Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Saul Lieberman (1898-1983): Talmudic Scholar and Classicist (review)

Saul Lieberman (1898-1983): Talmudic Scholar and Classicist (review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a$1>*ID>**`&)(-,$2W*J=)(2*]&11&2*A'&--E*I77I>**!!7* 44>*b##>#c>* d2&*4$--(.1&*5&<-9'&*$+*,8&*1<-,(2:*%<19&-*$+*-@8$1<'-B*)$'S-*(-*)8&,8&'*,8&('*.$$S-* '&5<(2* (2* 4'(2,* <+,&'* ,8&('* =&<,8>* N2$,8&'E* 4&'8<4-E* (-* )8&,8&'* <* 5&5$'(<1* %$195&* <44&<'&=*<2=*)8(@8*@$11&<:9&-*@$2,'(.9,&=*,$*(,>*Z8&'&*<'&*$+*@$9'-&*<==(,($2<1*(2=(@<e ,($2-*<-*)&11>*f2*,8&*@<-&*$+*V8<91*`(&.&'5<2E*(,*(-*(2,&'&-,(2:*,$*2$,&*,8<,*,$=</E*,)&2,/* /&<'-*<+,&'*8(-*=&<,8E*4'$.<.1/*5$'&*$+*8(-*.$$S-*<'&*(2*4'(2,*,8&2*&%&'*)&'&*(2*4'(2,*<,* <2/*$2&*,(5&*(2*,8&*4<-,g<2=*,$*,8&*.&-,*$+*5/*S2$)1&=:&E*2$2&*<'&*'&5<(2=&'&=h*Z8&* -1(5*.9,*(2,&'&-,(2:*%$195&*92=&'*'&%(&)*(-*<1-$*<*,&-,(5$2/*,$*,8&*&2=9'(2:*(2,&'&-,*(2* V8<91*`(&.&'5<2>*Z8&*4<',(@(4<2,-*<'&*<11*5<U$'*-@8$1<'->*f2*5$-,*5&5$'(<1*%$195&-E*,8&* <',(@1&-*@$2,'(.9,&=*'&+1&@,*,8&*@9''&2,*'&-&<'@8*<@,(%(,(&-*$+*,8&*<9,8$'-*'<,8&'*,8<2*'&1<,&* =('&@,1/* ,$* ,8&* 4&'-$2* (2* )8$-&* 5&5$'/* ,8&* %$195&* (-* 4'$=9@&=>* ;8<,* 5<S&-* ,8(-* %$195&*(2,&'&-,(2:*(-*,8<,*-$5&*$+*,8&('*<',(@1&-*<'&*=&%$,&=*,$*<*%<'($9-*+<@&,-*$+*V8<91** !L7 <=>?@%***;(2,&'*I77c***a$1>*IDE*\$>*I* `(&.&'5<2B-*@8<'<@,&'*<2=*'&-&<'@8>*Z$*<*1<':&*&C,&2,E*,8(-*.$$S*(-*<.$9,*`(&.&'5<2E*<2=* <*.$$S*)'(,,&2*./*(54$',<2,*@$11&<:9&-*<2=*-,9=&2,-*<.$9,*$2&*$+*,8&*:'&<,&-,*T9=<(@<* -@8$1<'-*$+*,8(-*:&2&'<,($2*(-*.$92=*,$*.&*<*%<19<.1&*<2=*(2,&'&-,(2:*$2&g<2=*-$*(,*(->* Z8&*%$195&*(-*(2,'$=9@&=*./*,8&*&=(,$'*<2=*./*J1(&*;(&-&1>*Z8&*-,/1&-*$+*,8&*,)$*<'&* =(<5&,'(@<11/*$44$-(,&*.9,*.$,8*,&C,-*<'&*5$%(2:g<2=*&21(:8,&2(2:>*N-*2$,&=E*,8&*.91S* $+*,8&*%$195&*=&<1-*)(,8*`(&.