Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

The commons problem in the presence of negative externalities

The commons problem in the presence of negative externalities While the commons problem and the issues related to the negative externalities of harvesting have been studied extensively, there remains a need to bridge these two streams of studies to comprehensively investigate the implications of the strategic interactions among resource harvesters in the presence of such negative externalities. This paper aims to fill this gap.Design/methodology/approachThe authors study a common-pool harvest problem when the extractive activities leave behind negative externalities which affect the resource growth rate and reduce the stock beyond the extracted levels. Markov perfect noncooperative and optimal solutions are presented under different scenarios regarding considerations of negative externalities into harvest decisions.FindingsResults of the study suggest that, in the presence of such externalities, all parties must scale down their extraction in accordance with their externalities. The resource can be preserved by implementation of such harvest rule. However, failure to incorporate the externalities exacerbates the commons problem and can even lead to exhaustion of the biomass even if countries manage to cooperate and coordinate their harvest. Suggesting that if such externalities are large enough – which empirical literature suggests they are – then recognition and consideration of these externalities in the harvest decisions is as crucial as cooperation.Originality/valueThis paper provides a framework that is capable of incorporating the negative externalities of harvest activities into a bioeconomic game theoretic model and thereby providing a more real-world representation of the state of the common-pool resource management. While, the authors extend a well-known simple model, the model of this research study has the capacity to explain the widespread incidences of resource collapses. Therefore, the important policy implication is that agents should rigorously work together to understand the extent of the negative externalities of their harvests on the resources. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Economic Studies Emerald Publishing

The commons problem in the presence of negative externalities

Masoudi, Nahid; Bowie, Donique
Journal of Economic Studies , Volume 48 (8): 20 – Oct 29, 2021
Download PDF
20 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/the-commons-problem-in-the-presence-of-negative-externalities-0EDnRPt0Vl
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0144-3585
DOI
10.1108/jes-07-2020-0340
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

While the commons problem and the issues related to the negative externalities of harvesting have been studied extensively, there remains a need to bridge these two streams of studies to comprehensively investigate the implications of the strategic interactions among resource harvesters in the presence of such negative externalities. This paper aims to fill this gap.Design/methodology/approachThe authors study a common-pool harvest problem when the extractive activities leave behind negative externalities which affect the resource growth rate and reduce the stock beyond the extracted levels. Markov perfect noncooperative and optimal solutions are presented under different scenarios regarding considerations of negative externalities into harvest decisions.FindingsResults of the study suggest that, in the presence of such externalities, all parties must scale down their extraction in accordance with their externalities. The resource can be preserved by implementation of such harvest rule. However, failure to incorporate the externalities exacerbates the commons problem and can even lead to exhaustion of the biomass even if countries manage to cooperate and coordinate their harvest. Suggesting that if such externalities are large enough – which empirical literature suggests they are – then recognition and consideration of these externalities in the harvest decisions is as crucial as cooperation.Originality/valueThis paper provides a framework that is capable of incorporating the negative externalities of harvest activities into a bioeconomic game theoretic model and thereby providing a more real-world representation of the state of the common-pool resource management. While, the authors extend a well-known simple model, the model of this research study has the capacity to explain the widespread incidences of resource collapses. Therefore, the important policy implication is that agents should rigorously work together to understand the extent of the negative externalities of their harvests on the resources.

Journal

Journal of Economic Studies – Emerald Publishing

Published: Oct 29, 2021

Keywords: Fishery; Common-pool resources; Dynamic games; Resource extraction; The tragedy of the commons; Negative externality; C70; Q20; Q22

