Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

The Limits of Institutions and the Reliance on Heuristics during the COVID-19 Pandemic

The Limits of Institutions and the Reliance on Heuristics during the COVID-19 Pandemic Leadership matters, but even more so in the midst of a crisis, where institutional mechanisms may be unequipped to deal with fast-moving circumstances. During such times, leaders are also prone to satisficing and relying on heuristics in order to come to decisions. This paper surveys the use of political heuristics and asserts that their use is directly proportional to the abilities of institutions; where institutions have no formal mechanisms to deal with a crisis, heuristics are relied on more heavily. In such a situation, policies tend to be more extreme than otherwise. Using the COVID-19 pandemic as the background, and in particular the decision to enter into a lockdown of varying degrees, this paper examines the use of heuristics by leaders during the crisis. Combining a case study approach with an empirical exercise, I show that institutional mechanisms were important for determining the response to the coronavirus as the pandemic began. However, once the full extent of the crisis was apparent, the attributes of leaders—relying on their pre-formed heuristics and playing out according to their ideologies, background, and experience—played a much more important role in determining the lockdown policy in a particular nation. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Applied Social Science SAGE

The Limits of Institutions and the Reliance on Heuristics during the COVID-19 Pandemic

Hartwell, Christopher A.
Journal of Applied Social Science , Volume 16 (2): 23 – Jun 1, 2022
Download PDF
23 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/sage/the-limits-of-institutions-and-the-reliance-on-heuristics-during-the-sbkKPTiDap
Publisher
SAGE
Copyright
© The Author(s) 2022
ISSN
1936-7244
eISSN
1937-0245
DOI
10.1177/19367244221077410
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Leadership matters, but even more so in the midst of a crisis, where institutional mechanisms may be unequipped to deal with fast-moving circumstances. During such times, leaders are also prone to satisficing and relying on heuristics in order to come to decisions. This paper surveys the use of political heuristics and asserts that their use is directly proportional to the abilities of institutions; where institutions have no formal mechanisms to deal with a crisis, heuristics are relied on more heavily. In such a situation, policies tend to be more extreme than otherwise. Using the COVID-19 pandemic as the background, and in particular the decision to enter into a lockdown of varying degrees, this paper examines the use of heuristics by leaders during the crisis. Combining a case study approach with an empirical exercise, I show that institutional mechanisms were important for determining the response to the coronavirus as the pandemic began. However, once the full extent of the crisis was apparent, the attributes of leaders—relying on their pre-formed heuristics and playing out according to their ideologies, background, and experience—played a much more important role in determining the lockdown policy in a particular nation.

