Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Overkill, we know it when we see it: examining definitions of excessive injury in homicide research

Overkill, we know it when we see it: examining definitions of excessive injury in homicide research The purpose of this paper is to examine how the term “overkill” is used in the homicide literature to identify definitional issues that may interfere with reliable data coding across studies. This preliminary examination of the concept can guide future studies seeking to develop a standard definition.Design/methodology/approachTo identify issues inherent in the term “overkill,” three definitions – ranging from broad and unclear to more specific and objective – were extracted or adapted from the existing literature. Using closed, homicide case files, nine coders were tasked with coding for the presence of overkill according to one of the definitions across two rounds of coding. Definitional components that made the coding of overkill difficult were identified using a qualitative sorting task to separate items into themes that represented similar issues; basic inter-rater agreement patterns were examined using pairwise percent agreement.FindingsBased on coder feedback, two problems were identified: conceptual issues with the definitions and logistical issues with coding. However, feedback also suggested that increasing the objectivity of the overkill definition led coders to feel the intended meaning of the term was lost. Two out of three groups showed an increase in coder agreement between the two phases of data collection, illustrating how increased training is useful in certain situations.Originality/valueThis study is the first in-depth methodological and empirical examination of how the term “overkill” has been operationalized in the literature, raises key questions that may help with more clearly coding this variable, and outlines issues that may add difficulty to the development of a standard definition. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Criminal Psychology Emerald Publishing

Overkill, we know it when we see it: examining definitions of excessive injury in homicide research

Download PDF
14 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/overkill-we-know-it-when-we-see-it-examining-definitions-of-excessive-93YYmUgJGv
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
2009-3829
DOI
10.1108/jcp-09-2018-0040
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to examine how the term “overkill” is used in the homicide literature to identify definitional issues that may interfere with reliable data coding across studies. This preliminary examination of the concept can guide future studies seeking to develop a standard definition.Design/methodology/approachTo identify issues inherent in the term “overkill,” three definitions – ranging from broad and unclear to more specific and objective – were extracted or adapted from the existing literature. Using closed, homicide case files, nine coders were tasked with coding for the presence of overkill according to one of the definitions across two rounds of coding. Definitional components that made the coding of overkill difficult were identified using a qualitative sorting task to separate items into themes that represented similar issues; basic inter-rater agreement patterns were examined using pairwise percent agreement.FindingsBased on coder feedback, two problems were identified: conceptual issues with the definitions and logistical issues with coding. However, feedback also suggested that increasing the objectivity of the overkill definition led coders to feel the intended meaning of the term was lost. Two out of three groups showed an increase in coder agreement between the two phases of data collection, illustrating how increased training is useful in certain situations.Originality/valueThis study is the first in-depth methodological and empirical examination of how the term “overkill” has been operationalized in the literature, raises key questions that may help with more clearly coding this variable, and outlines issues that may add difficulty to the development of a standard definition.

Journal

Journal of Criminal Psychology – Emerald Publishing

Published: Apr 26, 2019

Keywords: Offender profiling; Homicide; Operationalization; Crime scene analysis; Data coding; Overkill

References

  • An examination of behavioral consistency using individual behaviors or groups of behaviors in serial homicide
    Bateman, A.L.; Salfati, C.G.
  • Homicide in homosexual victims: a study of 67 cases from the broward county, Florida, medical examiner’s office (1982-1992), with special emphasis on ‘overkill’
    Bell, M.D.; Vila, R.I.
  • An empirical test of Holmes and Holmes’ serial murder typology
    Canter, D.; Wentink, N.
  • The organized/disorganized typology of serial murder: myth or model?
    Canter, D.V.; Alison, L.J.; Alison, E.; Wentink, N.
  • Modus operandi and personality disorder in incarcerated spousal killers
    Dutton, D.G.; Kerry, G.
  • Injuries inflicted on homicide victims: a longitudinal victiminologic study of lethal violence
    Ericsson, A.; Thiblin, L.
  • Near-death experience: the role of victim reaction in attempted homicide
    Fritzon, K.; Ridgway, J.
  • Victim–offender relationships and severity of victim injury
    Heller, M.S.; Ehrlich, S.M.; Lester, D.
  • Lessons from serial murder in South Africa
    Hodgskiss, B.
  • Juvenile sexual homicide
    Hunter, J.A.; Hazelwood, R.R.; Slesinger, D.
  • Relationship and injury trends in the homicide of women across the life span: a research note
    Jordan, C.E.; Pritchard, A.J.; Duckett, D.; Wilcox, P.; Corey, T.; Combest, M.
  • Searching the silver trail: Charles van Onselen, Joe Silver and Jack the Ripper
    Kaplan, R.
  • Profiling killers: a revised classification model for understanding sexual murder
    Keppel, R.D.; Walter, R.
  • Jack the Ripper Murders: a modus operandi and signature analysis of the 1888-1891 Whitechapel murders
    Keppel, R.D.; Weis, J.G.; Brown, K.M.; Welch, K.
  • Excessive violence and psychotic symptomatology among homicide offenders with schizophrenia
    Laajasalo, T.; Hakkanen, H.
  • Investigating the nature of expressiveness in stranger, acquaintance and intrafamilial homicides
    Last, S.K.; Fritzon, K.
  • Criminal personality profiling: an outcome and process study
    Pinizzotto, A.J.; Finkel, N.J.
  • Sexual killers and their victims: identifying patterns through crime scene analysis
    Ressler, R.K.; Burgess, A.W.; Douglas, J.E.; Hartman, C.R.; D’Agostino, R.B.
  • Reasonable men and provocative women: an analysis of gendered domestic homicide in Zambia
    Rude, D.
  • Examining attributes of homicides: toward quantifying qualitative values of injury severity
    Safarik, M.E.; Jarvis, J.P.
  • Sexual homicide of elderly females: linking offender characteristics to victim and crime scene attributes
    Safarik, M.E.; Jarvis, J.P.; Nussbaum, K.
  • The nature of expressiveness and instrumentality in homicide: implications for offender profiling
    Salfati, C.G.
  • Offender interaction with victims in homicide: a multidimensional analysis of frequencies in crime scene behaviors
    Salfati, C.G.
  • Death in the office
    Stanley, D.T.
  • Homicide injury quantification: correlations and reliability of injury severity scores applied to homicide victims
    Tamsen, F.; Logan, F.K.; Thiblin, I.
  • Cluster analysis examination of serial killer profiling categories: a bottom-up approach
    Taylor, S.; Lambeth, D.; Green, G.; Bone, R.; Cahillane, M.A.
  • Variations in wounding by relationship intimacy in homicide cases
    Trojan, C.; Krull, A.C.
  • Methodological considerations of determining dominance in multidimensional analyses of crime scene behaviours and offender characteristics
    Trojan, C.; Salfati, C.G.