Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

An Inverse Problem: Trappers Drove Hares to Eat Lynx

An Inverse Problem: Trappers Drove Hares to Eat Lynx The Canadian lynx and snowshoe hare pelt data by the Hudson Bay Company did not fit the classical predator–prey theory. Rather than following the peak density of the hare, that of the lynx leads it, creating the hares-eat-lynx (HEL) paradox. Although trappers were suspected to play a role, no mathematical model has ever demonstrated the HEL effect. Here we show that the long-held assumption that the pelt number is a proxy of the wild populations is false and that when the data are modeled by the harvest rates by the trappers, the problem is finally resolved: both the HEL paradox and the classical theory are unified in our mechanistic hare-lynx-competitor-trapper (HLCT) model where competitor stands for all predators of the hares other than the lynx. The result is obtained by systematically fitting the data to various models using Newton’s inverse problem method. Main findings of this study include: the prey-eats-predator paradox in kills by an intraguild top-predator can occur if the top-predator prefers the predator to the prey; the benchmark HLCT model is more sensitive to all lynx-trapper interactions than to the respective hare-trapper interactions; the Hudson Bay Company’s hare pelt number maybe under-reported; and, the most intriguing of all, the trappers did not interfere in each other’s trapping activities. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Acta Biotheoretica Springer Journals

An Inverse Problem: Trappers Drove Hares to Eat Lynx

Deng, Bo
Acta Biotheoretica , Volume 66 (3) – May 30, 2018
Download PDF
30 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/springer_journal/an-inverse-problem-trappers-drove-hares-to-eat-lynx-eunltaSWue
Publisher
Springer Journals
Copyright
Copyright © 2018 by Springer Science+Business Media B.V., part of Springer Nature
Subject
Philosophy; Philosophy of Biology; Evolutionary Biology
ISSN
0001-5342
eISSN
1572-8358
DOI
10.1007/s10441-018-9333-z
pmid
29846858
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The Canadian lynx and snowshoe hare pelt data by the Hudson Bay Company did not fit the classical predator–prey theory. Rather than following the peak density of the hare, that of the lynx leads it, creating the hares-eat-lynx (HEL) paradox. Although trappers were suspected to play a role, no mathematical model has ever demonstrated the HEL effect. Here we show that the long-held assumption that the pelt number is a proxy of the wild populations is false and that when the data are modeled by the harvest rates by the trappers, the problem is finally resolved: both the HEL paradox and the classical theory are unified in our mechanistic hare-lynx-competitor-trapper (HLCT) model where competitor stands for all predators of the hares other than the lynx. The result is obtained by systematically fitting the data to various models using Newton’s inverse problem method. Main findings of this study include: the prey-eats-predator paradox in kills by an intraguild top-predator can occur if the top-predator prefers the predator to the prey; the benchmark HLCT model is more sensitive to all lynx-trapper interactions than to the respective hare-trapper interactions; the Hudson Bay Company’s hare pelt number maybe under-reported; and, the most intriguing of all, the trappers did not interfere in each other’s trapping activities.

