Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

The elephant in the dark: the social origins of research in nonprofit financial management

The elephant in the dark: the social origins of research in nonprofit financial management The purpose of this paper is twofold. The first is to map the most influential literature in nonprofit finance and financial management. The second is to understand why the literature has evolved the way it has, including isolated silos developing in certain disciplines.Design/methodology/approachThe review includes articles assembled from three sources: a core list, an expert list and journal archive searches on phrases that emerged. Using social origins theory as a guide, we coded 119 articles for traits such as root discipline, methodology and author characteristics.FindingsResearch tends to stay confined within the doctoral discipline of the author, who publishes in journals valued by their discipline. This has caused limited cross-referencing across disciplines, and it has allowed different understandings and judgments of the same phenomenon to exist in different fields. Data availability drives much of the research agenda, but author teams of mixed disciplines are promising.Originality/valueUnlike a traditional literature review, this study identifies factors that have had a formative influence on the development of the diverse field of nonprofit finance and financial management. This diversity has resulted in a fractured field held in silos with few indigenous developments. Using social origins theory as a guide, this study provides an overview of the most consequential literature through the analysis of authors and institutional characteristics. This approach provides an evolutionary perspective and illustrates how this disciplinary adherence has created a research topography that limits progress for both scholars and practitioners. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management Emerald Publishing

The elephant in the dark: the social origins of research in nonprofit financial management

Download PDF
24 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/the-elephant-in-the-dark-the-social-origins-of-research-in-nonprofit-XHdMzdDm8S
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1096-3367
DOI
10.1108/jpbafm-04-2020-0048
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is twofold. The first is to map the most influential literature in nonprofit finance and financial management. The second is to understand why the literature has evolved the way it has, including isolated silos developing in certain disciplines.Design/methodology/approachThe review includes articles assembled from three sources: a core list, an expert list and journal archive searches on phrases that emerged. Using social origins theory as a guide, we coded 119 articles for traits such as root discipline, methodology and author characteristics.FindingsResearch tends to stay confined within the doctoral discipline of the author, who publishes in journals valued by their discipline. This has caused limited cross-referencing across disciplines, and it has allowed different understandings and judgments of the same phenomenon to exist in different fields. Data availability drives much of the research agenda, but author teams of mixed disciplines are promising.Originality/valueUnlike a traditional literature review, this study identifies factors that have had a formative influence on the development of the diverse field of nonprofit finance and financial management. This diversity has resulted in a fractured field held in silos with few indigenous developments. Using social origins theory as a guide, this study provides an overview of the most consequential literature through the analysis of authors and institutional characteristics. This approach provides an evolutionary perspective and illustrates how this disciplinary adherence has created a research topography that limits progress for both scholars and practitioners.

