Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

How analyst recommendations respond to corporate uncertainty caused by investment behavior

How analyst recommendations respond to corporate uncertainty caused by investment behavior Corporate investment behavior increases the uncertainty of a company’s operation and performance. The purpose of this paper is to investigate how analyst recommendations respond to corporate uncertainty caused by investment behavior and what motivates analysts to react as they do.Design/methodology/approachThe authors test two motivation hypotheses: the hypothesis that analysts are currying favor with management to obtain private information and the hypothesis that analysts have conflicts of interest due to connections. Using Chinese analyst-level data from 2007 to 2015, the authors find that overall investment levels, R&D investment and M&A events are significantly positively correlated with analyst recommendations, suggesting that analysts tend to react optimistically to corporate investment behavior.FindingsAnalysts are only optimistic about companies with low information transparency, suggesting that analysts may be trying to curry favor with management to gain access to private information. The authors find that analysts with stronger recommendations have more private information and analysts with more private information publish more accurate earnings forecasts, which supports the hypothesis that analysts curry favor with management through optimistic recommendations to obtain more private information. This is consistent with the logic that the difficulty of earnings forecasting increases under uncertain conditions, increasing the demand for private information. The authors then group the analysts according to their underwriting connections, securities company’s proprietary connections and fund connections, and find that the positive correlation between corporate investment behavior and analyst recommendations exists only in the unconnected groups. This is evidence against the hypothesis that analysts have conflicts of interest due to their connections.Originality/valueFirst, the authors link the optimism of analysts with the uncertainty of analysts’ information inputs to partially unpack the black box of analysts’ analyses. Second, the authors test the two hypotheses mentioned. There is a lack of comparative studies on the influence of different motivations on the behavior of analysts. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png China Finance Review International Emerald Publishing

How analyst recommendations respond to corporate uncertainty caused by investment behavior

Zhang, Longwen; Wei, Minghai
China Finance Review International , Volume 10 (3): 27 – Jun 18, 2020
Download PDF
27 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/how-analyst-recommendations-respond-to-corporate-uncertainty-caused-by-N2PD0g0Qol
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
2044-1398
DOI
10.1108/cfri-05-2019-0046
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Corporate investment behavior increases the uncertainty of a company’s operation and performance. The purpose of this paper is to investigate how analyst recommendations respond to corporate uncertainty caused by investment behavior and what motivates analysts to react as they do.Design/methodology/approachThe authors test two motivation hypotheses: the hypothesis that analysts are currying favor with management to obtain private information and the hypothesis that analysts have conflicts of interest due to connections. Using Chinese analyst-level data from 2007 to 2015, the authors find that overall investment levels, R&D investment and M&A events are significantly positively correlated with analyst recommendations, suggesting that analysts tend to react optimistically to corporate investment behavior.FindingsAnalysts are only optimistic about companies with low information transparency, suggesting that analysts may be trying to curry favor with management to gain access to private information. The authors find that analysts with stronger recommendations have more private information and analysts with more private information publish more accurate earnings forecasts, which supports the hypothesis that analysts curry favor with management through optimistic recommendations to obtain more private information. This is consistent with the logic that the difficulty of earnings forecasting increases under uncertain conditions, increasing the demand for private information. The authors then group the analysts according to their underwriting connections, securities company’s proprietary connections and fund connections, and find that the positive correlation between corporate investment behavior and analyst recommendations exists only in the unconnected groups. This is evidence against the hypothesis that analysts have conflicts of interest due to their connections.Originality/valueFirst, the authors link the optimism of analysts with the uncertainty of analysts’ information inputs to partially unpack the black box of analysts’ analyses. Second, the authors test the two hypotheses mentioned. There is a lack of comparative studies on the influence of different motivations on the behavior of analysts.

Journal

China Finance Review International – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jun 18, 2020

Keywords: Investment behaviour; Uncertainty; Analyst optimism; Curry favour with management; Connections

