Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Spaces of active disengagement across the food retail shop floor

Spaces of active disengagement across the food retail shop floor The article challenges the narrow view in scholarship which presents disengagement as passive and simply the absence of condition of engagement and explores how food retail employees articulate their disengagement within the intensified customer-centric service work. The article adopts the term “active disengagement”, as presented by Ackroyd and Thompson (2016) and empirically examines this as a form of oppositional voice towards managerial norms and behavioural expectations.Design/methodology/approachThe article draws on qualitative data from two case study organisations in the Cypriot food retail sector. Forty-six interviews took place with participants across different departments, including front-line employees and front-line and senior managers, to better understand the research problem through different perspectives.FindingsThe data show that disengagement is an integral part of organisational life and it is expressed in an individual and less-risky way. The data also reveal a variation in disengagement actions across departments, depending on employees' mobility on the shop floor and the intensity of interaction with the customers and the line manager. Shop floor employees enjoyed a wider “space of disengagement”, in comparison to those working on the front-end/checkouts. Nevertheless, checkout employees have developed sophisticated actions to express disengagement.Research limitations/implicationsThis research provides a refined understanding of active disengagement in organisations. It empirically contributes to the existence of a spectrum of engagement and expands Ackroyd and Thompson's (2016) “active disengagement” framework, discussing it as a form of oppositional voice towards corporate values and the customer-centric work intensification.Practical implicationsThe research provides empirical evidence that employee disengagement is not merely the absence of engagement, as HRM scholars and practitioners have argued, but entails further social meanings. This article will be useful for practitioners to rethink, revisit and revise employee engagement programmes in organisations, as well as to re-write corporate values, mission and vision, to also consider employees' experiences within the workplace. This will allow the provision of social support by management to address active disengagement in service organisations.Originality/valueThe study provides an important insight in employees' individual actions to express disengagement towards corporate values and managerial expectations related to customer service. It highlights the variation of dynamics across the food retail shop floor, which has been treated as a contextual periphery within the disengagement debate. Applying a broader lens on retail work heterogeneity, it provides further understanding of the diversity of how frontline service workers express disengagement within the triadic employment relationship. This study offers ground for future research to examine active disengagement in various contexts for better conceptual and practical understanding of this behaviour in organisations. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Employee Relations: An International Journal Emerald Publishing

Spaces of active disengagement across the food retail shop floor

Download PDF
16 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/spaces-of-active-disengagement-across-the-food-retail-shop-floor-DUe5jsII9p
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0142-5455
DOI
10.1108/er-03-2021-0096
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The article challenges the narrow view in scholarship which presents disengagement as passive and simply the absence of condition of engagement and explores how food retail employees articulate their disengagement within the intensified customer-centric service work. The article adopts the term “active disengagement”, as presented by Ackroyd and Thompson (2016) and empirically examines this as a form of oppositional voice towards managerial norms and behavioural expectations.Design/methodology/approachThe article draws on qualitative data from two case study organisations in the Cypriot food retail sector. Forty-six interviews took place with participants across different departments, including front-line employees and front-line and senior managers, to better understand the research problem through different perspectives.FindingsThe data show that disengagement is an integral part of organisational life and it is expressed in an individual and less-risky way. The data also reveal a variation in disengagement actions across departments, depending on employees' mobility on the shop floor and the intensity of interaction with the customers and the line manager. Shop floor employees enjoyed a wider “space of disengagement”, in comparison to those working on the front-end/checkouts. Nevertheless, checkout employees have developed sophisticated actions to express disengagement.Research limitations/implicationsThis research provides a refined understanding of active disengagement in organisations. It empirically contributes to the existence of a spectrum of engagement and expands Ackroyd and Thompson's (2016) “active disengagement” framework, discussing it as a form of oppositional voice towards corporate values and the customer-centric work intensification.Practical implicationsThe research provides empirical evidence that employee disengagement is not merely the absence of engagement, as HRM scholars and practitioners have argued, but entails further social meanings. This article will be useful for practitioners to rethink, revisit and revise employee engagement programmes in organisations, as well as to re-write corporate values, mission and vision, to also consider employees' experiences within the workplace. This will allow the provision of social support by management to address active disengagement in service organisations.Originality/valueThe study provides an important insight in employees' individual actions to express disengagement towards corporate values and managerial expectations related to customer service. It highlights the variation of dynamics across the food retail shop floor, which has been treated as a contextual periphery within the disengagement debate. Applying a broader lens on retail work heterogeneity, it provides further understanding of the diversity of how frontline service workers express disengagement within the triadic employment relationship. This study offers ground for future research to examine active disengagement in various contexts for better conceptual and practical understanding of this behaviour in organisations.

