Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

The singular touchstone: the enduring relevance of The Evolution of Management Thought

The singular touchstone: the enduring relevance of The Evolution of Management Thought The purpose of this paper is to examine what qualities contributed to the durability of The Evolution of Management Thought (EMT) as a classic that provided scholars a grand narrative of management history for half a century. Specifically, this paper aspires to reveal how the EMT has overcome the boundedness of time over the past 50 years by being both timeless (signaling continuity/permanence) and historical (signaling change/contingency).Design/methodology/approachThe authors analyze both the metaphorical (i.e. universal) and the historical (i.e. particular) meanings that the EMT authors have communicated over eight editions of the classic.FindingsThe authors found that Wren and Bedeian have managed to balance temporality and referentiality in the EMT by writing it as the “practical past” of management. The authors also found that the authors ensured the ongoing renewal of their classic by innovating it as an everlasting contemporary text.Originality/valueThis paper provides an original analysis of the EMT explaining why it is a “classic” of management history. The analysis presented in this paper reveals why this timeless work has been a singular touchstone that exemplifies the history of management discipline. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Management History Emerald Publishing

The singular touchstone: the enduring relevance of The Evolution of Management Thought

Download PDF
17 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/the-singular-touchstone-the-enduring-relevance-of-the-evolution-of-RIM7to4CF0
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1751-1348
eISSN
1751-1348
DOI
10.1108/jmh-07-2022-0028
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to examine what qualities contributed to the durability of The Evolution of Management Thought (EMT) as a classic that provided scholars a grand narrative of management history for half a century. Specifically, this paper aspires to reveal how the EMT has overcome the boundedness of time over the past 50 years by being both timeless (signaling continuity/permanence) and historical (signaling change/contingency).Design/methodology/approachThe authors analyze both the metaphorical (i.e. universal) and the historical (i.e. particular) meanings that the EMT authors have communicated over eight editions of the classic.FindingsThe authors found that Wren and Bedeian have managed to balance temporality and referentiality in the EMT by writing it as the “practical past” of management. The authors also found that the authors ensured the ongoing renewal of their classic by innovating it as an everlasting contemporary text.Originality/valueThis paper provides an original analysis of the EMT explaining why it is a “classic” of management history. The analysis presented in this paper reveals why this timeless work has been a singular touchstone that exemplifies the history of management discipline.

Journal

Journal of Management History – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jan 16, 2023

