Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Effect of underdog (vs topdog) brand storytelling on brand identification: exploring multiple mediation mechanisms

Effect of underdog (vs topdog) brand storytelling on brand identification: exploring multiple... The purpose of this paper is to focus on the building of consumer–brand identification through the use of two themes (underdog and topdog) in the design of brand storytelling. It proposes that the underdog theme is superior because it is more effective in immersing readers in the story and generates higher emotional responses. The moderating effect of consumers’ implicit mindsets is also explored.Design/methodology/approachAn experimental study with a single-factorial design is conducted with 301 consumers assigned at random to one of two brand storytelling conditions: underdog theme or topdog theme.FindingsThe results show a full mediating effect of the underdog (vs topdog) theme on brand identification through reader immersion and empathic feelings.Research limitations/implicationsThe use of a fictitious brand and a specific product category may limit the generalizability of the results.Practical implicationsPlacing the brand in a story with an underdog plot is more effective in catching consumers’ attention than using a topdog brand story. In particular, using an underdog theme is a good approach for targeting consumers who have a growth mindset.Originality/valueThis study explains the persuasiveness of brand storytelling in terms of the characteristics of the storytelling itself rather than the individual characteristics of consumers (e.g. their own underdog dispositions). The results also suggest that the implicit mindset of the individual plays a role. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Product & Brand Management Emerald Publishing

Effect of underdog (vs topdog) brand storytelling on brand identification: exploring multiple mediation mechanisms

Download PDF
13 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/effect-of-underdog-vs-topdog-brand-storytelling-on-brand-rdSkWWjDXL
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1061-0421
DOI
10.1108/jpbm-11-2019-2639
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to focus on the building of consumer–brand identification through the use of two themes (underdog and topdog) in the design of brand storytelling. It proposes that the underdog theme is superior because it is more effective in immersing readers in the story and generates higher emotional responses. The moderating effect of consumers’ implicit mindsets is also explored.Design/methodology/approachAn experimental study with a single-factorial design is conducted with 301 consumers assigned at random to one of two brand storytelling conditions: underdog theme or topdog theme.FindingsThe results show a full mediating effect of the underdog (vs topdog) theme on brand identification through reader immersion and empathic feelings.Research limitations/implicationsThe use of a fictitious brand and a specific product category may limit the generalizability of the results.Practical implicationsPlacing the brand in a story with an underdog plot is more effective in catching consumers’ attention than using a topdog brand story. In particular, using an underdog theme is a good approach for targeting consumers who have a growth mindset.Originality/valueThis study explains the persuasiveness of brand storytelling in terms of the characteristics of the storytelling itself rather than the individual characteristics of consumers (e.g. their own underdog dispositions). The results also suggest that the implicit mindset of the individual plays a role.

Journal

Journal of Product & Brand Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: May 11, 2021

Keywords: Immersion; Brand storytelling; Empathic feelings; Implicit mindsets; Topdog; Underdog

