Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

UK leisure centres under best value: a strategic analysis

UK leisure centres under best value: a strategic analysis Purpose – To understand the effects of the best value regime on the public provision of recreation at the level of the leisure centre. Design/methodology/approach – A strategic auditing device is applied to 87 leisure centres to investigate the strategic variables of environmental stability and attractiveness, service strengths and financial resources. The analysis produces a typology of leisure centres, and evaluates the prospects of each type under best value. Findings – The findings suggest that a large number of leisure centres managed by local authorities will make limited headway in implementing best value. What is more, many face problems that will be exacerbated, rather than eased, by current policy. Leisure centres managed by Trusts generally face more benign local environments, which appear to offer greater prospects, but it is clear that Trust status itself offers few advantages outside a greater range of financial sources. Research limitations/implications – The research focuses on strategic choices as they face leisure centre managers. It does not directly explore the strategic and policy decisions made at other levels. Practical implications – The paper argues for subtler recreation policy (and by implication, the provision of public sector services generally) that pays due regard to the local conditions of service providers. Policy that focuses only on general prescription of managerial (and often rhetorical) practices will frequently lead strategies towards satisficing performance indicators that may be arbitrary, rather than focusing on problems and issues as they face professional leisure managers. Originality/value – The use of a formal strategy tool as the level of a service provider is novel, and augments work on hybrid firms facing strategic choices based not only on political factors but also private sector market‐oriented competitors. Further, useful comparisons are made between leisure centres managed by Trusts and those still controlled by a Local Authority. The data provided will also help to inform practical and academic debates concerning the application of quality standards and management practices in the leisure sector. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png International Journal of Public Sector Management Emerald Publishing

UK leisure centres under best value: a strategic analysis

Download PDF
20 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/uk-leisure-centres-under-best-value-a-strategic-analysis-SrSaQ2J24v
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2005 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
0951-3558
DOI
10.1108/09513550510591515
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – To understand the effects of the best value regime on the public provision of recreation at the level of the leisure centre. Design/methodology/approach – A strategic auditing device is applied to 87 leisure centres to investigate the strategic variables of environmental stability and attractiveness, service strengths and financial resources. The analysis produces a typology of leisure centres, and evaluates the prospects of each type under best value. Findings – The findings suggest that a large number of leisure centres managed by local authorities will make limited headway in implementing best value. What is more, many face problems that will be exacerbated, rather than eased, by current policy. Leisure centres managed by Trusts generally face more benign local environments, which appear to offer greater prospects, but it is clear that Trust status itself offers few advantages outside a greater range of financial sources. Research limitations/implications – The research focuses on strategic choices as they face leisure centre managers. It does not directly explore the strategic and policy decisions made at other levels. Practical implications – The paper argues for subtler recreation policy (and by implication, the provision of public sector services generally) that pays due regard to the local conditions of service providers. Policy that focuses only on general prescription of managerial (and often rhetorical) practices will frequently lead strategies towards satisficing performance indicators that may be arbitrary, rather than focusing on problems and issues as they face professional leisure managers. Originality/value – The use of a formal strategy tool as the level of a service provider is novel, and augments work on hybrid firms facing strategic choices based not only on political factors but also private sector market‐oriented competitors. Further, useful comparisons are made between leisure centres managed by Trusts and those still controlled by a Local Authority. The data provided will also help to inform practical and academic debates concerning the application of quality standards and management practices in the leisure sector.

Journal

International Journal of Public Sector Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: May 1, 2005

Keywords: Strategic choices; Leisure facilities; Local authorities; United Kingdom

