Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

The influence of real women in advertising on mass market fashion brand perception

The influence of real women in advertising on mass market fashion brand perception Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to investigate how the weight of ideal users affects the perception of mass market fashion brands. Design/methodology/approach – An experiment was carried out in which 640 university students replied to a web survey, rating the brand personality of jeans and shirts according to Aaker's Big Five construct. The garments were worn by thin, overweight, and obese models. Findings – The findings show that consumers’ impressions of mass market fashion brands are significantly affected by the weight of ideal users. Slender models lead to the most positive brand perception followed by obese models. Overweight user imagery is for pure fashion brand building the least attractive kind. Research limitations/implications – A limitation of this study is the use of convenient student samples. Consequently, the generalization of the results beyond this convenience sample may be limited. It is further possible, even probable, that high fashion would suffer more from the negative imagery of overweight and obese users than mass market fashion. It would therefore be interesting to replicate this experiment using clothes of higher fashion grade and price. Practical implications – The demonstrated effects of user imagery support the industry practice of slim ideal female imagery. Social implications – The results inform the debate over skinny models vs real women in advertising. Originality/value – Previous research regarding the effectiveness of real women in advertising has been inconclusive. This paper demonstrates not only that model weight affects consumers’ brand perception, but also how. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management Emerald Publishing

The influence of real women in advertising on mass market fashion brand perception

Ulf Aagerup
Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management , Volume 15 (4): 17 – Sep 20, 2011
Download PDF
17 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/the-influence-of-real-women-in-advertising-on-mass-market-fashion-2c6k2E9q5K
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2011 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
1361-2026
DOI
10.1108/13612021111169960
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to investigate how the weight of ideal users affects the perception of mass market fashion brands. Design/methodology/approach – An experiment was carried out in which 640 university students replied to a web survey, rating the brand personality of jeans and shirts according to Aaker's Big Five construct. The garments were worn by thin, overweight, and obese models. Findings – The findings show that consumers’ impressions of mass market fashion brands are significantly affected by the weight of ideal users. Slender models lead to the most positive brand perception followed by obese models. Overweight user imagery is for pure fashion brand building the least attractive kind. Research limitations/implications – A limitation of this study is the use of convenient student samples. Consequently, the generalization of the results beyond this convenience sample may be limited. It is further possible, even probable, that high fashion would suffer more from the negative imagery of overweight and obese users than mass market fashion. It would therefore be interesting to replicate this experiment using clothes of higher fashion grade and price. Practical implications – The demonstrated effects of user imagery support the industry practice of slim ideal female imagery. Social implications – The results inform the debate over skinny models vs real women in advertising. Originality/value – Previous research regarding the effectiveness of real women in advertising has been inconclusive. This paper demonstrates not only that model weight affects consumers’ brand perception, but also how.

Journal

Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: Sep 20, 2011

Keywords: Brand personality; User imagery; Fashion; Clothing; Women; Individual psychology

