Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

“You are a disgrace and traitor to our country”: incivility against “The Squad” on Twitter

“You are a disgrace and traitor to our country”: incivility against “The Squad” on Twitter For many, the sole source for news content is social media, where passionate opinions are posted at an alarming speed. These opinions can cross the line from differing opinions shared in a public forum onto uncivil dialogue and even hate speech. Such online discourse threatens democratic values and creates a hostile environment. The purpose of this paper is to examine such incivility using the case of four congresswomen known as “The Squad”.Design/methodology/approachThe authors conducted a content analysis examining 20,563 replies to tweets sent by the four congresswomen. The social media data analysis and library, Brandwatch, was used to aggregate tweets posted by the four representatives, as well as all the replies posted to these tweets. The replies were coded to understand the types of incivility against each of the four congresswomen, whether the topics of a tweet can predict the types of incivility received in response, and the impact of Trump's tweet against the congresswomen.FindingsThe study findings show that the majority of replies contained uncivil language. The most common types of incivility are related to name-calling, stereotypes, threats to individual rights and vulgarity. Tweets about immigration and the Muslim ban, as well as tweets with negative tones received more replies. Following Donald Trump's Twitter attack on the representatives, replies to the congresswomen's tweets almost doubled. Mainly two types of incivility were observed to have increased significantly – the use of stereotypes and threats to individual rights.Originality/valueThe study examines incivility on Twitter against four black, indigenous and people of color (BIPOC) congresswomen as an exploratory case to observe and understand the growing phenomenon of uncivil language which feeds a polarized society and threatens democratic values. “The Squad” is more than an isosteric case study. It captures key changes in American politics. In the context of democratic discourse, the attack by the former president on these congresswomen and the response on social media address key issues of gender, religion and race in the United States. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Internet Research Emerald Publishing

“You are a disgrace and traitor to our country”: incivility against “The Squad” on Twitter

Download PDF
16 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/you-are-a-disgrace-and-traitor-to-our-country-incivility-against-the-MB2HsL7BnB
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1066-2243
DOI
10.1108/intr-06-2021-0363
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

For many, the sole source for news content is social media, where passionate opinions are posted at an alarming speed. These opinions can cross the line from differing opinions shared in a public forum onto uncivil dialogue and even hate speech. Such online discourse threatens democratic values and creates a hostile environment. The purpose of this paper is to examine such incivility using the case of four congresswomen known as “The Squad”.Design/methodology/approachThe authors conducted a content analysis examining 20,563 replies to tweets sent by the four congresswomen. The social media data analysis and library, Brandwatch, was used to aggregate tweets posted by the four representatives, as well as all the replies posted to these tweets. The replies were coded to understand the types of incivility against each of the four congresswomen, whether the topics of a tweet can predict the types of incivility received in response, and the impact of Trump's tweet against the congresswomen.FindingsThe study findings show that the majority of replies contained uncivil language. The most common types of incivility are related to name-calling, stereotypes, threats to individual rights and vulgarity. Tweets about immigration and the Muslim ban, as well as tweets with negative tones received more replies. Following Donald Trump's Twitter attack on the representatives, replies to the congresswomen's tweets almost doubled. Mainly two types of incivility were observed to have increased significantly – the use of stereotypes and threats to individual rights.Originality/valueThe study examines incivility on Twitter against four black, indigenous and people of color (BIPOC) congresswomen as an exploratory case to observe and understand the growing phenomenon of uncivil language which feeds a polarized society and threatens democratic values. “The Squad” is more than an isosteric case study. It captures key changes in American politics. In the context of democratic discourse, the attack by the former president on these congresswomen and the response on social media address key issues of gender, religion and race in the United States.