Journal

Acta Biotheoretica – Springer Journals

Published: May 30, 2018

References

  • Wild mammals of North America: biology, management and economies
    Bittner, S; Rongstad, O
  • Complex dynamics and phase synchronization in spatially extended ecological systems
    Blasius, B; Huppert, A; Stone, L
  • Essential mathematical biology
    Britton, NF
  • A statistical analysis of the 10-year cycle in Canada
    Bulmer, MG
  • Are indirect measures of abundance a useful index of population density? The case of red grouse harvesting records
    Cattadori, IM; Haydon, DT; Thirgood, SJ; Hudson, PJ
  • The Time Invariance Principle, the absence of ecological chaos, and a fundamental pitfall of discrete modeling
    Deng, B
  • Can discrete modelers work without the TIP?
    Deng, B
  • From energy gradient and natural selection to biodiversity and stability of ecosystems
    Deng, B
  • The ten-year cycle in numbers of the lynx in Canada
    Elton, C; Nicholson, M
  • Cycles in Canadian lynx
    Finerty, JP
  • Bifurcations and chaos in ecology: lynx returns revisited
    Gamarra, JGP; Solé, RV
  • Do hares eat lynx?
    Gilpin, ME
  • An assessment of several of the historically most influential theoretical-models used in ecology and of the data provided in their support
    Hall, CAS
  • Small-rodent dynamics and predation
    Hanski, I; Henttonen, H; Korpimäki, E; Oksanen, L; Turchin, P
  • The conservation of the wild life of Canada
    Hewitt, CG
  • Some characteristics of simple types of predation and parasitism
    Holling, CS
  • Experimental studies on predation: dispersion factors and predator–prey oscillations
    Huffaker, CB
  • Ecology and the evolution of communities
    Hutchinson, GE
  • Wildlife’s ten-year cycle
    Keith, LB
  • The geometry of a population cycle: a mechanistic model of snowshoe hare demography
    King, AA; Schaffer, WM
  • Impact of food and predation on the showshoe hare cycle
    Krebs, CJ; Boutin, S; Boonstra, R; Sinclair, ARE; Smith, NNM; Dale, MRT; Martin, K; Turkington, R
  • What drives the 10-year cycle of snowshoe hares?
    Krebs, CJ; Boonstra, R; Boutin, S; Sinclair, ARE
  • Ecological stability
    Lawton, JH; Beddington, JR; Bonser, R
  • Some mathematical problems in biology
    Leigh, ER
  • Applied mathematics
    Logan, D
  • Elements of physical biology
    Lotka, AJ
  • Fluctuation in the number of the varying hare
    MacLulich, DA
  • Stability and complexity in model ecosystem
    May, RM
  • The functional response of predators
    Murdoch, WW
  • Functional responses of coyotes and lynx to the snowshoe hare cycle
    O’Donoghue, M; Boutin, S; Krebs, CJ; Zuleta, G; Murray, DL; Hofer, EJ
  • Fundamentals of ecology
    Odum, EP; Barrett, GW
  • The numerical response of great horned owls to the snowshoe hare cycle: consequences of non-territorial ‘floaters’ on demography
    Rohner, C
  • Graphical representation and stability conditions of predator–prey interactions
    Rosenzweig, ML; MacArthur, RH
  • Reproductive potential and sex ratios of snowshoe hares in northern Alberta
    Rowan, W; Keith, LB
  • Analytical population dynamics
    Royama, T
  • Nonlinear optimization
    Ruszczynski, AP
  • Stretching and folding in lynx fur returns—evidence for a strange attractor
    Schaffer, WM
  • Population regulation in snowshoe hare and Canadian lynx: asymmetric food web configurations between hare and lynx
    Stenseth, NC; Falck, W; Bjørnstad, ON; Krebs, CJ
  • From patterns to processes: Phase and density dependencies in the Canadian lynx cycle
    Stenseth, NC; Falck, W; Chan, K-S; Bjørnstad, ON; O’Donoghue, M; Tong, H; Boonstra, R; Boutin, S; Krebs, CJ; Yoccoz, NG
  • Phase- and density-dependent population dynamics in norwegian lemmings: interaction between deterministic and stochastic processes
    Stenseth, NC; Chan, K-S; Framstad, E; Tong, H
  • Chaotic oscillations and cycles in multi-trophic ecological systems
    Stone, L; He, D
  • Interlinking hare and lynx dynamics using a century’s worth of annual data
    Vik, JO; Brinch, CN; Boutin, S; Stenseth, N
  • Fluactuations in the abundance of species, considered mathematically
    Volterra, V
  • Hares, lynx, and trappers
    Weinstein, MS
  • Canadian fur bearer cycles and Cree-Ojibwa hunting and trapping practices
    Winterhalder, BP
  • Factors affecting hare-lynx dynamics in the classic time series of the Hudson Bay Company, Canada
    Zhang, ZB; Tao, Y; Li, ZQ