Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

The role of variability in the property listing task

The role of variability in the property listing task It is generally believed that concepts can be characterized by their properties (or features). When investigating concepts encoded in language, researchers often ask subjects to produce lists of properties that describe them (i.e., the Property Listing Task, PLT). These lists are accumulated to produce Conceptual Property Norms (CPNs). CPNs contain frequency distributions of properties for individual concepts. It is widely believed that these distributions represent the underlying semantic structure of those concepts. Here, instead of focusing on the underlying semantic structure, we aim at characterizing the PLT. An often disregarded aspect of the PLT is that individuals show intersubject variability (i.e., they produce only partially overlapping lists). In our study we use a mathematical analysis of this intersubject variability to guide our inquiry. To this end, we resort to a set of publicly available norms that contain information about the specific properties that were informed at the individual subject level. Our results suggest that when an individual is performing the PLT, he or she generates a list of properties that is a mixture of general and distinctive properties, such that there is a non-linear tendency to produce more general than distinctive properties. Furthermore, the low generality properties are precisely those that tend not to be repeated across lists, accounting in this manner for part of the intersubject variability. In consequence, any manipulation that may affect the mixture of general and distinctive properties in lists is bound to change intersubject variability. We discuss why these results are important for researchers using the PLT. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Behavior Research Methods Springer Journals

The role of variability in the property listing task

Download PDF
17 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/springer_journal/the-role-of-variability-in-the-property-listing-task-S774zx3bRq
Publisher
Springer Journals
Copyright
Copyright © 2017 by Psychonomic Society, Inc.
Subject
Psychology; Cognitive Psychology
eISSN
1554-3528
DOI
10.3758/s13428-017-0920-8
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

It is generally believed that concepts can be characterized by their properties (or features). When investigating concepts encoded in language, researchers often ask subjects to produce lists of properties that describe them (i.e., the Property Listing Task, PLT). These lists are accumulated to produce Conceptual Property Norms (CPNs). CPNs contain frequency distributions of properties for individual concepts. It is widely believed that these distributions represent the underlying semantic structure of those concepts. Here, instead of focusing on the underlying semantic structure, we aim at characterizing the PLT. An often disregarded aspect of the PLT is that individuals show intersubject variability (i.e., they produce only partially overlapping lists). In our study we use a mathematical analysis of this intersubject variability to guide our inquiry. To this end, we resort to a set of publicly available norms that contain information about the specific properties that were informed at the individual subject level. Our results suggest that when an individual is performing the PLT, he or she generates a list of properties that is a mixture of general and distinctive properties, such that there is a non-linear tendency to produce more general than distinctive properties. Furthermore, the low generality properties are precisely those that tend not to be repeated across lists, accounting in this manner for part of the intersubject variability. In consequence, any manipulation that may affect the mixture of general and distinctive properties in lists is bound to change intersubject variability. We discuss why these results are important for researchers using the PLT.

Journal

Behavior Research Methods – Springer Journals

Published: Jun 22, 2017

References

  • Categorization as probability density estimation
    Ashby, FG; Alfonso-Reese, LA
  • Concepts and conceptual development: Ecological and intellectual factors in categorization
    Barsalou, LW
  • Theories of memory
    Barsalou, LW
  • Moving beyond Kucera and Francis: A critical evaluation of current word frequency norms and the introduction of a new and improved word frequency measure for American English
    Brysbaert, M; New, B
  • When are concepts comparable across minds?
    Canessa, E; Chaigneau, SE
  • Conceptual agreement theory
    Chaigneau, SE; Canessa, E; Gaete, J
  • Quantitative modeling of the neural representation of objects: How semantic feature norms can account for fMRI activation
    Chang, KK; Mitchell, T; Just, MA
  • Ideology and discontent
    Converse, PE
  • Analyzing the factors underlying the structure and computation of the meaning of chipmunk, cherry, chisel, cheese, and cello (and many other such concrete nouns)
    Cree, GS; McRae, K
  • The Centre for Speech, Language and the Brain (CSLB) concept property norms
    Devereux, BJ; Tyler, LK; Geertzen, J; Randall, B
  • Translations from the philosophical writings of Gottlob Frege
    Frege, G
  • Toward an ecological theory of concepts
    Gabora, L; Rosch, E; Aerts, D
  • Concepts: Where subjectivism goes wrong
    Glock, HJ
  • Semantic richness effects in spoken word recognition: A lexical decision and semantic categorization megastudy
    Goh, WD; Yap, MJ; Lau, MC; Ng, MMR; Tan, L-C
  • Formal approaches in categorization
    Griffiths, TL; Sanborn, AN; Canini, KR; Navarro, DJ; Tenenbaum, JB
  • Shared features dominate semantic richness effects for concrete concepts
    Grondin, R; Lupker, SJ; McRae, K
  • Polymorphous concepts in semantic memory
    Hampton, JA
  • Multivariate data analysis
    Hair, J; Anderson, R; Tatham, R; Black, W
  • Memory loss in Alzheimer’s disease
    Jahn, H
  • Applied regression analysis and other multivariable methods
    Kleinbaum, DG; Kupper, LL; Muller, KE
  • Feature–feature causal relations and statistical co-occurrences in object concepts
    McNorgan, C; Kotack, RA; Meehan, DC; McRae, K
  • Semantic feature production norms for a large set of living and nonliving things
    McRae, K; Cree, GS; Seidenberg, MS; McNorgan, C
  • Further evidence for feature correlations in semantic memory
    McRae, K; Cree, GS; Westmacott, R; Sa, VR
  • The big book of concepts
    Murphy, GL
  • Alzheimer's disease and semantic deficits: A feature-listing study
    Perri, R; Zannino, G; Caltagirone, C; Carlesimo, GA
  • There are many ways to be rich: Effects of three measures of semantic richness on visual word recognition
    Pexman, PM; Hargreaves, IS; Siakaluk, PD; Bodner, GE; Pope, J
  • Number-of-features effects and semantic processing
    Pexman, PM; Holyk, GG; MonFils, MH
  • The impact of feed-back semantics in visual word recognition: Number-of-features effects in lexical decision and naming tasks
    Pexman, PM; Lupker, SJ; Hino, Y
  • Introduction to the research topic meaning in mind: Semantic richness effects in language processing
    Pexman, PM; Siakaluk, PD; Yap, MJ
  • Formal approaches in categorization
  • Categorization and cognitive science
    Prinz, JJ
  • The semantic richness of abstract concepts
    Recchia, G; Jones, MN
  • Cognitive Development and the acquisition of Language
    Rosch, E
  • Family resemblances: Studies in the internal structure of categories
    Rosch, E; Mervis, CB
  • Structural bases of typicality effects
    Rosch, E; Simpson, C; Miller, RS
  • The problems of philosophy
    Russell, B
  • Property generation reflects word association and situated simulation
    Santos, A; Chaigneau, SE; Simmons, WK; Barsalou, LW
  • The development of features in object concepts
    Schyns, PG; Goldstone, RL; Thibaut, JP
  • Tests for comparing elements of a correlation matrix
    Steiger, JH
  • Features of similarity
    Tversky, A
  • Subtlex-UK: A new and improved word frequency database for British English
    Heuven, WJB; Mandera, P; Keuleers, E; Brysbaert, M
  • Representing the meanings of object and action words: The featural and unitary semantic space hypothesis
    Vigliocco, G; Vinson, DP; Lewis, W; Garrett, MF
  • Perceptual simulation in conceptual combination: Evidence from property generation
    Wu, LL; Barsalou, LW