Journal

Employee Relations: An International Journal – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jan 2, 2023

Keywords: Customer service; Food retail; Service work; Active disengagement; Employee engagement; Organisational misbehaviour

References

  • Work disengagement: a review of the literature
    Afrahi, B.; Blenkinsopp, J.; Fernandez de Arroyabe, J.C.; Karim, M.S.
  • Investigating the antecedents of work disengagement in the workplace
    Aslam, U.; Muqadas, F.; Imran, M.K.; Rahman, U.U.
  • Service employee burnout and engagement: the moderating role of power distance orientation
    Auh, S.; Menguc, B.; Spyropoulou, S.; Wang, F.
  • Employee disengagement from the perspective of frontline employees: a hotel case study in Zimbabwe
    Bhebhe, M.
  • The punctuation of mundane jobs with extreme work: christmas at the supermarket deli counter
    Bozkurt, Ö.
  • ‘It's like a war zone’: jay's liminal experience of normal and extreme work in a UK supermarket during the COVID-19 pandemic
    Cai, M.; Tindal, S.; Tartanoglu Bennett, S.; Velu, J.
  • Customers' perceptions of employee engagement: fortifying the service–profit chain
    Cain, L.; Tanford, S.; Shulga, L.
  • Retail jobs in comparative perspective
    Carré, F.; Tilly, C.; Van Klaveren, M.; Voss-dahm, D.; Gautie, J.; Schmint, J.
  • Customer engagement and employee engagement: systematic review and future directions
    Chandni, S.; Rahman, Z.
  • Employee engagement and visionary leadership: impact on customer and employee satisfaction
    Cheema, S.; Akram, A.; Javed, F.
  • Active engagement to active disengagement: a proposed model
    Dawsey, J.C.; Taylor, E.C.
  • The job demands-resources model of burnout
    Demerouti, E.; Bakker, A.B.; Nachreiner, F.; Schaufeli, W.B.
  • The psychologisation of employment relations
    Godard, J.
  • Front-line service managers’ misbehavior and disengagement: the elephant in the store?
    Hadjisolomou, A.
  • Doing and negotiating transgender on the front line: customer abuse, transphobia, and stigma in the food retail sector
    Hadjisolomou, A.
  • (De) regulation of working time, employer capture, and ‘forced availability’: a comparison between the UK and Cyprus food retail sector
    Hadjisolomou, A.; Newsome, K.; Cunningham, I.
  • Retail employee pilferage: a study of moral disengagement
    Harris, L.C.; He, H.
  • A theory of workplace conflict development: from grievances to strikes
    Hebdon, R.; Noh, S.; Gall, G.
  • It’s like hating puppies!” employee disengagement and corporate social responsibility
    Hejjas, K.; MillerScarles, G.C.; Scarles, C.
  • Context matters: examining ‘soft’ and ‘hard’ approaches to employee engagement in two workplaces
    Jenkins, S.; Delbridge, R.
  • Perceptions of customer service orientation, training, and employee engagement in Jamaica's hospitality sector
    Johnson, K.R.; Park, S.; Bartlett, K.R.
  • Psychological conditions of personal engagement and disengagement at work
    Kahn, W.A.
  • Customer abuse to service workers: an analysis of its social creation within the service economy
    Korczynski, M.; Evans, C.
  • Engagement as a privilege and disengagement as a pathology
    Lemmon, G.; Jensen, J.M.; Wilson, M.S.; Posig, M.; Thompson, K.T.
  • The measurement of experienced burnout
    Maslach, C.; Jackson, S.E.
  • Disengaging from engagement
    Purcell, J.
  • Work disengagement among SME workers: evidence from India
    Rastogi, A.; Pati, S.P.; Dixit, J.K.; Kumar, P.
  • Causes, contingencies, and consequences of disengagement at work: an integrative literature review
    Rastogi, A.; Pati Surya, P.; KrishnanKrishnan, T.N.S.
  • Dysfunctional customer behavior severity: an empirical examination
    Reynolds, K.L.; Harris, L.C.
  • Dignity at work: broadening the agenda
    Sayer, A.
  • Driving customer satisfaction and financial success through employee engagement
    Schneider, B.; Macey, W.H.; Barbera, K.M.; Martin, N.
  • Critical realism and interviewing subjects
    Smith, C.; Elger, T.; Edwards, P.; O'Mahoney, J.; Vincent, S.
  • Unpacking the service triangle: arranging power relations between frontline occupations
    Subramanian, D.; Suquet, J.-B.
  • Who commits? Who engages?
    Sutherland, J.
  • Dissent at work and the resistance debate: departures, directions, and dead ends
    Thompson, P.
  • Employee dissent on social media and organisational discipline
    Thompson, P.; McDonald, P.; O'Connor, P.
  • The extra mile deconstructed: a critical and discourse perspective on employee engagement and HRD
    Valentin, C.
  • Quiet desperation: another perspective on employee engagement
    Wollard, K.