Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Structure and performance of the Italian alpine “core”: a counterfactual analysis

Structure and performance of the Italian alpine “core”: a counterfactual analysis The competitiveness of the Alpine regions is strongly influenced by environmental constraints and its relationship with the urban network in the valley floor, which cannot be one of pure dependence. This study aims to analyse the health of the Italian Alpine economy through the performance of its capital companies, defined as those operating in the strictly mountainous are-as within the territories covered by the Alpine Convention. The authors compare the performance (2012-2018) of the “inner core” firms with a counterfactual sample of companies from neighbouring territories to delineate the strengths and weaknesses of the Alpine enterprises. The paper addresses policymakers and practitioners who will design the future policies for the high lands, exploiting a vast collaborative planning network.Design/methodology/approachThe study analyses two broad strands of literature on territorial competitiveness. It uses the coarsened exact matching techniques for the selection of a counterfactual sample at the enterprise level. The study follows a policy-oriented design, offering answers to future challenges.FindingsThe Alpine region has several different local production systems, with a significant level of heterogeneity among firms that differentiate the top 25% from the rest. The counterfactual analysis carried out does not provide clear evidence of significant differences. Instead, it con-firms strong similarities between the Alpine core and the peri-Alpine belt. It is only in terms of employment growth that the core grows less (with a high statistical significance). Finally, the authors introduce the analysis of sustainable value added (SVA) in the core area and use the “tourism chain” to compare different models. The focus here is on two keywords – rarefied and uncontaminated – that enable the transformation of some typical weaknesses of the “minor (or marginal) mountain” into assets for development, provided that place-based and network policies are activated.Research limitations/implicationsThe study focusses on the Italian Alps and could be extended in the future to the other countries participating in the Alpine Convention. It may also be enriched by qualitative analyses of partnerships and sole proprietorships that are not identified by the balance sheet analysis.Practical implicationsThe study follows a policy-oriented design, offering possible solutions to future challenges.Social implicationsThe study offers some suggestions on the post-COVID-19 phase. The bottom-up, reluctant and community dimension are possible strengths to face the challenges that are opening up.Originality/valueThe study is one of the very few to carry out a counterfactual analysis of Alpine enterprises. It offers evidence on the strengths and weaknesses of the productive fabric of the high lands and updates the assessment of the health status of Alpine enterprises to accompany future fact-based policies after the COVID pandemic. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Worldwide Hospitality and Tourism Themes Emerald Publishing

Structure and performance of the Italian alpine “core”: a counterfactual analysis

Download PDF
21 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/structure-and-performance-of-the-italian-alpine-core-a-counterfactual-nfJu2YlOiw
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1755-4217
eISSN
1755-4217
DOI
10.1108/whatt-05-2020-0026
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The competitiveness of the Alpine regions is strongly influenced by environmental constraints and its relationship with the urban network in the valley floor, which cannot be one of pure dependence. This study aims to analyse the health of the Italian Alpine economy through the performance of its capital companies, defined as those operating in the strictly mountainous are-as within the territories covered by the Alpine Convention. The authors compare the performance (2012-2018) of the “inner core” firms with a counterfactual sample of companies from neighbouring territories to delineate the strengths and weaknesses of the Alpine enterprises. The paper addresses policymakers and practitioners who will design the future policies for the high lands, exploiting a vast collaborative planning network.Design/methodology/approachThe study analyses two broad strands of literature on territorial competitiveness. It uses the coarsened exact matching techniques for the selection of a counterfactual sample at the enterprise level. The study follows a policy-oriented design, offering answers to future challenges.FindingsThe Alpine region has several different local production systems, with a significant level of heterogeneity among firms that differentiate the top 25% from the rest. The counterfactual analysis carried out does not provide clear evidence of significant differences. Instead, it con-firms strong similarities between the Alpine core and the peri-Alpine belt. It is only in terms of employment growth that the core grows less (with a high statistical significance). Finally, the authors introduce the analysis of sustainable value added (SVA) in the core area and use the “tourism chain” to compare different models. The focus here is on two keywords – rarefied and uncontaminated – that enable the transformation of some typical weaknesses of the “minor (or marginal) mountain” into assets for development, provided that place-based and network policies are activated.Research limitations/implicationsThe study focusses on the Italian Alps and could be extended in the future to the other countries participating in the Alpine Convention. It may also be enriched by qualitative analyses of partnerships and sole proprietorships that are not identified by the balance sheet analysis.Practical implicationsThe study follows a policy-oriented design, offering possible solutions to future challenges.Social implicationsThe study offers some suggestions on the post-COVID-19 phase. The bottom-up, reluctant and community dimension are possible strengths to face the challenges that are opening up.Originality/valueThe study is one of the very few to carry out a counterfactual analysis of Alpine enterprises. It offers evidence on the strengths and weaknesses of the productive fabric of the high lands and updates the assessment of the health status of Alpine enterprises to accompany future fact-based policies after the COVID pandemic.