Journal

Internet Research – Emerald Publishing

Published: Sep 7, 2022

Keywords: Incivility; “The squad”; Twitter; Trump; Types of incivility; Predictors of incivility

References

  • Black and Asian women MPs abused more online
  • The ‘nasty effect’: online incivility and risk perceptions of emerging technologies
    Anderson, A.A.; Brossard, D.; Scheufele, D.A.; Xenos, M.A.; Ladwig, P.
  • For female candidates, harassment and threats come every day
    Astor, M.
  • The rhetoric of civility: power, authenticity, and democracy
    Benson, T.
  • Interactions of news frames and incivility in the political blogosphere: examining perceptual outcomes
    Borah, P.
  • Does it matter where you read the news story? Interaction of incivility and news frames in the political blogosphere
    Borah, P.
  • Political Facebook use: campaign strategies used in 2008 and 2012 presidential elections
    Borah, P.
  • Not all tweets are created equal: gender and politics in the platform age
    Bürger, T.; Jansen, M.; Ross, K.
  • The role of peer attachment and normative beliefs about aggression on traditional bullying and cyberbullying
    Burton, K.A.; Florell, D.; Wygant, D.B.
  • How Facebook and Twitter decided to take down Trump's accounts
    Byers, D.
  • We should not get rid of incivility online
    Chen, G.; Muddiman, A.; Wilner, T.; Pariser, E.; Stroud, N.J.
  • Online and uncivil? Patterns and determinants of incivility in newspaper website commentary
    Coe, K.; Kenski, K.; Rains, S.
  • Here are some of the women who made history in the midterm elections
    Cooney, S.
  • Women from the establishment versus the Squad: Feminine political representation styles in the US congress
    Cruz Lera, E.
  • The composure and civility of “the Squad” against Trump's attacks
    Fleming, C.
  • Good arguments: modern adventures in the theory and practice of deliberative democracy
    Gastil, J.
  • Rousing the partisan combatant: Elite incivility, anger, and anti deliberative attitudes
    Gervais, B.T.
  • Diversity and incivility: toward an action-oriented approach
    Githens, R.P.
  • Social media filtering and democracy: effects of social media news use and uncivil political discussions on social media unfriending
    Goyanes, M.; Borah, P.; Gil de Zúñiga, H.
  • Birds of a feather Tweet together: integrating network and content analyses to examine cross-ideology exposure on Twitter
    Himelboim, I.; McCreery, S.; Smith, M.
  • Does negative campaign advertising stimulate uncivil communication on social media? Measuring audience response using big data
    Hopp, T.; Vargo, C.J.
  • Seeing is believing: effects of uncivil online debate on political polarization and expectations of deliberation
    Hwang, H.; Kim, Y.; Huh, C.U.
  • A refresher on the Twitter Rules: what happens when you report?
    India, T.
  • Squad’ jumped from pop culture to become the most politically polarizing word of the year
    Izadi, E.; Epstein, K.
  • A visual timeline on how the attack on Capitol Hill unfolded
    Jacobo, J.
  • Does social media promote democracy? some empirical evidence
    Jha, C.K.; Kodila-Tedika, O.
  • Tolerating and managing extreme speech on social media
    Johnson, B.G.
  • Important tweets matter: predicting retweets in the# BlackLivesMatter talk on Twitter
    Keib, K.; Himelboim, I.; Han, J.Y.
  • Pseudo-information, media, publics, and the failing marketplace of ideas: theory
    Kim, J.N.; Gil de Zúñiga, H.
  • Political identity ownership: symbolic contests to represent members of the public
    Kreiss, D.; Lawrence, R.G.; McGregor, S.C.
  • Executive overreach and its disastrous results: the case of Trump and Netanyahu
    Kuttab, D.
  • What do others' reactions to news on Internet portal sites tell us? effects of presentation format and readers' need for cognition on reality perception
    Lee, E.J.; Jang, Y.J.
  • Online harassment among college students
    Lindsay, M.; Krysik, J.
  • The squad: where diversity is strength
    MacDonald, T.
