Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Using gay models in mainstream media: an expanded match-up hypothesis perspective

Using gay models in mainstream media: an expanded match-up hypothesis perspective To be successful, brands should incorporate diversity in their advertising strategy. One way is to demonstrate their support for the LGBTQI community in mainstream media. This study aims to examine situational factors that affect the responses to gay presenters in mainstream media.Design/methodology/approachTwo experimental studies were conducted in a 2 (luxury vs value brand) × 2 (gay vs heterosexual presenters) between-subjects design. Study 1 explores the interaction effects, whereas Study 2 introduces perceived congruence between the presenters and the product as a mediator.FindingsThe results show that using gay presenters in luxury brand ads leads to a more positive attitude toward the advertisement and higher product evaluation than using heterosexual presenters, whereas using heterosexual presenters to represent a value brand leads to a higher attitude and product evaluation than using gay presenters.Practical implicationsNowadays, there is a greater need for inclusiveness and diversity in advertising. Brands need to pay attention to various underrepresented groups and adapt their strategy accordingly. This study shows that in appropriate situations, gay presenters can improve the image of a brand among heterosexual as well as gay consumers.Originality/valueExpanding the match-up hypothesis theory, this work shows that a match can include not just an individual endorser but also the social category the endorser represents and stereotypical beliefs associated with that group. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Consumer Marketing Emerald Publishing

Using gay models in mainstream media: an expanded match-up hypothesis perspective

Download PDF
10 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/using-gay-models-in-mainstream-media-an-expanded-match-up-hypothesis-EC8riutp31
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0736-3761
eISSN
0736-3761
DOI
10.1108/jcm-02-2022-5179
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

To be successful, brands should incorporate diversity in their advertising strategy. One way is to demonstrate their support for the LGBTQI community in mainstream media. This study aims to examine situational factors that affect the responses to gay presenters in mainstream media.Design/methodology/approachTwo experimental studies were conducted in a 2 (luxury vs value brand) × 2 (gay vs heterosexual presenters) between-subjects design. Study 1 explores the interaction effects, whereas Study 2 introduces perceived congruence between the presenters and the product as a mediator.FindingsThe results show that using gay presenters in luxury brand ads leads to a more positive attitude toward the advertisement and higher product evaluation than using heterosexual presenters, whereas using heterosexual presenters to represent a value brand leads to a higher attitude and product evaluation than using gay presenters.Practical implicationsNowadays, there is a greater need for inclusiveness and diversity in advertising. Brands need to pay attention to various underrepresented groups and adapt their strategy accordingly. This study shows that in appropriate situations, gay presenters can improve the image of a brand among heterosexual as well as gay consumers.Originality/valueExpanding the match-up hypothesis theory, this work shows that a match can include not just an individual endorser but also the social category the endorser represents and stereotypical beliefs associated with that group.

Journal

Journal of Consumer Marketing – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jan 16, 2023

