Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Towards a contingency approach to performance measurement: an empirical study in Scottish SMEs

Towards a contingency approach to performance measurement: an empirical study in Scottish SMEs Purpose – The literature emphasizes the important role performance measurement systems (PMS) play in supporting organizational development in small and medium enterprises (SMEs). However, there are very few empirical and theoretical studies on the factors that influence performance measurement practices in SMEs. This paper aims to contribute to filling this gap using both theoretical and empirical approaches.Design/methodology/approach – A literature review and interviews were used to identify four key contingency factors for PMS in SMEs. A qualitative research design involving a multiple case study methodology was carried out to investigate how these factors influence performance measurement.Findings – The relationship between the contingency factors and performance measurement were formalized in four theoretical propositions. First corporate governance structure is one of the main factors influencing performance measurement adoption and use. Second, advanced information practices and advanced behaviours on the part of the people involved appear to be a necessary condition for the effective implementation and use of PMS in SMEs. Third, a change in a firm's business model seems to lead to the development of an improved PMS. Finally, the successful implementation of a PMS seems to be driven by an authoritative management style.Research limitations/implications – Contingency factors were studied independently. Future research might investigate how these factors collectively influence performance measurement practices to make interdependence more explicit.Practical implications – The theoretical propositions provide useful knowledge for defining a methodology and managerial tool to support performance measurement in SMEs.Originality/value – This paper defines key contingency factors influencing performance measurement in SMEs; it contributes to clarifying how these factors could influence performance measurement practices in companies. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png International Journal of Operations & Production Management Emerald Publishing

Towards a contingency approach to performance measurement: an empirical study in Scottish SMEs

Download PDF
24 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/towards-a-contingency-approach-to-performance-measurement-an-empirical-BdvboxiPod
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © Emerald Group Publishing Limited
ISSN
0144-3577
DOI
10.1108/01443570710763787
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – The literature emphasizes the important role performance measurement systems (PMS) play in supporting organizational development in small and medium enterprises (SMEs). However, there are very few empirical and theoretical studies on the factors that influence performance measurement practices in SMEs. This paper aims to contribute to filling this gap using both theoretical and empirical approaches.Design/methodology/approach – A literature review and interviews were used to identify four key contingency factors for PMS in SMEs. A qualitative research design involving a multiple case study methodology was carried out to investigate how these factors influence performance measurement.Findings – The relationship between the contingency factors and performance measurement were formalized in four theoretical propositions. First corporate governance structure is one of the main factors influencing performance measurement adoption and use. Second, advanced information practices and advanced behaviours on the part of the people involved appear to be a necessary condition for the effective implementation and use of PMS in SMEs. Third, a change in a firm's business model seems to lead to the development of an improved PMS. Finally, the successful implementation of a PMS seems to be driven by an authoritative management style.Research limitations/implications – Contingency factors were studied independently. Future research might investigate how these factors collectively influence performance measurement practices to make interdependence more explicit.Practical implications – The theoretical propositions provide useful knowledge for defining a methodology and managerial tool to support performance measurement in SMEs.Originality/value – This paper defines key contingency factors influencing performance measurement in SMEs; it contributes to clarifying how these factors could influence performance measurement practices in companies.

Journal

International Journal of Operations & Production Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jul 24, 2007

Keywords: Performance measurement (quality); Small to medium‐sized enterprises; Corporate governance; Management information systems; Organizational culture

