Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Entrepreneurial cognition and premature scaling of startups: a qualitative analysis of determinants of start-up failures

Entrepreneurial cognition and premature scaling of startups: a qualitative analysis of... This study aims to explore the behavioral patterns of entrepreneurs, their cognitive styles and personality characteristics that can lead to a self-destructive chain of events during the transition from a fledgling business to one capable of long-term, profitable growth. This study adopts the self-regulation attitude theory to uncover the reasons for premature start-up scaling, which will help founders to study on their cognitive biases, emotions and behaviors and make efforts to do what does not come naturally to them.Design/methodology/approachThe respondents for this qualitative study were selected from a group of entrepreneurs with extensive experience with technology start-ups that have either failed or succeeded during their development stages. In-depth semi-structured interviews were conducted with eight participants, who were selected through snowball sampling, on the theme of understanding “How do premature scaling mistakes happen?”. Thematic analysis was used to unearth common themes.FindingsThe results of this study identified the following themes, “comparison,” “emotional over-reaction,” “impatience,” “mistaken customer priorities,” “overestimation” and “overconfidence,” which eventually leads to premature scaling. The underlying decision-making heuristics of entrepreneurs can be identified as engulfed in different cognitive biases and emotions resulting in negative behavioral patterns, as in the case of premature scaling. Of the six themes, “comparison,” “mistaken customer priorities,” “overestimation” and “overconfidence relates to cognitive bias” and “emotional over-reaction” and “impatience” relate to emotional factors.Research limitations/implicationsThe study was made possible with the support of the voluntary participants chosen by purposive and snowballing data sampling. The interviewee and interviewer biases could have also crept in as part of this qualitative approach. The study pertains only to start-ups in the information technology sector and further studies need to be done to generalize the results across industries as well.Practical implicationsThis early-stage underestimation of unexpected obstacles in the entrepreneurship journey necessitates a focus on the entrepreneur too, as much as the concept. In these hectic and fast-paced circumstances, aspiring entrepreneurs must be taught how to deal objectively with themselves and others, as well as think strategically. Leaders who scale do so because they take purposeful measures to overcome their weaknesses through self-discipline, soliciting advice from others and using their right to change their attitude and points of view.Originality/valueThe study frames the new approach into the entrepreneurial literature, linking it to self-regulation attitude theory and adds to the nascent literature on neuroentrepreneurship which discuss entrepreneurial cognition, decision-making, and entrepreneurial behavior. This study attempted to explore the reasons behind the premature scaling of startups on an individual level. This study is pioneering in exploring the cognitive factors underlying an entrepreneur’s decision that results in premature scaling. This study provides insights for academicians, entrepreneurs and policymakers and helps understand the cognitive journey that leads to premature scaling. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Entrepreneurship in Emerging Economies Emerald Publishing

Entrepreneurial cognition and premature scaling of startups: a qualitative analysis of determinants of start-up failures

Download PDF
17 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/entrepreneurial-cognition-and-premature-scaling-of-startups-a-0OUJwiRhe3
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
2053-4604
eISSN
2053-4604
DOI
10.1108/jeee-11-2020-0412
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

This study aims to explore the behavioral patterns of entrepreneurs, their cognitive styles and personality characteristics that can lead to a self-destructive chain of events during the transition from a fledgling business to one capable of long-term, profitable growth. This study adopts the self-regulation attitude theory to uncover the reasons for premature start-up scaling, which will help founders to study on their cognitive biases, emotions and behaviors and make efforts to do what does not come naturally to them.Design/methodology/approachThe respondents for this qualitative study were selected from a group of entrepreneurs with extensive experience with technology start-ups that have either failed or succeeded during their development stages. In-depth semi-structured interviews were conducted with eight participants, who were selected through snowball sampling, on the theme of understanding “How do premature scaling mistakes happen?”. Thematic analysis was used to unearth common themes.FindingsThe results of this study identified the following themes, “comparison,” “emotional over-reaction,” “impatience,” “mistaken customer priorities,” “overestimation” and “overconfidence,” which eventually leads to premature scaling. The underlying decision-making heuristics of entrepreneurs can be identified as engulfed in different cognitive biases and emotions resulting in negative behavioral patterns, as in the case of premature scaling. Of the six themes, “comparison,” “mistaken customer priorities,” “overestimation” and “overconfidence relates to cognitive bias” and “emotional over-reaction” and “impatience” relate to emotional factors.Research limitations/implicationsThe study was made possible with the support of the voluntary participants chosen by purposive and snowballing data sampling. The interviewee and interviewer biases could have also crept in as part of this qualitative approach. The study pertains only to start-ups in the information technology sector and further studies need to be done to generalize the results across industries as well.Practical implicationsThis early-stage underestimation of unexpected obstacles in the entrepreneurship journey necessitates a focus on the entrepreneur too, as much as the concept. In these hectic and fast-paced circumstances, aspiring entrepreneurs must be taught how to deal objectively with themselves and others, as well as think strategically. Leaders who scale do so because they take purposeful measures to overcome their weaknesses through self-discipline, soliciting advice from others and using their right to change their attitude and points of view.Originality/valueThe study frames the new approach into the entrepreneurial literature, linking it to self-regulation attitude theory and adds to the nascent literature on neuroentrepreneurship which discuss entrepreneurial cognition, decision-making, and entrepreneurial behavior. This study attempted to explore the reasons behind the premature scaling of startups on an individual level. This study is pioneering in exploring the cognitive factors underlying an entrepreneur’s decision that results in premature scaling. This study provides insights for academicians, entrepreneurs and policymakers and helps understand the cognitive journey that leads to premature scaling.