Journal

Journal of Applied Social Science – SAGE

Published: Jun 1, 2022

Keywords: COVID-19; heuristics; lockdown; institutions

References

  • Decisive Leadership Is a Necessity in the COVID-19 Response
    Al Saidi, A. M. O.; Nur, F. A.; Al-Mandhari, A. S.; El Rabbat, M.; Hafeez, A.; Abubakar, A.
  • Taming Deep Uncertainty: The Potential of Pragmatist Principles for Understanding and Improving Strategic Crisis Management
    Ansell, C.; Boin, A.
  • Heuristics as Adaptive Decision Strategies in Management
    Artinger, F.; Petersen, M.; Gigerenzer, G.; Weibler, J.
  • A Brief History of the Cuomo-de Blasio Feud
    Barkan, R.
  • Managerial Decision Making in Customer Management: Adaptive, Fast and Frugal?
    Bauer, J. C.; Schmitt, P.; Morwitz, V. G.; Winer, R. S.
  • Age Effects and Heuristics in Decision Making
    Besedeš, T.; Deck, C.; Sarangi, S.; Shor, M.
  • Leadership Style, Crisis Response and Blame Management: The Case of Hurricane Katrina
    Boin, A.; Hart, P. T.; McConnell, A.; Preston, T.
  • Designing Resilient Institutions for Transboundary Crisis Management: A Time for Public Administration
    Boin, A.; Lodge, M.
  • The Danger of Inflating Expectations of Macroeconomic Stability: Heuristic Switching in an Overlapping-generations Monetary Model
    Brazier, A.; Harrison, R.; King, M.; Yates, T.
  • Challenging Some Common Beliefs: Empirical Work within the Adaptive Toolbox Metaphor
    Bröder, A.; Newell, B. R.
  • The Availability Heuristic, Political Leaders, and Decision Making
    Cohen, M.; Thompson, W. R.
  • Determinants and Effects of Health Policy
    Correa, H.; Namkoong, K.
  • Altered States: Explaining Domestic Institutional Change
    Cortell, A. P.; Peterson, S.
  • Gender Differences in Preferences
    Croson, R.; Gneezy, U.
  • Interview by J. Scarborough
    de Blasio, W
  • Rational Heuristics? Expectations and Behaviors in Evolving Economies with Heterogeneous Interacting Agents
    Dosi, G.; Napoletano, M.; Roventini, A.; Stiglitz, J. E.; Treibich, T.
  • Crisis Management
    Dyson, S. B.; t’Hart, P.; Huddy, L.; Sears, D. O.; Levy, J. S.
  • Misrule of Experts? The Financial Crisis as Elite Debacle
    Engelen, E.; Ertürk, I.; Froud, J.; Johal, S.; Leaver, A.; Moran, M.; Williams, K.
  • Intuition and Reasoning: A Dual-process Perspective
    Evans, J. S. B.
  • Does Gender Matter for Political Leadership? The Case of US Mayors
    Ferreira, F.; Gyourko, J.
  • Crisis Decision-making in Finland: Cognition, Institutions and Rationality
    Forsberg, T.; Pursiainen, C.
  • How Good Are Fast and Frugal Heuristics?
    Gigerenzer, G.; Czerlinski, J.; Martignon, L.; Shanteau, J.; Mellers, B. A.; Schum, D. A.
  • Reasoning the Fast and Frugal Way: Models of Bounded Rationality
    Gigerenzer, G.; Goldstein, D. G.
  • Postscript: Fast and Frugal Heuristics
    Gigerenzer, G.; Hoffrage, U.; Goldstein, D. G.
  • How Delays and Unheeded Warnings Hindered New York’s Virus Fight
    Goodman, J. D.
  • Gender Differences in How Physicians Access and Process Information
    Gotlieb, R.; Abitbol, J.; How, J. A.; Ben-Brith, I.; Abenhaim, H. A.; Lau, S. K.; Basik, M.; Rosberger, Z.; Geva, N.; Gotlieb, W. H.; Mintz, A.
  • A Preference for War: How Fairness and Rhetoric Influence Leadership Incentives in Crises
    Gottfried, M. S.; Trager, R. F.
  • Heuristics, Biases, and the Regulation of Risk
    Gowda, R.
  • Applied Decision Making with Fast-and-frugal Heuristics
    Hafenbrädl, S.; Waeger, D.; Marewski, J. N.; Gigerenzer, G.
  • The Cognitive Revolution and the Political Psychology of Elite Decision Making
    Hafner-Burton, E. M.; Hughes, D. A.; Victor, D. G.
  • Variation in Government Responses to COVID-19
    Hale, T.; Petherick, A.; Phillips, T.; Webster, S.
  • De Blasio doubles down on support of Black Lives Matter protests in NYC
