Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Performance gaming: a systematic review of the literature in public administration and other disciplines with directions for future research

Performance gaming: a systematic review of the literature in public administration and other... Through comparative analysis with other social science disciplines, gaps are identified in the performance gaming literature of public administration as it compares to other social science disciplines in order to understand directions for future research in this space.Design/methodology/approachThis study involves a systematic review of the performance gaming literature, focusing on important drivers of performance gaming. Using Google Scholar, Web of Science, and ProQuest Central, the systematic review covers years ranging from 1990 through 2019 and revealed empirical studies that were deemed relevant based on whether an article was (1) an empirical study and (2) performance gaming or cheating behavior was the outcome variable. Out of the 81 articles surmised from the search, 51 were regarded as relevant by meeting these criteria.FindingsThe main finding is that public administration has primarily focused on drivers that are embedded in the performance system. The other social sciences (psychology and economics, in particular) focus mainly on individual factors, mostly cognitive in nature. Public administration has also looked at organizational drivers, though this is a burgeoning area. Scholars in public administration may benefit from the other social sciences by determining how individual drivers work within the context of public organizations and how these shape organizational behavior.Originality/valuePer my knowledge, the paper is the first to systematically compare the performance gaming literature of public administration to other social science disciplines. The paper provides a direction for this burgeoning area of research. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png International Journal of Public Sector Management Emerald Publishing

Performance gaming: a systematic review of the literature in public administration and other disciplines with directions for future research

Download PDF
21 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/performance-gaming-a-systematic-review-of-the-literature-in-public-J3RBEYJumv
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0951-3558
DOI
10.1108/ijpsm-07-2019-0191
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Through comparative analysis with other social science disciplines, gaps are identified in the performance gaming literature of public administration as it compares to other social science disciplines in order to understand directions for future research in this space.Design/methodology/approachThis study involves a systematic review of the performance gaming literature, focusing on important drivers of performance gaming. Using Google Scholar, Web of Science, and ProQuest Central, the systematic review covers years ranging from 1990 through 2019 and revealed empirical studies that were deemed relevant based on whether an article was (1) an empirical study and (2) performance gaming or cheating behavior was the outcome variable. Out of the 81 articles surmised from the search, 51 were regarded as relevant by meeting these criteria.FindingsThe main finding is that public administration has primarily focused on drivers that are embedded in the performance system. The other social sciences (psychology and economics, in particular) focus mainly on individual factors, mostly cognitive in nature. Public administration has also looked at organizational drivers, though this is a burgeoning area. Scholars in public administration may benefit from the other social sciences by determining how individual drivers work within the context of public organizations and how these shape organizational behavior.Originality/valuePer my knowledge, the paper is the first to systematically compare the performance gaming literature of public administration to other social science disciplines. The paper provides a direction for this burgeoning area of research.

Journal

International Journal of Public Sector Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jun 22, 2020