Keywords: Evolution of management Thought; Wren; Bedeian; Classic

References

  • Managerial fads and fashions: the diffusion and rejection of innovations
    Abrahamson, E.
  • An a is an a’: the new bottom line for valuing academic research
    Aguinis, H.; Cummings, C.; Ramani, R.S.; Cummings, T.G.
  • Accounting for management and organizational history: strategies and conceptions
    Arseneault, R.; Deal, N.M.; Helms Mills, J.
  • Writing beyond time: the durability of historical texts
    Aurell, J.
  • What is a classic in history?
    Aurell, J.
  • EP Thompson, politics and history: writing social history fifty years after the making of the English working class
    Batzell, R.; Beckert, S.; Gordon, A.; Winant, G.
  • Management history thought
    Bedeian, A.G.
  • The gift of professional maturity
    Bedeian, A.G.
  • The historical universal: the role of cultural value in the historical sociology of Pierre Bourdieu
    Bennett, T.
  • The dynamics and spillovers of management interventions: evidence from the training within industry program
    Bianchi, N.; Giorcelli, M.
  • Management history in the modern world: an overview
    Bowden, B.; Bowden, B.; Muldoon, J.; Gould, A.; McMurray, A.
  • Elton Mayo and the deification of human relations
    Bruce, K.; Nyland, C.
  • Back to the future: can counterhistory accelerate theoretical advancement in management?
    Bylund, P.L.; Packard, M.D.
  • Wren, Daniel A. The evolution of management thought
    Chandler, A.D.
  • The denial of slavery in management studies
    Cooke, B.
  • Amodern and modern warfare in the making of a commercial airline
    Deal, N.M.; Mills, A.J.; Helms Mills, J.
  • History in the making: following the failed attempt of Wolfgang Langewiesche in pan American airways history project
    Deal, N.M.; Mills, A.J.; Helms Mills, J.; Durepos, G.; Hartt, C.M.
  • Taking an eventful historic turn down the cultural memory lane
    Deal, N.M.; Novicevic, M.M.; Mills, A.J.; Lugar, C.W.; Roberts, F.
  • Contextualizing the historian: an anti-history perspective
    Durepos, G.; Mills, A.J.; McLaren, P.G.; Bruce, K.
  • Developing critical organizational history: context, practice and implications
    Durepos, G.; Shaffner, E.C.; Taylor, S.
  • Review of the evolution of management thought, by wren, D.A. and Bedeian, A.G
    Fertig, J.
  • The new deal, history, and management and organization studies: constructing disciplinary actors and theories
    Foster, J.; Mills, A.J.; Weatherbee, T.G.
  • A first look at the first 30 years of the first division
    Greenwood, R.; Bowden, B.; Lamond, D.
  • The role of non-corporeal actant theory in historical research: a case study of Henry Wallace and the new deal
    Hartt, C.M.; Mills, A.J.; Helms Mills, J.
  • Review of the history of management thought
    Heald, M.; George, C.S.
  • Guest editorial
    Helms Mills, J.; Mills, A.J.
  • Towards advancing African management scholarship
    Ibeh, K.; Eyong, J.E.; Amaeshi, K.
  • Review of the evolution of management thought, by D.A. Wren
    Knowles, W.H.
  • Towards a philosophy of the history of thought?
    Kuukkanen, J.M.
  • Review of the history of management thought
    Litzinger, W.D.; George, C.S.
  • History and theory
    Lorenz, C.
  • A call to practice context in management and organization studies
    McLaren, P.G.; Durepos, G.
  • From the editors – new times, new histories of the business school
    McLaren, P.G.; Bridgman, T.; Cummings, S.; Lubinski, C.; O’Connor, E.; Spender, J.C.; Durepos, G.
  • Conceptualizing historical organization studies
    Maclean, M.; Harvey, C.; Clegg, S.R.
  • Review of the history of management thought
    Mahoney, T.A.; George, C.S.
  • The problem of generations
    Mannheim, K.; Kecskemetied, P.
  • ANTi-history of the functionalist paradigm in organization theory: using the lens of March and Simon’s organizations
    Mills, A.J.; Novicevic, M.M.; Roberts, F.
  • The Hawthorne legacy: a reassessment of the impact of the Hawthorne studies on management scholarship, 1930‐1958
    Muldoon, J.
  • The Hawthorne studies: an analysis of critical perspectives, 1936-1958
    Muldoon, J.
  • Stubborn things: evidence, postmodernism, and the craft of history
    Muldoon, J.
  • Conflicting visions: a recap about the debates within management history
    Muldoon, J.; Bowden, B.; Muldoon, J.; Gould, A.M.; McMurray, A.
  • Debates within management history
    Muldoon, J.; Bowden, B.; Muldoon, J.; Gould, A.M.; McMurray, A.
  • Where eagles dare: a discussion on the debates about management history
    Muldoon, J.
  • John Florio and the introduction of management into the English vocabulary
    Muldoon, J.; Marin, D.B.
  • Sailing away: the influences on and motivations of George Caspar Homans
    Muldoon, J.; Liguori, E.W.; Bendickson, J.
  • The past masters: the impact of the evolution of management thought on history
    Muldoon, J.; Deal, N.M.; Smith, D.; Lakshmikanth, G.S.
  • Revisiting perspectives on George Homans: correcting misconceptions
    Muldoon, J.; Liguori, E.W.; Bendickson, J.; Bauman, A.
  • Controversy as a non-corporeal actant in the community of management historians
    Novicevic, M.M.; Mills, A.J.; Hartt, C.M.
  • Decentering wren’s evolution of management thought
    Novicevic, M.M.; Jones, J.; Carrahar, S.; McLaren, P.G.; Mills, A.J.; Weatherbee, T.G.
  • Foucault’s iconic afterlife: the posthumous reach of words and things
    Partner, N.
  • Responding to crisis: World War 2, COVID‐19, and the business school
    Pattit, J.; Pattit, K.
  • What is a scholarly persona? Ten theses on virtues, skills, and desires
    Paul, H.
  • Introduction: post-concepts in historical perspective
    Paul, H.
  • The diffusion of management fads: a popularization perspective
    Pollach, I.
  • Women issues to wonder woman: contributions made by the students of Hugo Munsterberg
    Prieto, L.C.
  • Re-discovering Charles Clinton Spaulding’s ‘the administration of big business’: insight into early 20th century African-American management thought
    Prieto, L.C.; Phipps, S.T.
  • Toward a historical consciousness: following the historic turn in management thought
    Suddaby, R.
  • Theorizing with the help of the classics
    Swedberg, R.
  • What was a classic
    Tatum, J.
  • Frances Perkins: gender, context and history in the neglect of a management theorist
    Williams, K.S.; Mills, A.J.
  • Reassessing Bernard Bailyn's the ideological origins of the American revolution on the occasion of its jubilee
    Wood, G.S.
  • Review of the evolution of management thought, by D. A. Wren
    Woolf, D.A.
  • The historic (wrong) turn in management and organizational studies
    Bowden, B.