Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Dissociating Controllable and Uncontrollable Effects of Affective Stimuli on Attitudes and Consumption

Dissociating Controllable and Uncontrollable Effects of Affective Stimuli on Attitudes and... This research studies a fundamental and seemingly straightforward question: Can basic advertising elements, such as the presence of attractive imagery, have uncontrollable effects on consumers’ attitudes and consumption decisions? Answering this question is methodologically challenging, because the presence of an uncontrollable process can be masked by a simultaneously operating controllable process. We argue first that existing methods conflate the contribution of both processes and are therefore unable to measure the presence of an uncontrollable process reliably. To solve the conundrum, we present a novel application of processing tree modeling. Evaluative conditioning is employed as a paradigm to study the influence of affective visual stimuli on attitudes and behavior. Across six experiments, we demonstrate the validity of the model parameters estimating controllable and uncontrollable processes. As predicted, the parameter estimate of the controllable process is susceptible to cognitive resources and levels of motivation to exert control. The parameter estimate of the uncontrollable process appears unaffected by these factors. We also demonstrate the external validity of our findings and their relevance to stimuli and instructions typical for consumer research. Finally, we find that controllable and uncontrollable processes are both predictive of product choice and consumption. We discuss implications for consumer protection. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Consumer Research Oxford University Press

Dissociating Controllable and Uncontrollable Effects of Affective Stimuli on Attitudes and Consumption

Hütter, Mandy; Sweldens, Steven
Journal of Consumer Research , Volume 45 (2): 30 – Aug 1, 2018
Download PDF
30 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/ou_press/dissociating-controllable-and-uncontrollable-effects-of-affective-Uc0Fcmbs7R
Publisher
Oxford University Press
Copyright
© The Author(s) 2018. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Journal of Consumer Research, Inc. All rights reserved. For permissions, please e-mail: journals.permissions@oup.com
ISSN
0093-5301
eISSN
1537-5277
DOI
10.1093/jcr/ucx124
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

This research studies a fundamental and seemingly straightforward question: Can basic advertising elements, such as the presence of attractive imagery, have uncontrollable effects on consumers’ attitudes and consumption decisions? Answering this question is methodologically challenging, because the presence of an uncontrollable process can be masked by a simultaneously operating controllable process. We argue first that existing methods conflate the contribution of both processes and are therefore unable to measure the presence of an uncontrollable process reliably. To solve the conundrum, we present a novel application of processing tree modeling. Evaluative conditioning is employed as a paradigm to study the influence of affective visual stimuli on attitudes and behavior. Across six experiments, we demonstrate the validity of the model parameters estimating controllable and uncontrollable processes. As predicted, the parameter estimate of the controllable process is susceptible to cognitive resources and levels of motivation to exert control. The parameter estimate of the uncontrollable process appears unaffected by these factors. We also demonstrate the external validity of our findings and their relevance to stimuli and instructions typical for consumer research. Finally, we find that controllable and uncontrollable processes are both predictive of product choice and consumption. We discuss implications for consumer protection.

Journal

Journal of Consumer Research – Oxford University Press

Published: Aug 1, 2018

Keywords: attitudes; evaluative conditioning; evaluative learning; controllability; automaticity; multinomial processing tree models