&'5<2B-*-@8$1<'1/*$9,49,>*f,*(-*92=&'-,<2=<.1/*=(++(@91,*,$* 8<'2&--*=(++&'&2,*<9,8$'-*,$*<*-,<2=<'=*+$'5<,*<2=*-(5(1<'*-@$4&>*f2*,8&*@<-&*$+*,8(-* %$195&E*(+*,8&'&*)&'&*&++$',-*,$*8<%&*-$5&*92(+$'5(,/E*,8&/*)&'&*2$,*,$,<11/*-9@@&--+91>* ;8(1&*<15$-,*<1)</-*(2,&'&-,(2:*<2=*%<19<.1&E*,8&'&*(-*<*@&',<(2*1<@S*$+*.<1<2@&>*G$%* 31$,2(@SB-*<',(@1&E*XZ8&*]&,8$=$1$:/*$+*A'$+&--$'*V<91*`(&.&'5<2EY*,<S&-*$2&*4<',(@91<'* ](-82<*<2=*<2<1/Q&-*`(&.&'5<2B-*5&,8$=$1$:/*,8'$9:8*8(-*=(-@9--($2*$+*,8(-*](-82<>* Z8(-*-8$',*-,9=/*(-*+<-@(2<,(2:E*.9,E*$+*@$9'-&E*<2*&C<541&*$+*$2&*](-82<E*&21(:8,&2(2:* <-*(,*5</*.&E*=$&-*2$,*&C8<9-,*,8&*,$4(@>*Z)$*'&1<,(%&1/*1$2:*K+$'*,8&*%$195&M*<',(@1&-E* ,8$-&*$+*T<@$.-$2*<2=*]<'.1&-,$2&E*=&<1*)(,8*`(&.&'5<2*,8&*@1<--(@(-,*<2=*(2*4<',(@91<'E* )(,8*@1<(5-*,8<,*`(&.&'5<2*)<-*2$,*<*5<-,&'*$+*F'&&S*<2=*`<,(2>*Z8&*<',(@1&-*=&%<-,<,&* ,8&*@'(,(O9&-*<2=*1&<%&*,8&*'&<=&'*)(,8*,8&*@$2@19-($2*,8<,*(+*<2/$2&*8<=*4'$.1&5-*)(,8* F'&&S*<2=*`<,(2E*(,*)<-*,8&*@'(,(@*<2=*2$,*`(&.&'5<2>*N.'<8<5*F$1=.&':*)'$,&*$2*)</-* ,$*9-&*49.1(-8&=*%$195&-*$+*`(&.&'5<2B-*)$'S-*,$*1$@<,&*8(-*@$55&2,-*$2*,&C,-*,$* )8(@8*8&*=(=*2$,*)'(,&*<*+911*@$55&2,<'/>*f-'<&1*Z<*V85<*@$2,'(.9,&=*,)$*<',(@1&->*f2*8(-* J2:1(-8*1<2:9<:&*$2&E*8&*=&<1,*)(,8*`(&.&'5<2B-*@$2,'(.9,($2-*,$*,8&*-,9=/*$+*5&=(&%<1* ,&C,-> Z8&'&*<'&*<1-$*<*295.&'*$+*<',(@1&-*<.$9,*,$4(@-*<2=*2$,*<.$9,*`(&.&'5<2>*]&2<8&5* V@85&1Q&'*@$2,'(.9,&=*<2*<',(@1&*$2*,8&*)</*,8&*8(:8*4'(&-,*(2*,8&*-&@$2=*,&541&*4&'($=* )<-*S&4,*<) *Z8&*&=(,$'E*]&('*`9.&,-S(E*@$2,'(.9,&=*<2*<',(@1&*<.$9,* <* '<'&* )$'=E* i2*,-2*,-EB* (2* .(.1(@<1* <2=* '<..(2(@* ,&C,->* Z8&* <',(@1&* ./* ]&('* 0<'* f1<2E* `(&.&'5<2B-*2&48&)E*(-*<*'&,9'2*,$*`(&.&'5<2*<-*<*,$4(@>*6&*)'$,&*<.$9,*`(&.&'5<2B-* :'&<,2&--* <2=* 8(-* )(11(2:2&--* ,$* <=5(,* ,$* 8<%(2:* 5<=&* <2* &''$'>* ^2+$',92<,&1/E* ,8(-* @8<'<@,&'(-,(@*-&&5-*,$*.&*'<'&'*,8<2*(,*-8$91=*.&*(2*,8&*-@8$1<'1/*)$'1=>*Z8&*6&.'