References

  • Do analyst conflicts matter? Evidence from stock recommendations
    Agrawal, A.; Chen, M.
  • Adverse selection, brokerage coverage, and trading activity on the Tokyo Stock Exchange
    Ahn, H.; Cai, J.; Hamao, Y.; Ho, R.Y.K.
  • Performance pricing in bank debt contracts
    Asquith, P.; Anne, B.; Joseph, P.W.
  • MD&A quality as measured by the SEC and analysts’ earnings forecasts
    Barron, O.; Kile, C.; O’Keefe, T.
  • High-technology intangibles and analysts’ forecasts
    Barron, O.E.; Byard, D.; Kile, C.; Riedl, E.J.
  • Analyst coverage and intangible assets
    Barth, M.E.; Kasznik, R.; McNichols, M.F.
  • Firm characteristics and analyst following
    Bhushan, R.
  • Do conference calls affect analysts’ forecasts?
    Bowen, R.; Davis, A.; Matsumoto, D.
  • Analysts’ forecasts: what do we know after decades of work?
    Bradshaw, M.T.
  • Investment analysis and price formation in securities markets
    Brennan, M.J.; Subrahmanyam, A.
  • Does M&A pay? A survey of evidence for the decision-maker
    Bruner, R.F.
  • The informational role of financial analysts: interpreting public disclosures
    Byard, D.; Kenneth, W.S.
  • Securities firms’ proprietary business and analyst optimism
    Cao, S.; Zhu, H.
  • Production of information, information asymmetry, and the bid-ask spread: empirical evidence from analysts’ forecasts
    Chung, K.H.; Mc-Inish, T.H.; Wood, R.A.; Wyhowski, D.J.
  • How do analyst recommendations respond to major news?
    Conrad, J.; Cornell, B.; Landsman, W.; Rountree, B.
  • Which types of analyst firms are more optimistic?
    Cowen, A.; Groysberg, B.; Healy, P.
  • Earnings predictability and bias in analysts’ earnings forecasts
    Das, S.; Levine, C.B.; Sivaramakrishnan, K.
  • The information content of dividend changes: cash flow signaling, over-investment, and dividend clienteles
    Denis, D.; Denis, D.; Sarin, A.
  • Optimal release of information by firms
    Diamond, D.W.
  • International diversification and analysts’ forecasts’ accuracy and bias
    Duru, A.; Reeb, D.
  • The interdependent use of earnings and dividends in financial analysts’ earnings forecasts
    Ely, K.; Mande, V.
  • The client is king: do mutual fund relationships bias analyst recommendations?
    Firth, M.; Lin, C.; Liu, P.; Xuan, Y.
  • Analysts’ decisions as products of a multi-task environment
    Francis, J.; Philbrick, D.
  • The superiority and disciplining role of independent analysts
    Gu, Z.; Xue, J.
  • Monitors or predators: the influence of institutional investors on sell-side analysts
    Gu, Z.; Li, G.; Li, Z.; Yang, Y.
  • The accuracy of financial analysts’ forecasts after merges
    Haw, I.; Jung, K.; Ruland, W.
  • Stock performance and intermediation changes surrounding sustained increases in disclosure
    Healy, P.; Hutton, A.; Palepu, K.
  • Security analysts’ career concerns and herding of earnings forecasts
    Hong, H.; Kubik, J.; Solomon, D.
  • Trade generation, reputation, and sell-side analysts
    Jackson, A.
  • Do non-investment bank analysts make better earnings forecasts?
    Jacob, J.; Rock, S.; Weber, D.
  • Corporate disclosure policy and analyst behavior
    Lang, M.; Lundholm, R.
  • Rationality and analysts’ forecast bias
    Lim, T.
  • Underwriting relationships, analysts’ earnings forecasts and investment recommendations
    Lin, H.; McNichols, M.
  • Self-selection and analyst coverage
    McNichols, M.; O’Brien, P.C.
  • The economics of conflicts of interest in financial institutions
    Mehran, H.; Stulz, R.M.
  • Conflict of interest and credibility of underwriter analyst recommendations
    Michaely, R.; Womack, K.
  • Does forecast accuracy matter to security analysts?
    Mikhail, M.; Walther, B.; Willis, R.
  • Security analyst monitoring activity: agency costs and information demands
    Moyer, R.C.; Chatfield, R.E.; Sisneros, P.M.
  • Analyst impartiality and investment banking relationships
    O’Brien, P.C.; McNichols, M.; Lin, M.H.
  • Analysts following and institutional ownership
    O’Brien, P.C.; Bhushan, R.
  • A content analysis of sell-side financial analyst company reports
    Previts, G.; Bricker, R.; Robinson, T.; Young, S.
  • Content analysis of information cited in reports of sell-side financial analysts
    Rogers, R.; Grant, J.
  • The impact of acquisitions on operating performance: some Australian evidence
    Sharma, D.S.; Ho, J.
  • How well do adverse selection components measure adverse selection
    Van Ness, B.F.; Van Ness, R.A.; Warr, R.S.
  • The relation between a prior earnings forecast by management and analyst response to a current management forecast
    Williams, P.
  • The dependence of china’s economic growth on exports and investment
    Zhu, A.D.; Kotz, D.M.
  • Information environment, market-wide sentiment and IPO initial returns: evidence from analyst forecasts before listing
    Zhu, H.J.; Zhang, C.; Li, H.; Chen, S.M.
  • Using analysts’ forecasts to measure properties of analysts’ information environment
    Barron, O.E.; Kim, O.; Lim, S.C.; Stevens, D.E.
  • The financial analyst forecasting literature: a taxonomy with suggestions for further research
    Ramnath, S.; Rock, S.; Shane, P.