References

  • Sharing a fish resource - bioeconomic analysis of an applied allocation rule
    Armstrong, C.W.
  • The impacts of mobile fishing gear on seafloor habitats in the Gulf of Maine (Northwest Atlantic): implications for conservation of fish populations
    Auster, P.J.; Malatesta, R.J.; Langton, R.W.; Watting, L.; Valentine, P.C.; Donaldson, C.L.S.; Langton, E.W.; Shepard, A.N.; Babb, W.G.
  • Application of game theory to fisheries over three decades
    Bailey, M.; Sumaila, U.R.; Lindroos, M.
  • Reconstructing the lionfish invasion: insights into Greater Caribbean biogeography
    , Betancur‐R, R.; Hines, A.; Acero, P.A.; Ortí, G.; Wilbur, A.E.; Freshwater, D.W.
  • Predators lack complementarity in a degraded stream
    Boeckman, K.R.; Whiteman, H.H.
  • A Great Fish War model with asymmetric players
    Breton, M.; Keoula, M.Y.
  • Ghost fishing in European waters: impacts and management responses
    Brown, J.; Macfadyen, G.
  • Management of the Argentine Hake
    Cauhépé, M.E.
  • Impacts of lost fishing gear on coral reef sessile invertebrates in the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary
    Chiappone, M.; Dienes, H.; Swanson, D.W.; Miller, S.L.
  • A century of fish biomass decline in the ocean
    Christensen, V.; Coll, M.; Piroddi, C.; Steenbeek, J.; Joe, B.; Pauly, D.
  • Shifting gears: assessing collateral impacts of fishing methods in US waters
    Chuenpagdee, R.; Morgan, L.E.; Maxwell, S.M.; Norse, E.A.; Pauly, D.
  • Overexploiting marine ecosystem engineers: potential consequences for biodiversity
    Coleman, F.C.; Williams, S.L.
  • Harvesting the commons
    Dasgupta, P.; Mitra, T.; Sorger, G.
  • Defining and estimating global marine fisheries bycatch
    Davies, R.W.D.; Cripps, S.J.; Nickson, A.; Porter, G.
  • Coral reef cascades and the indirect effects of predator removal by exploitation
    Dulvy, N.K.; Freckleton, R.P.; Polunin, N.V.C.
  • Fishing technology and optimal distribution of harvest rates
    Escapa, M.; Prellezo, R.
  • A review of bioeconomic modelling of habitat-fisheries interactions
    Foley, N.S.; Armstrong, C.W.; Kahui, V.; Mikkelsen, E.; Reithe, S.
  • Ghost nets hurting marine environment
    Food and Agriculture Organization
  • The state fisheries and aquaculture in the world 2018
    Food and Agriculture Organization
  • Global ecological impacts of invasive species in aquatic ecosystems
    Gallardo, B.; Clavero, M.; Sánchez, M.I.; Vilà, M.
  • Crayfish invading Europe: the case study of Procambarus clarkii
    Gherardi, F.
  • Game theory and fisheries
    Grønbœk, L.; Lindroos, M.; Munro, G.; Pedro, P.
  • Game theory and fisheries
    Hannesson, R.
  • Coral reefs in crisis
    Hinrichsen, D.
  • When fishermen save seals
    Johnson, W.M.; Karamanlidis, A.A.
  • Fishing on cold water coral reefs: a bioeconomic model of habitat-fishery connections
    Kahui, V.; Armstrong, C.W.
  • Catches in ‘ghost fishing’ set nets
    Kaiser, M.J.; Bullimore, B.; Newman, P.; Lock, K.; Gilbert, S.
  • 12 impacts of fishing gear on marine benthic habitats
    Kaiser, M.J.; Collie, J.S.; Hall, S.J.; Jennings, S.; Poiner, I.R.
  • An estimation of compliance of the fisheries of Argentina with Article 7 (Fisheries Management) of the un code of conduct for responsible fishing
    Kalikoski, D.C.; Cunha Vasconcellos, M.; Tony Pitcher
  • Evidence that the great pacific garbage patch is rapidly accumulating plastic
    Lebreton, L.; Slat, B.; Ferrari, F.; Sainte-Rose, B.; MarthouseAitken, R.J.; Hajbane, S.; Cunsolo, S.; Schwarz, A.; Levivier, A.; Noble, K.; Debeljak, P.; Maral, H.; Schoeneich-Argent, R.; Brambini, R.; Reisser, J.
  • The great fish war: an example using a dynamic Cournot–Nash solution
    Levhari, D.; Mirman, L.J.
  • Understanding impacts of fisheries bycatch on marine megafauna
