Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
Loading next page...
/lp/sage/culture-religion-and-strategy-the-islamic-contours-of-iran-s-nuclear-Kr18b81dAm
References (134)
-
(2014)
When the Ayatollah said no to the nukes -
Shelford Bidwell (1986)
The sources of military doctrine: France, Britain, and Germany between the world warsInternational Affairs, 62
-
(2012)
For further discussion on the repercussions of this programme, see Fuhrmann -
Bayānāt dar dīdār bā aʿżā - yi majlisI khubrigān - I rahbariyy [ Remarks in the meeting with members of the assembly of experts ] -
M. Finnemore (2011)
The Culture of National Security : Norms and Identity in World Politics -
Karsten Frey (2006)
India's Nuclear Bomb and National Security -
R. Matthews (2014)
Cultural realism?Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal, 10
-
Mark Suchman, D. Eyre (1992)
Military procurement as rational myth: Notes on the social construction of weapons proliferationSociological Forum, 7
-
K. Afrasiabi (1994)
After Khomeini: New Directions In Iran's Foreign Policy -
F. Rajaee (1983)
Islamic Values and World View: Khomeyni on Man, the State and International Politics -
(1980)
17); for an analysis of the role of ulama in Safavid political culture, see Savory -
David Rousseau (2006)
Identifying Threats and Threatening Identities: The Social Construction of Realism and Liberalism -
(2013)
Mūssah Khānah Haqūq Āriyā (Aria-Law Center Institution) -
Iranian students stormed the US Embassy in Tehran and held hostage some 70 diplomats and citizens of the US -
Dennis Jett (2017)
The Iran Nuclear Deal: Bombs, Bureaucrats, and Billionaires -
Jalil Mehdi (2017)
Nuclear Strategy and Regional Stability in Southern AsiaJournal of Asian Security and International Affairs, 4
-
Brenton Clark (2012)
Iranian foreign policy towards Tajikistan and Afghanistan during the Ahmadinejad presidency: the rising Salience of Persian national identity -
E. Adler (1992)
The emergence of cooperation: national epistemic communities and the international evolution of the idea of nuclear arms controlInternational Organization, 46
-
More fingers on nuclear triggers? -
K. Sadjadpour (2008)
Reading Khamenei: The World View of Iran's Most Powerful Leader -
A. Levite (2003)
Never Say Never Again: Nuclear Reversal RevisitedInternational Security, 27
-
(2014)
Going to Tehran: Why America must accept the Islamic Republic of Iran -
Rūḥ Khumaynī, H. Algar (1983)
Islam and revolution : writings and declarations of Imam Khomeini -
Iran: Nuclear intentions and capabilities. National Intelligence Estimate. National Intelligence Council-United States -
(2005)
Arguments by some Iranian officials on the side-lines of the conference -
Iran to hand over nuclear waste to suppliers -
(1995)
For an understanding of what such cultural objects of analysis could be and how they could serve in deciphering the strategic preference ranking of states -
R. Savory (1980)
Iran Under the Safavids -
(2012)
Supreme Leader’s inaugural speech at the 16th non-aligned summit -
The President's Message of felicitation to the leaders of the Countries of Afghanistan -
M. Faghfoory (1987)
The Ulama–State Relations in Iran: 1921–1941International Journal of Middle East Studies, 19
-
(2021)
Wilayat-e Faqih and Hukm Hakim [Wilayat-e Faqih and the Ruler’s Ruling -
(2011)
Islam and the bomb: Religious justification for and against Nuclear Weapons -
(2000)
Security-seeking under anarchy: Defensive realism reconsidered -
(1992)
September). Ray of light: Detailed statements of the supreme leader. Department of Culture and Islamic Guidance in West Azerbaijan (Shahrivar 1371) -
(1989)
For the arguments and the different references in this regard, see Idris al-Hilli -
H. Algar (1969)
Religion and state in Iran, 1785-1906;: The role of the ulama in the Qajar period -
Rafsanjani made this statement during his address to the closing session of the 'International Conference on Nuclear Technologies and Sustainable Development' convened in Tehran on -
(2005)
Iran admits keeping nuclear program secret -
Khamenei reiterated the threat the Islamic government is having (see Khamenei -
R. Jepperson, Alexander Wendt, Peter Katzenstein (1996)
Norms, Identity and Culture in National Security -
(1980)
Q&A/Former Iran nuclear negotiator: Bush negotiation bid was rebuffed -
Atoms for peace agreement with Iran -
(1983)
For the Islamic character of the Revolution and the subsequent Islamisation, see Akhavi -
Timeline on Iran's Nuclear Program. The New York Times -
(1989)
Al-Sara'ir Al-Ḥāwī Taḥrīr Al-Fatāwī -
Elizabeth Kier (1997)
Imagining War: French and British Military Doctrine between the Wars -
K. Taremi (2014)
Iranian Strategic Culture: The Impact of Ayatollah Khomeini's Interpretation of Shiite IslamContemporary Security Policy, 35
