Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Sainsbury's in Egypt: the strange case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde?

Sainsbury's in Egypt: the strange case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde? Purpose – The purpose of this paper is first, to explore the role of institutional theory constructs in a case of international retail divestment. Second, to examine the potential of constructed metaphors as a means of analyzing and communicating the findings of managerial research. Design/methodology/approach – The data were generated from participant observations and interactions with stakeholder groups during a three‐month ethnographic study based in a Sainsbury store in Egypt. Data were analysed and presented via a constructed metaphor – namely Robert Louis Stevenson's story of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde. Findings – The case illustrated an apparent paradox between Sainsbury's technical superiority as a retail operator in the Egyptian market, and its social inferiority in its interactions with a variety of stakeholders, primarily customers and employees. The use of the metaphor to organize, analyse and present the findings proves to be a fruitful way to illustrate this issue, and parallels between the two “stories” provide further insights into behaviour – the denial of responsibility for (and the existence of) social inadequacies; and the implicit (and inevitable) existence of the capacity for social inadequacy in any business organization. Practical implications – The potential to communicate managerial lessons by telling “stories” (the case) through well‐known “stories” (the novel) is highlighted. Originality/value – The use of the constructed metaphor to analyse a case of international retail divestment is, to the authors' knowledge, unique and enhances the understanding of the legitimisation process and the role of socio‐moral codes in this process. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management Emerald Publishing

Sainsbury's in Egypt: the strange case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde?

Download PDF
23 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/sainsbury-s-in-egypt-the-strange-case-of-dr-jekyll-and-mr-hyde-VGmAKAhClz
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2008 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
0959-0552
DOI
10.1108/09590550810862697
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is first, to explore the role of institutional theory constructs in a case of international retail divestment. Second, to examine the potential of constructed metaphors as a means of analyzing and communicating the findings of managerial research. Design/methodology/approach – The data were generated from participant observations and interactions with stakeholder groups during a three‐month ethnographic study based in a Sainsbury store in Egypt. Data were analysed and presented via a constructed metaphor – namely Robert Louis Stevenson's story of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde. Findings – The case illustrated an apparent paradox between Sainsbury's technical superiority as a retail operator in the Egyptian market, and its social inferiority in its interactions with a variety of stakeholders, primarily customers and employees. The use of the metaphor to organize, analyse and present the findings proves to be a fruitful way to illustrate this issue, and parallels between the two “stories” provide further insights into behaviour – the denial of responsibility for (and the existence of) social inadequacies; and the implicit (and inevitable) existence of the capacity for social inadequacy in any business organization. Practical implications – The potential to communicate managerial lessons by telling “stories” (the case) through well‐known “stories” (the novel) is highlighted. Originality/value – The use of the constructed metaphor to analyse a case of international retail divestment is, to the authors' knowledge, unique and enhances the understanding of the legitimisation process and the role of socio‐moral codes in this process.

Journal

International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: Mar 28, 2008

Keywords: Egypt; Corporate strategy; Divestment; Metaphors; International business

