Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

How victim credibility and cooperation influence investigative decision-making: examining DOJ's gender bias principles for investigating domestic and sexual violence

How victim credibility and cooperation influence investigative decision-making: examining DOJ's... The purpose of this exploratory study is to examine if and how victim credibility affects investigative decision-making and case outcomes in domestic violence and sexual assault reports through the use of the US Department of Justice's Gender Bias Principles (GBPs).Design/methodology/approachThe authors conducted a content analysis of 370 DVSA police reports from one agency in the western US. Multivariate regression models were estimated to examine the relationships among victim credibility and investigative activities, victim cooperation and case clearance.FindingsVictim credibility significantly predicts specific investigative actions and case clearance, but not victim cooperation. Multiple aspects of DVSA investigations significantly impact victim cooperation as well as case clearance, regardless of victim credibility issues. The GBPs are an effective framework for disaggregating investigative activities and identifying specific areas for improvement in policing response to DVSA.Research limitations/implicationsFurther study is needed to determine the temporal ordering of officer assessment of victim credibility and investigative activities, the stability of such assessments during investigations, and if credibility problems noted in police reports are valid indicators of myth acceptance among officers or represent a downstream orientation of information requested by prosecutors. Victim service referral as a part of policing response is vastly under-researched given referral's strong effects on victim cooperation and case clearance. Crime-specific differences exist in many cases, yet not in others, suggesting separate and combined DVSA analyses are warranted.Practical implicationsA more complex analysis of investigative actions offers a targeted approach to officer training and administrative rule-making that may be more efficient and effective than current generalized approaches.Originality/valueThe study is the first to empirically test the utility of the GBP framework, as well as individual aspects of DVSA investigations, and from a gender-based crime rather than crime-specific approach. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management Emerald Publishing

How victim credibility and cooperation influence investigative decision-making: examining DOJ's gender bias principles for investigating domestic and sexual violence

Download PDF
16 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/how-victim-credibility-and-cooperation-influence-investigative-ltJrKDdIFB
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1363-951X
DOI
10.1108/pijpsm-02-2021-0018
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The purpose of this exploratory study is to examine if and how victim credibility affects investigative decision-making and case outcomes in domestic violence and sexual assault reports through the use of the US Department of Justice's Gender Bias Principles (GBPs).Design/methodology/approachThe authors conducted a content analysis of 370 DVSA police reports from one agency in the western US. Multivariate regression models were estimated to examine the relationships among victim credibility and investigative activities, victim cooperation and case clearance.FindingsVictim credibility significantly predicts specific investigative actions and case clearance, but not victim cooperation. Multiple aspects of DVSA investigations significantly impact victim cooperation as well as case clearance, regardless of victim credibility issues. The GBPs are an effective framework for disaggregating investigative activities and identifying specific areas for improvement in policing response to DVSA.Research limitations/implicationsFurther study is needed to determine the temporal ordering of officer assessment of victim credibility and investigative activities, the stability of such assessments during investigations, and if credibility problems noted in police reports are valid indicators of myth acceptance among officers or represent a downstream orientation of information requested by prosecutors. Victim service referral as a part of policing response is vastly under-researched given referral's strong effects on victim cooperation and case clearance. Crime-specific differences exist in many cases, yet not in others, suggesting separate and combined DVSA analyses are warranted.Practical implicationsA more complex analysis of investigative actions offers a targeted approach to officer training and administrative rule-making that may be more efficient and effective than current generalized approaches.Originality/valueThe study is the first to empirically test the utility of the GBP framework, as well as individual aspects of DVSA investigations, and from a gender-based crime rather than crime-specific approach.

Journal

Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: Aug 31, 2021

Keywords: Investigations; Victim credibility; Domestic violence; Sexual assault; Officer decision-making

