Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Need to downsize? Your future employees may like the idea of cutting pay more

Need to downsize? Your future employees may like the idea of cutting pay more Studies comparing the consequences of payroll cost reduction methods (i.e. cutting pay and downsizing) have been limited, with no studies comparing these methods' impact on job-seeker attraction. The current research tries to close this gap by comparing the effects of cutting pay and downsizing on job-seeker attraction outcomes.Design/methodology/approachTwo studies are conducted. The first study compares the effects of the two payroll cost reduction methods (i.e. cutting pay vs downsizing) on job-seeker attraction through a within-subject design experiment of people in the United States. The second study analyzes secondary data in South Korea to compare the two methods' effects on the number of job applicants applying for job openings.FindingsThe results demonstrate that organizations with a history of pay cuts yield more favorable job-seeker attraction outcomes than organizations with a history of downsizing.Practical implicationsAlthough firms that choose to downsize may better maintain the morale of surviving employees, the decision of downsizing can have long-term costs, such as having a worse capability to attract job-applicants than firms that choose to cut pay and share the pain as a group.Originality/valueThe research provides an insight into which payroll cost reduction method yields better outcomes in terms of job-seeker attraction. The research responds to the call in the payroll cost reduction method literature of identifying a feasible alternative to downsizing in terms of various outcomes other than the morale of current (or remaining) employees. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Employee Relations: An International Journal Emerald Publishing

Need to downsize? Your future employees may like the idea of cutting pay more

Yoon, Yeongjoon
Employee Relations: An International Journal , Volume 44 (2): 24 – Feb 14, 2022
Download PDF
24 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/need-to-downsize-your-future-employees-may-like-the-idea-of-cutting-j6sV5pjKr6
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0142-5455
DOI
10.1108/er-01-2021-0009
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Studies comparing the consequences of payroll cost reduction methods (i.e. cutting pay and downsizing) have been limited, with no studies comparing these methods' impact on job-seeker attraction. The current research tries to close this gap by comparing the effects of cutting pay and downsizing on job-seeker attraction outcomes.Design/methodology/approachTwo studies are conducted. The first study compares the effects of the two payroll cost reduction methods (i.e. cutting pay vs downsizing) on job-seeker attraction through a within-subject design experiment of people in the United States. The second study analyzes secondary data in South Korea to compare the two methods' effects on the number of job applicants applying for job openings.FindingsThe results demonstrate that organizations with a history of pay cuts yield more favorable job-seeker attraction outcomes than organizations with a history of downsizing.Practical implicationsAlthough firms that choose to downsize may better maintain the morale of surviving employees, the decision of downsizing can have long-term costs, such as having a worse capability to attract job-applicants than firms that choose to cut pay and share the pain as a group.Originality/valueThe research provides an insight into which payroll cost reduction method yields better outcomes in terms of job-seeker attraction. The research responds to the call in the payroll cost reduction method literature of identifying a feasible alternative to downsizing in terms of various outcomes other than the morale of current (or remaining) employees.