Keywords: Performance gaming; Performance management; Unethical behavior

References

  • Representative evidence on lying costs
    Abeler, J.; Becker, A.; Falk, A.
  • An identity-based model of organizational monitoring: integrating information privacy and organizational justice
    Alge, B.J.; Greenberg, J.; Brinsfield, C.T.
  • How leaders respond to diversity: the moderating role of organizational culture on performance information use
    Andersen, S.C.; Moynihan, D.P.
  • Gaming emotions in social interactions
    Andrade, E.B.; Ho, T.H.
  • The self-importance of moral identity
    Aquino, K.; Reed, A.
  • Testing a social-cognitive model of moral behavior: the interactive influence of situations and moral identity centrality
    Aquino, K.; Freeman, D.; Reed, A.; Felps, W.; Lim, V.K.
  • The normalization of corruption in organizations
    Ashforth, B.E.; Anand, V.
  • Three principles to REVISE people's unethical behavior
    Ayal, S.; Gino, F.; Barkan, R.; Ariely, D.
  • The association between organizational culture and the use of management initiatives in the public sector
    Baird, K.M.; Harrison, G.L.
  • The pot calling the kettle black: distancing response to ethical dissonance
    Barkan, R.; Ayal, S.; Gino, F.; Ariely, D.
  • Crime and punishment: an economic approach
    Becker, G.S.
  • What causes unethical behavior? a meta-analysis to set an agenda for public administration research
    Belle, N.; Cantarelli, P.
  • Leading to make a difference: a field experiment on the performance effects of transformational leadership, perceived social impact, and public service motivation
    Belle, N.
  • Sloppy work, lies and theft: a novel experimental design to study counterproductive behavior
    Belot, M.; Schroder, M.
  • Identity, morals, and taboos: beliefs as assets
    Benabou, R.; Tirole, J.
  • Hitting and missing targets by ambulance services for emergency calls: effects of different systems of performance measurement within the UK
    Bevan, G.; Hamblin, R.
  • What's measured is what matters: targets and gaming in the English Public Health Care System
    Bevan, G.; Hood, C.
  • Ethics instruction and the perceived acceptability of cheating
    Bloodgood, J.; Turnley, W.H.; Mudrack, P.E.
  • Goal displacement: assessing the motivation for organizational Cheating
    Bohte, J.; Meier, K.
  • The bright side of being prosocial at work, and the dark side, too: a review and agenda for research on other-oriented motives, behavior, and impact in organizations
    Bolino, M.; Grant, A.M.
  • Performance measurement in the public sector: strategies to cope with the risks of performance measurement
    Bruijn, H.D.
  • The role of incentives in the public sector: issues and evidence
    Burgess, S.; Ratto, M.
  • Estimating the incidence of wrongdoing and whistle blowing: results of a study using randomized response technique
    Burton, B.; Near, J.
  • In-group favoritism and moral decision-making
    Cadsby, C.B.; Du, N.; Song, F.
  • Psychological incentives, financial incentives, and risk attitudes in tournaments: an artefactual field experiment
    Cadsby, C.B.; Engle-Warnick, J.; Fang, T.; Song, F.
  • Are you paying your employees to cheat? an experimental investigation
    Cadsby, C.B.; Song, F.; Tapon, F.
  • Leaning for the tape: evidence of gaming behavior in equity mutual funds
    Carhart, M.; Kaniel, R.; Musto, D.K.; Reed, A.V.
  • Performance information use in public administration: an exploratory study of determinants and effects
    Cepiku, D.; Hinna, A.; Scarozza, D.; Savignon, A.B.
  • Dishonesty and charitable behavior
    Cojoc, D.C.; Stoian, A.
  • Dynamics of performance-measurement systems
    Courty, P.; Marschke, G.
  • Making government accountable: lessons from a federal job training program
    Courty, P.; Marschke, G.
  • In search of virtue: the role of virtues, values and character strengths in ethical decision making
    Crossan, M.; Mazutis, D.; Seijts, G.
  • The riskiness of public sector performance measurement: a review and research agenda
    Cuganesan, S.; Guthrie, J.; Vranic, V.
  • Creating a performance culture: incentives, climate, and organizational change
    Destler, K.N.
  • Gaming the system: building an online management game to spread and gather insights into the dynamics of performance management systems
    Douglas, S.; Hood, C.; Overmans, T.; Scheepers, F.
  • White lies
    Erat, S.; Gneezy, U.
  • Selection, tournaments, and dishonesty
    Faravelli, M.; Friesena, L.; Gangadharan, L.
  • Lies in disguise-an experimental study on cheating
    Fischbacher, U.; Follmi-Heusi, F.
  • Organizational control systems and pay-for performance in the public service
    Frey, B.S.; Homberg, F.; Osterloh, M.