    Hicks, N.; Campanile, J.
  • Reconsidering ‘Evidence’ for Fast-and-frugal Heuristics
    Hilbig, B. E.
  • Order Effects in Belief Updating: The Belief-adjustment Model
    Hogarth, R. M.; Einhorn, H. J.
  • Heuristic and Linear Models of Judgment: Matching Rules and Environments
    Hogarth, R. M.; Karelaia, N.
  • Does Culture Matter Social Distancing under the COVID-19 Pandemic?
    Huynh, T. L. D.
  • Persuasive Power Concerning COVID-19 Employed by Premier Imran Khan: A Socio-political Discourse Analysis
    Iqbal, Z.; Aslam, M. Z.; Aslam, T.; Ashraf, R.; Kashif, M.; Nasir, H.
  • Gender and Political Leadership in a Time of COVID
    Johnson, C.; Williams, B.
  • Effort and Accuracy in Choice
    Johnson, E. J.; Payne, J. W.
  • Ideology, Motivated Reasoning, and Cognitive Reflection: An Experimental Study
    Kahan, D. M.
  • Opening the Window for Reform: Mandates, Crises, and Extraordinary Policymaking
    Keeler, J. T.
  • German Parliamentary Party Groups in Europeanised Policymaking: Awakening from the Sleep? Institutions and Heuristics as MPs’ Resources
    Kropp, S.
  • The Illusion of Control
    Langer, E. J.
  • Understanding EU Crisis Decision-making: The Case of Chechnya and the Finnish Presidency
    Lintonen, R.
  • Ecological Rationality: Fast-and-frugal Heuristics for Managerial Decision Making under Uncertainty
    Luan, S.; Reb, J.; Gigerenzer, G.
  • Fast and Frugal Crisis Management: An Analysis of Rule-based Judgment and Choice during Water Contamination Events
    MacGillivray, B. H.
  • Decision Making and Uncertainty: The Role of Heuristics and Experience in Assessing a Politically Hazardous Environment
    Maitland, E.; Sammartino, A.
  • Heterogeneous Expectations in Monetary DSGE Models
    Massaro, D.
  • Lesson-drawing from New Zealand and Covid-19: The Need for Anticipatory Policy Making
    Mazey, S.; Richardson, J.
  • The Limitations of Heuristics for Political Elites
    Miler, K. C.
  • The Noncompensatory Principle of Coalition Formation
    Mintz, A.
  • How Do Leaders Make Decisions? A Poliheuristic Perspective
    Mintz, A.
  • Public Affairs in a Time of Coronavirus
    Moss, D.; Harris, P.
  • Heuristics Are Tools for Uncertainty
    Mousavi, S.; Gigerenzer, G.
  • Politics, Welfare Regimes, and Population Health: Controversies and Evidence
    Muntaner, C.; Borrell, C.; Ng, E.; Chung, H.; Espelt, A.; Rodriguez-Sanz, M.; Benach, J.; O’Campo, P.
  • Hypothesis-consistent Testing and Semantic Priming in the Anchoring Paradigm: A Selective Accessibility Model
    Mussweiler, T.; Strack, F.
  • Do Female and Male Entrepreneurs Differ in Their Proneness to Heuristics and Biases?
    Nouri, P.; AhmadiKafeshani, A.
  • Transcript: Mayor de Blasio Holds Media Availability
  • Transcript: Mayor de Blasio Holds Media Availability
  • Transcript: Mayor de Blasio Holds Media Availability on COVID-19
  • Politics and Population Health: Testing the Impact of Electoral Democracy
    Patterson, A. C.; Veenstra, G.
  • Differential Effects of Intervention Timing on COVID-19 Spread in the United States
    Pei, S.; Kandula, S.; Shaman, J.
  • Evolutionary Political Psychology: On the Origin and Structure of Heuristics and Biases in Politics
    Petersen, M. B.
  • When Heuristics Go Bad: Citizens’ Misevaluations of Campaign Pledge Fulfilment
    Pétry, F.; Duval, D.
  • Bill de Blasio Mandates Transgender Access to NYC Bathrooms
    Richardson, B.
  • Invariants of Human Behavior
    Simon, H. A.
  • NYC COVID-19 Contact Tracers Not Asking about George Floyd Protest Participation, Despite Fears of New Virus Wave
    Smith, G. B.
  • Reasoning Chains: Causal Models of Policy Reasoning in Mass Publics
    Sniderman, P. M.; Hagen, M. G.; Tetlock, P. E.; Brady, H. E.
  • Reactions to Terror Attacks: A Heuristic Model
