Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
References for this paper are not available at this time. We will be adding them shortly, thank you for your patience.
338 ChinaReviewInternational:Vol.17,No.3,2010 RebeccaE.Karl.Mao Zedong and China in the Twentieth-Century World: A Concise History.Durham,NC:DukeUniversityPress,2010.xii,200pp. Paperback$21.95,isbn978-0-8223-4795-8. RebeccaE.Karlhaswrittenarich,deeplyanalytical,yethighlyaccessibleaccount ofMaoZedong,whohasdefiedbothdeificationanddemonizationandremained relevanttohistoriansandthegeneralreadingpublic.Whilebreakingnonew ground,KarltakesafreshapproachtoexplainingMao.ShecontextualizesMao andMaoismininternationalupheavalsofthelatenineteenthcenturyintothe twentiethcentury,whichinteractedwithChina'sownsearchforitsplaceinthe changingworld.ThisnewassessmentofMaocontainstwohundredpages,divided intotenchapters.Thenarrativefollowsachronologicalorder,startingwiththe birthofMaoin1893andendingwith"The2008BeijingOlympicsand Beyond"--thelastsectionheadinginthelastchapterofthebook. AsKarlherselfadmits,thisbookisforgeneralreadersmorethanforspecialists.Theinspirationbehindwritingthebookcamefromherencounterswith peopleovertheyearswhoare"genuinelyinterestedbutperhapsnotveryknowledgeableaboutChina"(China Beat,interviewwithJeffWasserstrom,June10, 2010).Indicationsthatitisnotwrittenforspecialistsincludespartanusageof footnotesandaveryfocusedyetlimitedbibliography.Asaresult,hernarrative readssmoothly,withoutmuchinterruptionfromfootnotes.Eachofthetenchaptersisfurtherdividedintosections,withheadingsthatclearlysignifythefocusof thefollowingcontent.Infact,whilethechaptertitlesgenerallyindicateaperiodin historyunderreview,suchas"GreatLeapandRestoration,19581965"ofchapter7, thesectionheadingsarechosentocaptureaspecificmomentofthatperiod.For example,inthechapter"TheCulturalRevolution:PoliticsinCommand,1966 1969,"thesectionheadingsguidethereaderthroughseveralkeymomentsduring thosechaoticyears--"ThePrelude:HaiRui,"markingthebeginningofthegatheringofclouds,and"TheNinthNationalCongressoftheChineseCommunist Party,"signifyingtheendofthemostluan(disorderlyandlawless)periodinthe CulturalRevolution. Aimingatabroaderreadingpublic,theauthordoesnotscaledownher analyticalrigorandreduceMaotoeitherthesimplecaricatureofatyrannical monsteroraniconiccharismaticleader.HerpurposeistoexamineandcomprehendMaoinavolatileandoftenhostileenvironment.MaoandMaoismcanonly beunderstoodinthehistoricalmomentinChinaandbeyondthatproducedMao thepersonandMaoismthephilosophy.Thebibliographyreflectsthiseffortofthe author.Itmaynotimpressaspecialistatfirstglance,butacarefulreadercan discernthatallthebooksinthebibliographyaredirectlyrelevanttotheauthoras shesuccessfullyinterweavesMao'slife,character,andideologywiththeimmediate andtranscendentalenvironmentthattumbledandforgedhim. © 2012 by University of Hawai`i Press Reviews 339 Itis,therefore,imperativetobringthereadertotheworldintowhichMao wasborn.Thebookopenswiththesection"FreeTrade,Opium,Tea,andSilver," clearlyatimewhenChinawasfastdisintegratinginthefaceofWesternintrusion andimposition.Itwasthebeginningofthe"centuryofhumiliation,"whichMao andmanypeopleofhisgenerationdevotedtheirlivestoending.Againstthis backdrop,MaowouldemergeastheleaderwhoultimatelyfoundedanindependentChinain1949,afterdecadesofstruggleagainsthisenemies,bothforeignand domestic,includingmanymembersfromwithinhisownparty. AsforMao'schildhoodandearlyadulthood,Karldoesnotoffermuchnew materialorfreshviewpoints.Maolefthomewhenhewassixteen,tooyoungand tooinexperiencedtohaveafirmideology.Atthesametime,Karlpointsoutthat hisruralrootswouldshapehispersonalhabitsthathewouldpurposefullymaintain"asanexpressionofpoliticalpurity"(p.8).Bytheendofchapter2,whenMao