  • Performance measure properties and incentive system design
    Gibbs, M.J.; Merchant, K.A.; Van der Stede, W.A.; Vargus, M.E.
  • Contagion and differentiation in unethical behavior: the effect of one bad apple on the barrel
    Gino, F.; Ayal, S.; Ariely, D.
  • Self-serving altruism? the lure of unethical actions that benefit others
    Gino, F.; Ayal, S.; Ariely, D.
  • Conflict in roles: lying to the in-group versus the out-group in negotiations
    Glac, K.; Warren, D.E.; Chen, C.C.
  • Doing good, doing harm, being well and burning out: the interactions of perceived prosocial and antisocial impact in service work
    Grant, A.M.; Campbell, E.M.
  • The significance of task significance: job performance effects, relational mechanisms, and boundary conditions
    Grant, A.
  • Leading with meaning: beneficiary contact, prosocial impact, and the performance effects of transformational leadership
    Grant, A.
  • The determinants of cheating by high school economics students: a comparative study of academic dishonesty in the transitional economies
    Grimes, P.W.; Rezek, J.P.
  • Cheating and loss aversion: do people cheat more to avoid a loss?
    Grolleau, G.; Kocher, M.G.; Sutan, A.
  • Moral maturation and moral conation: a capacity approach to explaining moral thought and action
    Hannah, S.T.; Avolio, B.J.; May, D.R.
  • Does moral identity effectively predict moral behavior?: a meta-analysis
    Hertz, S.G.; Krettenauer, T.
  • What lies beneath: how the distance between truth and lie drives dishonesty
    Hilbig, B.E.; Hessler, C.M.
  • Knowledge of peer success and risk of detection as determinants of cheating
    Hill, J.; Kochendorfer, R.A.
  • Gaming in targetworld: the targets approach to managing British public services
    Hood, C.
  • Public service management by numbers: why does it vary? where has it come from? what are the gaps and the puzzles?
    Hood, C.
  • Public management by numbers as a performance-enhancing drug: two hypotheses
    Hood, C.
  • The political payoff from performance target systems: no brainer or no-gainer?
    Hood, C.; Dixon, R.
  • Impartial institutions, pathogen stress and the expanding social network
    Hruschka, D.; Efferson, C.; Jiang, T.; Falletta-Cowden, A.; Sigurdsson, S.; McNamara, R.; Sands, M.; Munira, S.; Slingerland, E.; Henrich, J.
  • Would I lie to you? on social preferences and lying aversion
    Hurkens, S.; Kartik, N.
  • Health care fraud and abuse: market change, social norms, and the trust ‘reposed in the workmen’
    Hyman, D.A.
  • Why do we lie? a practical guide to the dishonesty literature
    Jacobsen, C.; Fosgaard, T.R.; Pascual‐Ezama, D.
  • Making sense of performance regimes: rebalancing external accountability and internal learning
    Jakobsen, M.L.; Baekgaard, M.; Moynihan, D.P.; van Loon, N.
  • Which clients are deserving of help? a theoretical model and experimental test
    Jilke, S.; Tummers, L.
  • Strategic misrepresentation in budgeting
    Jones, L.R.; Euske, K.J.
  • Ethical decision making by individuals in organizations: an issue contingent model
    Jones, T.
  • Management tenure and network time: how experience affects bureaucratic dynamics
    Juenke, E.G.
  • Ethical distancing: rationalizing violations of organizational norms
    Kaufmann, J.B.; West, T.; Ravenscroft, S.P.; Shrader, C.B.
  • Performance improvement and performance dysfunction: an empirical examination of distortionary impacts of the emergency room wait-time target in the English national health service
    Kelman, S.; Friedman, J.
  • The cost of high-powered incentives: employee gaming in enterprise software sales
    Larkin, I.
  • How control system design influences performance misreporting
    Maas, V.S.; Van Rinsum, M.
  • The dishonesty of honest people: a theory of self concept maintenance
    Mazar, N.; Amir, O.; Ariely, D.
  • Academic dishonesty: honor codes and other contextual influences
    McCabe, D.; Trevino, L.K.
  • Too tired to tell the truth: self-control resource depletion and dishonesty
    Mead, N.L.; Baumeister, R.F.; Gino, F.; Schweitzer, M.E.; Ariely, D.
  • Research on ethics and integrity in governance: a review an assessment
    Menzel, D.C.
  • Performance measurement in the public sector in England: searching for the golden thread
    Micheli, P.; Neely, A.
  • Cheating under pressure: a self-protection model of workplace cheating behavior
    Mitchell, M.S.; Baer, M.D.; Ambrose, M.L.; Folger, R.; Palmer, N.F.
  • Ethically adrift: how others pull our moral compass from true north, and how we can fix it
    Moore, C.; Gino, F.
  • How do public organizations learn? bridging cultural and structural perspectives
    Moynihan, D.P.; Landuyt, N.
