Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Near-peer video-based feedback: a useful activity for aspiring school leaders?

Near-peer video-based feedback: a useful activity for aspiring school leaders? This study examined the value of using near-peer video-based feedback to help train aspiring school leaders in coaching strategies. This research is part of a larger study in which feedback was solicited from both aspiring teachers and aspiring school leaders. The current study focused on the responses provided by the aspiring school leaders.Design/methodology/approachThis study utilized a phenomenological design. Undergraduate students enrolled in a public university in the Southwestern United States were recorded delivering instruction during their final semester of student teaching. These videos were uploaded to a secure website using EdPuzzle. Graduate students aspiring to be principals who were enrolled in a supervision course at the same university observed these classroom videos and provided feedback.FindingsIn regard to what participants learned about using video recordings, responses of aspiring principals fell into three themes as follows: establishing trust, providing critical feedback and broadening perspectives.Research limitations/implicationsThis study is limited by it being a small-scale study conducted at one public university in the Southwestern United States. Accordingly, the findings of this study are limited in their generalizability.Practical implicationsThis study highlights the usefulness of collaborations between educator preparation programs and principal preparation programs to enhance the learning of both student groups.Originality/valueThis research adds to the small but growing body of literature regarding near-peer video-based feedback and its potential value in helping aspiring principals practice coaching skills using written feedback. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png International Journal of Mentoring and Coaching in Education Emerald Publishing

Near-peer video-based feedback: a useful activity for aspiring school leaders?

Download PDF
17 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/near-peer-video-based-feedback-a-useful-activity-for-aspiring-school-ZiTGSxZgGa
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
2046-6854
DOI
10.1108/ijmce-09-2019-0087
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

This study examined the value of using near-peer video-based feedback to help train aspiring school leaders in coaching strategies. This research is part of a larger study in which feedback was solicited from both aspiring teachers and aspiring school leaders. The current study focused on the responses provided by the aspiring school leaders.Design/methodology/approachThis study utilized a phenomenological design. Undergraduate students enrolled in a public university in the Southwestern United States were recorded delivering instruction during their final semester of student teaching. These videos were uploaded to a secure website using EdPuzzle. Graduate students aspiring to be principals who were enrolled in a supervision course at the same university observed these classroom videos and provided feedback.FindingsIn regard to what participants learned about using video recordings, responses of aspiring principals fell into three themes as follows: establishing trust, providing critical feedback and broadening perspectives.Research limitations/implicationsThis study is limited by it being a small-scale study conducted at one public university in the Southwestern United States. Accordingly, the findings of this study are limited in their generalizability.Practical implicationsThis study highlights the usefulness of collaborations between educator preparation programs and principal preparation programs to enhance the learning of both student groups.Originality/valueThis research adds to the small but growing body of literature regarding near-peer video-based feedback and its potential value in helping aspiring principals practice coaching skills using written feedback.

Journal

International Journal of Mentoring and Coaching in Education – Emerald Publishing

Published: Nov 21, 2020

Keywords: Near-peer observations; Supervision; Feedback; Coaching; Leadership preparation