References

  • Sexual assault victim participation in police investigations and prosecution
    Alderden, M.A.; Long, L.
  • Creating a more complete and current picture: examining police and prosecutor decision-making when processing sexual assault cases
    Alderden, M.A.; Ullman, S.E.
  • A survey of police officers' and prosecutors' beliefs about crime victim behaviors
    Ask, K.
  • Response to domestic violence in a pro-active court setting- final report
    Buzawa, E.; Hotaling, G.T.; Klein, A.; Byrne, J.
  • The determination of victim credibility by adult and juvenile sexual assault investigators
    Campbell, B.A.; Menaker, T.A.; King, W.R.
  • Joint statement of the Office of Community Oriented Policing Services, The Office for Victims of Crime, and the Office on Violence against Women on addressing gender-discrimination in policing
  • Police officer perceptions of intimate partner violence: an analysis of observational data
    DeJong, C.; Burgess-Proctor, A.; Elis, L.
  • Crime in the United States 2019
  • Victim's relationship to the offender, 2019
  • The effect of rape myth endorsement on police response to sexual assault survivors
    Garza, A.D.; Franklin, C.A.
  • Perceptions of victim advocates and predictors of service referral among law enforcement personnel
    Goodson, A.; Garza, A.D.; Franklin, C.A.; Updegrove, A.H.; Bouffard, L.A.
  • Law enforcement officers' attitudes about domestic violence
    Gover, A.R.; Paul, D.P.; Dodge, M.
  • Rape crimes: are victims’ acute psychological distress and perceived social support associated with police case decision and victim willingness to participate in the investigation?
    Hansen, N.B.; Hansen, M.; Nielsen, L.H.; Bramsen, R.H.; Elklit, A.; Campbell, R.
  • The influence of ‘high’ vs. ‘low’ rape myth acceptance on police officers' judgements of victim and perpetrator responsibility, and rape authenticity
    Hine, B.; Murphy, A.
  • Making domestic violence arrest: a test of expectancy theory
    Johnson, R.R.
  • Determinants of social desirability bias in sensitive surveys: a literature review
    Krumpal, I.
  • Focal concerns and police decision making in sexual assault cases: a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Lapsey, Jr.; Campbell, B.A.; Plumlee, B.T.
  • Victims' perceptions of police response to intimate partner violence
    Leisenring, A.
  • Ending gender bias in the law enforcement response to sexual assault and domestic violence. Report on the OVW roundtable August 2016
    Martinson, R.; Gamache, D.
  • The use of forensic evidence in sexual assault investigations: perceptions of sex crimes investigators
    Menaker, T.A.; Campbell, B.A.; Wells, W.
  • It all just piles up: challenges to victim credibility accumulate to influence sexual assault case processing
    Morabito, M.S.; Pattavina, A.; Williams, L.M.
  • Criminal victimization, 2016: revised
    Morgan, R.E.; Kena, G.
  • Criminal victimization, 2018
    Morgan, R.E.; Oudekerk, B.A.
  • Who will help me? Domestic violence survivors speak about law enforcement responses
  • Identifying and preventing gender bias in law enforcement response to sexual assault and domestic violence. A roundtable discussion
  • Police response to domestic violence, 2006-2015
    Reaves, B.A.
  • The domestic violence arrest decision: examining demographic, attitudinal, and situational variables
    Robinson, A.L.; Chandek, M.S.
  • Police evaluations of intimate partner violence in heterosexual and same-sex relationships: do experience and training play a role?
    Russell, B.; Sturgeon, J.A.
  • Police perceptions in intimate partner violence cases: the influence of gender and sexual orientation
    Russell, B.
  • Justifying injustice: how the criminal justice system explains its response to sexual assault
    Shaw, J.
  • The view from inside the system: how police explain their response to sexual assault
    Shaw, J.; Campbell, R.; Cain, D.
  • Beyond surveys and scales: how rape myths manifest in sexual assault police records
    Shaw, J.; Campbell, R.; Cain, D.; Feeney, H.
  • Police perceptions of rape victims and the impact on case decision making: a systematic review
    Sleath, E.; Bull, R.
  • The criminal justice system's response to sexual violence
    Spohn, C.; Tellis, K.
  • Sexual assault case outcomes: disentangling the overlapping decisions of police and prosecutors
    Spohn, C.; Tellis, K.
  • Public's and police officers' interpretation and handing of domestic violence cases: divergent realities
    Stalans, L.J.; Finn, M.A.
  • Stop blaming the victim: a meta-analysis on rape myths
    Suarez, E.; Gadalla, T.M.
  • Factors that affect the arrest decision in domestic violence cases
    Tatum, K.M.; Pence, R.
  • Intimate partner violence myths in police reports: a directed content analysis
    Twis, M.K.; Nguyen, A.P.; Nordberg, A.
  • Identifying and preventing gender bias in law enforcement response to sexual assault and domestic violence
  • Making judgments: how blame mediates the influence of rape myth acceptance in police response to sexual assault
    Venema, R.M.
  • Attitudes and beliefs about domestic violence: results of a public opinion survey. II. Beliefs about causes
    Worden, A.P.; Carlson, B.E.