Journal

Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: Oct 15, 2021

Keywords: Nonprofit finance; Nonprofit financial management; Social origins

References

  • Organisational capacity and enterpreneurial behavior in nonprofit organizations: an empirical exploration
    Andersson, F.O.
  • The making of ‘professional amateurs’: professionalizing the voluntary work of service user representatives
    Andreassen, T.A.; Breit, E.; Legard, S.
  • Do government grants to private charities crowd out giving or fund-raising?
    Andreoni, J.; Payne, A.A.
  • Schools and communities: ecological and institutional dimensions
    Arum, R.
  • Nonprofit competition in the grants marketplace
    Ashley, S.; Faulk, L.
  • Toward a new metrics for the evaluation of the social added value of social enterprises
    Bassi, A.; Vincenti, G.
  • Engaged or divorced? Cross-service findings on government relations with non-state service-providers
    Batley, R.
  • Financial ratios as predictors of failure
    Beaver, W.H.
  • Nonprofit organizations in the mixed economy: a demand and supply analysis
    Ben-ner, A.; Van Hoomissen, T.
  • Surviving mission drift: how charities can turn dependence on government contract funding to their own advantage
    Bennett, R.; Savani, S.
  • On the provate provision of public goods
    Bergstrom, T.; Blume, L.; Varian, H.
  • The exemption of nonprofit organizations from federal income taxation
    Bittker, B.I.; Rahdert, G.K.
  • Asset composition
    Bowman, W.; Calabrese, T.; Searing, E.A.M.
  • Should donors care about overhead costs? Do they care?
    Bowman, W.
  • Corporate linkages and organizational environment: a test of the resource dependence model
    Boyd, B.
  • Do government subsidies to nonprofits crowd out donations or donors?
    Brooks, A.C.
  • Borrowing for the public good the growing importance of tax-exempt bonds for public charities
    Calabrese, T.D.; Ely, T.L.
  • Testing competing capital structure theories of nonprofit organizations
    Calabrese, T.D.
  • Running on empty: the operating reserves of US nonprofit organizations
    Calabrese, T.D.
  • Revenue diversification in nonprofit organizations: does it lead to financial stability?
    Carroll, D.A.; Stater, K.J.
  • Do higher property tax rates increase the market share of nonprofit hospitals?
    Chang, C.F.; Tuckman, H.P.
  • Financial vulnerability and attrition as measures of nonprofit performance
    Chang, C.F.; Tuckman, H.P.
  • Revenue diversification among non-profits
    Chang, C.F.; Tuckman, H.P.
  • Adoption and use of the Hirshman-Herfindahl Index in nonprofit research: does revenue diversification measurement matter?
    Chikoto, G.L.
  • French NGOs in the global era: professionalization ‘without borders’?
    Cumming, G.
  • Skills are not enough: the case for journalism as an academic discipline
    De Burgh, H.
  • Taxation of nonprofit associations in an international comparison
    Dehne, A.; Friedrich, P.; Chang, W.; Nam; Parsche, R.
  • The sociology of nonprofit organizations and sectors
    Dimaggio, P.J.; Anheier, H.K.
  • Synthesizing and extending resource dependence theory: a meta-analysis
    Drees, J.M.; Heugens, P.P.
  • Resource dependence, economic performance, and political stability
    Dunning, T.
  • The marketization of the nonprofit sector: civil society at risk?
    Eikenberry, A.; Drapal Kluver, J.
  • Public borrowing for private organizations: costs and structure of tax‐exempt debt through conduit issuers
    Ely, T.L.; Calabrese, T.D.
  • The double‐edged sword of social service contracting: public accountability versus nonprofit autonomy
    Ferris, J.M.
  • Diversification of revenue strategies: evolving resource dependence in nonprofit organizations
    Froelich, K.A.
  • The governance self-assessment checklist: an instrument for assessing board effectivemess
    Gill, M.; Flynn, R.J.; Reissing, E.D.
  • Not-for-profit entrepreneurs
    Glaeser, E.L.; Shleifer, A.
  • Thirty years of social accounting, reporting and auditing: what (if anything) have we learnt?
    Gray, R.
  • The social accounting project and accounting organizations and society privileging engagement, imaginings, new accountings and pragmatism over critique?
    Gray, R.
  • Predicting the financial vulnerability of charitable organizations
    Greenlee, J.S.; Trussel, J.M.
  • Understanding collaboration among nonprofit organizations: combining resource dependency, institutional, and network perspectives
    Guo, C.; Acar, M.
  • When government becomes the principal philanthropist: the effects of public funding on patterns of nonprofit governance
    Guo, C.
  • Disciplinary departures and discipline formation: the institutional rationale
    Gupta, S.
  • Tales from the grave: organizations' accounts of their own demise
    Hager, M.; Galaskiewicz, J.; Bielefeld, W.; Pins, J.