Journal

Worldwide Hospitality and Tourism Themes – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jun 23, 2020

Keywords: Counterfactual analysis; Small villages; Structural policies; Mountain competitiveness

References

  • Our vision for 2030. Alpine food heritage as a lever for sustainable development in peripheral Mountain areas
  • Greening the economy in the alpine region
  • Mountain Agriculture
  • Più che resilienza, antifragilità
    Blečic, I.; Cecchini, A.
  • Piccole italie
    Borghi, E.
  • SLo sviluppo territoriale nell’economia della conoscenza: teorie, attori, strategie
    Bramanti, A.; Salone, C.
  • The forms of territorial collaboration: experiences, limits and prospects
    Bramanti, A.; Ratti, R.
  • Strategie di sviluppo, enti locali, capitale umano. Le sfide dell’innovazione per il futuro degli enti locali: Il caso del friuli venezia giulia
    Bramanti, A.; Rosso, P.
  • Challenges for the degrowth transition: the debate about well-being
    Büchs, M.; Koch, M.
  • La realtà aumentata dei piccoli comuni
  • Resilienza territoriale e politiche per la competitività: la Lombardia nella programmazione 2007-2013
    Dal Bianco, A.; Fratesi, U.
  • The institutionalisation of Mountain regions in Europe
    Debarbieux, B.; Price, M.F.; Balsiger, J.
  • Montagna e aree interne nelle politiche di coesione territoriale italiane ed europee
    Dematteis, G.
  • Servizi vitali per un territorio
  • Come cambiano i rapporti città–montagna
  • Overview: tourism sustainability in the Alpine region: the major trends and challenges
    Dornier, R.; Mauri, C.
  • Il futuro del turismo in alto adige 2030
  • Resilience: the emergence of a perspective for Social-Ecological systems analyses
    Folke, C.
  • Rapporto Montagne Italia 2017
  • Produrre paesaggio: patrimonio e contesto territoriale delle denominazioni geografiche agroalimentari. Il caso studio del Piemonte
    Gottero, E.
  • Causal inference without balance checking: coarsened exact matching
    Iacus, S.M.; King, G.; Porro, G.
  • Resilienza economica e resilienza sociale: una analisi delle regioni italiane dopo la crisi del 2007
    Martini, B.
  • The spatial dimension of productivity: Connecting the dots across industries, firms and places
  • Towns in the Alps
    Perlik, M.; Messerli, P.; Bätzing, W.
  • I contratti di transizione ecologica
    Poli, D.
  • La resilienza territoriale: un concetto polisemico per lo sviluppo delle scienze regionali
    Rizzi, P.
  • Landscape change in the European Mountain areas. Settlement of the alps: evolution and trajectories
    Romano, B.; Zullo, F.
  • Adattarsi per resiliere: nuovi approcci metodologici ed evidenze empiriche micro territoriali
    Sottrici, F.
  • Eusalp and the challenge of multilevel governance policies in the alps
    Teston, F.; Bramanti, A.
  • A definition of mountains and their bioclimatic belts for global comparisons of biodiversity data
    Körner, C.; Paulsen, J.; Spehn, E.M.
  • Matching to remove bias in observational studies
    Rubin, D.B.