Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

When learning how to lead, an exploratory look at role models

When learning how to lead, an exploratory look at role models The purpose of this study is to identify who people indicate are their role models for learning how to lead and explore how demographic characteristics may affect these choices.Design/methodology/approachA global online survey, involving over 34,000 respondents, indicated, from a list of 14 possibilities, the role model category from whom they learned to lead. Respondents indicated their age, gender, ethnicity, nationality, educational level, hierarchical level and job function. Chi-square analysis was used to identify how these factors may have affected the choice of role models distribution.FindingsFamily member (parents, siblings and other family outside of the immediate family) was found to be the most important role model category when it came to learning how to lead. Ranked second was immediate supervisor/manager. The rank order in terms of frequency of role model choices was not substantially different across demographic characteristics, though there were statistically significant differences regarding the relative importance of the various role model categories by demographics.Research limitations/implicationsThe results offer plentiful opportunities for future scholars to delve more into both the nature and actions of role models, in keeping with social learning theory. Future scholars can investigate the nature of people's relationships with leadership role models, especially conceptualizing why and how various demographic factors affect how people learn to lead.Practical implicationsUnderstanding who people have as role models for what they have learned about leadership can provide important insights for those responsible for leadership development. Similarly, individuals who are in role model “positions” (e.g. parents, teachers, managers) can be more aware of how their behaviors have implications for how their audience learns what effective leadership looks like in action.Originality/valueThis study addressed a relatively unexplored area in the leadership literature, namely within what category of role model have people found to be most important in helping them learn to lead. The large and diverse sample, across a multitude of demographic characteristics, strengthens the generalizability of the findings. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Leadership & Organization Development Journal Emerald Publishing

When learning how to lead, an exploratory look at role models

Download PDF
17 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/when-learning-how-to-lead-an-exploratory-look-at-role-models-HUCLfa6DAe
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0143-7739
DOI
10.1108/lodj-05-2020-0191
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to identify who people indicate are their role models for learning how to lead and explore how demographic characteristics may affect these choices.Design/methodology/approachA global online survey, involving over 34,000 respondents, indicated, from a list of 14 possibilities, the role model category from whom they learned to lead. Respondents indicated their age, gender, ethnicity, nationality, educational level, hierarchical level and job function. Chi-square analysis was used to identify how these factors may have affected the choice of role models distribution.FindingsFamily member (parents, siblings and other family outside of the immediate family) was found to be the most important role model category when it came to learning how to lead. Ranked second was immediate supervisor/manager. The rank order in terms of frequency of role model choices was not substantially different across demographic characteristics, though there were statistically significant differences regarding the relative importance of the various role model categories by demographics.Research limitations/implicationsThe results offer plentiful opportunities for future scholars to delve more into both the nature and actions of role models, in keeping with social learning theory. Future scholars can investigate the nature of people's relationships with leadership role models, especially conceptualizing why and how various demographic factors affect how people learn to lead.Practical implicationsUnderstanding who people have as role models for what they have learned about leadership can provide important insights for those responsible for leadership development. Similarly, individuals who are in role model “positions” (e.g. parents, teachers, managers) can be more aware of how their behaviors have implications for how their audience learns what effective leadership looks like in action.Originality/valueThis study addressed a relatively unexplored area in the leadership literature, namely within what category of role model have people found to be most important in helping them learn to lead. The large and diverse sample, across a multitude of demographic characteristics, strengthens the generalizability of the findings.

Journal

Leadership & Organization Development Journal – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jun 23, 2021

Keywords: Leadership; Leadership role models; Learning leadership; Social learning theory; Family member; Immediate supervisor/manager; Generations; Gender; Ethnicity; Education; Position; Function

