Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Perceptual constancy and perceptual representation

Perceptual constancy and perceptual representation Perceptual constancy has played a significant role in philosophy of perception. It figures in debates about direct realism, color ontology, and the minimal conditions for perceptual representation. Despite this, there is no general consensus about what constancy is. I argue that an adequate account of constancy must distinguish it from three distinct phenomena: mere sensory stability through proximal change, perceptual categorization of a distal dimension, and stability through irrelevant proximal change. Standard characterizations of constancy fall short in one or more of these respects. I develop an account of constancy that overcomes these problems. The account has two parts: an analysis of constancy mechanisms, and an analysis of the conditions under which a constancy capacity is exercised. I then employ this account to evaluate whether constancy is a necessary condition for perceptual representation, as some have conjectured. I argue that explanatory practice in perceptual psychology fails to support this view. Rather, it fits better with the weaker principle that representation requires specific tracking of a distal dimension. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Analytic Philosophy Wiley

Perceptual constancy and perceptual representation

Green, E. J.
Analytic Philosophy , Volume Early View – Mar 13, 2023
Download PDF
41 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/wiley/perceptual-constancy-and-perceptual-representation-I7SPHEifNk
Publisher
Wiley
Copyright
© 2023 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
ISSN
2153-9596
eISSN
2153-960X
DOI
10.1111/phib.12293
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Perceptual constancy has played a significant role in philosophy of perception. It figures in debates about direct realism, color ontology, and the minimal conditions for perceptual representation. Despite this, there is no general consensus about what constancy is. I argue that an adequate account of constancy must distinguish it from three distinct phenomena: mere sensory stability through proximal change, perceptual categorization of a distal dimension, and stability through irrelevant proximal change. Standard characterizations of constancy fall short in one or more of these respects. I develop an account of constancy that overcomes these problems. The account has two parts: an analysis of constancy mechanisms, and an analysis of the conditions under which a constancy capacity is exercised. I then employ this account to evaluate whether constancy is a necessary condition for perceptual representation, as some have conjectured. I argue that explanatory practice in perceptual psychology fails to support this view. Rather, it fits better with the weaker principle that representation requires specific tracking of a distal dimension.

