Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

“Not in the business of indoctrination”: religious education in South Australian public schools, 1968–1980

“Not in the business of indoctrination”: religious education in South Australian public schools,... This paper explores religious education (RE) in South Australia from 1968–1980. It focuses especially on the collapse of the RE settlement from 1968–1972 and the controversial legislation and subsequent curricula emerging from changes to the Education Act in 1972.Design/methodology/approachThis paper draws upon archival materials, published sources from the South Australian Institute of Teachers, the South Australian Education Department and the Religious Education Project Team, as well as an interview with Malcolm McArthur, one of the most influential figures in the controversy.FindingsFollowing the collapse of religious instruction from 1968–1972, the Minister of Education quickly passed legislation regarding a new course of religious education. A major controversy subsequently broke out over the appropriateness and design of a new programme of religious education. Educators attempted to design an educationally sound programme of RE that would avoid the problem of indoctrination. Ultimately, a new programme was created that satisfied neither proponents nor opponents of religion in state schools, and General Religious Teaching gradually faded from South Australian classrooms by 1980.Originality/valueThe article engages with broader debates on the nature of secularity in Australian history. In particular, it complicates the political-institutional approach developed by Damon Mayrl by stressing the agency and significance of elite educational and religious actors in the creation of new secular settlements. It also provides a useful addition to an older South Australian historiography by utilising newly available sources on the topic. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png History of Education Review Emerald Publishing

“Not in the business of indoctrination”: religious education in South Australian public schools, 1968–1980

Jackson, Stephen James
History of Education Review , Volume 49 (2): 14 – Dec 1, 2020
Download PDF
14 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/not-in-the-business-of-indoctrination-religious-education-in-south-VFe6hhCvEP
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0819-8691
DOI
10.1108/her-01-2020-0006
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

This paper explores religious education (RE) in South Australia from 1968–1980. It focuses especially on the collapse of the RE settlement from 1968–1972 and the controversial legislation and subsequent curricula emerging from changes to the Education Act in 1972.Design/methodology/approachThis paper draws upon archival materials, published sources from the South Australian Institute of Teachers, the South Australian Education Department and the Religious Education Project Team, as well as an interview with Malcolm McArthur, one of the most influential figures in the controversy.FindingsFollowing the collapse of religious instruction from 1968–1972, the Minister of Education quickly passed legislation regarding a new course of religious education. A major controversy subsequently broke out over the appropriateness and design of a new programme of religious education. Educators attempted to design an educationally sound programme of RE that would avoid the problem of indoctrination. Ultimately, a new programme was created that satisfied neither proponents nor opponents of religion in state schools, and General Religious Teaching gradually faded from South Australian classrooms by 1980.Originality/valueThe article engages with broader debates on the nature of secularity in Australian history. In particular, it complicates the political-institutional approach developed by Damon Mayrl by stressing the agency and significance of elite educational and religious actors in the creation of new secular settlements. It also provides a useful addition to an older South Australian historiography by utilising newly available sources on the topic.

Journal

History of Education Review – Emerald Publishing

Published: Dec 1, 2020

Keywords: South Australia; Religious education; Indoctrination; Religious studies

References

  • The struggle for religious education in South Australia's state schools, 1875–1940
    Bleby, M.
  • ‘Free, compulsory and (not) secular’: the failed in Australian education
    Byrne, C.
  • Bibles in state schools: moral formation in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century Queensland
    Carden, C.
  • How should we teach about religion in state schools?
    Chandler, J.
  • The latest instalment in the whig interpretation of Australian educational history: catherine Byrne's JORH article ‘free, compulsory, and (not) secular’
    Hastie, D.
  • Tragedy if religious courses not given fair trial
    Hudson, H.
  • Report on R.Ed
    Johnston, B.
  • Circular to teachers, no. 149 [republished with amendments]: religious instruction in public schools
    Jones, E.
  • Religious education: ‘an adult activity, for the most part inappropriate to children,’ says Tom Marriott
    Marriott, T.
  • Interviewed by Stephen Jackson
    McArthur, M.
  • Two steps forward, one step back: religious education in South Australia
    Ninnes, A.
  • Call to withdraw RE from primary schools- but state school parent organisation wants it
    Pearson, M.
  • Queensland's Bible in state schools referendum 1910: a case study of democracy
    Perkins, Y.
  • KOSSS committee welcomes changes in ALP policy on RE
    Potter, S.
  • Chaplaincy in South Australian state schools
    Rayner, W.; Hawkins, S.; Lush, H.
  • A dozen questions teachers ask about R.Ed
  • Letter to the editor: religious education
  • The future
  • Does religion have A legitimate place in state schools?
    Speedy, G.
  • Religious education: a progress report
  • KOSSS
  • State Branch of ALP changes policy on RE
  • Virtually impossible not to indoctrinate
  • Humanists fear they might be excluded
    Woolcock, P.
  • Reports available: religious education in state schools
  • Some criteria for introducing religious education
  • Reports available: religious education in state schools
  • Religious education in South Australia
    Waters, K.