  • Guidelines without lines, communities without borders: the marketplace of ideas and digital manifest destiny in social media platform policies
    Maddox, J.; Malson, J.
  • Opinion conflicts: an effective route to detect incivility in Twitter
    Maity, S.K.; Chakraborty, A.; Goyal, P.; Mukherjee, A.; Nichols, J.
  • H.Res.489 – ‘Condemning president Trump's racist comments directed at members of congress’
    Malinowski, T.
  • Freedom of speech, liberal democracy and emerging evidence on civility and effective democratic engagement
    Massaro, T.M.; Stryker, R.
  • How Americans navigated the news in 2020: a tumultuous year in review
    Mitchell, A.; Jurkowtiz, J.; Baxter, O.; Shearer, E.
  • Anonymity and roles associated with aggressive posts in an online forum
    Moore, M.J.; Nakano, T.; Enomoto, A.; Suda, T.
  • Personal and public levels of political incivility
    Muddiman, A.
  • Scaling social movements through social media: the case of Black Lives Matter
    Mundt, M.; Ross, K.; Burnett, C.M.
  • The new videomalaise: effects of televised incivility on political trust
    Mutz, D.C.; Reeves, B.
  • Flagging uncivil user comments: effects of intervention information, type of victim, and response comments on bystander behavior
    Naab, T.K.; Kalch, A.; Meitz, T.G.
  • Here's the resolution condemning Trump's racist comments about congresswomen
    Naylor, B.
  • How 4 congresswomen came to be called “the squad”
    North, A.
  • Twitter versus Facebook: comparing incivility, impoliteness, and deliberative attributes
    Oz, M.; Zheng, P.; Chen, G.M.
  • Democracy online: civility, politeness, and the democratic potential of online political discussion groups
    Papacharissi, Z.
  • The missing marketplace of ideas theory
    Papandrea, M.R.
  • Americans' views of government: low trust, but some positive performance ratings
  • Everyday incivility: towards a benchmark
    Phillips, T.; Smith, P.
  • Incivility in controversies: the influence of presumed media influence and perceived media hostility on the antagonists in the German conflict over aircraft noise
    Post, S.
  • The future of free speech, trolls, anonymity and fake news online
    Rainie, L.; Anderson, J.; Albright, J.
  • Dangerous minds? effects of uncivil online comments on aggressive cognitions, emotions, and behavior
    Rösner, L.; Winter, S.; Krämer, N.C.
  • Network news coverage of Congress
    Robinson, M.J.; Appel, K.R.
  • Beyond incivility: understanding patterns of uncivil and intolerant discourse in online political talk
    Rossini, P.
  • Civility 2.0: ‘A comparative analysis of incivility in online political discussion’
    Rowe, I.
  • Virtuous or vitriolic: the effect of anonymity on civility in online newspaper reader comment boards
    Santana, A.D.
  • Social media and its intersections with free speech, freedom of information and privacy. an analysis
    Segado-Boj, F.; Díaz-Campo, J.
  • Conversation is the soul of democracy: expression effects, communication mediation, and digital media
    Shah, D.
  • A minimalistic model of bias, polarization and misinformation in social networks
    Sikder, O.; Smith, R.E.; Vivo, P.; Livan, G.
  • From incivility to outrage: political discourse in blogs, talk radio, and cable news
    Sobieraj, S.; Berry, J.M.
  • What is political incivility?
    Stryker, R.; Conway, B.A.; Danielson, J.T.
  • Linking perceptions of role stress and incivility to workplace aggression: the moderating role of personality
    Taylor, S.G.; Kluemper, D.H.
  • Combating the challenges of social media hate speech in a polarized society: a Twitter ego lexalytics approach
    Udanor, C.; Anyanwu, C.C.
  • Identity and impoliteness in computer-mediated reader responses
    Upadhyay, S.R.
  • Socioeconomic status, social capital, and partisan polarity as predictors of political incivility on Twitter: a congressional district-level analysis
    Vargo, C.J.; Hopp, T.
  • Worldwide threats to the homeland. U.S. Senate
    Wray, C.