Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

“Young America” and the Anti-Emersonian Western: John Williams’s Butcher’s Crossing

“Young America” and the Anti-Emersonian Western: John Williams’s Butcher’s Crossing “Young America” and the Anti- Emersonian Western John Williams’s Butcher’s Crossing Anthony Hutchison In October 1870 Bret Harte published a review of Ralph Waldo Emerson’s latest essay collection Society and Solitude in Overland Monthly, the lively new San Francisco- based literary magazine already being lauded in the East for its “Far Western fl avor” and “Pacifi c freshness” (qtd. in Tarnoff 159). Overall, Harte was content to defer to the celebrated “Sage of Concord,” eff ectively using the occasion to endorse the idea of Emerson as an authentically national fi gure wholly worthy of the cultural esteem bestowed upon him by his fellow American citizens. “Th ere remains to Mr. Emerson, we think,” the piece concludes, “the praise of doing more than any other American thinker to voice the best philosophic conclusions of American life and experience” (387). Harte’s forerunning judgment nonetheless sounded a few more equivocal notes. Notably, given his own relatively recent success producing fi ction depicting the pioneer mining communities of California, Harte took issue with Emerson’s portrayal of the American West. Th is was presented in the “Civilization” chapter of Society and Solitude where the region is interpreted as a benign domain in which powerful http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Western American Literature The Western Literature Association

“Young America” and the Anti-Emersonian Western: John Williams’s Butcher’s Crossing

Western American Literature , Volume 55 (3) – Nov 23, 2020

Loading next page...
 
/lp/the-western-literature-association/young-america-and-the-anti-emersonian-western-john-williams-s-butcher-sP0o1cOA0c

References

References for this paper are not available at this time. We will be adding them shortly, thank you for your patience.

Publisher
The Western Literature Association
Copyright
Copyright © Western Literature Association
ISSN
1948-7142

Abstract

“Young America” and the Anti- Emersonian Western John Williams’s Butcher’s Crossing Anthony Hutchison In October 1870 Bret Harte published a review of Ralph Waldo Emerson’s latest essay collection Society and Solitude in Overland Monthly, the lively new San Francisco- based literary magazine already being lauded in the East for its “Far Western fl avor” and “Pacifi c freshness” (qtd. in Tarnoff 159). Overall, Harte was content to defer to the celebrated “Sage of Concord,” eff ectively using the occasion to endorse the idea of Emerson as an authentically national fi gure wholly worthy of the cultural esteem bestowed upon him by his fellow American citizens. “Th ere remains to Mr. Emerson, we think,” the piece concludes, “the praise of doing more than any other American thinker to voice the best philosophic conclusions of American life and experience” (387). Harte’s forerunning judgment nonetheless sounded a few more equivocal notes. Notably, given his own relatively recent success producing fi ction depicting the pioneer mining communities of California, Harte took issue with Emerson’s portrayal of the American West. Th is was presented in the “Civilization” chapter of Society and Solitude where the region is interpreted as a benign domain in which powerful

Journal

Western American LiteratureThe Western Literature Association

Published: Nov 23, 2020

There are no references for this article.