References

  • Building Strong Brands
    Aaker, D.A.
  • Dimensions of brand personality
    Aaker, J.L.
  • The malleable self: the role of self‐expression in persuasion
    Aaker, J.L.
  • Consumption symbols as carriers of culture: a study of Japanese and Spanish brand personality constructs
    Aaker, J.L.; Benet‐Martinez, V.; Garolera, J.
  • Nike jumps on ‘real women’ bandwagon
    Associated Press
  • Do brand personality scales really measure brand personality?
    Azoulay, A.; Kapferer, J.‐N.L.
  • The impact of physically attractive models on advertising evaluations
    Baker, M.J.; Churchill Jr, G.A.
  • Negative symbolic consumption and consumers’ drive for self‐esteem
    Banister, E.N.; Hogg, M.K.
  • Culture, the media, and eating disorders
    Becker, A.E.; Hamburg, R.
  • Fame, fortune, and the occasional branding misstep: when good celebrities go bad
    Behr, A.; Beeler‐Norrholm, A.
  • Student surrogates in consumer research
    Beltramini, R.F.
  • Real women on real beauty: self‐discrepancy, internalisation of the thin ideal, and perceptions of attractiveness and thinness in Dove's Campaign for real beauty
    Bissell, K.; Rask, A.
  • Undesired self‐image congruence in a low‐involvment product context
    Bosnjak, M.; Rudolph, N.
  • Is beauty best? Highly versus normally attractive models in advertising
    Bower, A.B.; Landreth, S.
  • Consumption of disposed goods for moral identities: a nexus of organization, place, things and consumers
    Brace‐Govan, J.; Binay, I.
  • The Sociology of Fashion
    Brenninkmeyer, I.
  • Designing research for application
    Calder, B.J.; Phillips, L.W.; Tybout, A.M.
  • Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences
    Cohen, J.
  • The applicability of cluster theory to Canada's small and medium‐sized apparel companies
    Constantine, C.; Steve, H.; Michael, J.; Richard, M.
  • Prejudice against fat people: ideology and self‐interest
    Crandall, C.S.
  • Are students real people?
    Cunningham Jr, W.H.; Thomas Jr, A.; John, H.M.
  • Advertisements: interpreting images used to sell to young adults
    Dana, A.; Kim, A.; Johnson, P.
  • From Brand Vision to Brand Evaluation
    De Chernatony, L.
  • Female body‐shape in print advertisements and the increase in anorexia nervosa
    Fay, M.; Price, C.
  • The effect and moderation of gender identity congruity: utilizing ‘real women’ advertising images
    Feiereisen, S.P.; Broderick, A.J.; Douglas, S.P.
  • How to Design and Report Experiments
    Field, A.P.; Hole, G.J.
  • Mannequins vs reality
    Grapentine, T.
  • Research Design
    Haberfeld, Y.
  • Does size matter? The impact of model's body size on women's body‐focused anxiety and advertising effectiveness
    Halliwell, E.; Dittmar, H.
  • The impact of advertisements featuring ultra‐thin or average‐size models on women with a history of eating disorders
    Halliwell, E.; Dittmar, H.; Howe, J.
  • The relationship between media consumption and eating disorders
    Harrison, K.; Cantor, J.
  • Dedicated Followers of Fashion. An Economic Geographic Analysis of the Swedish Fashion Industry. Department of Social and Economic Geography
    Hauge, A.
  • Female images in advertising: the implications of social comparison for marketing
    Hogg, M.K.; Bruce, M.; Hough, K.
  • Real women have curves, and ads
    Howard, T.
  • Value‐expressive versus utilitarian advertising appeals: when and why to use which appeal
    Johar, J.S.; Sirgy, M.J.
  • Physical attractiveness of the celebrity endorser: a social adaptation perspective
    Kahle, L.R.; Homer, P.M.
  • An investigation into the “match‐up” hypothesis in celebrity advertising: when beauty may be only skin deep
    Kamins, M.A.
  • Congruence between spokesperson and product type: a matchup hypothesis perspective
    Kamins, M.A.; Gupta, K.
  • Effects of human models on perceived product quality
    Kanungo, R.N.; Pang, S.
  • Personality and consumer behavior: a review
    Kassarjian, H.H.
  • Modeologi
    Kawamura, Y.
  • The brand report card
    Keller, K.L.
  • Strategic Brand Management – Building, Measuring, and Managing Brand Equity
    Keller, K.L.
  • Obesity and heart disease
    Keys, A.
  • A cross‐national investigation on how ethical consumers build loyalty toward fair trade brands
    Kim, G.‐S.; Lee, G.; Park, K.
  • Marketing research – an applied approach
    Kinnear, T.C.; Taylor, J.R.
  • Principles of Marketing
    Kotler, P.; Armstrong, G.
  • Women's responses to fashion media images: a study of female consumers aged 30 to 59
    Kozar, J.M.
  • Direct and indirect effects of self‐image congruence on brand loyalty
    Kressman, F.; Sirgy, M.J.; Herrmann, A.; Huber, F.; Huber, S.; Lee, D.‐J.
  • Social comparison and women's body satisfaction
    Lin, L.F.; Kulik, J.A.
  • Study finds real women don’t sell
    Lunau, K.
  • The matchup effect of spokesperson and product congruency: a schema theory interpretation
    Lynch, J.; Schuler, D.
  • Culture and Consumption – New Approaches to the Symbolic Character of Consumer Goods
    McCracken, G.
  • Elle magazine breaks fashion's last taboo: plus‐size models on the cover
    McVeigh, T.
  • A scale to measure self concepts, person concepts, and product concepts
    Malhotra, N.K.
  • How do consumers react to physically larger models? Effects of model body size, weight control beliefs and product type on evaluations and body perceptions
    Martin, B.A.S.; Xavier, R.
  • Unilever: don’t let beauty get too real
    Neff, J.
  • Study: Skinny Women Better for Bottom Line
    Neff, J.
  • Is it really ‘designer’? From budget to couture, the lowdown on categories
    Nellis, C.
  • External validity and the use of real people as subjects
    Oakes, W.
  • The undesired self: a neglected variable in personality research
    Ogilvie, D.M.
  • A comparison of brand personality and brand user‐imagery congruence
    Parker, B.T.
  • A meta‐analysis of effect sizes in consumer behavior experiments
    Peterson, R.A.; Albaum, G.; Beltramini, R.F.
  • Italian fashion bosses scupper deal aimed at halting ‘X‐ray look’
    Popham, P.
  • New insights about the FCB grid
    Ratchford, B.T.
  • Visual issues in marketing, management, and consumer research
    Schroeder, J.
  • Self concept in consumer behavior: a critical review
    Sirgy, M.J.
  • A path analytic model of store loyalty involving self‐concept, store image, geographic loyalty, and socioeconomic status
    Sirgy, M.J.; Samli, A.C.
  • The effects of thin and heavy media images on overweight and underweight consumers: social comparison processes and behavioral implications
    Smeesters, D.; Mussweiler, T.; Mandel, N.
  • The beauty match‐up hypothesis: congruence between types of beauty and product images in advertising
    Solomon, M.R.; Ashmore, R.D.; Longo, L.
  • How sexy illustrations affect brand recall
    Steadman, M.
  • Mode Svea – en genomlysning av området svensk modedesign. S. O. Utredningar
    Sundberg, G.
  • Brand personality: exploring the potential to move from factor analytical to circumplex models
    Sweeney, J.C.; Brandon, C.
  • The match‐up hypothesis: physical attractiveness, expertise, and the role of fit on brand attitude, purchase intent and brand beliefs
    Till, B.D.; Busler, M.
  • Living it up – Our Love Affair with Luxury
    Twitchell, J.B.
  • Real women campaign
    Ultimo
  • How Fashion Works – Couture, Ready‐To‐Wear & Mass Production
    Waddell, G.
  • WHO Consultation on Obesity
    WHO
  • Personality: theory and perspectives
    Wilderdom
  • Real women of Wonderbra
    Wonderbra Website
  • Obesity and women ‐I: a closer look at the facts
    Wooley, S.C.; Wooley, O.W.
  • Response to activewear apparel advertisements by US baby boomers: an examination of cognitive versus chronological age factors
    Wray, A.Z.; Hodges, N.N.