&)* -&@,($2*@$2,<(2-*<*+<-@(2<,(2:*<2&@=$,&*'&,$1=*./*f-'<&1*Z<*V85<*(2*,8'&&*4<:&-*Kf*)$2B,* -4$(1*(,*./*-955<'(Q(2:*(,g(,*(-*)$',8*'&<=(2:M*<2=*<*+(%&e4<:&*1&<'2&=*@$55&2,<'/* &C41<(2(2:* ,8&* <2&@=$,&h* V(2@&* .(.1($:'<48(&-* $+* `(&.&'5<2B-* )$'S* &C(-,E* ,8&* .$$S* @$2@19=&-*)(,8*<*.(.1($:'<48/*$+*)$'S-*<.$9,*8(5>* ]$-,*$+*,8&*@$2,&2,-*$+*,8(-*.$$S*<'&*(2,&'&-,(2:>*V$5&*<',(@1&-*<'&*=&,<(1&=*-,9=(&-* $+*`(&.&'5<2B-*)$'SE*-$5&*<'&*92'&1<,&=E*<2=*-$5&*@$5&*,$*4'<(-&*.9,*2$,*,$*<2<1/Q&>* [$8&'&2@&*(-*2$,*<2*<.-$19,&*%<19&E*.9,*(,*(-*-,(11*=&-('<.1&>*Z8&*<',(@1&-*,8<,*)&'&*2$,* =&%$,&=*,$*`(&.&'5<2*@$91=*8<%&*.&&2*49.1(-8&=*(2*U$9'2<1-*$'*(2*%$195&-*=&%$,&=*,$* -,9=(&-*$+*<*4<',(@91<'*,$4(@>*Z8&('*4'&-&2@&*,$:&,8&'*(2*,8(-*%$195&*(-*2$,*@1&<'>**f,*5(:8,* 8<%&*.&&2*5$'&*9-&+91*,$*1&<%&*$9,*,8&*<',(@1&-*2$,*=&%$,&=*,$*`(&.&'5<2*<2=*,$*9-&*,8&* -4<@&*-<%&=*,$*'&4'(2,*'&1&%<2,*<',(@1&-*$2*`(&.&'5<2*,8<,*8<%&*<1'&<=/*<44&<'&=*(2*4'(2,>* ]<2/* $+* ,8&-&* <'&* 8<'=* ,$* ,'<@S* =$)2* <2=* ,8&/* )$91=* 8<%&*-,'&2:,8&2&=*,8&*.$$S>** !""#$%&'(&)* !L! V(5(1<'1/E*(+*,8(-*.$$S*(-*(2,&2=&=*+$'*,8&*J2:1(-8*'&<=&'E*)8/*)&'&2B,*,8&*6&.'&)* <',(@1&-*,'<2-1<,&=j*N+,&'*<11E*,8&/*,<S&*94*1&--*,8<2*,&2*4<:&->*f2*(,-*49.1(-8&=*+$'5* =&-4(,&*,8&*:'&<,*&++$',*,8<,*)&2,*(2,$*(,E*,8(-*%$195&*'&5<(2-*<*%&'/*92&%&2*)$'S>*f,* (2@19=&-*,8'&&*(2=(@&-*$+*,&C,-*@(,&=*<2=*$+*(2=(%(=9<1-*5&2,($2&=>*f2=(@&-*<'&*(2=&&=* %<19<.1&*,$$1-E*.9,*$2&*'<'&1/*+(2=-*,8&5*(2*<*!77e4<:&*.$$S*$+*,8(-*2<,9'&>* V8<91*V,<54+&'* G&4<',5&2,*$+*T&)(-8*6(-,$'/* 6&.'&)*^2(%&'-(,/* =(;78'78<;)(>*'??% #,6% @';<9*';78(;% A(,B(,% )('% @",,"8% C*(,6 **[$1$:2&*<2=*a(&22<W*0k81<9*a&'1<:E*I77!>**Dl7*44>* http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Shofar: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Jewish Studies Purdue University Press

Saul Lieberman (1898-1983): Talmudic Scholar and Classicist (review)

Loading next page...