Journal

Journal of Entrepreneurship in Emerging Economies – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jan 20, 2023

Keywords: Entrepreneurship practice; Entrepreneurial cognition; Decision-making heuristics; Premature scaling; Self-regulation attitude theory; Sustainable development of startups

References

  • The relationship between entrepreneurial cognitions and sustainability orientation: the case of an emerging market
    Abdelnaeim, S.M.; El-Bassiouny, N.
  • Human capital and entrepreneurial intentions: do entrepreneurship education and training provided by universities add value?
    Aboobaker, N.; Renjini, D.
  • Psychological capital for success: the mediating role of entrepreneurial persistence and risk-taking
    Al Issa, H.E.
  • A survivability model for saudi ICT startups
    Almakenzi, S.; Bramantoro, A.; Rashideh, W.
  • Cognitive reflection, decision biases, and response times
    Alos-Ferrer, C.; Garagnani, M.; Hugelschafer, S.
  • The effect of management commitment to service quality on employee affective and performance outcomes
    Babakus, E.; Yavas, U.; Karatepe, O.; Avci, T.
  • The self-regulation of attitudes, intentions, and behavior
    Bagozzi, R.P.
  • Social cognitive theory of self‐regulation
    Bandura, A.
  • Startup genome report 01
    Berman, R.; Eesley, C.; Blank, S.
  • SME development strategy and product/service innovation intention: a NCaRBS analysis of the role of uncertainty
    Beynon, M.J.; Jones, P.; Pickernell, D.
  • Configurations of resources, strategy, structure and environment in young high-technology firms: evidence from qualitative comparative analysis
    Blank, S.; Dorf, B.; Balodi, K.C.; Basu, S.
  • Self-regulation and decision heuristics in entrepreneurial opportunity evaluation and exploitation
    Bryant, P.
  • Making sense of overconfidence in market entry
    Cain, D.M.; Moore, D.A.; Haran, U.
  • Conflict management in family businesses: a bibliometric analysis and systematic literature review
    Caputo, A.; Marzi, G.; Pellegrini, M.M.; Rialti, R.
  • Exploring the heart: entrepreneurial emotion is a hot topic
    Cardon, M.S.; Foo, M.D.; Shepherd, D.; Wiklund, J.
  • Entrepreneurial passion as mediator of the self–efficacy to persistence relationship
    Cardon, M.S.; Kirk, C.P.
  • Misfortunes or mistakes? Cultural sensemaking of entrepreneurial failure
    Cardon, M.S.; Stevens, C.E.; Potter, D.R.
  • Cross-Cultural Psychology as a Solution to Global Inequality: Optimism, Overconfidence, or Naiveté?: A commentary on “The Positive Role of Culture: What Cross-Cultural Psychology Has to Offer to Developmental Aid Effectiveness Research
    Chaudhary, N.; Brouwers, Symen A.
  • Business area changes and entrepreneurial persistence in ecology- and food-related industries: knowledge heterogeneity and emotion perspectives
    Chen, H.M.; Tsai, F.S.; Ling, H.C.
  • Making the same mistake all over again: CEO overconfidence and corporate resistance to corrective feedback
    Chen, G.; Crossland, C.; Luo, S.
  • Experiential learning within the process of opportunity identification and exploitation
    Corbett, A.C.
  • Initiating a new research phase in the field of international entrepreneurship: an interview with professor nicole coviello
    Coviello, N.; Tanev, S.
  • Entrepreneurial optimism, credit availability, and cost of financing: evidence from US small businesses
    Dai, N.; Ivanov, V.; Cole, R.A.
  • The effect of risk perception and cognitive biases on the evaluation of opportunity in family and non-family entrepreneurs: the case of tunisian entrepreneurs
    Dali, N.; Harbi, S.
  • Cognitive biases and strategic decision processes: an integrative perspective
    Das, T.K.; Teng, B.