References

  • Sainsbury's are getting rid of their problems at the expense of Egypt's reputation
    Abd El‐Hameed, T.A.
  • Quantitative usage & attitudes study: household shopping in Egypt
    AC Nielsen AMER
  • Supermarket hysterics
    Al‐Ahram Weekly
  • International retail divestment
    Alexander, N.; Quinn, B.
  • International retail divestment activity
    Alexander, N.; Quinn, B.; Cairns, P.
  • Hometown ideology and retailer legitimation: the institutional semiotics of Wal‐Mart flyers
    Arnold, S.; Kozinets, R.V.; Handelman, J.
  • Market‐oriented ethnography: interpretation building and marketing strategy formulation
    Arnould, E.J.; Wallendorf, M.
  • Ethnography: post, past and present
    Atkinson, P.; Coffey, A.; Delamont, S.
  • Ethnography: relating the part to the whole
    Baszanger, I.; Dodier, N.
  • Ethnography and the book that was lost
    Behar, R.
  • Home depot in Chile: case study
    Bianchi, C.
  • An institutional perspective on retail internationalization success: home depot in Chile
    Bianchi, C.; Arnold, S.
  • Lessons learned from unsuccessful internationalization attempts: examples of multinational retailers in Chile
    Bianchi, C.C.; Ostale, E.
  • Relativism and the moral obligations of multinational corporations
    Bowie, N.
  • Sex ‘n’ shopping: a ‘Novel’ approach to consumer research
    Brown, S.
  • Beyond ethnography: towards writerly accounts of organising in marketing
    Brownlie, D.
  • UK supermarket Sainsbury's travel Mid‐east's rocky road
    Bryant, E.
  • Manufacturing the global
    Burawoy, M.
  • Retail internationalization: evolution of theory and practice
    Burt, S.
  • Wal‐Mart's world
    Burt, S.; Sparks, L.
  • Retail internationalization and retail failure: issues from the case of Marks and Spencer
    Burt, S.; Dawson, J.; Sparks, L.
  • Failure in international retailing: research propositions
    Burt, S.; Dawson, J.; Sparks, L.
  • The international divestment activities of European grocery retailers
    Burt, S.; Dawson, J.; Sparks, L.
  • Retail internationalization: from format to implants
    Burt, S.; Davies, K.; McAuley, A.; Sparks, L.
  • The Economic Census for Egypt, Arab REP. (1996/7) for Wholesale & Retail in the Private Sector (in Arabic), 71(12214/97)
    CAPMAS
  • Sustainable development: mainstream and critical perspectives
    Castro, C.J.
  • Using narrative fiction within management education
    Cohen, C.
  • Metaphor as method in the domain of marketing
    Cornelissen, J.P.
  • Metaphor and the dynamics of knowledge in organisation theory: a case study of the organizational identity metaphor
    Cornelissen, J.P.
  • Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing among Five Traditions
    Creswell, J.W.
  • Managing Retail Consumption
    Davies, B.; Ward, P.
  • British food chain hounded out of Egypt
    Davies, D.
  • Sainsbury's on Egyptians boycott list
    Dawoud, K.; Whitaker, B.
  • Organization/literature: exploring the seam
    de Cock, C.; Land, C.
  • Sainsbury counts cost of its supermarket victory in Egypt: Sainsbury's fought to establish itself in Cairo but is now thinking of leaving after barely a year
    Drummond, J.
  • Business distance and global retailing: a model for analysis of key success and failure factors
    Dupuis, M.; Prime, N.
  • The assertion of the Egyptian identity
    El‐Hamamsy, L.S.
  • Using ethnography in strategic consumer research
    Elliott, R.; Jankel‐Elliott, N.
  • Pyramid selling
    Eltahawy, M.
  • Food Distribution Technology: A Critical Oversight in Economic Development (Focus – Egypt)
    Feller, L.
  • Ethnography: Step by Step
    Fetterman, D.M.
  • David Reader: from promotion to development
    Fitzpatrick, P.
  • Qualitative research – state of the art
    Flick, U.
  • The human resources management practice of retail branding: an ethnography within Oxfam Trading Division
    Girod, S.J.G.
  • Mummy, is this what pyramid selling is?
    Gordon, J.
  • Snow fictional sociology of management and organizations
    Grey, C.C.P.
  • Qualitative research in marketing
    Gummesson, E.
  • Local consumers are voting with their feet: the retailer's arrival in Egypt is shaking up a once protected market with a strong element of competition
    Huband, M.
  • Is ethnography jazz?
    Humphreys, M.; Brown, A.D.; Hatch, M.J.
  • Shutting up shop: understanding the international exit process in retailing
    Jackson, P.; Mellahi, K.; Sparks, L.
  • Business and Society: Ethics and Stakeholder Management
    Karakowsky, L.; Carroll, A.B.; Buchholtz, A.
  • Objectivity, reflexivity, and fiction: humanity, inhumanity, and the science of the social
    Linstead, S.
  • The power of ethnography
    Mariampolski, H.
  • Sainsbury hit by heavy Cairo losses
    MEED
  • Introduction
    Mighall, R.
  • Qualitative Data Analysis
    Miles, M.B.; Huberman, A.M.
  • Paradigms, metaphors, and puzzle‐solving in organisation theory
    Morgan, G.
  • Ethnographic contributions to organizational sociology
    Morrill, C.; Fine, G.A.
  • Ethical Marketing
    Murphy, P.E.; Laczniak, G.R.; Bowie, N.E.; Klein, T.A.
  • Sainsbury's and Shaw's: reflections on making an acquisition a reality
    Muskett, D.
  • Egyptian Food Distribution Systems: An Assessment and Recommended Plan of Action
    National Co‐operative Business Association
  • International retail restructuring and divestment: the case of Tesco
    Palmer, M.
  • An exploratory framework for analyzing international retail learning
    Palmer, M.; Quinn, B.
  • The nature of international retail divestment: insights from Ahold
    Palmer, M.; Quinn, B.
  • Mining the international consumer
    Pawle, J.
  • Introduction to Social Research
    Punch, K.
  • Control and support in an international franchise network
    Quinn, B.
  • Retailing in Egypt: Part 1
    Retail Monitor International
  • Retailing in Egypt: Part 2
    Retail Monitor International
  • Sainsbury Storm Sweeps Egypt
    Salem, M.
  • Retailer internationalisation: a culturally constructed phenomenon
    Shackleton, R.
  • Exploring corporate culture and strategy: Sainsbury's at home and abroad
    Shackleton, R.
  • Using fiction to develop managerial judgment
    Shaw, G.; Locke, K.
  • A socio‐cultural analysis of a Midwestern American flea market
    Sherry, J.
  • Case studies
    Stake, R.
  • Fictions: legal and organizational
    Stanley, J.D.
  • Towards critical ethnography: a reexamination of the Chicago legacy
    Thomas, J.
  • Marketing paradise: citizen professionals on the road to paradise (via Damascus)
    Thomas, M.
  • Ethnographic fiction science: making sense of managerial work and organizational research processes with Caroline and Terry
    Watson, T.J.
  • Constructing the source: metaphor as a discourse strategy
    Wee, L.
  • The war metaphor in retailing: do soldiers see going to war as like going shopping?
    Whysall, P.
  • British food retail capital in the USA – Part 1: Sainsbury's and Shaw's experience
    Wrigley, N.
  • British food retail capital in the USA – Part 2: giant prospects?
    Wrigley, N.
  • Strategic market behaviour in the internationalisation of food retailing: interpreting third wave of Sainsbury's US diversification
    Wrigley, N.