  • The big question for performance management: why do managers use performance information?
    Moynihan, D.P.; Pandey, S.
  • Through a glass, darkly: understanding the effects of performance regimes
    Moynihan, D.P.
  • A workforce of cynics? the effects of contemporary reforms on public service motivation
    Moynihan, D.P.
  • Monitoring, motivation, and management: the determinants of opportunistic behavior in a field experiment
    Nagin, D.S.; Rebitzer, J.B.; Sanders, S.; Taylor, L.J.
  • People and organisational culture: a profile comparison approach to assessing person‐organisation fit
    O'Reilly, C.A; Chatman, J.; Caldwell, D.F.
  • Naive audience and communication bias
    Ottaviani, M.; Squintani, F.
  • Hitting the target and missing the point? developing an understanding of organizational gaming
    Radnor, Z.
  • Muddled, massaging, manoeuvring or manipulated? a typology of organizational gaming
    Radnor, Z.
  • The effects of competition on the nature of cheating behavior
    Rigdon, M.L.; D'Esterre, A.P.
  • Social identity theory's self-esteem hypothesis: a review and some suggestions for clarification
    Rubin, M.; Hewstone, M.
  • The frame of the game: loss-framing increases dishonest behavior
    Schindler, S.; Pfattheicherb, S.
  • Do job corps performance measures track program impacts?
    Schocket, P.; Burghardt, J.
  • Organizational culture in public sector organizations: promoting change through training and leading by example
    Schraeder, M.; Tears, R.S.; Jordan, M.H.
  • Stretching the truth: elastic justification and motivated communication of uncertain information
    Schweitzer, M.E.; Hsee, C.K.
  • Does competition enhance performance or cheating? a laboratory experiment
    Schwieren, C.; Weichselbaumer, D.
  • Justified, ethicality: observing desired counterfactuals modifies ethical perceptions and behavior
    Shalvi, S.; Dana, J.; Handgraaf, M.J.; De Dreu, C.K.
  • Dishonestly increasing the likelihood of winning
    Shalvi, S.
  • Signing at the beginning makes ethics salient and decreases dishonest self-reports in comparison to signing at the end
    Shu, L.L.; Mazar, N.; Gino, F.; Ariely, D.; Bazerman, M.H.
  • Conceptualizing dysfunctional consequences of performance measurement in the public sector
    Siverbo, S.; Cäker, M.; Akesson, J.
  • On the unintended consequences of publishing performance data in the public sector
    Smith, P.
  • Culture and organisational change
    Smith, M.
  • Doing good at work feels good at home, but not right away: when and why perceived prosocial impact predicts positive affect
    Sonnentag, S.; Grant, A.M.
  • Organizational culture and the paradox of performance management
    Taylor, J.
  • Misrepresentation and expectation of misrepresentation in an ethical dilemma, the role of incentives and temptation
    Tenbrunsel, A.E.
  • Unethical for the sake of the group: risk of social exclusion and pro-group unethical behavior
    Thau, S.; Derfler-Rozin, R.; Pitesa, M.; Mitchell, M.S.; Pillutla, M.M.
  • Disadvantageous lies in individual decisions
    Utikal, V.; Fischbacher, U.
  • How to measure public administration performance: a conceptual model with applications for budgeting, human resources management, and open government
    Van Dooren, W.; De Caluwe, C.; Lonti, Z.
  • The performance paradox in the public sector
    Van Thiel, S.; Leeuw, F.L.
  • Why do people keep their promise? an experimental test of two explanations
    Vanberg, C.
  • Exploring the conceptual expansion within the field of organizational behaviour: organizational climate and organizational culture
    Verbeke, W.; Volgering, M.; Hessels, M.
  • Stretching the moral gray zone: positive affect, moral disengagement, and dishonesty
    Vincent, L.C.; Emich, K.J.; Goncalo, J.A.
  • Conscience without cognition: the effects of subconscious priming on ethical behavior
    Welsh, D.T.; Ordóñez, L.D.
  • Cheating more when the spoils are split
    Wiltermuth, S.S.
  • Auditor independence decision making: the role of organizational culture perceptions
    Windsor, C.A.; Ashkanasy, N.M.
  • Examining perceived honest performance reporting by public organizations: bureaucratic politics and organizational practice
    Yang, K.
  • CEOs on the edge: earnings manipulation and stock-based incentive misalignment
    Zhang, X.; Bartol, K.M.; Smith, K.G.; Pfarrer, M.D.; Khanin, D.M.
  • Good lamps are the best police: darkness increases dishonesty and self-interested behavior
    Zhong, C.B.; Bohns, V.K.; Gino, F.
  • Strategic management and the performance of public organizations: testing venerable ideas against recent theories
    Meier, K.J.; O'Toole, L.J.; Boyne, G.A.; Walker, R.M.
  • The motivational bases of public service
    Perry, J.L.; Wise, L.R.