    Lewison, R.L.; Crowder, L.B.; Read, A.J.; Freeman, S.A.
  • Overfishing reduces resilience of kelp beds to climate-driven catastrophic phase shift
    Ling, S.D.; Johnson, C.R.; Frusher, S.D.; Ridgway, K.R.
  • Indirect effects of overfishing on Caribbean reefs: sponges overgrow reef-building corals
    Loh, T.-L.; McMurray, S.E.; Henkel, T.P.; Jan, V.; Pawlik, J.R.
  • Resource exploitation in a stochastic horizon under two parametric interpretations
    López-Barrientos, J.D.; Gromova, E.V.; Miroshnichenko, E.S.
  • Abandoned, Lost or Otherwise Discarded Fishing Gear
    Macfadyen, G.; Huntington, T.; Cappell, R.
  • Fishery externalities and biodiversity: trade-offs between the viability of shrimp trawling and the conservation of Frigatebirds in French Guiana
    Martinet, V.; Blanchard, F.
  • Resource extraction under heterogeneous growth in demand
    Masoudi, N.; Santugini, M.
  • A review of ghost fishing: scientific approaches to evaluation and solutions
    Matsuoka, T.; Nakashima, T.; Nagasawa, N.
  • Aquaculture
  • The conservation and management of shared fish stocks: legal and economic aspects
    Munro, G.; Van Houtte, A.; Rolf, W.
  • Why do fish stocks collapse? the example of cod in Atlantic Canada
    Myers, R.A.; Hutchings, J.A.; Barrowman, N.J.
  • Effect of aquaculture on world fish supplies
    Naylor, R.L.; Goldburg, R.J.; Primavera, J.H.; Kautsky, N.; Malcolm, C.; Beveridge, M.; Clay, J.; Folke, C.; Jane Lubchenco; Mooney, H.; Troell, M.
  • North pacific right whale
  • Small-scale fisheries bycatch jeopardizes endangered Pacific loggerhead turtles
    Peckham, S.H.; Diaz, D.M.; Walli, A.; Ruiz, G.; Crowder, L.B.; Nichols, W.J.
  • How does fishing alter marine populations and ecosystems sensitivity to climate?
    Planque, B.; Fromentin, J.-M.; Cury, P.; Drinkwater, K.F.; Jennings, S.; Ian Perry, R.; Kifani, S.
  • Objectionable algae with reference to the killing of fish and other animals
    Prescott, G.W.
  • Strategic harvesting of age-structured populations
    Quaas, M.F.; Tahvonen, O.
  • Responses of benthic scavengers to fishing disturbance by towed gears in different habitats
    Ramsay, K.; Kaiser, M.J.; Hughes, R.N.
  • Environmental restoration of invaded ecosystems: how much versus how often?
    Ranjan, R.
  • Bycatch of marine mammals in US and global fisheries
    Read, A.J.; Drinker, P.; Simon, N.
  • Cascading effects of overfishing marine systems
    Scheffer, M.; Carpenter, S.; de Young, B.
  • Effects of fishing within UK European marine sites: guidance for Nature Conservation Agencies
    Sewell, J.; Hiscock, K.
  • Why study bycatch? an introduction to the theme section on fisheries bycatch
    Soykan, C.U.; Moore, J.E.; Zydelis, R.; Crowder, L.B.; Safina, C.; Lewison, R.L.
  • The effects of fishing on sharks, rays, and chimaeras (chondrichthyans), and the implications for marine ecosystems
    Stevens, J.D.; Bonfil, R.; Dulvy, N.K.; Walker, P.A.
  • Sustainability of elasmobranchs caught as bycatch in a tropical prawn (shrimp) trawl fishery
    Stobutzki, I.C.; Miller, M.J.; Heales, D.S.; Brewer, D.T.
  • Regional fishery organizations: how and why organizational diversity matters
    Sydnes, A.K.
  • The great pacific garbage patch
  • Fish as food: aquaculture's contribution: ecological and economic impacts and contributions of fish farming and capture fisheries
    Tidwell, J.H.; Allan, G.L.
  • Fishing impacts and the degradation or loss of habitat structure
    Turner, S.J.; Thrush, S.F.; Hewitt, J.E.; Cummings, V.J.; Funnell, G.
  • Dynamite fishing in Sierra Leone. Naga
    Vakily, J.M.
  • Disturbance of the seabed by mobile fishing gear: a comparison to forest clearcutting
    Watling, L.; Norse, E.A.
  • Dynamite fishing in northern Tanzania–pervasive, problematic and yet preventable
    Wells, S.