References

  • Fairness and preference for underdog and top dogs
    Allison, S.T.; Burnette, J.; Kramer, R.; Tenbrunsel, A.; Bazerman, M.
  • Effects of Brand attitude and eWOM on consumers’ willingness to pay in the banking industry: mediating role of consumer-Brand identification and Brand equity
    Augusto, M.; Torres, P.
  • The strategic use of brand biographies
    Avery, J.; Paharia, N.; Keinan, A.; Schor, J.; Belk, R.
  • Five studies testing two new egoistic alternatives to the empathy-altruism hypothesis
    Batson, C.D.; Dyck, J.L.; Brandt, R.; Batson, J.G.; Iówell, A.L.; McMaster, M.R.; Griffitt, C.
  • Empathy and attitudes: can feeling for a member of a stigmatized group improve feelings toward the group?
    Batson, C.D.; Polycarpou, M.P.; Harmon-Jones, E.; Imhoff, H.J.; Mitchener, E.C.; Bednar, L.L.; Klein, T.R.; Highberger, L.
  • Meaningful stories and attitudes toward the Brand: the moderating role of consumers’ implicit mindsets
    Carnevale, M.; Yucel-Aybat, O.; Kachersky, L.
  • How to align your Brand stories with your products
    Chiu, H.C.; Hsieh, Y.C.; Kuo, Y.C.
  • Keeping it real: how perceived Brand authenticity affects product perceptions
    Cinelli, M.D.; LeBoeuf, R.A.
  • The role of self definitional principles in consumer identification with a socially responsible company
    Currás-Pérez, R.; Bigné-Alcañiz, E.; Alvarado-Herrera, A.
  • Do ads that tell a story always perform better? The role of character identification and character type in storytelling ads
    Dessart, L.
  • How stories generate consumer engagement: an exploratory study
    Dessart, L.; Pitardi, V.
  • Advertising narratives: What are they and how do they work
    Escalas, J.E.; Stern, B.
  • Fishing for feelings? Hooking viewers help!
    Escalas, J.E.; Moore, M.C.; Britton, J.E.
  • Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error
    Fornell, C.; Larcker, D.F.
  • Authenticity in branding – exploring antecedents and consequences of Brand authenticity
    Fritz, K.; Schoenmueller, V.; Bruhn, M.
  • The underdog narrative in movies: when our memory facts us
    Goldschmied, N.; Ruiz, J.; Olagaray, S.
  • In the mind’s eye transportation-imagery model of narrative persuasion
    Green, M.C.; Brock, T.C.; Green, M.C.; Strange, J.J.; Brock, T.C.
  • Cultural variations in country of origin effects
    Gürhan-Canli, Z.; Maheswaran, D.
  • Interaction of the underdog with equality and scarcity
    Han, B.; Kim, M.
  • Feelings and consumer decision making: the appraisal-tendency framework
    Han, S.; Lerner, J.S.; Keltner, D.
  • Story perspective and character similarity as drivers of identification and narrative persuasion
    Hoeken, H.; Kolthoff, M.; Sanders, J.
  • Understanding the influences of story elements in service businesses
    Hsieh, Y.C.; Chiu, H.C.; Tang, Y.C.; Liu, C.H.
  • How power states influence the persuasiveness of top-dog versus underdog appeals
    Jin, L.; Huang, Y.
  • Mindsets matter: implications for branding research and practice
    John, D.R.; Park, J.K.
  • Effects of underdog (vs. top dog) positioning advertising
    Jun, S.; Sung, J.; Gentry, J.W.; McGinnis, L.P.
  • Is Cinderella resurging? The impact of consumers’ underdog disposition on Brand preferences: underdog brand biography and brand status as moderators
    Kao, D.T.
  • The impact of envy on Brand preference: brand storytelling and psychological distance as moderators
    Kao, D.T.
  • The impact of construal level on Brand preferences: ad metaphors and brand biography as moderators
    Kao, D.T.; Wu, P.H.; Yu, A.P.
  • Consumer research insights on brands and branding: a JCR curation
    Keller, K.L.
  • The underdog trap: the moderating role of transgression type in forgiving underdog brands
    Kim, Y.; Park, K.; Lee, S.S.
  • Doing well versus doing good: the differential effect of underdog positioning on moral and competent service provides
    Kirmani, A.; Hamilton, R.W.; Thompson, D.V.; Lantzy, S.
  • Investigating antecedents and consequences of Brand identification
    Kuenzel, S.; Halliday, S.V.
  • Building consumer-brand relationships through Brand experience and brand identification
    Kumar, V.; Kaushik, A.K.
  • Why do older consumers buy older brands? The role of attachment and declining innovativeness
    Lambert-Pandraud, R.; Laurent, G.
  • Stereotype formation and endorsement: the role of implicit theories
    Levy, S.R.; Stroessner, S.J.; Dweck, C.S.
  • Must the underdog win? The moderation effect of product type in the underdog effect of Brand stories
    Li, Y.; Zhao, M.
  • Narrative ads: the effect or argument strength and story format
    Lien, N.H.; Chen, Y.L.
