Howard Smith, Peter Fingar (2003)
Business Process Management: The Third Wave
Welcome to 8 Omega v2.0 [online
James Kohnen (2003)
X-Engineering the Corporation: Reinventing Your Business in the Digital AgeQuality Management Journal, 10
(2008)
Business process transformation in the software industry [online]. Available from
The article elaborates on business process maturity, which indicates how well an organisation can perform based on its business processes, i.e. on its way of working. This topic is of paramount importance for managers who try to excel in today's competitive world. Hence, business process maturity is an emerging research field. However, no consensus exists on the capability areas (or skills) needed to excel. Moreover, their theoretical foundation and synergies with other fields are frequently neglected. To overcome this gap, our study presents a conceptual framework with six main capability areas and 17 sub areas. It draws on theories regarding the traditional business process lifecycle, which are supplemented by recognised organisation management theories. The comprehensiveness of this framework is validated by mapping 69 business process maturity models (BPMMs) to the identified capability areas, based on content analysis. Nonetheless, as a consensus neither exists among the collected BPMMs, a classification of different maturity types is proposed, based on cluster analysis and discriminant analysis. Consequently, the findings contribute to the grounding of business process literature. Possible future avenues are evaluating existing BPMMs, directing new BPMMs or investigating which combinations of capability areas (i.e. maturity types) contribute more to performance than others.
Enterprise Information Systems – Taylor & Francis
Published: Mar 4, 2014
Keywords: business process management; maturity; conceptual framework; capabilities; process improvement; excellence; business process reengineering; business process transformation
Read and print from thousands of top scholarly journals.
Already have an account? Log in
Bookmark this article. You can see your Bookmarks on your DeepDyve Library.
To save an article, log in first, or sign up for a DeepDyve account if you don’t already have one.
Copy and paste the desired citation format or use the link below to download a file formatted for EndNote
Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
All DeepDyve websites use cookies to improve your online experience. They were placed on your computer when you launched this website. You can change your cookie settings through your browser.