  • Social Capital, cognition, and entrepreneurial opportunities: a theoretical framework
    De Carolis, D.M.; Saparito, P.
  • From barriers to barring: Why emotion matters for entrepreneurial development
    Doern, R.; Goss, D.
  • ‘Bats are blind?’ Cognitive biases in risk perception of entrepreneurs
    Dolarslan, E.S.; Kocak, A.; Ozer, A.
  • The logic of cognitive biases in the behavioral decision-making process
    Domeier, M.; Sachse, P.
  • Mentor expectations and entrepreneurial venture creation: mediating role of the sense of nothing to lose and entrepreneurial resilience
    Dost, M.; Shah, S.M.M.; Saleem, I.
  • Developing and investigating the use of single-item measures in organizational research
    Fisher, G.G.; Matthews, R.A.; Gibbons, A.M.
  • Are some entrepreneurs more overconfident than others?
    Forbes, D.P.
  • Mass or only ‘niche customization’? Why we should interpret configuration toolkits as learning instrument
    Franke, N.; Hader, C.
  • Contextualizing entrepreneurial innovation: a narrative perspective
    Garud, R.; Gehman, J.; Giuliani, A.P.
  • The impact of Covid-19 on global startup ecosystems
    Gauthier, J.F.; Morelix, A.; Officer, C.I.
  • Why early stage software startups fail: a behavioral framework
    Giardino, C.; Wang, X.; Abrahamsson, P.
  • The importance of being emotional: how do emotions affect entrepreneurial opportunity evaluation and exploitation?
    Grichnik, D.; Smeja, A.; Welpe, I.
  • The evolution of cognitive bias
    Haselton, M.G.; Nettle, D.; Murray, D.R.; Buss, D.M.
  • A hubris theory of entrepreneurship
    Hayward, M.L.; Shepherd, D.A.; Griffin, D.
  • Beyond hubris: how highly confident entrepreneurs rebound to venture again
    Hayward, M.L.; Forster, W.R.; Sarasvathy, S.D.; Fredrickson, B.L.
  • We should totally open a restaurant: How optimism and overconfidence affect beliefs
    Heger, S.A.; Papageorge, N.W.
  • Entrepreneurs’ optimism and new venture performance: a social cognitive perspective
    Hmieleski, K.M.; Baron, R.A.
  • Focus entrepreneurship policy on Scale-Up, not Start-Up
    Isenberg, D.
  • Opportunity evaluation under risky conditions: the cognitive processes of entrepreneurs
    Keh, H.T.; Der Foo, M.; Lim, B.C.
  • Entrepreneurial potential and potential entrepreneurs
    Krueger Jr , N.F.; Brazeal, D.V.
  • Traits of Entrepreneurs of Small-Scale Sector
    Kumar, A.; Sihag, S.
  • Entrepreneurial leadership, capabilities and firm growth
    Koryak, O.; Mole, K.F.; Lockett, A.; Hayton, J.C.; Ucbasaran, D.; Hodgkinson, G.P.
  • Cognitive bias modification of expectancies (cbm-e): effects on interpretation bias and autobiographical memory, and relations with social and attachment anxiety
    Krans, J.; Bosmans, G.; Salemink, E.; De Raedt, R.
  • The changing role of network ties and critical capabilities in an international new venture’s early development
    Laurell, H.; Achtenhagen, L.; Andersson, S.
  • Exploration of the initiation and process of business model innovation of successful Chinese ICT enterprises
    Liu, P.; Bell, R.
  • Who makes acquisitions? CEO overconfidence and the market's reaction
    Malmendier, U.; Tate, G.
  • Entrepreneurial judgment as empathic accuracy: a sequential decision-making approach to entrepreneurial action
    McMullen, J.S.
  • Startup genome report extra: Premature scaling
    Marmer, M.; Herrmann, B.L.; Dogrultan, E.; Berman, R.; Eesley, C.; Blank, S.
  • The startup ecosystem report 2012
    Marmer, M.; Herrmann, B.L.; Dogrultan, E.; Berman, R.; Eesley, C.; Blank, S.
  • A business success versus failure prediction model for small businesses in Israel
    Marom, S.; Lussier, R.N.
  • Toward a theory of entrepreneurial cognition: rethinking the people side of entrepreneurship research
