Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

The reading background of Goodreads book club members: a female fiction canon?

The reading background of Goodreads book club members: a female fiction canon? Despite the social, educational and therapeutic benefits of book clubs, little is known about which books participants are likely to have read. In response, the purpose of this paper is to investigate the public bookshelves of those that have joined a group within the Goodreads social network site.Design/methodology/approachBooks listed as read by members of 50 large English-language Goodreads groups – with a genre focus or other theme – were compiled by author and title.FindingsRecent and youth-oriented fiction dominate the 50 books most read by book club members, whilst almost half are works of literature frequently taught at the secondary and postsecondary level (literary classics). Whilst J.K. Rowling is almost ubiquitous (at least 63 per cent as frequently listed as other authors in any group, including groups for other genres), most authors, including Shakespeare (15 per cent), Goulding (6 per cent) and Hemmingway (9 per cent), are little read by some groups. Nor are individual recent literary prize winners or works in languages other than English frequently read.Research limitations/implicationsAlthough these results are derived from a single popular website, knowing more about what book club members are likely to have read should help participants, organisers and moderators. For example, recent literary prize winners might be a good choice, given that few members may have read them.Originality/valueThis is the first large scale study of book group members’ reading patterns. Whilst typical reading is likely to vary by group theme and average age, there seems to be a mainly female canon of about 14 authors and 19 books that Goodreads book club members are likely to have read. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Documentation Emerald Publishing

The reading background of Goodreads book club members: a female fiction canon?

Thelwall, Mike; Bourrier, Karen
Journal of Documentation , Volume 75 (5): 23 – Sep 12, 2019
Download PDF
23 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/the-reading-background-of-goodreads-book-club-members-a-female-fiction-ES6Ss4ggOc
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0022-0418
DOI
10.1108/jd-10-2018-0172
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Despite the social, educational and therapeutic benefits of book clubs, little is known about which books participants are likely to have read. In response, the purpose of this paper is to investigate the public bookshelves of those that have joined a group within the Goodreads social network site.Design/methodology/approachBooks listed as read by members of 50 large English-language Goodreads groups – with a genre focus or other theme – were compiled by author and title.FindingsRecent and youth-oriented fiction dominate the 50 books most read by book club members, whilst almost half are works of literature frequently taught at the secondary and postsecondary level (literary classics). Whilst J.K. Rowling is almost ubiquitous (at least 63 per cent as frequently listed as other authors in any group, including groups for other genres), most authors, including Shakespeare (15 per cent), Goulding (6 per cent) and Hemmingway (9 per cent), are little read by some groups. Nor are individual recent literary prize winners or works in languages other than English frequently read.Research limitations/implicationsAlthough these results are derived from a single popular website, knowing more about what book club members are likely to have read should help participants, organisers and moderators. For example, recent literary prize winners might be a good choice, given that few members may have read them.Originality/valueThis is the first large scale study of book group members’ reading patterns. Whilst typical reading is likely to vary by group theme and average age, there seems to be a mainly female canon of about 14 authors and 19 books that Goodreads book club members are likely to have read.

Journal

Journal of Documentation – Emerald Publishing

Published: Sep 12, 2019

Keywords: Gender; Goodreads; Book groups; Fiction authors; Fiction cannon; Fiction genres; Fiction reading; Reading groups