    Sniderman, P. M.; Petersen, M. B.; Slothuus, R.; Stubager, R.; Petrov, P.
  • Recent Developments in the Experimental Investigation of the Illusion of Control. A Meta-analytic Review
    Stefan, S.; David, D.
  • Comparing and Assessing Gender Effects in Political Leadership
    Stevens, A.; Helms, L.
  • Politicians, the Representativeness Heuristic and Decision-making Biases
    Stolwijk, S.; Vis, B.
  • The Effect of Myopia and Loss Aversion on Risk Taking: An Experimental Test
    Thaler, R. H.; Tversky, A.; Kahneman, D.; Schwartz, A.
  • A Social Psychological Approach to Enduring Rivalries
    Thies, C. G.
  • How Do We Judge Personal Control? Unconfounding Contingency and Reinforcement in Control Judgments
    Thompson, S. C.; Nierman, A.; Schlehofer, M. M.; Carter, E.; Bovin, M. J.; Wurzman, L.; Tauber, Peter; Trifskin, Sharone; Marks, Peter; Sumner, Jennifer; Jackson, Ashley; Jackson, A.
  • Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases
    Tversky, A.; Kahneman, D.
  • National Identity Predicts Public Health Support during a Global Pandemic: RESULTS from 67 Nations
    van Bavel, J. J.; Cichocka, A.; Capraro, V.; Sjåstad, H.; Nezlek, J. B.; Alfano, M.; Azevedo, Flavio; Cislak, Aleksandra; Lockwood, Patricia; Ross, Robert M.; Agadullina, Elena; Apps, Matthew A. J.; Aruta, John Jamir Benzon R.; Bor, Alexander; Crabtree, Charles; Cunningham, William A.; De Koustav Elbaek, Christian T.; Ejaz, Waqas; Findor, Andrej; Gjoneska, Biljana; Horiuchi, Yusaku; Huynh, Toan Luu Duc; Ibanez, Agustin; Israelashvili, Jacob; Jasko, Katarzyna; Kantorowicz, Jaroslaw; Kantorowicz-Reznichenko, Elena; Krouwel, André; Laakasuo, Michael; Lamm, Claus; Leygue, Caroline; Mansoor, Mohammad Sabbir; Mayiwar, Lewend; Mazepus, Honorata; McHugh, Cillian; Mitkidis, Panagiotis; Olsson, Andreas; Otterbring, Tobias; Perry, Anat; Packer, Dominic; Petersen, Michael Bang; Puthillam, Arathy; Rothmund, Tobias; TEWARI, SHRUTI; Tsakiris, Manos; Tung, Hans; Yucel, Meltem; Vanags, Edmunds; Vlasceanu, Madalina; Antazo, Benedict G.; Barbosa, Sergio; Bastian, Brock; Bilancini, Ennio; Bogatyreva, Natalia; Boncinelli, Leonardo; Booth, Jonathan E.; Borau, Sylvie; Buchel, Ondrej; Carvalho, Chrissie Ferreira de; Celadin, Tatiana; Cerami, Chiara; Cian, Luca; Crespi, Chiara; Cutler, Jo; Delouvée, Sylvain; Dezecache, Guillaume; Paolo, Roberto Di; Dulleck, Uwe; Etienne, Tom W.; Farkhari, Fahima; Fugelsang, Jonathan Albert; Gkinopoulos, Theofilos; Gray, Kurt; Griffin, Siobhan; Gronfeldt, Bjarki; Gruber, June; Harris, Elizabeth Ann; Hruska, Matej; Isler, Ozan; Jangard, Simon; Jørgensen, Frederik Juhl; Koppel, Lina; Leota, Josh; Lermer, Eva; Levy, Neil L.; Longoni, Chiara; Miura, Asako; Muda, Rafał; Myer, Annalisa; Nash, Kyle; Nitschke, Jonas Paul; Ohtsubo, Yohsuke; Mello, Victoria Oldemburgo de; Pan, Yafeng; Zsófia, Papp; Pärnamets, Philip; Paruzel-Czachura, Mariola; Pitman, Michael Mark; Pyrkosz-Pacyna, Joanna; Rathje, Steve; Raza, Ali; Rhee, Kasey; Rêgo, Gabriel Gaudencio do; Robertson, Claire; Salvador-Ginez, Octavio; Sampaio, Waldir M.; Savage, David Alan; Scheffer, Julian Andrew; Schönegger, Philipp; Scott, Andy; Skali, Ahmed; Strickland, Brent; Stafford, Clara Alexandra; Stefaniak, Anna; Sternisko, Anni; Tinghög, Gustav; Torgler, Benno; Tucciarelli, Raffaele; Ungson, Nick D’Angelo; Uysal, Mete Sefa; Prooijen, Jan-Willem van; Rooy, Dirk Van; Västfjäll, Daniel; Vieira, Joana B.; Walker, Alexander C.; Wetter, Erik; Willardt, Robin; Wojcik, Adrian; Wu, Kaidi; Yamada, Yuki; Yilmaz, Onurcan; Yogeeswaran, Kumar; Zwaan, Rolf; Boggio, Paulo; Cameron, Daryl; Tyrala, Michael; Gualda, Estrella; Moreau, David; Palomäki, Jussi; Hudecek, Matthias
  • Leadership and Gender Advantage
    Vecchio, R. P.
  • Heuristics and Political Elites’ Judgment and Decision-making
    Vis, B.
  • Toward a New Theory of Institutional Change
    Weyland, K.