 
/lp/purdue-university-press/saul-lieberman-1898-1983-talmudic-scholar-and-classicist-review-f30XIIEsqn
Publisher
Purdue University Press
Copyright
Copyright © 2005 Purdue University.
ISSN
1534-5165
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

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a$1>*ID>**`&)(-,$2W*J=)(2*]&11&2*A'&--E*I77I>**!!7* 44>*b##>#c>* d2&*4$--(.1&*5&<-9'&*$+*,8&*1<-,(2:*%<19&-*$+*-@8$1<'-B*)$'S-*(-*)8&,8&'*,8&('*.$$S-* '&5<(2* (2* 4'(2,* <+,&'* ,8&('* =&<,8>* N2$,8&'E* 4&'8<4-E* (-* )8&,8&'* <* 5&5$'(<1* %$195&* <44&<'&=*<2=*)8(@8*@$11&<:9&-*@$2,'(.9,&=*,$*(,>*Z8&'&*<'&*$+*@$9'-&*<==(,($2<1*(2=(@<e ,($2-*<-*)&11>*f2*,8&*@<-&*$+*V8<91*`(&.&'5<2E*(,*(-*(2,&'&-,(2:*,$*2$,&*,8<,*,$=</E*,)&2,/* /&<'-*<+,&'*8(-*=&<,8E*4'$.<.1/*5$'&*$+*8(-*.$$S-*<'&*(2*4'(2,*,8&2*&%&'*)&'&*(2*4'(2,*<,* <2/*$2&*,(5&*(2*,8&*4<-,g<2=*,$*,8&*.&-,*$+*5/*S2$)1&=:&E*2$2&*<'&*'&5<(2=&'&=h*Z8&* -1(5*.9,*(2,&'&-,(2:*%$195&*92=&'*'&%(&)*(-*<1-$*<*,&-,(5$2/*,$*,8&*&2=9'(2:*(2,&'&-,*(2* V8<91*`(&.&'5<2>*Z8&*4<',(@(4<2,-*<'&*<11*5<U$'*-@8$1<'->*f2*5$-,*5&5$'(<1*%$195&-E*,8&* <',(@1&-*@$2,'(.9,&=*'&+1&@,*,8&*@9''&2,*'&-&<'@8*<@,(%(,(&-*$+*,8&*<9,8$'-*'<,8&'*,8<2*'&1<,&* =('&@,1/* ,$* ,8&* 4&'-$2* (2* )8$-&* 5&5$'/* ,8&* %$195&* (-* 4'$=9@&=>* ;8<,* 5<S&-* ,8(-* %$195&*(2,&'&-,(2:*(-*,8<,*-$5&*$+*,8&('*<',(@1&-*<'&*=&%$,&=*,$*<*%<'($9-*+<@&,-*$+*V8<91** !L7 <=>?@%***;(2,&'*I77c***a$1>*IDE*\$>*I* `(&.&'5<2B-*@8<'<@,&'*<2=*'&-&<'@8>*Z$*<*1<':&*&C,&2,E*,8(-*.$$S*(-*<.$9,*`(&.&'5<2E*<2=* <*.$$S*)'(,,&2*./*(54$',<2,*@$11&<:9&-*<2=*-,9=&2,-*<.$9,*$2&*$+*,8&*:'&<,&-,*T9=<(@<* -@8$1<'-*$+*,8(-*:&2&'<,($2*(-*.$92=*,$*.&*<*%<19<.1&*<2=*(2,&'&-,(2:*$2&g<2=*-$*(,*(->* Z8&*%$195&*(-*(2,'$=9@&=*./*,8&*&=(,$'*<2=*./*J1(&*;(&-&1>*Z8&*-,/1&-*$+*,8&*,)$*<'&* =(<5&,'(@<11/*$44$-(,&*.9,*.$,8*,&C,-*<'&*5$%(2:g<2=*&21(:8,&2(2:>*N-*2$,&=E*,8&*.91S* $+*,8&*%$195&*=&<1-*)(,8*`(&.