References

  • A Closer Look at Classical Conditioning,”
    Allen, Chris T.; Madden, Thomas J.
  • “Overcoming Intuition: Metacognitive Difficulty Activates Analytic Reasoning,”
    Alter, Adam L.; Oppenheimer, Daniel M.; Epley, Nicholas; Eyre, Rebecca N.
  • Human Evaluative Conditioning: Acquisition Trials, Presentation Schedule, Evaluative Style and Contingency Awareness,”
    Baeyens, Frank; Eelen, Paul; Crombez, Geert; Vandenbergh, Omer
  • Theoretical and Empirical Review of Multinomial Process Tree Modeling,”
    Batchelder, William H.; Riefer, David M.
  • Ban the Sunset? Nonpropositional Content and Regulation of Pharmaceutical Advertising,”
    Biegler, Paul; Vargas, Patrick
  • Classical Conditioning of Preferences for Stimuli,”
    Bierley, Calvin; McSweeney, Frances K.; Vannieuwkerk, Renee
  • “Conflict Monitoring and Cognitive Control,”
    Botvinick, Matthew M.; Braver, Todd S.; Barch, Deanna M.; Carter, Cameron S.; Cohen, Jonathan D.
  • “Beyond Awareness and Resources: Evaluative Conditioning May Be Sensitive to Processing Goals,”
    Corneille, Olivier; Yzerbyt, Vincent; Pleyers, Gordy; Mussweiler, Thomas
  • “Violations of the Independence Assumption in Process Dissociation,”
    Curran, Tim; Hintzman, Douglas L.
  • Motivated Forgetting in Response to Social Identity Threat,”
    Dalton, Amy N.; Huang, Li
  • “Using the Implicit Association Test Does Not Rule Out an Impact of Conscious Propositional Knowledge on Evaluative Conditioning,”
    De Houwer, Jan
  • Implicit Measures: A Normative Analysis and Review,”
    De Houwer, Jan; Teige-Mocigemba, Sarah; Spruyt, Adriaan; Moors, Agnes
  • “Associative Learning of Likes and Dislikes: A Review of 25 Years of Research on Human Evaluative Conditioning,”
    De Houwer, Jan; Thomas, Sarah; Baeyens, Frank
  • “Evaluative Conditioning of High-Novelty Stimuli Does Not Seem to Be Based on an Automatic Form of Associative Learning,”
    Dedonder, Jonathan; Corneille, Olivier; Yzerbyt, Vincent; Kuppens, Toon
  • At the Boundaries of Automaticity: Negation as Reflective Operation,”
    Deutsch, Roland; Gawronski, Bertram; Strack, Fritz
  • “Fast and Fragile: A New Look at the Automaticity of Negation Processing,”
    Deutsch, Roland; Kordts-Freudinger, Robert; Gawronski, Bertram; Strack, Fritz
  • “Evaluative Conditioning Depends on Higher Order Cognitive Processes,”
    Fiedler, Klaus; Unkelbach, Christian
  • Asking Questions Can Change Choice Behavior: Does It Do So Automatically or Effortfully?”
    Fitzsimons, Gavan J.; Williams, Patti
  • Can the Formation of Conditioned Attitudes Be Intentionally Controlled?”
    Gawronski, Bertram; Balas, Robert; Creighton, Laura A.
  • Associative and Propositional Processes in Evaluation: An Integrative Review of Implicit and Explicit Attitude Change,”
    Gawronski, Bertram; Bodenhausen, Galen V.
  • Is Evaluative Conditioning Really Uncontrollable? A Comparative Test of Three Emotion-Focused Strategies to Prevent the Acquisition of Conditioned Preferences,”
    Gawronski, Bertram; Mitchell, Derek G.; Balas, Robert
  • Can Evaluative Conditioning Change Attitudes Toward Mature Brands? New Evidence from the Implicit Association Test,”
    Gibson, Bryan
  • The Effects of Music in Advertising on Choice Behavior: A Classical Conditioning Approach,”
    Gorn, Gerald J.
  • Evaluative Conditioning in Humans: A Meta-Analysis,”
    Hofmann, Wilhelm; De Houwer, Jan; Perugini, Marco; Baeyens, Frank; Crombez, Geert
  • “The Statistical Analysis of Engineering Processing Tree Models with the EM Algorithm,”
    Hu, Xiangen; Batchelder, William H.
  • “Applying Processing Trees in Social Psychology,”
    Hütter, Mandy; Klauer, Karl C.
  • “Implicit Misattribution of Evaluative Responses: Contingency-Unaware Evaluative Conditioning Requires Simultaneous Stimulus Presentations,”
    Hütter, Mandy; Sweldens, Steven