  • Being hooked” by a brand story: a view of regulatory focus
    Lin, C.H.; Chen, M.Y.
  • The power of social media storytelling in destination branding
    Lund, N.F.; Cohen, S.A.; Scarles, C.
  • Motivational bases for consumers’ underdog affection in commerce
    McGinnis, L.P.; Gao, T.; Jun, S.; Gentry, J.
  • Underdog consumption: an exploration into meanings and motives
    McGinnis, L.P.; Gentry, J.W.
  • Consumer mindsets and self-enhancement: signaling versus learning
    Mathur, P.; Chun, H.H.; Maheswaran, D.
  • Mindsets shape consumer behavior
    Murphy, M.; Dweck, C.S.
  • Support for the underdog Brand biography: effects on consumer attitude and behavior
    Nagar, K.
  • Improving fundraising efficiency in small and medium sized nonprofit organizations using online solutions
    Nageswarakurukkal, K.; GonÇalves, P.; Moshtari, M.
  • Meeting of minds: dialogue, sympathy, and identification in reading fiction
    Oately, K.
  • Compassion, pride, and social intuitions of self-other similarity
    Oveis, C.; Horberg, E.J.; Keltner, D.
  • Positioning firms against large competitors to increase sales
    Paharia, N.; Avery, J.; Keinat, A.
  • The underdog effect: the marketing of disadvantage and determination through Brand biography
    Paharia, N.; Keinan, A.; Avery, J.; Schor, J.B.
  • Judging a book by its cover: the influence of implicit self theories on brand user perceptions
    Park, J.K.; John, D.R.
  • Exploring how video digital storytelling builds relationship experiences
    Pera, R.; Viglia, G.
  • Consumer-Brand identification revisited: an integrative framework of brand identification, customer satisfaction, and price image and their role for brand loyalty and word of mouth
    Popp, B.; Woratschek, H.
  • Do consumers react differently to sweatshop allegations on luxury and non-luxury brands? A brand entiativity-based account
    Rashid, M.; Chattaraman, V.
  • Effect of a brand story structure on narrative transportation and perceived brand image of luxury hotels
    Ryu, K.; Lehto, X.; Gordon, S.E.; Fu, X.
  • Exploring narrative structure and hero enactment in Brand stories
    Sanders, J.; van Krieken, K.
  • The underdog effect in the context of Brand management: an abstract
    Schmidt, H.J.; Steenkamp, P.; Rossi, P.; Krey, N.
  • You are what you watch: identification and transportation effects on temporary self-concept
    Sestir, M.; Green, M.C.
  • Underdog effects: the role of consumption domain and retail crowding
    Shirai, M.
  • The relational value of perceived brand globalness and localness
    Sichtmann, C.; Davvetas, V.; Diamantopoulos, A.
  • Entertainment-education and elaboration likelihood: understanding the processing of narrative persuasion
    Slater, M.D.; Rouner, D.
  • The missing link in building customer Brand identification: the role of Brand attractiveness
    So, K.K.F.; King, C.; Hudson, S.; Meng, F.
  • Short Brand stories on packaging: an examination of consumer responses
    Solja, E.; Liljander, V.; Söderlund, M.
  • Emotional marketing: How pride and compassion impact preferences for underdog and top dog brands
    Staton, M.; Paharia, N.; Oveis, C.
  • Drivers of customer-brand identification
    Stokburger-Sauer, N.E.; Ratneshwar, S.; Sen, S.
  • Communicating Brand biographies effectively: the role of communication source
    Tezer, A.; Bodur, H.O.; Grohmann, B.
  • Predicting high consumer-brand identification and high repurchase: necessary and sufficient conditions
    Torres, P.; Augusto, M.; Godinho, P.
  • Consumers’ identification with corporate brands: brand prestige, anthropomorphism and engagement in social media
    Tuskej, U.; Podnar, K.
  • The extended transportation-imagery model: a meta-analysis of the antecedents and consequences of consumers’ narrative transportation
    Van Laer, T.; de Ruyter, K.; Visconti, L.M.; Wetzels, M.
  • Storytelling in the digital era: a Meta-analysis of relevant moderators of the narrative transportation effect
    Van Laer, T.; Feiereisen, S.; Visconti, L.M.
  • Underdogs as heroes
    Vandello, J.A.; Goldschmied, N.; Michniewicz, K.; Allison, S.T.; Kramer; , R.M.
  • Conducting measurement validation with experimental data: cautions and recommendations
    Voss, G.B.; Parasuraman, A.P.
  • Does mindset matter for using social networking sites? Understanding motivations for and uses of Instagram with growth versus fixed mindset
    Young-A, S.; Lee, S.Y.; Kim, Y.
  • Empathic concern is part of a more general communal emotion
    Zickfeld, J.H.; Schubert, T.W.; Seibt, B.; Fiske, A.P.
  • The role of transportation in the persuasiveness of public narratives
    Green, M.C.; Brock, T.C.