-
S. Hashmi (2004)
Ethics and Weapons of Mass Destruction: Islamic Ethics and Weapons of Mass Destruction: An Argument for Nonproliferation -
N. Keddie, S. Nasr (2008)
Modern Iran: Roots and Results of RevolutionInternational Journal of Environmental Studies, 65
-
United States Policy toward Iran (Includes NSC Staff Study on Certain Problems Relating to Iran) Top Secret -
M. Fitzpatrick, M. Elleman, Paulina Izewicz (2019)
Uncertain future: The JCPOA and Iran’s nuclear and missile programmes -
Peter Katzenstein (2013)
The Culture of National Security -
(2014)
This was revealed in an interview of former minister of IRGC in the war time -
(2009)
US-Iran tensions: Timeline of events leading to Soleimani killing -
(2017)
For an overview of the problems of structural realism in explaining nuclear programmes of other regional states, see Mehdi -
Shahrough Akhavi (1983)
The Ideology and Praxis of Shi'ism in the Iranian RevolutionComparative Studies in Society and History, 25
-
Steven Ward (2005)
The Continuing Evolution of Iran's Military DoctrineMiddle East Journal, 59
-
G. Quester (1977)
The Shah and the BombPolicy Sciences, 8
-
Michael Brown, Sean Lynn-Jones, Steven Miller (1996)
The Perils of Anarchy Contemporary Realism and International SecurityForeign Affairs, 75
-
W. Bowen, M. Morán (2014)
Iran's Nuclear Programme: A Case Study in Hedging?Contemporary Security Policy, 35
-
(1965)
Kohl (1971) and Frey -
Supreme leader's speech to Basij members -
(2013)
We will never develop nuclear weapons -
Remarks at the visit of the Universities of Semnan -
Mansoor Moaddel (1986)
The Shi'i ulama and the state in IranTheory and Society, 15
-
(2008)
The nuclear Sphinx of Tehran -
(2008)
Islamic government: Governance of the Jurist (H -
(2012)
The Islamic Propagation Organization (online edition) -
Answer from Ayatollah Montazeri on investment and use of nuclear energy in weapons technology -
(1980)
For the ulama's role in the Qajar period, see Algar -
A. Johnston (1995)
Cultural Realism: Strategic Culture and Grand Strategy in Chinese History -
No credible evidence of Iranian nuclear weapons, says UN inspector. The Guardian -
Michael Fischer (2010)
The Rhythmic Beat of the Revolution in IranCultural Anthropology, 25
-
Bayānāt dar dīdār bā aʿżā-yi majlis-I khubrigān-I rahbariyy -
Truman Driggs, L. Scheinman (1966)
Atomic Energy Policy in France Under the Fourth Republic, 19
-
(2018)
Renaming the Persian Gulf and the National Identity Crisis: Investigating and analysing the attitude of Iranians towards distorting the Name of the Persian Gulf (translated from Persian) -
Quran: 2:190. Wherever required, Yusuf Ali's translation of Quran is used in this article -
US supplied nuclear material to Iran -
(2011)
Shiite jurisprudence, political expediency, and nuclear weapons -
(1995)
For a discussion on military's preference for offensive strategies, see Posen (1984); for understanding the cultural basis of such strategies, see Kier -
(1996)
Norms, identity, and national security in Germany and Japan -
Jeffrey Lantis (2002)
Strategic Culture and National Security PolicyInternational Studies Review, 4
-
(2012)
Fatwa H[ urmat Tawlīd Bekārgīri Salāh haye Kushtār Jam‘ī, Gharb rā dar Banbast Qarār Dādah ast [Fatwa regarding the production of nuclear weapons has put the West in stalemate -
(1993)
Kalamat-e Qisar: Pand-ha va Hikmat-ha-ye Imam Khomeini [Short sentences: Advice and wise sayings of Ayatollah Khomeini -
Gerhard Böwering (1997)
The Concept of Time in Islam, 141
-
The man who turned Iran nuclear -
Leader's address to Air Force servicemen -
(2021)
Leadership message to Tehran International Conference on disarmament and non-proliferation -
D. Houghton (2007)
Reinvigorating the Study of Foreign Policy Decision Making: Toward a Constructivist ApproachForeign Policy Analysis, 3
-
Report to the Security Council (Annex B) -
A. Johnston (1995)
Thinking about Strategic CultureInternational Security, 19
-
(2016)
Bayānāt dar Dīdār Jam‘ī az Maddahān Ahlebayt Alaih Salam [Remarks in a Meeting with a Group of Maddahan Ahlulbayt Peace be upon Them -
P. Cornish, G. Edwards (2005)
The strategic culture of the European Union: a progress reportInternational Affairs, 81
-
(2008)
Mutahhari was one of the closest associates of Ayatollah Khomeini. He was described by Khomeini as 'achievement of my life -
(2013)
Article 14-part A of the Laws of the Armed Forces of Iran; see (Mūssah Khānah Haqūq Āriyā -
Iran nuclear 'threat' hyped: IAEA's ElBaradei. Reuters -
W. Bowen, M. Morán (2015)
Living with nuclear hedging: the implications of Iran's nuclear strategyInternational Affairs, 91
-
Kenneth Waltz (2012)
Why Iran Should Get the BombForeign Affairs
-
Donald Gentles (2002)
The Tragedy of Great Power PoliticsMilitary review, 82
-
S. Akbarzadeh, James Barry (2016)