Journal

Analytic Philosophy – Wiley

Published: Mar 13, 2023

References

  • Universals: An opinionated introduction
    Armstrong, D. M.
  • Seeing shape: Shape appearances and shape constancy
    Bennett, D. J.
  • A model for the neuronal substrate of dead reckoning and memory in arthropods: A comparative computational and behavioral study
    Bernardet, U.; Badia, S. B.; Verschure, P. F.
  • Recognizing depth‐rotated objects: Evidence and conditions for three‐dimensional viewpoint invariance
    Biederman, I.; Gerhardstein, P. C.
  • Psychologism and behaviorism
    Block, N.
  • Perception of three‐dimensional shape influences colour perception through mutual illumination
    Bloj, M. G.; Kersten, D.; Hurlbert, A. C.
  • The new visual neurosciences
    Brainard, D. H.; Radonjic, A.
  • Perceptual entitlement
    Burge, T.
  • Origins of objectivity
    Burge, T.
  • Origins of perception
    Burge, T.
  • Reply to Rescorla and Peacocke: Perceptual content in light of perceptual constancies and biological constraints
    Burge, T.
  • Topological structure in visual perception
    Chen, L.
  • Topological structure in the perception of apparent motion
    Chen, L.
  • The topological approach to perceptual organization
    Chen, L.
  • Outside color: Perceptual science and the puzzle of color in philosophy
    Chirimuuta, M.
  • Colour constancy as counterfactual
    Cohen, J.
  • Oxford handbook of philosophy of perception
    Cohen, J.
  • The paradox of colour constancy: Plotting the lower borders of perception
    Davies, W.
  • Discourse on method, optics, geometry, and meteorology
    Descartes, R.
  • Knowledge and the flow of information
    Dretske, F. I.
  • Orientation dependence in the recognition of familiar and novel views of three‐dimensional objects
    Edelman, S.; Bülthoff, H. H.
  • Individualism, computation, and perceptual content
    Egan, F.
  • Computational models: A modest role for content
    Egan, F.
  • Amodal volume completion and the thin building illusion
    Ekroll, V.; Mertens, K.; Wagemans, J.
  • The process of ‘taking‐into‐account’ in visual perception
    Epstein, W.
  • From sensory signals to modality‐independent conceptual representations: A probabilistic language of thought approach
    Erdogan, G.; Yildirim, I.; Jacobs, R. A.
  • Humans integrate visual and haptic information in a statistically optimal fashion
    Ernst, M. O.; Banks, M. S.
  • Shape perception in human and computer vision
    Feldman, J.; Singh, M.; Briscoe, E.; Froyen, V.; Kim, S.; Wilder, J.
  • The modularity of mind
    Fodor, J. A.
  • A theory of content
    Fodor, J. A.
  • Memory and the computational brain: Why cognitive science will transform neuroscience
    Gallistel, C. R.; King, A. P.
  • Burge's defense of perceptual content
    Ganson, T.; Bronner, B.; Kerr, A.
  • The ecological approach to visual perception
    Gibson, J. J.
  • Seeing black and white
    Gilchrist, A.
  • An anchoring theory of lightness perception
    Gilchrist, A.; Kossyfidis, C.; Bonato, F.; Agostini, T.; Cataliotti, J.; Li, X.; Spehar, B.; Annan, V.; Economou, E.
  • The validity of the size‐distance invariance hypothesis with cue reduction
    Gogel, W. C.
  • Perceptual learning
    Goldstone, R. L.
  • Categorical perception
    Goldstone, R. L.; Hendrickson, A. T.
  • Size constancy in infants: 4‐month‐olds' responses to physical versus retinal image size
    Granrud, C. E.
  • A layered view of shape perception
    Green, E. J.
  • On the perception of structure
    Green, E. J.
  • Use your illusion: Spatial functionalism, vision science, and the case against global skepticism
    Green, E. J.; Rabin, G. O.
  • Measuring causal specificity
    Griffiths, P. E.; Pocheville, A.; Calcott, B.; Stotz, K.; Kim, H.; Knight, R.
  • Perception and the origins of temporal representation
    Gross, S.
  • Cognitive penetration and attention
    Gross, S.
  • Perception and cognition
    Hatfield, G.
  • Color constancy and the complexity of color
    Hilbert, D.
  • Perceptual relativity
    Hill, C. S.
  • Dynamic binding in a neural network for shape recognition
    Hummel, J. E.; Biederman, I.
  • Scientific explanation
    Kitcher, P.
  • The perspectival character of perception
    Lande, K. J.
  • A computational model that recovers the 3D shape of an object from a single 2D retinal representation
    Li, Y.; Pizlo, Z.; Steinman, R. M.
  • Computing local surface orientation and shape from texture for curved surfaces
    Malik, J.; Rosenholtz, R.
  • Vision: A computational investigation into the human representation and processing of visual information
    Marr, D.
  • Perceiving the world
    Matthen, M.
  • Contour integration with colour and luminance contrast
    McIlhagga, W. H.; Mullen, K. T.
  • On a. D. Smith's constancy based defence of direct realism
    Meadows, P. J.
  • Direct perception
    Michaels, C. F.; Carello, C.
  • Biosemantics
    Millikan, R. G.
  • Mindless accuracy: On the ubiquity of content in nature
    Morgan, A.
  • A mark of the mental: In defense of informational Teleosemantics
    Neander, K.
  • Action in perception
    Noë, A.
  • The detection of surface curvatures defined by optical motion
    Norman, J. F.; Lappin, J. S.
  • Color constancy for an unseen surface
    Norman, L. J.; Akins, K.; Heywood, C. A.; Kentridge, R. W.
  • Burge on perception and sensation
    Olin, L.
  • The innocent eye: Why vision is not a cognitive process
    Orlandi, N.
  • Vision science: Photons to phenomenology
    Palmer, S. E.
  • Does unconscious perception really exist? Continuing the ASSC20 debate
    Peters, M. A.; Kentridge, R. W.; Phillips, I.; Block, N.
  • Unconscious perception reconsidered
    Phillips, I.
  • 3D shape: Its unique place in visual perception
    Pizlo, Z.
  • Making a machine that sees like us
    Pizlo, Z.; Li, Y.; Sawada, T.; Steinman, R. M.
  • Shape constancy from novel views
    Pizlo, Z.; Stevenson, A. K.
  • Perceptual constancies and perceptual modes of presentation
    Rescorla, M.
  • Perceptual co‐reference
    Rescorla, M.
  • The logic of perception
    Rock, I.
  • Causal theories of mental content
    Rupert, R. D.
  • Visual detection of symmetry of 3D shapes
    Sawada, T.
  • The situation‐dependency of perception
    Schellenberg, S.
  • Perceiving the world outside: How to solve the distality problem for informational teleosemantics
    Schulte, P.
  • The nature of perceptual constancies
    Schulte, P.
  • Representation in cognitive science
    Shea, N.
  • Biological origins of color categorization
    Skelton, A. E.; Catchpole, G.; Abbott, J. T.; Bosten, J. M.; Franklin, A.
  • The problem of perception
    Smith, A. D.
  • The visual perception of 3D shape
    Todd, J. T.
  • On the relative detectability of configural properties
    Todd, J. T.; Weismantel, E.; Kallie, C. S.
  • Increasing confidence in vergence as a cue to distance
    Tresilian, J. R.; Mon‐Williams, M.; Kelly, B. M.
  • Recognition by linear combinations of models
    Ullman, S.; Basri, R.
  • Sensory integration and the Unity of consciousness
    Dam, L. C. J.; Parise, C. V.; Ernst, M. O.
  • Distance perception within near visual space
    Viguier, A.; Clément, G.; Trotter, Y.
  • A century of gestalt psychology in visual perception, I: Perceptual grouping and figure‐ground organization
    Wagemans, J.; Elder, J. H.; Kubovy, M.; Palmer, S. E.; Peterson, M. A.; Singh, M.; Heydt, R.
  • Variations in the anisotropy and affine structure of visual space: A geometry of visibles with a third dimension
    Wagner, M.; Gambino, A. J.
  • Making things happen: A theory of causal explanation
    Woodward, J.
  • Causation in biology: Stability, specificity, and the choice of levels of explanation
    Woodward, J.
  • Topological change disturbs object continuity in attentive tracking
    Zhou, K.; Luo, H.; Zhou, T.; Zhuo, Y.; Chen, L.