Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

“The wo‐men and the boys”: patterns of identification and differentiation in senior women executives' representations of career identity

“The wo‐men and the boys”: patterns of identification and differentiation in senior women... Research into “corporate masculinity” suggests that executive men position their difference, status and power through discourses which involve the strategies of “identification with some men and differentiation from others, including women”. While these processes apparently place women in an antithetical relationship to power, women are increasingly achieving executive leadership. This paper examines the career representations of 30 senior women executives. Drawing on a social constructionist approach to gender and identity, examines women's positioning of self within the discourse and discusses how they deal with the apparent paradoxes or contradictions of female identity within a world dominated by corporate masculinity. Our findings suggest that women engage in processes of identification and differentiation comparable to those of men. Perhaps unexpectedly, these processes often involve an assertion and celebration of female difference that includes distinctions between “the wo‐men and the boys”. They also involve a more tentative process of differentiation from corporate masculinity through the construction of an emerging new culture, the culture of women in business. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Women In Management Review Emerald Publishing

“The wo‐men and the boys”: patterns of identification and differentiation in senior women executives' representations of career identity

Su Olsson; Robyn Walker
Women In Management Review , Volume 19 (5): 8 – Jul 1, 2004
Download PDF
8 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/the-wo-men-and-the-boys-patterns-of-identification-and-differentiation-WtXLqq5LN5
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2004 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
0964-9425
DOI
10.1108/09649420410545962
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Research into “corporate masculinity” suggests that executive men position their difference, status and power through discourses which involve the strategies of “identification with some men and differentiation from others, including women”. While these processes apparently place women in an antithetical relationship to power, women are increasingly achieving executive leadership. This paper examines the career representations of 30 senior women executives. Drawing on a social constructionist approach to gender and identity, examines women's positioning of self within the discourse and discusses how they deal with the apparent paradoxes or contradictions of female identity within a world dominated by corporate masculinity. Our findings suggest that women engage in processes of identification and differentiation comparable to those of men. Perhaps unexpectedly, these processes often involve an assertion and celebration of female difference that includes distinctions between “the wo‐men and the boys”. They also involve a more tentative process of differentiation from corporate masculinity through the construction of an emerging new culture, the culture of women in business.

Journal

Women In Management Review – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jul 1, 2004

Keywords: Organizations; Women executives; Gender; Careers

References

  • Language as Symbolic Action: Essays on Life, Literature and Method
    Burke, K.
  • A Rhetoric of Motives
    Burke, K.
  • Narrating men as men: implications for work, organization and management
    Collinson, D.L.; Hearn, J.
  • Women in management
    Davidson, M.; Burke, R.
  • Gender as a Verb: Gender Segregation at Work
    Fitzsimons, A.
  • Contemporary Perspectives on Rhetoric
    Foss, S.K.; Foss, K.R.; Trapp, R.
  • Gender, Power and Organisations
    Halford, S.; Leonard, P.
  • Engineering selves: negotiating gender and identity in technical work
    Jorgenson, J.
  • Strategies for managing multiple organizational identifications: a case of competing identities
    Larson, G.S.; Pepper, G.L.
  • Gender cultures
    Maddock, S.; Parkin, D.
  • On the gendered substructure of organization: dimensions and dilemmas of corporate masculinity
    Maier, M.
  • Breaking through the ‘glass ceiling’: can linguistic awareness help?
    McConnell‐Ginet, S.
  • Rhetoric versus reality: a progress report on the rise of women's power in New Zealand
    McGregor, J.
  • Researching women and leadership: some comments on challenges and opportunities
    Marshall, J.
  • Talking about gender and career identities
    Marshall, H.; Wetherell, M.
  • Women executives: public and private sectors as sites of advancement?
    Olsson, S.; Pringle, J.K.
  • Through a gendered lens? Male and female executives' representations of one another
    Olsson, S.; Walker, R.
  • Discursive and Social Psychology
    Potter, J.; Wetherell, M.
  • Sites of hope and success? A cross‐perceptual study of executive women in the New Zealand public and private sectors
    Pringle, J.K.; Olsson, S.
  • Development of a structuration model of identification in organizations
    Scott, C.R.; Corman, S.R.; Cheney, G.
  • The Australian executive culture: heroes and women
    Sinclair, A.
  • Doing Leadership Differently: Gender, Power and Sexuality in a Changing Business Culture
    Sinclair, A.
  • Women's businesses: the flexible alternative workstyle for women
    Still, L.V.; Timms, W.
  • Forget Mars and Venus, let's get back to earth! Challenging gender stereotypes in the workplace
    Stubbe, M.; Holmes, J.; Vine, B.; Marra, M.
  • The position of women in management in Europe
    Vinnicombe, S.
  • Gender, Language and Discourse
    Weatherall, A.
  • Organizational Behaviour and Gender
    Wilson, F.