  • “Dissociating Contingency Awareness and Conditioned Attitudes: Evidence of Contingency-Unaware Evaluative Conditioning,”
    Hütter, Mandy; Sweldens, Steven; Stahl, Christoph; Unkelbach, Christian; Klauer, Karl C.
  • Negative Information Weighs More Heavily on the Brain: The Negativity Bias in Evaluative Categorizations,”
    Ito, Tiffany A.; Larsen, Jeff T.; Smith, N. Kyle; Cacioppo, John T.
  • “A Process Dissociation Framework—Separating Automatic from Intentional Uses of Memory,”
    Jacoby, Larry L.
  • “Toward a Psychometric Analysis of Violations of the Independence Assumption in Process Dissociation,”
    Jacoby, Larry L.; Shrout, Patrick E.
  • The Influence of Classical Conditioning Procedures on Subsequent Attention to the Conditioned Brand,”
    Janiszewski, Chris; Warlop, Luk
  • “Mapping the Frontiers: Theoretical Advances in Consumer Research on Memory, Affect, and Persuasion,”
    Johar, Gita V.; Maheswaran, Durairaj; Peracchio, Laura A.
  • “Implicit Misattribution as a Mechanism Underlying Evaluative Conditioning,”
    Jones, Christopher R.; Fazio, Russell H.; Olson, Michael A.
  • “The Invariance Assumption in Process-Dissociation Models: An Evaluation Across Three Domains,”
    Klauer, Karl Christoph; Dittrich, Kerstin; Scholtes, Christine; Voss, Andreas
  • “Resource Availability and Explicit Memory Largely Determine Evaluative Conditioning Effects in a Paradigm Claimed to Be Conducive to Implicit Attitudes Acquisition,”
    Mierop, Adrien; Hütter, Mandy; Corneille, Olivier
  • The Propositional Nature of Human Associative Learning,”
    Mitchell, Chris J.; De Houwer, Jan; Lovibond, Peter F.
  • “Automaticity: A Conceptual and Theoretical Analysis,”
    Moors, Agnes; De Houwer, Jan
  • “MultiTree: A Computer Program for the Analysis of Multinomial Processing Tree Models,”
    Moshagen, Morten
  • Implicit Attitude Formation through Classical Conditioning,”
    Olson, Michael A.; Fazio, Russell H.
  • “Social Psychology of a Classical Conditioning of Attitudes Experiment,”
    Page, Monte M.
  • “An Integrative Review of Process Dissociation and Related Models in Social Cognition,”
    Payne, B. Keith; Bishara, Anthony J.
  • Contingent Processes of Source Identification,”
    Pham, Michel T.; Johar, Gita V.
  • “Evaluative Conditioning May Incur Attentional Costs,”
    Pleyers, Gordy; Corneille, Olivier; Yzerbyt, Vincent; Luminet, Olivier
  • “Costs of a Predictable Switch between Simple Cognitive Tasks,”
    Rogers, Robert D.; Monsell, Stephen
  • Learning: From Association to Action,”
    Shanks, David R.
  • “When an Ad’s Influence Is Beyond Our Conscious Control: Perceptual and Conceptual Fluency Effects Caused by Incidental Ad Exposure,”
    Shapiro, Stewart
  • A Program of Classical-Conditioning Experiments Testing Variations in the Conditioned-Stimulus and Context,”
    Shimp, Terence A.; Stuart, Elnora W.; Engle, Randall W.
  • “HMMTree: A Computer Program for Latent-Class Hierarchical Multinomial Processing Tree Models,”
    Stahl, Christoph; Klauer, Karl C.
  • Classical Conditioning of Consumer Attitudes: Four Experiments in an Advertising Context,”
    Stuart, Elnora W.; Shimp, Terence A.; Engle, Randall W.
  • The Role of Awareness in Attitude Formation through Evaluative Conditioning,”
    Sweldens, Steven; Corneille, Olivier; Yzerbyt, Vincent
  • “How to Study Consciousness in Consumer Research: A Commentary on Williams and Poehlman,”
    Sweldens, Steven; Tuk, Mirjam; Hütter, Mandy
  • Evaluative Conditioning Procedures and the Resilience of Conditioned Brand Attitudes,”
    Sweldens, Steven; van Osselaer, Stijn M. J.; Janiszewski, Chris
  • “Ironic Processes of Mental Control,”
    Wegner, Daniel M.
  • “Inhibition versus Switching Deficits in Different Forms of Rumination,”
    Whitmer, Anson J.; Banich, Marie T.
  • “Conceptualizing Consciousness in Consumer Research,”
    Williams, Lawrence E.; Poehlman, Andrew