&'5<2B-*-@8$1<'1/*$9,49,>*f,*(-*92=&'-,<2=<.1/*=(++(@91,*,$* 8<'2&--*=(++&'&2,*<9,8$'-*,$*<*-,<2=<'=*+$'5<,*<2=*-(5(1<'*-@$4&>*f2*,8&*@<-&*$+*,8(-* %$195&E*(+*,8&'&*)&'&*&++$',-*,$*8<%&*-$5&*92(+$'5(,/E*,8&/*)&'&*2$,*,$,<11/*-9@@&--+91>* ;8(1&*<15$-,*<1)</-*(2,&'&-,(2:*<2=*%<19<.1&E*,8&'&*(-*<*@&',<(2*1<@S*$+*.<1<2@&>*G$%* 31$,2(@SB-*<',(@1&E*XZ8&*]&,8$=$1$:/*$+*A'$+&--$'*V<91*`(&.&'5<2EY*,<S&-*$2&*4<',(@91<'* ](-82<*<2=*<2<1/Q&-*`(&.&'5<2B-*5&,8$=$1$:/*,8'$9:8*8(-*=(-@9--($2*$+*,8(-*](-82<>* Z8(-*-8$',*-,9=/*(-*+<-@(2<,(2:E*.9,E*$+*@$9'-&E*<2*&C<541&*$+*$2&*](-82<E*&21(:8,&2(2:* <-*(,*5</*.&E*=$&-*2$,*&C8<9-,*,8&*,$4(@>*Z)$*'&1<,(%&1/*1$2:*K+$'*,8&*%$195&M*<',(@1&-E* ,8$-&*$+*T<@$.-$2*<2=*]<'.1&-,$2&E*=&<1*)(,8*`(&.&'5<2*,8&*@1<--(@(-,*<2=*(2*4<',(@91<'E* )(,8*@1<(5-*,8<,*`(&.&'5<2*)<-*2$,*<*5<-,&'*$+*F'&&S*<2=*`<,(2>*Z8&*<',(@1&-*=&%<-,<,&* ,8&*@'(,(O9&-*<2=*1&<%&*,8&*'&<=&'*)(,8*,8&*@$2@19-($2*,8<,*(+*<2/$2&*8<=*4'$.1&5-*)(,8* F'&&S*<2=*`<,(2E*(,*)<-*,8&*@'(,(@*<2=*2$,*`(&.&'5<2>*N.'<8<5*F$1=.&':*)'$,&*$2*)</-* ,$*9-&*49.1(-8&=*%$195&-*$+*`(&.&'5<2B-*)$'S-*,$*1$@<,&*8(-*@$55&2,-*$2*,&C,-*,$* )8(@8*8&*=(=*2$,*)'(,&*<*+911*@$55&2,<'/>*f-'<&1*Z<*V85<*@$2,'(.9,&=*,)$*<',(@1&->*f2*8(-* J2:1(-8*1<2:9<:&*$2&E*8&*=&<1,*)(,8*`(&.&'5<2B-*@$2,'(.9,($2-*,$*,8&*-,9=/*$+*5&=(&%<1* ,&C,-> Z8&'&*<'&*<1-$*<*295.&'*$+*<',(@1&-*<.$9,*,$4(@-*<2=*2$,*<.$9,*`(&.&'5<2>*]&2<8&5* V@85&1Q&'*@$2,'(.9,&=*<2*<',(@1&*$2*,8&*)</*,8&*8(:8*4'(&-,*(2*,8&*-&@$2=*,&541&*4&'($=* )<-*S&4,*<) *Z8&*&=(,$'E*]&('*`9.&,-S(E*@$2,'(.9,&=*<2*<',(@1&*<.$9,* <* '<'&* )$'=E* i2*,-2*,-EB* (2* .(.1(@<1* <2=* '<..(2(@* ,&C,->* Z8&* <',(@1&* ./* ]&('* 0<'* f1<2E* `(&.&'5<2B-*2&48&)E*(-*<*'&,9'2*,$*`(&.&'5<2*<-*<*,$4(@>*6&*)'$,&*<.$9,*`(&.&'5<2B-* :'&<,2&--* <2=* 8(-* )(11(2:2&--* ,$* <=5(,* ,$* 8<%(2:* 5<=&* <2* &''$'>* ^2+$',92<,&1/E* ,8(-* @8<'<@,&'(-,(@*-&&5-*,$*.&*'<'&'*,8<2*(,*-8$91=*.