Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

NGO responses to financial evaluation: auditability, purification and performance

NGO responses to financial evaluation: auditability, purification and performance Literature has widely studied the financial accountability pressures on NGOs but rarely analysed how NGOs respond to them. This paper studies one large humanitarian NGO to address this question. It investigates the NGO's responses to understand the extent to which NGOs are able to regain control over their own work and turn the frames of evaluation and accountability to their own advantage.Design/methodology/approachThis article draws on a case study of one of the largest French humanitarian NGOs. Interviews and observation (both participant and non-participant) were conducted in the financial department of the NGO. These data are supplemented with field-level contextual interviews.FindingsIn the NGO studied, institutional pressure is largely mediated by compliance audits. The paper thus traces the consequences of compliance audits for the NGO's central finance teams and describes how they respond. The findings detail three responses to evaluation. First, to respond to the burden of evaluation, the organisation makes itself auditable and develops preparedness. Second, to respond to the anxiety of evaluation, the organisation engages in a process of purification and succumbs to the allure of the single figure. Third, building on its newly acquired auditability and purity, the organisation performs itself as a “corporatised NGO”. Together, these three responses constitute the NGO as an “entrepreneur” competing for eligibility, and financial literacy and managerialism become crucial to respond to pressure from institutional funders.Originality/valueThis paper extends the understanding of organisational responses to evaluation. The authors show the influence of evaluation systems on NGOs, but also how NGOs can react to regain control over their work and turn the frames of evaluation and accountability to their own advantage. However, despite several decades of calls for broader conceptions of NGO accountability, the case NGO prefers to promote a very narrow view of its performance, based solely on accounting compliance. It takes some pride in its ability to comply with funders' and auditors' demands. Turning a simple matter of compliance into a display of good performance, it builds a strategy and competitive advantage on its ability to respond competently to evaluation. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal Emerald Publishing

NGO responses to financial evaluation: auditability, purification and performance

Download PDF
26 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/ngo-responses-to-financial-evaluation-auditability-purification-and-8cl2G0PWtx
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0951-3574
DOI
10.1108/aaaj-01-2020-4397
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Literature has widely studied the financial accountability pressures on NGOs but rarely analysed how NGOs respond to them. This paper studies one large humanitarian NGO to address this question. It investigates the NGO's responses to understand the extent to which NGOs are able to regain control over their own work and turn the frames of evaluation and accountability to their own advantage.Design/methodology/approachThis article draws on a case study of one of the largest French humanitarian NGOs. Interviews and observation (both participant and non-participant) were conducted in the financial department of the NGO. These data are supplemented with field-level contextual interviews.FindingsIn the NGO studied, institutional pressure is largely mediated by compliance audits. The paper thus traces the consequences of compliance audits for the NGO's central finance teams and describes how they respond. The findings detail three responses to evaluation. First, to respond to the burden of evaluation, the organisation makes itself auditable and develops preparedness. Second, to respond to the anxiety of evaluation, the organisation engages in a process of purification and succumbs to the allure of the single figure. Third, building on its newly acquired auditability and purity, the organisation performs itself as a “corporatised NGO”. Together, these three responses constitute the NGO as an “entrepreneur” competing for eligibility, and financial literacy and managerialism become crucial to respond to pressure from institutional funders.Originality/valueThis paper extends the understanding of organisational responses to evaluation. The authors show the influence of evaluation systems on NGOs, but also how NGOs can react to regain control over their work and turn the frames of evaluation and accountability to their own advantage. However, despite several decades of calls for broader conceptions of NGO accountability, the case NGO prefers to promote a very narrow view of its performance, based solely on accounting compliance. It takes some pride in its ability to comply with funders' and auditors' demands. Turning a simple matter of compliance into a display of good performance, it builds a strategy and competitive advantage on its ability to respond competently to evaluation.

Journal

Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jun 1, 2021

Keywords: Non-governmental organisations; NGO performance measurement; Accountability; Auditing