References

  • A novel alternative. Book groups, women, and workplace networking
    Alsop, R.
  • Ask me anything: what is Reddit?
    Anderson, K.E.
  • The structure of literary taste: class, gender and reading in the UK
    Atkinson, W.
  • Towards a new sociological model of fiction reading
    Birdi, B.; Ford, N.
  • The book people targets reading groups
  • A database of online book response and the nature of the literary thriller
    Boot, P.
  • The social lives of books: Goodreads and victorian literature for the twenty-first century
    Bourrier, K.; Thelwall, M.
  • The performance and construction of subjectivities of early adolescent girls in book club discussion groups
    Broughton, M.A.
  • Book clubs and reconciliation: a pilot study on book clubs reading the ‘fictions of reconciliation’
    Clarke, R.; Nolan, M.
  • Reading in community, reading for community: a survey of book clubs in regional Australia
    Clarke, R.; Hookway, N.; Burgess, R.
  • Illusions of a ‘Bond’: tagging cultural products across online platforms
    Desrochers, N.; Laplante, A.; Martin, K.; Quan-Haase, A.; Spiteri, L.
  • Faraway, so close: seeing the intimacy in Goodreads reviews
    Driscoll, B.; Rehberg Sedo, D.
  • Social class and cultural mobility: reconfiguring the cultural omnivore thesis
    Emmison, M.
  • ‘Reading as a contact sport’: online book groups and the social dimensions of reading
    Fister, B.
  • Online reading communities: from book clubs to book blogs
    Foasberg, N.M.
  • Searching for interreligious understanding: complex engagements with sameness and difference in an American women’s interfaith book group
    Gramstrup, L.K.
  • The ‘Oprahfication’ of literacy: reading ‘Oprah’s book club’
    Hall, R.M.
  • Feasibility and acceptability of active book clubs in cancer survivors – an explorative investigation
    Hammer, N.M.; Egestad, L.K.; Nielsen, S.G.; Bjerre, E.; Johansen, C.; Egerod, I.; Midtgaard, J.
  • Reading together: the role of the reading group inside prison
    Hartley, J.; Turvey, S.
  • How we developed a trainee-led book group as a supplementary education tool for psychiatric training in the 21st century
    Kan, C.; Harrison, S.; Robinson, B.; Barnes, A.; Chisolm, M.S.; Conlan, L.
  • Different stories: how levels of familiarity with literary and genre fiction relate to mentalizing
    Kidd, D.; Castano, E.
  • Using book club to engage culturally and linguistically diverse learners in reading, writing, and talking about books
    Kong, A.; Fitch, E.
  • Can Amazon.com reviews help to assess the wider impacts of books?
    Kousha, K.; Thelwall, M.
  • Literary socialization and reading preferences. Effects of parents, the library, and the school
    Kraaykamp, G.
  • Preferences in leisure time book reading: a study on the social differentiation in book reading for the Netherlands
    Kraaykamp, G.; Dijkstra, K.
  • The experience of older adults with sight loss participating in audio book groups
    Lang, C.; Brooks, R.
  • ‘Just don’t call it a book club’: boys’ reading experiences and motivation in school and in an after school book club
    Lattanzi, J.A.
  • Book group therapy: a survey reveals some truths about why some book groups work and others may need some time on the couch
    McArdle, M.
  • Fiction readers’ appreciation of text attributes in literary and popular novels: some empirical findings
    Miesen, H.
  • The borrowers: library records as unobtrusive measures of children’s reading preferences
    Moss, G.; McDonald, J.W.
  • The role of reading classic fiction in book groups for people with dementia is better understood through use of a qualitative feasibility study
    Muellenbach, J.M.
  • Examining the effects of classroom discussion on students’ comprehension of text: a meta-analysis
    Murphy, P.K.; Wilkinson, I.A.; Soter, A.O.; Hennessey, M.N.; Alexander, J.F.
  • Finding good reads on Goodreads: readers take RA into their own hands
    Naik, Y.
  • What is the best work of American fiction of the last 25 years?
  • Selecting fiction as part of everyday life information seeking
    Ooi, K.; Liew, C.
  • Beyond traditional publishing models: an examination of the relationships between authors, readers, and publishers.
    Pecoskie, J.; Hill, H.
  • Nordic democracy of taste? Cultural omnivorousness in musical and literary taste preferences in Finland
    Purhonen, S.; Gronow, J.; Rahkonen, K.
  • New study: 55% of YA books bought by adults
  • Book club: an alternative framework for reading instruction
    Raphael, T.E.; McMahon, S.I.
  • Peer reviewed: literary Alzheimer’s, a qualitative feasibility study of dementia-friendly book groups
    Rimkeit, B.S.; Claridge, G.
  • Dimensions of reading motivation and their relation to reading behavior and competence
    Schiefele, U.; Schaffner, E.; Möller, J.; Wigfield, A.
  • Using a book group to facilitate student learning about social work
    Scourfield, J.; Taylor, A.
  • Readers in reading groups: an online survey of face-to-face and virtual book clubs
    Sedo, D.R.
  • Talking about ‘real stuff’: explorations of agency and romance in an all-girls’ book club
    Smith, S.A.
  • A dialectic with the everyday: communication and cultural politics on Oprah Winfrey’s book club
    Striphas, T.
  • The omnivore thesis revisited: voracious cultural consumers
    Sullivan, O.; Katz-Gerro, T.
  • Reading groups and the language of literary texts: a case study in social reading
    Swann, J.; Allington, D.
  • Good for what? Non-appeal, discussability, and book groups (Part 1)
    Taylor, J.B.
  • Good for what? Non-appeal, discussability, and book groups (Part 2)
    Taylor, J.B.
  • The top 100 bestselling books of all time: how does Fifty Shades of Grey compare?
  • Book genre and author gender: romance>paranormal-romance to autobiography>memoir
    Thelwall, M.
  • Reader and author gender and genre in Goodreads
    Thelwall, M.
  • Goodreads: a social network site for book readers
    Thelwall, M.; Kousha, K.
  • Gender differences in research areas, methods and topics: can people and thing orientations explain the results?
    Thelwall, M.; Bailey, C.; Tobin, C.; Bradshaw, N.A.
  • Moderating readers and reading online
    Thomas, B.; Round, J.
  • Building on a firm foundation: readers’ advisory over the next twenty-five years
    Trott, B.
  • Doing time in college: student-prisoner reading groups and the object(s) of literary study
    Wiltse, E.
  • ‘Like a real friendship’: translation, coherence, and convergence of information values in librarything and Goodreads
    Worrall, A.
  • Altmetrics for the humanities: comparing Goodreads reader ratings with citations to history books
    Zuccala, A.A.; Verleysen, F.T.; Cornacchia, R.; Engels, T.C.