References

  • Audit Commission Performance Review in Local Government
    Audit Commission
  • Sport for Whom? Clarifying the Local Authority Role in Sport and Recreation
    Audit Commission
  • Changing Gear – Best Value: Annual Statement
    Audit Commission
  • Learning from Audit, Inspection and Research: Sport and Recreation
    Audit Commission
  • Looking inside for competitive advantage
    Barney, J.B.
  • Leisure research and its lack of relevance to planning management and policy formulation: a problem of major proportions
    Beaman, J.
  • The impact of best value on local authority performance: evidence from Welsh pilots
    Boyne, G.; Gold‐Williams, S.; Law, J.; Walker, R.
  • Best value: total quality management for local government?
    Boyne, G.; Gould‐Williams, S.; Law, J.; Walker, R.
  • Analytical frameworks for product marketing strategies
    Brownlie, D.
  • The PIMS Principle: Linking Strategy to Performance
    Buzzell, R.; Gale, B.
  • A vision for today: recreation and leisure services
    Carter, M.; Keller, M.; Beck, T.
  • Organisational structure, environment and performance
    Child, J.
  • Financial implications of major legislation
    Chisholm, M.
  • Sport in Society: Issues and Controversies
    Coakley, J.
  • Strategic analysis of the English football industry
    Cross, J.; Henderson, S.
  • Best Value Performance Plans: Practices and Procedures
    DETR
  • Local Government Act, Part 1, Best Value
    DETR
  • Improving Local Services through Best Value
    DETR
  • Modern Local Government – in Touch with the People
    DETR
  • Implementing Best Value – a Consultation Paper on Draft Guidance
    DETR
  • Marketing development in the leisure services, an empirical analysis
    Doherty, N.; Saker, J.; Smith, I.
  • Developing ‘appropriate’ marketing within the public leisure and library sectors: a comparative study
    Doherty, N.; Saker, J.; Smith, I.
  • Customer‐orientated public leisure services in the United Kingdom
    Guest, C.; Taylor, P.
  • The Politics of Leisure Policy
    Henry, I.
  • Leisure policy in Britain
    Henry, I.; Bramham, P.
  • Measuring customer service quality in sports and leisure centres
    Howat, G.; Adsher, J.; Crilley, C.; Milne, I.
  • Strategic management in hybrid organisations
    Joldersma, C.; Winter, V.
  • Just how new is best value?
    Keenan, J.
  • Untangling the tangibles: ‘physical evidence’ and customer satisfaction in UK leisure centres
    Lentell, R.
  • Customers’ views of the results of managing quality through ISO 9002 and Investors in People in leisure services
    Lentell, R.
  • The Impact of Sport for all Policy, 1966‐1984 and a Way Forward
    McIntosh, P.; Charlton, V.
  • Visions of best value: modernising or muddling through?
    Martin, S.
  • The modernization of UK local government: markets managers, monitors and mixed fortunes
    Martin, S.
  • Organisational Strategy, Structure and Process
    Miles, R.; Snow, C.
  • Impact of CCT on planning in leisure departments
    Nichols, G.
  • Reformulating the conceptualisation of marketing in the context of public leisure services
    Novatorov, E.; Crompton, J.
  • Competitive Strategy Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors
    Porter, M.
  • From competitive advantage to corporate strategy
    Porter, M.
  • The SPACE matrix: a tool for calibrating competition
    Radder, L.; Iouw, L.
  • Strategic management in smaller bio‐technology companies
    Ranchhod, A.; Henderson, S.
  • Public leisure provision and the good citizen
    Ravenscroft, N.
  • The changing regulation of public sector leisure provision
    Ravenscroft, N.
  • Barriers to total quality management in public sector services
    Robinson, L.
  • Following the quality strategy: the reasons for the use of quality management in UK public leisure facilities
    Robinson, L.
  • The performance of local authority sports halls and swimming pools in England
    Robinson, L.; Taylor, P.
  • Strategic Management: A Methodological Approach
    Rowe, A.; Mason, R.; Dickel, K.; Mann, R.; Mockler, R.
  • Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
    Rowling, J.K.
  • Fair Play: Violence and Sport in Society
    Ruskin, H.; Lammer, M.
  • Will best value survive?
    Stewart, J.
  • Performance measurements in English local authority sports facilities
    Taylor, P.; Godfrey, A.
  • Strategic Management Awareness and Change
    Thompson, J.
  • Effective marketing
    Torkildsen, G.
  • Leisure and Recreation Management
    Torkildsen, G.