Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

The Crown land accounting dilemma in New South Wales local government

The Crown land accounting dilemma in New South Wales local government The paper addresses the question of whether Crown land managed by local authorities in the New South Wales (NSW) local government system should be recognised as assets on municipal balance sheets.Design/methodology/approachThe paper provides a synoptic review of the literature on accounting for public goods assets followed by a critical analysis of the official requirements of the NSW government on the recognition of Crown land.FindingsThe NSW government holds that Crown land managed by local councils should be recognised as an asset on council books. However, following an assessment of the problem through the analytical prism of financial accounting, it is argued that councils do not possess control over Crown land and that such land should thus not be recognised by councils.Research limitations/implicationsThe paper covers the legal and accounting framework applicable to NSW local government. However, it has broader implications for other local government systems with similar institutional and legislative foundations, such as other Australian states, New Zealand and South Africa, and these implications are highlighted in the paper.Practical implicationsIt is argued that NSW government policymakers should re-consider the requirement for Crown land to be recognised on councils' books. Local authorities would then be able to save money and time on external auditing, management of land asset registers and the mandatory valuation of land.Originality/valueAlthough Crown land shares some of the characteristics of other public good assets, unique accounting challenges arise due to the existence of a market in which such land could be traded not by councils, but by its legal owner (the Crown). In financial accounting, legal ownership is not considered as the main criterion over assets. However, the authors argue that for Crown land vested with councils, it becomes a critical factor in decision making. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management Emerald Publishing

The Crown land accounting dilemma in New South Wales local government

Download PDF
16 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/the-crown-land-accounting-dilemma-in-new-south-wales-local-government-jxcvdLocuA
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1096-3367
DOI
10.1108/jpbafm-01-2021-0014
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The paper addresses the question of whether Crown land managed by local authorities in the New South Wales (NSW) local government system should be recognised as assets on municipal balance sheets.Design/methodology/approachThe paper provides a synoptic review of the literature on accounting for public goods assets followed by a critical analysis of the official requirements of the NSW government on the recognition of Crown land.FindingsThe NSW government holds that Crown land managed by local councils should be recognised as an asset on council books. However, following an assessment of the problem through the analytical prism of financial accounting, it is argued that councils do not possess control over Crown land and that such land should thus not be recognised by councils.Research limitations/implicationsThe paper covers the legal and accounting framework applicable to NSW local government. However, it has broader implications for other local government systems with similar institutional and legislative foundations, such as other Australian states, New Zealand and South Africa, and these implications are highlighted in the paper.Practical implicationsIt is argued that NSW government policymakers should re-consider the requirement for Crown land to be recognised on councils' books. Local authorities would then be able to save money and time on external auditing, management of land asset registers and the mandatory valuation of land.Originality/valueAlthough Crown land shares some of the characteristics of other public good assets, unique accounting challenges arise due to the existence of a market in which such land could be traded not by councils, but by its legal owner (the Crown). In financial accounting, legal ownership is not considered as the main criterion over assets. However, the authors argue that for Crown land vested with councils, it becomes a critical factor in decision making.

Journal

Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: Apr 26, 2022

Keywords: Local government; Accounting; Control; Crown land

References

  • A trusteeship theory of accounting for natural capital assets
    Barton, D.A.
  • Land under roads – a financial Bonanza of fool's gold
    Barton, D.A.
  • Who controls world heritage listed assets?
    Burritt, R.; Gibson, K.
  • Promoting accountability in municipalities
    Carnegie, G.D.
  • Observing the PSASB ED 50 and the recognition of infrastructure assets
    Carnegie, G.; West, B.
  • The financial value of cultural, heritage and scientific collections: an accounting fiction
    Carnegie, G.D.; Wolnizer, P.W.
  • Enabling accountability in museums
    Carnegie, G.D.; Wolnizer, P.W.
  • Unravelling the rhetoric about the financial reporting of public collections as assets
    Carnegie, G.; Wolnizer, P.
  • Highlights of the 30 November 2020 council meeting
  • Definition of the reporting entity
    Challen, D.; Jeffery, C.
  • Inconsistent depreciation practice and public policymaking: local government reform in New South Wales
    Drew, J.; Dollery, B.E.
  • Less haste, more speed: the fit for the future reform program in New South Wales local government
    Drew, J.; Dollery, B.E.
  • The debate that had to happen but never did: the changing role of Australian local government
    Dollery, B.E.; Wallis, J.L.; Allan, P.
  • Land under roads and the power of politic
    Elhawary, H.M.A.
  • All for nothing? Accounting for land under roads by Australian local governments
    Elhawary, H.M.A.; West, B.
  • Accounting for heritage assets: does measuring economic value ‘kill the cat’?
    Ellwood, S.; Greenwood, M.
  • The financial value of cultural, heritage and scientific collections: a public management Necessity
    Hone, P.
  • Rationality, accountability reform and accounting for land under roads in an Australian local government
    Hoque, Z.
  • Condition-based depreciation – the engineering perspective
    Howe, S.
  • Defining the reporting entity in the not-for-profit public sector: implementation issues associated with the control test
    Howieson, B.
  • Accounting problems in infrastructure asset valuation and depreciation in New South Wales local government
    Ivannikov, I.; Dollery, B.
  • Mind your accruals: perceived usefulness of financial information in the Australian public sector under different accounting systems
    Kober, R.; Lee, J.; Ng, J.
  • (NSW) (Austl)
  • Financial reporting of cultural, heritage, scientific and community collections
    Micallef, F.; Peirson, G.
  • Annual report 2019–20
  • Circular No. 08-07, Valuation of property plant and equipment at fair value, Circular 08-07
  • Merger myths: a functional analysis of scale economies in New South Wales local government
    Pallot, J.
  • Accounting for land under roads: accounting issues for valuers
    Rowles, T.; Hutton, B.; Bellamy, S.
  • Heritage reporting by the Australian public sector. Possibilities from concepts of new public governance
    Woon, P.P.; Chatterjee, B.; Cordery, C.J.