    Mitchell, R.K.; Busenitz, L.; Lant, T.; McDougall, P.P.; Morse, E.A.; Smith, J.B.
  • Ethical judgment and radical business changes: the role of entrepreneurial perspicacity
    Pellegrini, M.; Ciappei, C.
  • From startup to scalable enterprise: Laying the foundation
    Picken, J.C.
  • Embodied multi-discursivity: an aesthetic process approach to sustainable entrepreneurship
    Poldner, K.; Shrivastava, P.; Branzei, O.
  • Entrepreneurial behaviour and startups: the case of Germany and the USA
    Richter, N.; Jackson, P.; Schildhauer, T.
  • Overconfidence and risk perceptions: do they really matter for venture creation decisions?
    Robinson, A.T.; Marino, L.D.
  • Cognitive style and the management of small and medium-sized enterprises
    Sadler-Smith, E.
  • Perseverance of effort and consistency of interest for entrepreneurial career success: does resilience matter?
    Salisu, I.; Hashim, N.; Mashi, M.S.; Aliyu, H.G.
  • An effectual approach to international entrepreneurship: overlaps, challenges, and provocative possibilities
    Sarasvathy, S.; Kumar, K.; York, J.G.; Bhagavatula, S.
  • Neuroentrepreneurship: an integrative review and research agenda
    Sharma, Gagan. D.; Paul, J.; Srivastava, M.; Yadav, A.; Mendy, J.; Sarker, T.; Bansal, S.
  • Thinking about entrepreneurial decision making: review and research agenda
    Shepherd, D.A.; Williams, T.A.; Patzelt, H.
  • Cognitive biases, risk perception, and venture formation: how individuals decide to start companies
    Simon, M.; Houghton, S.M.; Aquino, K.
  • The impact of moral intensity and desire for control on scaling decisions in social entrepreneurship
    Smith, B.R.; Kistruck, G.M.; Cannatelli, B.
  • Is procrastination a ‘friend or foe’? Building the relationship between fear of the failure and entrepreneurs’ well-being
    Soomro, B.A.; Shah, N.
  • Two decades of cognitive bias research in entrepreneurship: what do we know and where do we go from here?
    Thomas, O.
  • The nature of entrepreneurial experience, business failure and comparative optimism
    Ucbasaran, D.; Westhead, P.; Wright, M.; Flores, M.
  • Effect of mind-power ability among achieving entrepreneurs in South Africa: identifying accustomed internal drivers
    Van Rensburg, N.; Ogujiuba, K.
  • Too much positive thinking hinders entrepreneur success
    Von Bergen, C.W.; Bressler, M.S.
  • Toward a greater understanding of entrepreneurship and strategy in the informal economy
    Webb, J.W.; Ireland, R.D.; Ketchen, D.J. Jr
  • Bouncing back” from a loss: entrepreneurial orientation, emotions, and failure narratives
    Wolfe, M.T.; Shepherd, D.A.
  • A temporal view of entrepreneurial opportunities
    Wood, M.S.; Bakker, R.
  • The nature of information and overconfidence on venture capitalists’ decision making
    Zacharakis, A.L.; Shepherd, D.A.
  • Self-Regulation. Directions and challenges for future research
    Zeidner, M.; Boekaerts, M.; Pintrich, P.; Boekaerts, M.; Pintrich, P.; Zeidner, M.
  • The study of bias in entrepreneurship
    Zhang, S.X.; Cueto, J.
  • Configurations of resources, strategy, structure and environment in young high-technology firms: evidence from qualitative comparative analysis
    Balodi, K.C.; Basu, S.
  • Cognition and capabilities in entrepreneurial ventures
    Busenitz, L.W.; Arthurs, J.D.
  • The dark triad and nascent entrepreneurship: an examination of unproductive versus productive entrepreneurial motives
    Hmieleski, K.M.; Lerner, D.A.
  • Entrepreneurs' attitudes towards failure: an experiential learning approach
    Politis, D.; Gabrielsson, J.
  • Risk premium shocks can create inefficient recessions working paper (no. w26721)
    Tella, S.D.; Hall, R.E.
  • Opportunity evaluation as rule‐based decision making
    Wood, M.S.; Williams, D.W.