&*(2*,8&*-@8$1<'1/*)$'1=>*Z8&*6&.'&)* -&@,($2*@$2,<(2-*<*+<-@(2<,(2:*<2&@=$,&*'&,$1=*./*f-'<&1*Z<*V85<*(2*,8'&&*4<:&-*Kf*)$2B,* -4$(1*(,*./*-955<'(Q(2:*(,g(,*(-*)$',8*'&<=(2:M*<2=*<*+(%&e4<:&*1&<'2&=*@$55&2,<'/* &C41<(2(2:* ,8&* <2&@=$,&h* V(2@&* .(.1($:'<48(&-* $+* `(&.&'5<2B-* )$'S* &C(-,E* ,8&* .$$S* @$2@19=&-*)(,8*<*.(.1($:'<48/*$+*)$'S-*<.$9,*8(5>* ]$-,*$+*,8&*@$2,&2,-*$+*,8(-*.$$S*<'&*(2,&'&-,(2:>*V$5&*<',(@1&-*<'&*=&,<(1&=*-,9=(&-* $+*`(&.&'5<2B-*)$'SE*-$5&*<'&*92'&1<,&=E*<2=*-$5&*@$5&*,$*4'<(-&*.9,*2$,*,$*<2<1/Q&>* [$8&'&2@&*(-*2$,*<2*<.-$19,&*%<19&E*.9,*(,*(-*-,(11*=&-('<.1&>*Z8&*<',(@1&-*,8<,*)&'&*2$,* =&%$,&=*,$*`(&.&'5<2*@$91=*8<%&*.&&2*49.1(-8&=*(2*U$9'2<1-*$'*(2*%$195&-*=&%$,&=*,$* -,9=(&-*$+*<*4<',(@91<'*,$4(@>*Z8&('*4'&-&2@&*,$:&,8&'*(2*,8(-*%$195&*(-*2$,*@1&<'>**f,*5(:8,* 8<%&*.&&2*5$'&*9-&+91*,$*1&<%&*$9,*,8&*<',(@1&-*2$,*=&%$,&=*,$*`(&.&'5<2*<2=*,$*9-&*,8&* -4<@&*-<%&=*,$*'&4'(2,*'&1&%<2,*<',(@1&-*$2*`(&.&'5<2*,8<,*8<%&*<1'&<=/*<44&<'&=*(2*4'(2,>* ]<2/* $+* ,8&-&* <'&* 8<'=* ,$* ,'<@S* =$)2* <2=* ,8&/* )$91=* 8<%&*-,'&2:,8&2&=*,8&*.$$S>** !""#$%&'(&)* !L! V(5(1<'1/E*(+*,8(-*.$$S*(-*(2,&2=&=*+$'*,8&*J2:1(-8*'&<=&'E*)8/*)&'&2B,*,8&*6&.'&)* <',(@1&-*,'<2-1<,&=j*N+,&'*<11E*,8&/*,<S&*94*1&--*,8<2*,&2*4<:&->*f2*(,-*49.1(-8&=*+$'5* =&-4(,&*,8&*:'&<,*&++$',*,8<,*)&2,*(2,$*(,E*,8(-*%$195&*'&5<(2-*<*%&'/*92&%&2*)$'S>*f,* (2@19=&-*,8'&&*(2=(@&-*$+*,&C,-*@(,&=*<2=*$+*(2=(%(=9<1-*5&2,($2&=>*f2=(@&-*<'&*(2=&&=* %<19<.1&*,$$1-E*.9,*$2&*'<'&1/*+(2=-*,8&5*(2*<*!77e4<:&*.$$S*$+*,8(-*2<,9'&>* V8<91*V,<54+&'* G&4<',5&2,*$+*T&)(-8*6(-,$'/* 6&.'&)*^2(%&'-(,/* =(;78'78<;)(>*'??% #,6% @';<9*';78(;% A(,B(,% )('% @",,"8% C*(,6 **[$1$:2&*<2=*a(&22<W*0k81<9*a&'1<:E*I77!>**Dl7*44>*

Journal

Shofar: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Jewish StudiesPurdue University Press

Published: Feb 24, 2005

There are no references for this article.