State Identity in Iranian Foreign PolicyBritish Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, 43
-
Kerry Longhurst (2013)
Germany and the use of force: The Evolution of German Security Policy, 1990-2003 -
H. Moshirzadeh (2007)
Discursive Foundations of Iran's Nuclear PolicySecurity Dialogue, 38
-
Elizabeth Kier (1995)
Culture and Military Doctrine: France between the WarsInternational Security, 19
-
(2011)
The strategic culture of the Islamic Republic of Iran: Operational and policy implications -
A. Keshavarzian (2003)
Turban or Hat, Seminarian or Soldier: State Building and Clergy Building in Reza Shah's IranJournal of Church and State, 45
-
M. Fuhrmann (2012)
Atomic Assistance: How "Atoms for Peace" Programs Cause Nuclear Insecurity -
(1962)
Afaridgar-I Jahan -
Scott Sagan (1996)
Why Do States Build Nuclear Weapons? Three Models in Search of a BombInternational Security, 21
-
M. Nia (2010)
Understanding Iran’s Foreign Policy: An Application of Holistic ConstructivismAlternatives: Turkish Journal of International Relations, 9
-
A. Melamid, Graham Fuller (1992)
The center of the universe : the geopolitics of IranGeographical Review, 82
-
(2008)
Sahifeh-ye Imam: An anthology of Imam Khomeini's speeches, messages, interviews, decrees, religious permissions, and letters. The Institute for Compilation and Publication of Imam Khomeini's Works -
(2009)
U.S.-Iran nuclear negotiations in 1970s featured Shah’s nationalism and U.S. weapons worries (National Security Archive Electronic Briefing Book No. 268) -
M. Muṭahharī (2014)
Jihad : the holy war of Islam and its legitimacy in the Quran -
(1993)
The problem of retaliation in modern warfare from the point of view of Fiqh -
A. Ansari (2018)
Losing an enemy: Obama, Iran, and the triumph of diplomacyInternational Affairs, 94
-
Peter Rudloff (2014)
ArkPSA Arkansas Political Science Association ─────────────────────────────────────────────── Offensive Realism, Defensive Realism, and the Role of Constraints -
(2009)
Supreme leader’s address on the occasion of Imam Khomeini’s demise anniversary -
Willis Stanley (2009)
Iranian Strategic Culture and Its Persian Origins -
Jeannie Johnson, Kerry Kartchner, J. Larsen (2009)
Strategic culture and weapons of mass destruction : culturally based insights into comparative national security policymaking -
(2022)
To be or not to be: Great power dilemmas and the Iranian nuclear question -
(2015)
About the revelations, see the timeline of 2002 in Sinha and Beachy -
(2008)
For the jurisprudential debate about the primacy of the state, see Khalaji -
(1986)
For the clergy's relations with the state during the Pahlavi era, see Faghfoory (1987); also see -
(2012)
Supreme leader meets with UN Secretary General -
Jaclyn Tandler (2014)
French Nuclear DiplomacyThe Nonproliferation Review, 21
-
P. Macmillan (2016)
Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) -
(2012)
Asl Ijtihad dar Islam (Dah Guftar -
Ayatollah Javadi Amoli: The manufacturing of nuclear weapons is forbidden by Islam (translated from Persian). IRNA -
(2006)
For threat perception based on diffusion of identity at the state and international levels -
E. Rosenberg (1992)
Myths of Empire: Domestic Politics and International Ambition.The Journal of American History, 79
-
N. York (1969)
Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear WeaponsAmerican Journal of International Law, 63
-
(1995)
Religion and politics in contemporary Iran: Shia radicalism, revolution, and national character -
Information circular (No. INFCIRC/657)
- Publisher
- SAGE
- Copyright
- © 2022 SAGE Publications
- ISSN
- 2347-7970
- eISSN
- 2349-0039
- DOI
- 10.1177/23477970221076715
- Publisher site
- See Article on Publisher Site
Abstract
This article proposes a fresh explanation of Iran’s nuclear programme by using the framework of strategic culture. The core argument of this article is that Iran’s strategic restraint in not overtly weaponising its nuclear programme is primarily driven by its strategic culture despite the continuously deteriorating regional security situation and a deeply hostile neighbourhood. This has incentivised a ‘Shia way’ of looking at and practising a strategy that sees nuclear weapons as fundamentally un-Islamic. Instead of weaponisation, Iran has shown remarkable flexibility to accept restrictions on its nuclear programme under the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA). Security-based realist explanations fail to account for such behaviour and can be better explained using a cultural framework. The strategic culture-based framework also explains the reasons behind Iran’s policy of nuclear hedging and its acceptability by major sections of the political elite in Iran.
Journal
Journal of Asian Security and International Affairs – SAGE
Published: Apr 1, 2022