  • Financial vulnerability among arts organizations: a test of the Tuckman-Chang measures
    Hager, M.A.
  • Resource dependence theory: a review
    Hillman, A.J.; Withers, M.C.; Collins, B.J.
  • A cross-disciplinary exploration of entrepreneurship research
    Ireland, D.; Webb, J.W.
  • How nonprofits grow: a model
    James, E.
  • The multiple sources of mission drift
    Jones, M.B.
  • Government funding and fundraising: an online experiment of nonprofit leader preferences and personality
    Kim, M.; Mason, D.P.
  • Federal income and state property tax exemption of commercialized nonprofits: should profit-seeking art museums be tax exempt
    Kosaras, A.
  • The influence of mergers on firms' product‐mix strategies
    Krishnan, R.A.; Joshi, S.; Krishnan, H.
  • Anatomy of the nonprofit starvation cycle: an analysis of falling overhead ratios in the nonprofit sector
    Lecy, J.D.; Searing, E.A.M.
  • Charity, philanthropy, public service, or enterprise: what are the big questions of nonprofit management today?
    Lohmann, R.
  • Lessons from resource dependence theory for contemporary public and nonprofit management
    Malatesta, D.; Smith, C.R.
  • A deficit model of collaborative governance: government-nonprofit fiscal relations in the provision of child welfare services
    Marwell, N.P.; Calabrese, T.D.
  • When cities go broke: a conceptual introduction to municipal bankruptcy
    McConnell, M.W.; Picker, R.C.
  • Silo
    Merriam-Webster
  • Operating in two worlds: tandem structures in social enterprise
    Mittermaier, I.; Neugart, J.
  • Accounting for the value of volunteer contributions
    Mook, L.; Sousa, J.; Elgie, S.; Quarter, J.
  • The changing role of private, nonprofit organizations in the development and delivery of human services in the United States
    Norris-Tirrell, D.
  • Nonprofit and for-profit partnerships: rationale and challenges of cross-sector contracting
    O'Regan, K.M.; Oster, S.M.
  • The coevolution of institutional entrepreneurship: a tale of two theories
    Pacheco, D.F.; York, J.G.; Dean, T.J.; Sarasvathy, S.D.
  • The not-for-profit hospital as a physicians' cooperative
    Pauly, M.; Redisch, M.
  • Organizational context and the characteristics and tenure of hospital administrators
    Pfeffer, J.; Salancik, G.R.
  • Do hospitals earn their nonprofit status? Evidence from New Hampshire in 2012
    Plante, C.; Ragland, L.
  • Contracting and patterns of nonprofit governance
    Saidel, J.R.; Harlan, S.L.
  • Social origins of civil society: explaining the nonprofit sector cross-nationally
    Salamon, L.M.; Anheier, H.K.
  • The social origins of civil society: explaining vairations in the size and structure of the global civil society sector
    Salamon, L.M.; Sokołowski, C.W.
  • Mission impossible?: Measuring success in nonprofit organizations
    Sawhill, J.C.; Williamson, D.
  • The state of nonprofit finance research across disciplines
    Schatteman, A.M.; Waymire, T.R.
  • Determinants of the recovery of distressed nonprofits
    Searing, E.A.M.
  • Government/third-sector relationship in a comparative perspective: in the cases of France and West Germany
    Seibel, W.
  • What happens on a rainy day? How nonprofit human service leaders create, maintain, and utilize operating reserves
    Sloan, M.F.; Grizzle, C.; Kim, M.
  • Why and where do academics publish?
    Starbuck, W.H.
  • The revealed objective functions of nonprofit firms
    Steinberg, R.
  • Administrative growth and grant payouts in nonprofit foundations: fulfilling the public good amid professionalization?
    Stewart, A.J.; Faulk, L.
  • Resource constraints or cultural conformity? Nonprofit relationships with businesses
    Suárez, D.F.; Hwang, H.
  • Collaboration and professionalization: the contours of public sector funding for nonprofit organizations
    Suárez, D.F.
  • Nonprofit fund-raising in competitive donor markets
    Thornton, J.
  • When is administrative efficiency associated with charitable donations?
    Tinkelman, D.; Mankaney, K.
  • How well is debt managed by nonprofits?
    Tuckman, H.P.; Chang, C.F.
  • Intended and unintended consequenses of a publish-or-perish culture: a worldwide survey
    Van Dalen, H.; Henkens, K.
  • Agents or stewards: using theory to understand the government-nonprofit social service contracting relationship
    Van Slyke, D.M.
  • A goal programming model for capital investment analysis in nonprofit hospitals
    Wacht, R.; Whitford, D.
  • Increasing fundraising efficiency through evaluation: applying communication theory to the nonprofit organization—donor relationship
    Waters, R.D.
  • How does program composition affect the revenues of nonprofit organizations?: Investigating a benefits theory of nonprofit finance
    Wilsker, A.L.; Young, D.R.
  • Institutional theories of organization
    Zucker, L.G.