Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Dissemination of knowledge and copyright: an historical case study

Dissemination of knowledge and copyright: an historical case study Purpose – Does copyright protection reduce or foster intellectual and industrial creation? Based on a case study from history of science, the aim is to provide more controversial evidence to this debate. Design/methodology/approach – The investigation used primary and secondary sources from the history of science and made the link to the actual debate on copyright, piracy and scientific communication. Findings – The paper describes how Elzevier, through non‐authorized exploitation of a new product and without consideration of the editor's legitimate interests, in a context of missing copyright protection, largely contributed to the dissemination of the French Journal de Savants and its content, and finally to the success of scientific journals. Obviously, rights infringement can not only promote the interest and objective of the rights holder but also and above all contribute to the emergence and development of new forms of scientific life. Sometimes, when barriers to communication and debate are too strong, tolerated and calculated infringement may be an option to move the lines/change the situation. Research limitations/implications – In the post‐Gutenberg galaxy, made up of open access, common goods and public domain, open data and e‐Science, evaluation, innovation, sustainability, communication and sharing, copyright is not necessarily the (only) option to develop scientific communication. At least, the authors have to study lessons from academic publishing, copyright protection and piracy very carefully. Originality/value – The paper sheds light on a surprising and not very well‐known part of the history of academic publishing. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Information, Communication and Ethics in Society Emerald Publishing

Dissemination of knowledge and copyright: an historical case study

Download PDF
12 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/dissemination-of-knowledge-and-copyright-an-historical-case-study-BY9Te0O0Rj
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2013 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
1477-996X
DOI
10.1108/JICES-06-2013-0018
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – Does copyright protection reduce or foster intellectual and industrial creation? Based on a case study from history of science, the aim is to provide more controversial evidence to this debate. Design/methodology/approach – The investigation used primary and secondary sources from the history of science and made the link to the actual debate on copyright, piracy and scientific communication. Findings – The paper describes how Elzevier, through non‐authorized exploitation of a new product and without consideration of the editor's legitimate interests, in a context of missing copyright protection, largely contributed to the dissemination of the French Journal de Savants and its content, and finally to the success of scientific journals. Obviously, rights infringement can not only promote the interest and objective of the rights holder but also and above all contribute to the emergence and development of new forms of scientific life. Sometimes, when barriers to communication and debate are too strong, tolerated and calculated infringement may be an option to move the lines/change the situation. Research limitations/implications – In the post‐Gutenberg galaxy, made up of open access, common goods and public domain, open data and e‐Science, evaluation, innovation, sustainability, communication and sharing, copyright is not necessarily the (only) option to develop scientific communication. At least, the authors have to study lessons from academic publishing, copyright protection and piracy very carefully. Originality/value – The paper sheds light on a surprising and not very well‐known part of the history of academic publishing.

Journal

Journal of Information, Communication and Ethics in Society – Emerald Publishing

Published: Aug 9, 2013

Keywords: Intellectual property; Privacy; Copyright; Academic publishing; Journal; Scientific communication

References

  • Nouvelles de la République des Lettres
    Bayle, P.
  • La communication scientifique et le numérique
    Beaudry, G.
  • Academic publications before 1940
    Cook, A.
  • Copyright, publishing, and scholarship
    Crews, K.D.; van Westrienen, G.
  • The digital public domain: relevance and regulation
    Dobusch, L.
  • Knowledge Rights – Legal, Societal and Related Technological Aspects, KnowRight 2008, Conference Proceedings, Krakow, Poland, 18‐19 September
  • CAM debate: access all areas
    Gatti, R.
  • In Oldenburg's Long Shadow: Librarians, Research Scientists, Publishers, and the Control of Scientific Publishing
    Guédon, J.‐C.
  • The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: An Inquiry into a Category of Bourgeois Society
    Habermas, J.
  • Geschichte und Wesen des Urheberrechts
    Höffner, E.
  • La propriété littéraire au XVIIIe siècle
    Laboulaye, E.; Guiffrey, G.
  • Free Culture: How Big Media Uses Technology and the Law to Lock Down Culture and Control Creativity
    Lessig, L.
  • Scholarly publishing
    Mabe, M.A.
  • Scritti editi ed ineditti
    Mazzini, G.
  • Avant propos
    Moureau, F.
  • The effect of the internet on researcher motivations, behaviour and attitudes
    Mulligan, A.; Mabe, M.
  • Does copyright have any future on the internet?
    Oppenheim, C.
  • Les journaux savants, formes de la communication et agents de la construction des savoirs (17e‐18e siècles)
    Peiffer, J.; Vittu, J.‐P.
  • Do patent and copyright law restrict competition and creativity excessively?
    Posner, R.A.
  • Cyberdemocracy: internet and the public sphere
    Poster, M.
  • Journal des savants
    Potts, C.H.
  • Scientific Publishing: From Vanity to Strategy
    Roosendaal, H.E.; Zalewska‐Kurek, K.; Geurts, P.A.; Th, M.; Hilf, E.R.
  • De la protection internationale des droits sur les œuvres littéraires et artistiques
    Ruffini, F.
  • Open Access
    Suber, P.
  • Les contrefaçons du Journal des savants de 1665 à 1714
    Vittu, J.‐P.
  • La formation d'une institution scientifique: le Journal des Savants de 1665 à 1714 (1)
    Vittu, J.‐P.
  • La formation d'une institution scientifique: le Journal des Savants de 1665 à 1714 (2)
    Vittu, J.‐P.
  • Science et théologie dans les débats savants de la seconde moitié du XVIIe siècle: La Genèse dans les Philosophical Transactions et le Journal des savants (1665‐1710)
    Volpe, T.
  • Promoting innovation in society
    Voyles, B.
  • Contrefaçon et droit de copie avant 1777
    Weil, F.