References

  • A thematic analysis of the experience of educational leaders introducing coaching into schools
    Anthony, D.; van Nieuwerburgh, C.
  • Human agency in social cognitive theory
    Bandura, A.
  • Effective student teacher supervision in the era of no child left behind
    Bates, A.J.; Burbank, M.D.
  • Using video editing to cultivate novice teachers' practice
    Calandra, B.; Brantley-Dias, L.; Lee, J.K.; Fox, D.L.
  • Peer observations of teaching: enhancing academic engagement for new participants
    Carroll, C.; O'Loughlin, D.
  • Seeing is believing: peer video coaching as professional development done with me and for me
    Cassada, K.; Kassner, L.
  • Teacher educators as learners: how supervisors shape their pedagogies by creating and using classroom videos with their student teachers
    Danielowich, R.M.; McCarthy, M.J.
  • Implementing teacher evaluation: lattice of leadership
    Derrington, M.L.
  • Implementing new teacher evaluation systems: principals' concerns and supervisor support
    Derrington, M.L.; Campbell, J.W.
  • What makes them the best? An analysis of the relationship between state education quality and principal preparation practices
    Dodson, R.L.
  • Ready from day one? The relationship between length of pre-service teacher field residency and teacher efficacy
    Dorel, T.; Kearney, W.S.; Garza, E.
  • Video as a metaphorical eye: images of positionality, pedagogy, and practice
    Hamilton, E.R.
  • His ideas are in my head: peer-to-peer teacher observations as professional development
    Hamilton, E.R.
  • The power of feedback
    Hattie, J.; Timperley, H.
  • The quality of guidance and feedback to students
    Hounsell, D.; McCune, V.; Hounsell, J.; Litjens, J.
  • Be proactive as empowered? The role of trust in one's supervisor in psychological empowerment, feedback seeking, and job performance
    Huang, J.
  • Retaining teachers how preparation matters
    Ingersoll, R.; Merrill, L.; May, H.
  • The coaching experience of four novice principals
    James-Ward, C.
  • Preparing undergraduate pre-service teachers through direct and video-based performance feedback and tiered supports in early head start
    Kennedy, A.S.; Lee, A.T.
  • ‘In their shoes’: exploring a modified approach to peer observation of teaching in a university setting
    Kenny, A.; Mitchell, E.; Chróinin, D.N.; Vaughan, E.; Mutagh, E.
  • A covariance structure analysis of employees' response to performance feedback
    Kinicki, A.J.; Prussia, G.E.; Wu, B.; McKee-Ryan, F.M.
  • An activity theory perspective on peer coaching
    Lofthouse, R.; Leat, D.
  • Trust and its role in principal succession: a preliminary examination of a continuum of trust
    Macmillan, R.B.; Meyer, M.J.; Northfield, S.
  • Beginning science teachers' use of a digital video annotation tool to promote reflective practices
    McFadden, J.; Ellis, J.; Anwar, T.; Roehrig, G.
  • Peer feedback in an undergraduate programme: using action research to overcome students' reluctance to criticize
    McMahon, T.
  • Development and retention of generation Y employees: a conceptual framework
    Naim, M.F.; Lenka, U.
  • Pre-service teachers' meaning-making when collaboratively analyzing video from school practice for the bachelor project at college
    Nielsen, B.L.
  • Exploring badging for peer review, extended learning and evaluation, and reflective/critical feedback within an online graduate course
    O'Connor, E.A.; McQuigge, A.
  • The influence of video reflection on preservice music teachers' concerns in peer- and field-teaching settings
    Powell, S.R.
  • The effects of field experience on delivery of feedback
    Ramos, A.R.; Esslinger, K.; Pyle, E.
  • Observation and feedback during student teaching: learning from peers
    Rauch, K.; Whittaker, C.R.
  • Teachers' and school administrators' attitudes and beliefs of teacher evaluation: a preliminary investigation of high poverty school districts
    Reddy, L.A.; Dudek, C.M.; Peters, S.; Alperin, A.; Kettler, R.J.; Kurz, A.
  • Coaching and mentoring for self-efficacious leadership in schools
    Rhodes, C.; Fletcher, S.
  • Decisions and reasons: examining preservice teacher decision-making through video self-analysis
    Rich, P.J.; Hannafin, M.J.
  • Equality of mentoring and coaching opportunity: making both available to pre-service teachers
    Salter, T.
  • Using activity theory to understand the role of the coach in K–12 curriculum redevelopment
    Sam, C.; Caliendo, A.
  • Learning to teach mathematics and to analyze teaching effectiveness: evidence from a video- and practice-based approach
    Santagata, R.; Yeh, C.
  • Teachers' epistemological world views and educational practices
    Schraw, G.; Olafson, L.
  • Influencing children's self-efficacy and self-regulation of reading and writing through modeling
    Schunk, D.H.; Zimmerman, B.J.
  • Variability versus continuity: student teachers' perceptions of two university supervision formats
    Shoulders, C.W.; Edgar, D.; Bolton, A.
  • Pushing forward: finding and using meaningful evidence of beginning teacher competency
    Sowder, M.
  • Policy implementation and cognition: reframing and refocusing implementation research
    Spillane, J.P.; Reiser, B.J.; Reimer, T.
  • Learning through observing in practice
    Tenenberg, J.
  • Action research on a collegial model of peer observations
    Tezcan-Unal, B.
  • Peer-supported review of teaching: an evaluation
    Thampy, H.; Bourke, M.; Naran, P.
  • From pedagogy to practice: mentoring and reciprocal peer coaching for preservice teachers
    Trautwein, B.; Ammerman, S.
  • The role of feedback from the school leader during teacher evaluation for teacher and school improvement
    Tuytens, M.; Devos, G.
  • Confidence building through peer observation in university departments: a good investment for some and not others
    Whipp, P.R.; Pengelley, R.
  • The need for instructional sensitivity and construct clarity in PACT: a commentary on ‘Examining the internal structure evidence for the Performance Assessment for California Teachers’
    Wilkerson, J.R.