wastwenty-eightyearsofage,hehadtransformedfromaliberaltoaBolshevik Communist.Thistransformationtookplaceagainstafragmentedintellectual sceneinChinaintheearly1920s.DisillusionedwithhisyouthfulsearchforsolutionstoChina'sproblemsinanarchismandliberalism,MaoembracedtheBolsheviktotalrevolutionby1921.Hewouldbeoneofthetwelvedelegatesthatmetand officiallyfoundedtheChineseCommunistPartyinShanghai."TheformalfoundingoftheCCP[ChineseCommunistParty]wasatotallyunremarkableevent" (p. 18),butitwasaremarkablemilestoneinMao'slifeandinChina'sdestiny. Thenextthreechapterscontinuefrom1921through1949.Thesedecades wouldwitnessMao'stransformationfromadedicatedbutordinaryCommunist PartymembertothesupremeleaderoftheParty.Furthermore,hewouldalso createanideologynamedafterhim--"MaoZedongthought"--andacquirea statusnottobechallengedwithoutsevereandadverseconsequencesforthosewho daredtoconfronthispolicies.Thefirstshiftinhiscommitmentoccurredwhenhe was"exhausted,dispirited,andreadytotakeabreak"(p.27)inlate1924after followingtheParty'sstrategyofcollaboratingwiththeNationalistsandagitatingin urbanareaswithoutmuchsuccess.AsChinastruggledtoreunifyitself,thetwo majorpoliticalpartiesfoundthemselvesfurtherapartpoliticallyandideologically. Maowentthroughbeinganeffectiveanddedicatedlabororganizer,tobeing disillusioned;andbytheendof1924,hewasreadytotakeabreakfromParty work.InruralHunan,Maorediscoveredhisrevolutionaryinspiration,andfrom thistimeonward,Maowascommittedtomobilizingthepeasantryforthetriumph oftheChineseCommunistRevolution. BecauseofChiangKai-shek's"whiteterror,"theCommunistswereforcedto hideundergroundandtoescapefromthecities.ThecircumstanceallowedMaoto practicehisstrategyinthecountry.JinggangshanofferedMaotimeandspacefor tyingtogethertheelementsthatwouldsecurethefinalvictoryoftheCCPintwo decades--thegununderthecommandofthePartywhosestrengthwasfirmly basedonthemassesofthepeasantry.AlthoughMaoemergedasfirstamongthe 340 ChinaReviewInternational:Vol.17,No.3,2010 leadersoftheCommunistPartyduringtheLongMarch,heandhisfollowershad towaituntiltheysafelyarrivedinYenanforMaotocompletehistransformation, elaborateMaothought,andsecurehisleadershipoftheCCPand,soon,ofthe wholeofChinauntilhisdeath. Chapters6and7describetheMaoisterabeforetheCulturalRevolution.Ifhe committedthefirstpartofhislifetothemakingoftheRevolution,Maowould devotethelatterhalfofhislifetosustainingthespiritofthatRevolution.The authormakesagoodpointthat,inMao'smind,theCCP'svictoryoverthewhole ofChinadidnotmeantheendoftheRevolution;rather,itwas"partofdeepening thetransformationofthecreatingtheconditionsforequalityinsociety"(p.84). KarlidentifiestheenemyofMao'scontinuousandpermanentrevolution--Party bureaucracy.MaowouldtirelesslylaunchmassivecampaignsagainsttheParty, whichhehelpedestablishandstrengthen.NowthattheCCPruledoverChina, MaowouldgototheextentofdissolvingthePartyifhebelievedthatitbetrayed hisvisionofempoweringtheChinesepeopleintheirattempttochangetheir destiny.ThesechaptersprepareusfortheviolentbreakupbetweenMaoandhis formercomrades,whichwouldcomeintheformoftheCulturalRevolution. TheCulturalRevolutiontakesupthenexttwochapters.DefiningtheCultural Revolutioninthefirstsectionofchapter8,Karlconfrontsseveralexistingviewpoints.ShearguesthatMaodidnotwanttoseizestatepower;hewantedtouse statepowerinwagingtheRevolution.Shestatesthatitwasnotfearofdeathor desireforpersonalimmortalitythatpushedhimtolaunchtheCulturalRevolution;rather,itwashisconcernaboutthelongevityoftheChineseCommunist Revolution.KarlthinksthattheCulturalRevolutionwasnotanexpressionof religiosity,oramovementfollowedblindlybyapeoplewhoweretyrannizedinto it.Chaoticandmaddening,ithadloftygoals,oneofwhichwastoreconnect