References

  • Strategy, structure, planning and control systems and performance evaluation
    Archer, S.; Otley, D.T.
  • A new approach to performance measurement for small to medium enterprises
    Barnes, M.; Dickinson, T.; Coulton, L.; Dransfield, S.; Field, J.; Fisher, N.; Saunders, I.; Shaw, D.
  • Hofstede never studied culture
    Baskervillle, R.F.
  • Webcenter – Manuale buone pratiche
  • Organisational self‐assessment options: a classification and a conceptual map for SMEs
    Biazzo, S.; Bernardi, G.
  • Dynamics of performance measurement systems
    Bititci, U.S.; Turner, T.; Begemann, C.
  • Creating and managing value in collaborative networks
    Bititci, U.S.; Martinez, V.; Albores, P.; Parung, J.
  • Web enabled performance measurement systems: management implications
    Bititci, U.S.; Nudurupati, S.; Turner, T.; Creighton, S.
  • Dynamics of performance measurement and organisational culture
    Bititci, U.S.; Mendibil, K.; Nudurupati, S.; Garengo, P.; Turner, T.
  • Designing, implementing and updating performance measurement systems
    Bourne, M.; Mills, J.; Wilcox, M.; Neely, A.; Platts, K.
  • The success and failure of performance measurement initiatives: perceptions of participating managers
    Bourne, M.; Neely, A.; Platts, K.; Mills, J.
  • Driving blind: strategic decision‐making in small companies
    Brouthers, K.; Andriessen, F.; Nicolaes, I.
  • Research Methodology and Business Decision
    Buckley, J.W.; Buckley, M.H.; Chiang, H.F.
  • Strategic Organizational Diagnosis and Design
    Burton, R.M.; Obel, B.
  • Diagnosing and Changing Organizational Culture: Based on the Competing Values Framework
    Cameron, K.S.; Quinn, R.E.
  • Management control systems design within its organizational context: findings from contingency‐based research and directions for the future
    Chenhall, R.H.
  • The performance of information systems through organization culture
    Claver, E.; Llopis, J.; Gonzàlez, R.; Gascò, J.L.
  • Corporate governance in Italian family‐owned small firms
    Compagno, C.
  • The role of family in family business
    Corbetta, G.; Montemerlo, D.
  • Manufacturing strategy literature review and some issues
    Dangayach, G.S.; Deshmukh, S.G.
  • The New Performance Challenge: Measuring Operations for World Class Competition
    Dixon, J.R.; Nanni, A.J.; Vollmann, T.E.
  • Management Research, An Introduction
    Easterby‐Smith, M.; Thorpe, R.; Lowe, A.
  • Building theories from case‐study research
    Eisenhardt, K.
  • Factors that play a role in managing through measures
    Franco, M.; Bourne, M.
  • A framework to classify PMS adopted by SMEs: an empirical study of the Italian leading companies
    Garengo, P.
  • Performance measurement systems in SMEs: a review for a research agenda
    Garengo, P.; Biazzo, S.; Bititci, U.
  • Benchmarking on managerial practices: a tool for SMEs
    Garengo, P.; Biazzo, S.; Simonetti, A.; Bernardi, G.
  • Multiparadigm perspectives on theory building
    Gioia, D.A.; Pitre, E.
  • Management accounting systems, perceived environmental uncertainty and organization structure: an empirical investigation
    Gordon, L.A.; Narayanan, V.K.
  • Governance and flexibility in family‐owned SMEs
    Gubitta, P.; Gianecchini, M.
  • Management Information Systems for the Information Age
    Haag, S.; Cummings, M.; McCubbrey, D.J.
  • Organization, Culture and Quality of Service: A Strategy for Releasing Love in the Workplace
    Harrison, R.
  • Cross‐cultural research in management control systems design: a review of the current state
    Harrison, G.; McKinnon, J.
  • Culture's Consequences
    Hofstede, G.
  • A contingency model of the association between strategy, environmental uncertainty and performance measurement: impact on organizational performance
    Hoque, Z.
  • Linking balanced scorecard measures to size and market factors: impact on organizational performance
    Hoque, Z.; James, W.
  • Theory and practice in SME performance measurement systems
    Hudson, M.; Smart, P.A.; Bourne, M.
  • Quality strategy, strategic control systems, and organizational performance
    Ittner, C.D.; Larcker, D.F.
  • Innovations in performance measurement: trends and research implications
    Ittner, C.D.; Larcker, D.F.
  • The balanced scorecard: the measures that drive performance
    Kaplan, R.; Norton, D.
  • Using the balanced scorecard as a strategic management system
    Kaplan, R.; Norton, D.
  • A framework of the factors affecting the evolution of performance measurement systems
    Kennerley, M.; Neely, A.
  • Measuring performance in a changing business environment
    Kennerley, M.; Neely, A.
  • Management control: the roles of rules, markets and culture
    Lebas, M.; Weigenstein, J.
  • From balanced scorecard to strategic gauges: is measurement worth it?
    Lingle, J.H.; Schiemann, W.A.
  • Business performance measures and alignment impact on strategy: the role of business improvement models
    McAdam, R.; Bailie, B.
  • Why business model matter
    Magretta, J.
  • Understanding value creation: the value matrix and the value cube
    Martinez, V.
  • The value matrix and its evolution
    Martinez, V.; Bititci, U.
  • Theory building through conceptual methods
    Meredith, J.
  • The case for configuration
    Miller, D.; Minztzberg, H.
  • Chief executive personality and corporate strategy and structure in small firms
    Miller, D.; Toulouse, J.M.
  • Management accounting systems and organizational configuration: a life‐cycle perspective
    Moores, K.; Yuen, S.
  • Integrating performance measurement: management accounting to support the new manufacturing realities
    Nanni, A.J.; Dixon, J.R.; Vollman, T.E.
  • The performance measurement revolution: why now and what next?
    Neely, A.
  • The Performance Prism: The Scorecard for Measuring and Managing Stakeholder Relationship
    Neely, A.; Adams, C.; Kennerley, M.
  • Realising strategy through measurement
    Neely, A.; Mills, J.F.; Platts, K.W.; Gregory, M.J.; Richards, A.H.
  • From value chain to value constellation: design interactive strategy
    Normand, R.; Ramirez, R.
  • OECD Principles of Corporate Governance
    OECD
  • Performance management: a framework for management control systems research
    Otley, D.
  • Organizational Cultures. Types and Transformation
    Pheysey, D.C.
  • The impact of contingencies on managerial accounting systems development
    Reid, G.C.; Smith, J.B.
  • Strategy and accounting in a UK conglomerate
    Roberts, J.
  • An empirical investigation of the performance consequences of non financial measures
    Said, A.A.; Hassab, E.R.; Wier, B.
  • Organizational Culture and Leadership
    Schein, E.H.
  • Five stages of growth in small business
    Scott, M.; Bruce, R.
  • Information systems evaluation in practice: a case study of organizational change
    Serafeimidis, V.; Smithson, S.
  • Benchmarking performance management systems
    Sharif, A.M.
  • Linking quality strategy with management control systems: empirical evidence from Japanese industry
    Shirley, D.J.; Reitsperger, W.D.
  • The role of management control systems in creating competitive advantage: new perspectives
    Simons, R.
  • The Art of Case Study Research
    Stake, R.E.
  • Assumptions and values in the practice of information systems evaluation
    Stone, D.N.
  • The Disciplines of the Market Leaders
    Treacy, M.; Wiersema, F.
  • Case research in operational management
    Voss, C.; Tsikriktsis, N.; Frohlich, M.
  • The forces that shape organizational performance measurement systems: an interdisciplinary review
    Waggoner, D.B.; Neely, A.; Kennerley, M.P.
  • Case Study Research, Design and Methods
    Yin, R.K.
  • Board of directors and corporate financial performance: a review and integrative model
    Zahra, S.A.; Pearce, J.A.
  • Entrepreneurship in medium sized firm: exploring the effects of ownership and governance systems
    Zahra, S.A.; Neubaum, D.O.; Huse, M.