References

  • Seeking ‘conversations for accountability’. Mediating the impact of non-governmental organization (NGO) upward accountability processes
    Agyemang, G.; O'Dwyer, B.; Unerman, J.; Awumbila, M.
  • NGO accountability: retrospective and prospective academic contributions
    Agyemang, G.; O'Dwyer, B.; Unerman, J.
  • Stakeholder salience and accounting practices in Tanzanian NGOS
    Assad, M.J.; Goddard, A.R.
  • Problems of inference and proof in participant observation
    Becker, H.S.
  • Account space: how accountability requirements shape nonprofit practice
    Benjamin, L.M.
  • Constituting the governable NGO: the correlation between conduct and counter-conduct in the evolution of funder-NGO accountability relations
    Boomsma, R.; O'Dwyer, B.
  • Accountability, strategy, and international nongovernmental organizations
    Brown, L.D.; Moore, M.H.
  • Social capital and management control systems: a study of a non-government organization
    Chenhall, R.H.; Hall, M.; Smith, D.
  • Performance measurement, modes of evaluation and the development of compromising accounts
    Chenhall, R.H.; Hall, M.; Smith, D.
  • How does accountability affect mission? The case of a nonprofit serving immigrants and refugees
    Christensen, R.A.; Ebrahim, A.
  • Organizing dissonance through institutional work: the embedding of social and environmental accountability in an investment field
    Clune, C.; O'Dwyer, B.
  • Enacting catastrophe: preparedness, insurance, budgetary rationalization
    Collier, S.J.
  • Dominant stakeholders, activity and accountability discharge in the CSO sector
    Cordery, C.J.; Sim, D.
  • NGO accounting and accountability: past, present and future
    Cordery, C.; Belal, A.R.; Thomson, I.
  • An institutional perspective on the rise, social transformation, and fall of a university budget category
    Covaleski, M.A.; Dirsmith, M.W.
  • Introduction: time and the field
    Dalsgaard, S.; Nielsen, M.
  • Strategy, organization and control: some possibilities for accounting research
    Dent, J.F.
  • Marching with the volunteers: their role and impact on beneficiary accountability in an Indonesian NGO
    Dewi, M.K.; Manochin, M.; Belal, A.R.
  • Towards a conceptual framework of beneficiary accountability by NGOs: an Indonesian case study
    Dewi, M.K.; Manochin, M.; Belal, A.R.
  • Microfinance: accountability from the grassroots
    Dixon, R.; Ritchie, J.; Siwale, J.
  • Exhibiting nongovernmental organizations: reifying the performance discourse through framing power
    Duval, A.M.; Gendron, Y.; Roux-Dufort, C.
  • Information struggles: the role of information in the reproduction of NGO-funder relationships
    Ebrahim, A.
  • Accountability in practice: mechanisms for NGOs
    Ebrahim, A.
  • Accountability myopia: losing sight of organizational learning
    Ebrahim, A.
  • Placing the normative logics of accountability in ‘Thick’ perspective
    Ebrahim, A.
  • Too close for comfort? The impact of official aid on nongovernmental organisations
    Edwards, M.; Hulme, D.
  • Rankings and reactivity: how public measures recreate social worlds
    Espeland, W.N.; Sauder, M.
  • Humanitarian accountability and performance in the Théâtre de l'Absurde
    Everett, J.; Friesen, C.
  • Measuring the unmeasurable: empirical studies of nonprofit organization effectiveness from 1977 to 1997
    Forbes, D.P.
  • Accounting and navigating legitimacy in Tanzanian NGOs
    Goddard, A.; Assad, M.J.
  • NGOs, civil society and accountability: making the people accountable to capital
    Gray, R.; Bebbington, J.; Collison, D.
  • Evaluation logics in the third sector
    Hall, M.
  • Accounting, non-governmental organizations and civil society: the importance of nonprofit organizations to understanding accounting, organizations and society
    Hall, M.; O'Dwyer, B.
  • Occupational identities of management accountants: the role of the IT system
    Heinzelmann, R.
  • The rationalization of charity: the influences of professionalism in the nonprofit sector
    Hwang, H.; Powell, W.W.
  • Time in ethnography
    Jeffrey, B.; Troman, G.
  • Disruption and transformation: the organisational evolution of an NGO
    Kuruppu, S.C.; Lodhia, S.
  • Shaping accountability at an NGO: a Bourdieusian perspective
    Kuruppu, S.C.; Lodhia, S.
  • Roles, authority and involvement of the management accounting function: a multiple case-study perspective
    Lambert, C.; Sponem, S.
  • How management accountants exert influence on managers – a micro-level analysis of management accountants' influence tactics in budgetary control meetings
    Mack, S.; Goretzki, L.
  • Assembling international development: accountability and the disarticulation of a social movement
    Martinez, D.E.; Cooper, D.J.
  • Assembling performance measurement through engagement
    Martinez, D.E.; Cooper, D.J.
  • Accounting in Bhopal: making catastrophe
    Matilal, S.; Adhikari, P.
  • Performance measurement in global governance: ranking and the politics of variability
    Mehrpouya, A.; Samiolo, R.
  • Accounting and the construction of the governable person
    Miller, P.; O'Leary, T.
  • Dirty work and the construction of identity. An ethnographic study of management accounting practices
    Morales, J.; Lambert, C.
  • The construction of the risky individual and vigilant organization: a genealogy of the fraud triangle
    Morales, J.; Gendron, Y.; Guénin-Paracini, H.
  • Doing missionary work: the World Bank and the diffusion of financial practices
    Neu, D.; Ocampo, E.
  • The construction of a social account: a case study in an overseas aid agency
    O'Dwyer, B.
  • The co-construction of NGO accountability: aligning imposed and felt accountability in NGO-funder accountability relationships
    O'Dwyer, B.; Boomsma, R.
  • From functional to social accountability. Transforming the accountability relationship between funders and non-governmental development organisations
    O'Dwyer, B.; Unerman, J.
  • The paradox of greater NGO accountability: a case study of Amnesty Ireland
    O'Dwyer, B.; Unerman, J.
  • Grassroots accountability promises in rights-based approaches to development: the role of transformative monitoring and evaluation in NGOs
    O'Leary, S.
  • Moments of resistance: an internally persuasive view of performance and impact reports in non-governmental organizations
    O'Leary, S.; Smith, D.
  • Conforming or transforming? How organizations respond to multiple rankings
    Pollock, N.; D'Adderio, L.; Williams, R.; Leforestier, L.
  • NGOs and the globalization of managerialism: a research framework
    Roberts, S.M.; Jones, J.P.; Fröhling, O.
  • In the mirror of the market: the disciplinary effects of company/fund manager meetings
    Roberts, J.; Sanderson, P.; Barker, R.; Hendry, J.
  • The ethnographic paradigm(s)
    Sanday, P.R.
  • The discipline of rankings: Tight coupling and organizational change
    Sauder, M.; Espeland, W.N.
  • Arbiters, entrepreneurs, and the shaping of business school reputations
    Sauder, M.; Fine, G.A.
  • ‘Improving ratings’: audit in the British University system
    Strathern, M.
  • The tyranny of transparency
    Strathern, M.
  • NGO accountability and sustainability issues in the changing global environment
    Unerman, J.; O'Dwyer, B.
  • The fact of fiction in organizational ethnography
    Van Maanen, J.
  • Focused ethnography: a methodological adaption for social research in emerging contexts
    Wall, S.