Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Reducing recidivism and encouraging desistance: a social entrepreneurial approach

Reducing recidivism and encouraging desistance: a social entrepreneurial approach This paper, which is both case study and conceptual in nature, presents a relative cost-benefit model to explain why people engage in criminal activity. It then uses the model to motivate a discussion of the major policy approaches to recidivism reduction and desistance, or decreasing the frequency and severity of criminal activity, a more nuanced measure of harm reduction than the binary concept of recidivism typically used to evaluate program success. Several private programs have successfully reduced recidivism and improved measures of desistance but remain applicable only to those who self-select into them. Changed policies and incentives, however, could stimulate social entrepreneurs to search for programs applicable to additional segments of the prison population.Design/methodology/approachThis paper describes case studies informed by economic theories of crime and incentive alignment. Most approaches to recidivism reduction/desistance have failed, but several programs, including the DOE Fund and PEP, have proven extremely effective: the first by employing former convicts in starter jobs and the latter by teaching inmates about entrepreneurship and general business skills and mentoring them after release.FindingsSuccessful cases cannot simply be scaled up because inmates self-select into the programs. Instead, policymakers should encourage further competition and innovation in the field by paying NGOs each week they manage to keep the formerly imprisoned persons in their charge alive and out of the criminal justice system.Research limitations/implicationsCase study and theoretical. Not yet tried in the real world.Practical implicationsLower recidivism, more desistance for the same budget.Social implicationsHumans will be better treated than currently.Originality/valueInstead of offering a specific recidivism reduction panacea, this paper suggests that incentive alignment and competition for funding will encourage nonprofit NGOs to discover which programs work best for different types of inmates. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Enterpreneurship and Public Policy Emerald Publishing

Reducing recidivism and encouraging desistance: a social entrepreneurial approach

Wright, Robert E.
Journal of Enterpreneurship and Public Policy , Volume 11 (2/3): 14 – Oct 25, 2022
Download PDF
14 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/reducing-recidivism-and-encouraging-desistance-a-social-2YIZzMy90H
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
2045-2101
DOI
10.1108/jepp-05-2022-0058
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

This paper, which is both case study and conceptual in nature, presents a relative cost-benefit model to explain why people engage in criminal activity. It then uses the model to motivate a discussion of the major policy approaches to recidivism reduction and desistance, or decreasing the frequency and severity of criminal activity, a more nuanced measure of harm reduction than the binary concept of recidivism typically used to evaluate program success. Several private programs have successfully reduced recidivism and improved measures of desistance but remain applicable only to those who self-select into them. Changed policies and incentives, however, could stimulate social entrepreneurs to search for programs applicable to additional segments of the prison population.Design/methodology/approachThis paper describes case studies informed by economic theories of crime and incentive alignment. Most approaches to recidivism reduction/desistance have failed, but several programs, including the DOE Fund and PEP, have proven extremely effective: the first by employing former convicts in starter jobs and the latter by teaching inmates about entrepreneurship and general business skills and mentoring them after release.FindingsSuccessful cases cannot simply be scaled up because inmates self-select into the programs. Instead, policymakers should encourage further competition and innovation in the field by paying NGOs each week they manage to keep the formerly imprisoned persons in their charge alive and out of the criminal justice system.Research limitations/implicationsCase study and theoretical. Not yet tried in the real world.Practical implicationsLower recidivism, more desistance for the same budget.Social implicationsHumans will be better treated than currently.Originality/valueInstead of offering a specific recidivism reduction panacea, this paper suggests that incentive alignment and competition for funding will encourage nonprofit NGOs to discover which programs work best for different types of inmates.

Journal

Journal of Enterpreneurship and Public Policy – Emerald Publishing

Published: Oct 25, 2022

Keywords: Criminality modeling; Desistance; Entrepreneurship education; Recidivism; Structural barriers to human flourishing