Journal

Employee Relations: An International Journal – Emerald Publishing

Published: Feb 14, 2022

Keywords: Payroll cost reduction; Pay cuts; Downsizing; Job-seeker attraction

References

  • Are you attracted? Do you intend to pursue? A recruiting policy-capturing study
    Aiman-Smith, L.; Bauer, T.N.; Cable, D.M.
  • Social identity theory and the organization
    Ashforth, B.E.; Mael, F.
  • From a paternalistic model towards what? HRM trends in Korea and Taiwan
    Bae, J.; Chen, S.J.; Rowley, C.
  • Why not cut pay?
    Bewley, T.F.
  • Rising wage inequality and the US gender gap
    Blau, F.D.; Kahn, L.M.
  • When trust matters: the moderating effect of outcome favorability
    Brockner, J.; Siegel, P.A.; Daly, J.P.; Tyler, T.; Martin, C.
  • The art of cutting pay, not people
    Buhayar, N.
  • Sorting and incentive effects of pay for performance: an experimental investigation
    Cadsby, C.B.; Song, F.; Tapon, F.
  • Applicant attraction to organizations and job choice: a meta-analytic review of the correlates of recruiting outcomes
    Chapman, D.S.; Uggerslev, K.L.; Carroll, S.A.; Piasentin, K.A.; Jones, D.A.
  • Improving interactional organizational research: a model of person– organization fit
    Chatman, J.A.
  • Pay cuts become more common in pandemic downturn
    Cleeland, N.
  • Organizational web sites: web site content and style as determinants of organizational attraction
    Cober, R.T.; Brown, D.J.; Levy, P.E.; Cober, A.B.; Keeping, L.M.
  • Building theory about theory building: what constitutes a theoretical contribution?
    Corley, K.G.; Gioia, D.A.
  • Companies prefer layoffs to pay cuts
    Coy, P.; McGregor, J.
  • Causes and effects of employee downsizing: a review and synthesis
    Datta, D.K.; Guthrie, J.P.; Basuil, D.; Pandey, A.
  • Why firms avoid cutting wages: survey evidence from European firms
    Du Caju, P.; Kosma, T.; Lawless, M.; Messina, J.; Room, T.
  • Keeping an eye on the mirror: the role of image and identity in organizational adaptation
    Dutton, J.E.; Dukerich, J.M.
  • Organizational commitment, human resource practices, and organizational characteristics
    Fiorito, J.; Bozeman, D.P.; Young, A.; Meurs, J.A.
  • As small businesses recover from the pandemic, they face a new obstacle: finding workers
    Fox, M.
  • Layoffs should come last
    Gracon, H.; Clark, M.
  • Employee theft as a reaction to underpayment inequity: the hidden cost of pay cuts
    Greenberg, J.
  • Measuring attraction to organizations
    Highhouse, S.; Lievens, F.; Sinar, E.F.
  • Would you like a pay cut or layoff? Marketplace
    Hobson, J.
  • Where intrinsic job satisfaction fails to work: national moderators of intrinsic motivation
    Huang, X.; Van de Vliert, E.
  • Job losses remain ‘enormous’: coronavirus unemployment claims are worst in history
    Iacurci, G.
  • Declining bias and gender wage discrimination? A meta- regression analysis
    Jarrell, S.B.; Stanley, T.D.
  • Why are job seekers attracted by corporate social performance? Experimental and field tests of three signal-based mechanisms
    Jones, D.A.; Willness, C.R.; Madey, S.
  • Workforce reduction and job‐seeker attraction: examining job-seekers' reactions to firm workforce‐reduction policies
    Kammeyer‐Mueller, J.; Liao, H.
  • Pay cuts may be the least-worst option when compared to layoffs and furloughs
    Kelly, J.
  • Corporate social responsibility as an organizational attractiveness for prospective public relations practitioners
    Kim, S.; Parke, H.
  • Globalization and labour market reform: patterns of response in Northeast Asia
    Kong, T.Y.
  • Multi-level modeling of individual and group level mediated effects
    Krull, J.L.; MacKinnon, D.P.
  • Do wage cuts damage work morale? Evidence from a natural field experiment
    Kube, S.; Maréchal, M.A.; Puppe, C.
  • Retracting a gift: how does employee effort respond to wage reductions?
    Lee, D.; Rupp, N.G.
  • IT professionals feel jittery about job security
    Leonard, B.
  • Cut pay, not people
    Lewin, D.
  • Pay cuts are becoming a defining feature of the coronavirus recession
    Long, H.; Van Dam, A.
  • Good deeds and misdeeds: a mediated model of the effect of corporate social performance on organizational attractiveness
    Luce, R.A.; Barber, A.E.; Hillman, A.J.
  • The impact of downsizing on workplace attitudes: differing reactions of managers and staff in a health care organization
    Luthans, B.C.; Sommer, S.M.
  • A turnover model for the Mexican Maquiladoras
    Maertz, C.P.; Stevens, M.J.; Campion, M.A.
  • Racioethnicity, community makeup, and potential employees' reactions to organizational diversity management approaches
    Olsen, J.E.; Martins, L.L.
  • Would you take a pay cut to save jobs?
    Omer, S.
  • Reader feedback: why layoffs instead of wage cuts? Economix
    Rampell, C.
  • Job displacement and crime: evidence from Norwegian register data
    Rege, M.; Skardhamar, T.; Telle, K.; Votruba, M.
  • Recruiter and job influences on candidates for employment
    Rynes, S.L.; Miller, H.E.
  • Corporate social performance and attractiveness as an employer to different job seeking populations
    Schmidt Albinger, H.; Freeman, S.J.
  • Inequality, corporate legitimacy and the Occupy Wall Street movement
    Shrivastava, P.; Ivanova, O.
  • Pay cuts are better than layoffs in this recession
    Smith, K.W.
  • Financial crisis and collapsed banks: psychological distress and work related factors among surviving employees−A nation‐wide study
    Snorradottir, A.; Vilhjalmsson, R.; Rafnsdottir, G.L.; Tomasson, K.
  • After the recession
  • Job market signaling
    Spence, M.
  • Gender wage discrimination bias? A meta-regression analysis
    Stanley, T.D.; Jarrell, S.B.
  • The influence of social-media sites on job-seeker intentions: Facebook, LinkedIn, and Twitter
    Stone, R.W.; Eveleth, D.M.; Baker-Eveleth, L.J.
  • Culture and CEO compensation
    Tosi, H.; Greckhamer, T.
  • Does image matter to different job applicants? The influences of corporate image and applicant individual differences on organizational attractiveness
    Tsai, W.C.; Yang, I.W.F.
  • Corporate social performance and organizational attractiveness
    Turban, D.B.; Greening, D.W.
  • Recruiting through the stages: a meta‐analytic test of predictors of applicant attraction at different stages of the recruiting process
    Uggerslev, K.L.; Fassina, N.E.; Kraichy, D.
  • Exploring the consequences of workforce reduction
    Wagar, T.H.
  • A meta‐analysis of the international gender wage gap
    Weichselbaumer, D.; Winter‐Ebmer, R.
  • The relationship between HR practices and firm performance: examining causal order
    Wright, P.M.; Gardner, T.M.; Moynihan, L.M.; Allen, M.R.
  • The role of business strategy on the adoption and effectiveness of broad-based employee share ownership
    Yoon, Y.; Sengupta, S.
  • Corporate social responsibility, applicants' individual traits, and organizational attraction: a person–organization fit perspective
    Zhang, L.; Gowan, M.A.
  • In a downturn do you cut pay, slash the workforce or protect precious talent?
    Zingheim, P.K.; Schuster, J.R.