Keywords: Match-up hypothesis; Gay ads; Diversity; Luxury advertising

References

  • Stereotypes in persuasive communication: influence exerted by a disapproved source
    Abbate, C.S.; Boca, S.; Bocchiaro, P.
  • MTurk research: review and recommendations
    Aguinis, H.; Villamor, I.; Ramani, R.S.
  • Celebrity endorsements: a literature review and research agenda
    Bergkvist, L.; Zhou, K.Q.
  • The effect of homosexual imagery in advertising on attitude toward the ad
    Bhat, S.; Leigh, T.W.; Wardlow, D.L.
  • The effect of consumer prejudices on ad processing: heterosexual consumers' responses to homosexual imagery in ads
    Bhat, S.; Leigh, T.W.; Wardlow, D.L.
  • Gay stereotypes: the use of sexual orientation as a cue for gender-related attributes
    Blashill, A.J.; Powlishta, K.K.
  • The gay family in the ad: consumer responses to non-traditional families in marketing communications
    Borgerson, J.J.; Schroeder, J.; Blomberg, B.; Thorssén, E.
  • Rich, lavish, and trendy is lesbian consumers’ fashion shopping behaviour similar to gay’s? A comparative study of lesbian fashion consumption behaviour in Germany
    Braun, K.; Cleff, T.; Walter, N.
  • Seeing is eating: how and when activation of a negative stereotype increases stereotype-conducive behavior
    Campbell, M.C.; Mohr, G.S.
  • It is a match: the impact of congruence between celebrity image and consumer ideal self on endorsement effectiveness
    Choi, S.M.; Rifon, N.J.
  • When do subgroup parts add up to the stereotypic whole? Mixed stereotype content for gay male subgroups explains overall ratings
    Clausell, E.; Fiske, S.T.
  • Observations: understanding the world of international luxury brands: the ‘dream formula’
    Dubois, B.; Paternault, C.
  • Consumer responses to homosexual imagery in advertising: a meta-analysis
    Eisend, M.; Hermann, E.
  • Commercials with a gay emphasis are moving to mainstream media
    Elliot, S.
  • Celebrity endorsement: a literature review
    Erdogan, B.Z.
  • Endorser effectiveness by product type
    Friedman, H.H.; Friedman, L.
  • The broad embrace of luxury: hedonic potential as a driver of brand extendibility
    Hagtvedt, H.; Patrick, V.M.
  • Introduction to mediation
    Hayes, A.F.
  • Targeting without alienating: multicultural advertising and the subtleties of targeted
    Johnson, G.D.; Grier, S.A.
  • An investigation into the match-up-hypothesis in celebrity advertising: when beauty may be only skin deep
    Kamins, M.A.
  • Congruence between spokesperson and product type: a matchup hypothesis perspective
    Kamins, M.A.; Gupta, K.
  • An analysis of data quality: professional panels, student, subject pools, and amazon’s mechanical Turk
    Kees, J.; Berry, C.; Burton, S.; Sheehan, K.
  • Process of opinion change
    Kelman, H.C.
  • Do social media marketing activities enhance customer equity? An empirical study of luxury fashion brand
    Kim, A.J.; Ko, E.
  • Gender belief systems: homosexuality and the implicit inversion theory
    Kite, M.E.; Deaux, K.
  • Youtube bloggers' influence on consumer luxury brand perceptions and intentions
    Lee, J.E.; Watkins, B.
  • The matchup effect of spokesperson and product congruency: a schema theory interpretation
    Lynch, J.; Schuler, D.
  • Negotiating subcultural authenticity through interpretation of mainstream advertising
    Mikkonen, I.
  • The effect of novel attributes on product evaluation
    Mukherjee, A.; Hoyer, W.D.
  • Queer eye for a gay guy: using market-specific symbols in advertising to attract gay consumers without alienating the mainstream
    Oakenfull, G.K.; Greenlee, T.B.
  • Targeting a minority without alienating the majority: advertising to gays and lesbians in mainstream media
    Oakenfull, G.K.; McCarthy, M.S.; Greenlee, T.B.
  • The global divide on homosexuality persists
  • The effect of celebrity endorsers' perceived credibility on product purchase intention
    Pornpitakpan, C.
  • Consumer response to gay and lesbian imagery: how product type and stereotypes affect consumers’ perceptions
    Pounders, K.; Mabry-Flynn, A.
  • Two birds and one stone: purposeful polysemy in minority targeting and advertising evaluations
    Puntoni, S.; Vanhamme, J.; Visscher, R.
  • Same-sex couples in advertisements: an investigation of the role of implicit attitudes on cognitive processing and evaluation
    Read, G.L.; van Driel, I.; Potter, R.F.
  • Conspicuous consumption versus utilitarian ideas: how different levels of power shape consumer behavior
    Rucker, D.D.; Galinsky, A.D.
  • Logo announces list of top 25 LGBT-friendly companies
    Salandra, A.
  • The gay financial agenda isn't what you think it is
    Schneider, J.; Auten, D.
  • Sincere, not sinful: political ideology and the unique role of brand sincerity in shaping heterosexual and LGBTQ consumers' views of LGBTQ ads
    Shepherd, S.; Chartrand, T.L.; Fitzsimons, G.J.
  • The match-up hypothesis: physical attractiveness, expertise, and the role of fit on brand attitude, purchase intent and brand beliefs
    Till, B.D.; Busler, M.
  • Co-creating value for luxury brands
    Tynan, C.; Mckenchie, S.; Chuon, C.
  • Symbols or icons in gay-themed ads: how to target gay audience
    Um, N.H.; Kim, K.O.; Kwon, E.S.; Wilcox, D.
  • The marketing of luxury goods: an exploratory study – three conceptual dimensions
    Vickers, J.S.; Renand, F.
  • Measuring perceptions of brand luxury
    Vigneron, F.; Johnson, L.W.
  • Reinvestigating the endorser by product matchup hypothesis in advertising
    Wright, S.A.
  • The cognitive representation of persons and events
    Wyer, R.S.; Carlston, D.E.; Wyer, R.S.; Srull, T.K.
  • Connoisseurs of consumption: gay identities, and the commodification of knowledgable spending
    Yaksich, M.J.