culturetorevolution,somethinginwhichMaopassionatelybelieved.ForMao,the wholepointoftheRevolutionwastocreatetheconditionsforthemassestoseek transformationoftheirlivesbythemselves(p.118). Inchapter9,theChineseCulturalRevolutionisnarratedagainsttheglobal upheavalscausedbybothanticolonialnationalisminAsia,Africa,andLatin America,andbydomesticradicalismallacrosstheworld.Mao'sCulturalRevolution,thoughhavinglostitsinitialtotallawlessness,racedforward,challengingthe existingnationalandinternationalordersandinspiringrevolutionsoutsideChina. However,intheend,theRevolutiondidnotfulfillitspotentialoftransforming Chinaandtheworld.Instead,Mao,hisbodyfailingfast,receivedNixoninBeijing, signalingtheendofthatdream. Theyear1976bodedillforthedyingleader.Therevolutionaryveteranswere passingawayinsuccession,startingwithZhouEnlaiinJanuary,thenDongBiwu inApril,andZhuDeinJuly.TherewasmassiveunrestthateruptedinApril, followedbytheTangshanearthquake,ahorrendousnaturaldisaster.DidMao Reviews 341 knowallthiswashappeningaroundhim?"Maolaydyinganddidnotwitnessthe finaldisintegrationofhisdreamsandlifework"(p.157). Chapter10brieflydescribesthelastthirtyyearsafterMao'sdeathandDeng's rise.Withthelastsectiononthe2008BeijingOlympics,Karlendsherbookon MaoZedongandChinanotingthattheOlympicsloganof"Oneworld,one dream"doesnotincludeMao'sdreamofsocialistrevolution.ButMaoisnot irrelevanttotoday'sleadersinChina.ForthenewgenerationoftheChinese Communistleaderstoclaimlegitimacyinthepost-Maoeraisatoncetorepudiate MaoismandtoretaintheimageandmemoryofMao. MaoemergesfromKarl'sproficientaccountasayoungmangrowingupinan erawhen"fundamentalglobaltransformationcouldbethought"(p.xi).Hedared tothinkanddaredtotry--tochallengeoldordersandtotransformChinaandthe world.MaofirmlybelievedinthetransformativepoweroftheCommunistmovement,andhewantedtheChinesepeopletobelieveitwithhim.Ironically,Mao's visionofa"newworldwithoutdominationorexploitation"(p.139)waspursued throughhisinsistenceofhisdominationofthecourseofaction,causingmuch violenceanddestruction,includinglives. ThebookfulfillsitspromiseofpresentingMaoinaglobalhistoricalcontext. ItsintendedaudiencewilllearnasufficientamountofChinesehistorythatcharacterizestheMaoera.Karlstrikesagoodbalancebetweenpresentinganoverall pictureofMao,Maoism,andMao'spoliciesandmorespecifickeymomentsof Mao'srevolutionandthehavocitcreated.WhileKarl'sbookismorethanasuperficialaccountofMaoandhisChina,thereisanabsenceofdepthofanalysiswith regardtoMao'scomplexinconsistencies,charisma,andutterbrutality.Forthe specialist,thereislittlenewtobegainedfromthebook,butitsvalueliesinprovidinganintricatestoryofMaoandChinaduringhiseratointerestedandintelligentgeneralreaders. YuShen Yu Shen is a professor of history at Indiana University Southeast, specializing in U.S.-China relations in the twentieth century. © 2012 by University of Hawai`i Press RichardKing,editor.Heroes of China's Great Leap Forward: Two Stories. Honolulu:UniversityofHawai`iPress,2010.133pp.Hardcover$35.00, isbn978-0-8248-3402-9.Paperback$15.00,isbn978-0-8248-3436-4.
China Review International – University of Hawai'I Press
Published: Jun 15, 2010
Read and print from thousands of top scholarly journals.
Already have an account? Log in
Bookmark this article. You can see your Bookmarks on your DeepDyve Library.
To save an article, log in first, or sign up for a DeepDyve account if you don’t already have one.
Copy and paste the desired citation format or use the link below to download a file formatted for EndNote
Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
All DeepDyve websites use cookies to improve your online experience. They were placed on your computer when you launched this website. You can change your cookie settings through your browser.