References

  • Uncertainty, evolution, and economic theory
    Alchian, A.A.
  • A phenomenological study addressing recidivism from the perspective of African American male ex-offenders
    Andrews, A.D.
  • An oration intended to have been spoken at a late commencement, on the unlawfulness and impolicy of public punishments, and the Pro1per means of reforming criminals
    Anon
  • How entrepreneurship is creating change in prisons across Colorado
    Anon
  • What is DEI doing for the formerly incarcerated?
    Barton, L.L.
  • The lived experience of African Americans that transition from prison to society who become entrepreneurs
    Battle, M.V.
  • Building criminal capital behind bars: peer effects in juvenile corrections
    Bayer, P.; Hjalmarsson, R.; Posen, D.
  • Crime and punishment: an economic approach
    Becker, G.S.
  • Police bureaucracies, their incentives, and the war on drugs
    Benson, B.L.; Rasmussen, D.W.; Sollars, D.L.
  • The benefits of economic freedom: a survey
    Berggren, N.
  • Incarceration, recidivism and employment
    Bhuller, M.; Dahl, G.B.; Loken, K.V.; Mogstad, M.
  • The impact of unemployment and poverty on recidivism in West Virginia: a quantitative analysis
    Bowen, D.E.
  • The successful road of reentry after conviction
    Butts, C.P.
  • The effectiveness of prison programming: a review of the research literature examining the impact of federal, state, and local inmate programming on post-release recidivism
    Byrne, J.M.
  • When the cops become the robbers: the impact of asset forfeiture on blacks and how to curtail asset forfeiture abuses
    Caruthers, C.
  • All aboard! The supreme court, guilty pleas, and the railroading of criminal defendants
    Cook, J.A.
  • Assessing protective factors in treated violent offenders: associations with recidivism reduction and positive community outcomes
    Coupland, R.B.A.; Olver, M.E.
  • Can entrepreneurship reduce recidivism? This Babson professor says yes
    Crawford, J.
  • Prison as a criminal school: peer effects and criminal learning behind bars
    Damm, A.P.; Gorinas, C.
  • Crime as risk taking
    Dhami, M.K.; Mandel, D.R.
  • Inmates-to-entrepreneurs
    Erdody, L.
  • The ineffectiveness of ‘observe and report’ patrols on crime
    Fabri, M.; Klick, J.
  • More entrepreneurship, less recidivism among the formerly incarcerated
    Field, A.
  • Measuring recidivism risk outcomes: a pilot project in collaboration with the Flathead reservation reentry program
    Fox, D.L.
  • Alternatives to incarceration
    Frana, J.F.; Schroeder, R.D.
  • Family visitation: decreasing jail infractions and recidivism
    Galli, P.M.
  • Erasing the mark of cain: an empirical analysis of the effect of ban-the-box legislation on the employment outcomes of people of color with criminal records
    Gubernick, L.
  • The resurgence of religion in America's prisons
    Hallett, M.; Johnson, B.
  • Is the ‘point’ of the market Pareto or Kaldor-Hicks efficiency?
    Heath, J.
  • ‘Get therapy and work on it’: managing dissent in an intentional community
    Holden, D.; Schrock, D.
  • Confronting recidivism: prisoner re-entry programs and a just future for all Americans
  • Entrepreneurship and incarceration
    Hwang, K.J.
  • Emotions and social movements: twenty years of theory and research
    Jasper, J.M.
  • Reducing recidivism: states deliver results
  • Measuring change: from rates of recidivism to markers of desistance
    Klingele, C.
  • Reducing recidivism in serious and violent youthful offenders: fact, fiction, and a path forward
    Kurlychek, M.; Gagnon, A.
  • Understanding why crime fell in the 1990s: four factors that explain the decline and six that do not
    Levitt, S.D.
  • An economic analysis of a drug-selling gang's finances
    Levitt, S.D.; Venkatesh, S.A.
  • A quasi-experimental evaluation of the impact of public assistance on prisoner recidivism
    Luallen, J.; Edgerton, J.; Rabideau, D.
  • Drug enforcement's double-edged sword: an assessment of asset forfeiture programs
    Miller, J.M.; Selva, L.H.
  • Relationships among patterns of criminal thinking Styles and recidivism in non-violent offenders on probation
    Mitsianis, L.
  • Discounting and criminals' implied risk preferences
    Mungan, M.C.; Klick, J.
  • Identifying criminals' risk preferences
    Mungan, M.C.; Klick, J.
  • Privileged emotion mangers: the case of actors
    Orzechowicz, D.
  • Overcoming the walls that constrain us: the role of entrepreneurship education programs in prison
    Patzelt, H.; Williams, T.A.; Shepherd, D.A.
  • Beyond recidivism: positive outcomes from higher education programs in prisons
    Pelletier, E.; Evans, D.
  • Policy reforms can strengthen community supervision: a framework to improve probation and parole
  • Convict criminology: voice from prison
    Richards, S.C.; Faggiani, D.; Roffers, J.; Hendricksen, R.; Krueger, J.
  • Perception and payment of economic sanctions: a survey of offenders
    Ruback, R.B.; Hoskins, S.N.; Cares, A.C.; Feldmeyer, B.
  • ‘Lost, lost, and lost’: a narrative analysis of desistance in the context of parole
    Sarver, C.M.
  • The creative response in economic history
    Schumpeter, J.A.
  • An outcome study of recidivism rates of a mental health court
    Strong, S.
  • Double-Edged hormone: a promising target for mood drugs turns out to both cause and relieve anxiety
    Sutherland, S.
  • Measuring criminal spillovers: evidence from three strikes
    Tabarrok, A.; Helland, E.
  • Businesses behind bars: the case for prisoner entrepreneurship
    Washburn, J.J.
  • Understanding desistance: a critical review of theories of desistance
    Weaver, B.
  • Exploring the positive punishment effect among incarcerated adult offenders
    Wood, P.B.
  • Robbery, recidivism, and the limits of the criminal justice system
    Wright, R.; Sabol, W.J.; Johnson, T.L.