References

  • The two things your boss must do to set you up for success
    Allen, T.
  • A meta-analytic review of leadership impact in research: experimental and Quasi-experimental studies
    Avolio, B.J.; Reichard, R.J.; Hannah, S.T.; Walumbwa, F.O.; Chan, A.
  • Charisma and beyond
    Bass, B.M.; Avolio, B.
  • Managers account for 70% of variance in employee engagement
    Beck, R.; Harter, J.
  • Examining the relationship between role models and leadership growth during the transition to adulthood
    Bowers, J.R.; Rosch, D.M.; Collier, D.A.
  • Do role models matter? An investigation of role modeling as an antecedent of perceived ethical leadership
    Brown, M.E.; Trevino, L.K.
  • Leadership in schools: flowing from administrators to their students
    Caldwell, R.K.
  • How do we get new entrants ‘on board’? Organizational socialization, psychological contracts, and realistic job previews
    Ellis, A.M.; Bauer, T.N.; Chmiel, N.; Fraccaroli, F.; Sverke, M.
  • Leaders as role models and ‘belief managers’ in social dilemmas
    Gachter, S.; Renner, E.
  • Developing the professional self-concept: role model constructs in early, middle, and late career stages
    Gibson, D.E.
  • Role models in career development: new directions for theory and research
    Gibson, D.E.
  • Exploring the impact of role models on older employees
    Gibson, D.E.; Barron, L.A.
  • Effects of race on organizational experiences: job performance evaluations, and career outcomes
    Greenhaus, J.H.; Parasuraman, S.; Wormley, W.M.
  • Does nationality affect leadership style?
    Holmes, R.
  • Role model behavior and youth violence: a study of positive and negative effects
    Hurd, N.M.; Zimmerman, M.A.; Reischl, T.M.
  • Organizational entry, assimilation, and exit
    Jablin, F.M.; Jablin, F.M.; Putnam, L.L.; Roberts, K.H.; Porter, L.W.
  • Time and work: toward an integrative perspective
    Katz, R.; Staw, B.M.; Cummings, L.L.
  • Managers as role models for health: moderators of the relationship of transformational leadership with employee exhaustion and cynicism
    Kranabetter, C.; Niessen, C.
  • Learning to lead from the best
    Leimbach, M.
  • The dark side of leadership: a three-level investigation of the cascading effect of abusive supervision on employee creativity
    Liu, D.; Liao, H.; Loi, R.
  • Superstars and me: predicting the impact of role models on self
    Lockwood, P.; Kunda, Z.
  • The availability and helpfulness of socialization practices
    Louis, M.R.; Posner, B.Z.; Powell, G.N.
  • A trickle‐down model of abusive supervision
    Mawritz, M.B.; Mayer, D.M.; Hoobler, J.M.; Wayne, S.J.; Marinova, S.V.
  • Why are air jordans so popular?
    Mike
  • Role models and moral exemplars: how do employees acquire virtues by observing others?
    Moberg, D.J.
  • It's all a matter of consensus: leader role modeling strength as a moderator of the links between ethical leadership and employee outcomes
    Ogunfowora, B.
  • Gender differences in managers' developmental job opportunities
    Ohlott, P.J.; Ruderman, M.N.; McCauley, C.D.
  • How can parents inspire leadership?
    Polin, A.
  • Cutting edge examples of the Kouzes Posner leadership framework in diverse student settings
    Posner, B.Z.; Luckhow, L.D.W.; Ma, H.; Caldwell, R.K.
  • Does education matter for leadership?
    Rottman, J.
  • Assessing opportunities for leadership development
    Ruderman, M.N.; Ohlott, P.H.; McCauley, C.D.; Clark, K.E.; Clark, M.B.
  • Leadership and generations at work: a critical review
    Rudolph, C.W.; Rauvola, R.S.; Zacher, H.
  • Role models, work identity and senior women's career progression — why are role models important?
    Sealy, R.; Singh, V.
  • The importance of role models in the development of leaders' professional identities
    Sealy, R.; Singh, V.; James, K.T.; Collins, J.
  • Moving up: role models, mentors, and the ‘Patron system’
    Shapiro, E.C.; Haseltine, F.P.; Rowe, M.P.
  • The importance of parents as role models
    Steber, C.
  • Bad apples in bad barrels: a causal analysis of ethical decision-making behavior
    Trevino, L.K.; Youngblood, S.A.
  • Breaking the cycle: the effects of role model performance and ideal leadership self-concepts on abusive supervision spillover
    Tu, M.; Bono, J.E.; Shum, C.; LaMontagne, L.
  • If you're not helping people develop, you're not management material
    Valcour, M.
  • How do positive role models affect our youth and communities?
    Wise, R.
  • The honeywell studies: how managers learn to manage
    Zemke, R.