Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Disaster recovery and violence in neoliberal times: community and spatial fragmentation in L’Aquila

Disaster recovery and violence in neoliberal times: community and spatial fragmentation in L’Aquila The purpose of this paper is to examine the disruption and reconfiguration of the territorial organisation of the central Italian town of L’Aquila resulting from actions taken by the special commissioner, a plenipotentiary official appointed by the central government, during the ten-month emergency period following the 2009 earthquake. The study attempts to determine how during the commissioner’s short tenure the territory of L’Aquila was restructured for many years to come.Design/methodology/approachThe paper discusses two major issues: first, the short-term reconfiguration of the territorial organisation through mixed operative centres (Centri Operativi Misti, henceforth COMs); and, second, the long-term fragmentation of the physical and social fabric of the town through the resettlement of thousands of families in 19 semi-permanent housing developments located in outlying, rural areas of the municipality. The methods adopted were both qualitative and quantitative. The qualitative methods involved in-depth examination of official documents and interviews with key witnesses such as local administrators, citizens and activists. Quantitative methods included the GIS analysis of spatial and census data to assess changes in population after the earthquake.FindingsThe most significant finding of this study concerns the COMs and their misuse as a tool of centralised, authoritarian governance. Analysis of the territory’s reorganisation revealed that the model of emergency management followed in L’Aquila, far from taking into account unique features of the local population and territory, was hetero-centred and consistent with neoliberal thought. Understanding violence to be an unfolding process, the author argues that such a model of management can be seen as an application of state violence.Originality/valueThis paper adds a new case study to the discussion of the role of the state and the application of neoliberal policies in disaster recovery. The main originality of the paper lies in its focus on COMs and their peculiar use as a tool for implementing an authoritarian model of disaster management. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Disaster Prevention and Management Emerald Publishing

Disaster recovery and violence in neoliberal times: community and spatial fragmentation in L’Aquila

Valent, Gianmaria
Disaster Prevention and Management , Volume 28 (4): 14 – Jul 31, 2019
Download PDF
14 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/disaster-recovery-and-violence-in-neoliberal-times-community-and-0JES6dKx7U
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0965-3562
DOI
10.1108/dpm-01-2018-0032
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to examine the disruption and reconfiguration of the territorial organisation of the central Italian town of L’Aquila resulting from actions taken by the special commissioner, a plenipotentiary official appointed by the central government, during the ten-month emergency period following the 2009 earthquake. The study attempts to determine how during the commissioner’s short tenure the territory of L’Aquila was restructured for many years to come.Design/methodology/approachThe paper discusses two major issues: first, the short-term reconfiguration of the territorial organisation through mixed operative centres (Centri Operativi Misti, henceforth COMs); and, second, the long-term fragmentation of the physical and social fabric of the town through the resettlement of thousands of families in 19 semi-permanent housing developments located in outlying, rural areas of the municipality. The methods adopted were both qualitative and quantitative. The qualitative methods involved in-depth examination of official documents and interviews with key witnesses such as local administrators, citizens and activists. Quantitative methods included the GIS analysis of spatial and census data to assess changes in population after the earthquake.FindingsThe most significant finding of this study concerns the COMs and their misuse as a tool of centralised, authoritarian governance. Analysis of the territory’s reorganisation revealed that the model of emergency management followed in L’Aquila, far from taking into account unique features of the local population and territory, was hetero-centred and consistent with neoliberal thought. Understanding violence to be an unfolding process, the author argues that such a model of management can be seen as an application of state violence.Originality/valueThis paper adds a new case study to the discussion of the role of the state and the application of neoliberal policies in disaster recovery. The main originality of the paper lies in its focus on COMs and their peculiar use as a tool for implementing an authoritarian model of disaster management.

Journal

Disaster Prevention and Management – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jul 31, 2019

Keywords: Deregulation; Authoritarian governance; L’Aquila earthquake; Neoliberal disaster management; State violence

References

  • Chronic disaster syndrome: displacement, disaster capitalism, and the eviction of the poor from New Orleans
    Adams, V.; van Hattum, T.; English, D.
  • The L’Aquila earthquake of 6 April 2009 and Italian Government policy on disaster response
    Alexander, D.
  • An evaluation of the recovery strategy after the 6 April 2009 earthquake in L’Aquila, central Italy
    Alexander, D.
  • An evaluation of medium-term recovery processes after the 6 April 2009 earthquake in L’Aquila, Central Italy
    Alexander, D.
  • Social fragmentation as a consequence of implementing a bus rapid transit system in the city of Bogota
    Bocarejo, J.P.; Portilla, I.; Melendez, D.
  • As a way of introduction. The ‘right to the city’: practices and imaginaries for rethinking the city
    Boniburini, I.
  • Cultura e territorialità: quando l’abitare diventa multitopico Esempi da L’Aquila post sisma
    Calandra, L.M.
  • Abitare i vicoli e ‘le case’ a L’Aquila post-sisma Diritto alla città e spazi di desiderio tra gli adolescenti
    Ciccaglione, R.
  • Disaster recovery and community renewal: housing approaches
    Comerio, M.C.
  • Dasymetric mapping and areal interpolation: implementation and evaluation
    Eicher, C.L.; Brewer, C.A.
  • Disaster recovery: narrating the resilience process in the reconstruction of L’Aquila (Italy)
    Forino, G.
  • The social costs of sprawl
    Freilich, R.H.; Peshoff, B.G.
  • En contra de la ciudad fragmentada: ¿hacia un cambio de paradigma urbanistico en la region metropolitana de Barcelona?
    Marmolejo Duarte, C.; Stallbohm, M.
  • Rendere Le Regioni Più Forti in Seguito a Un Disastro Naturale
  • Dimensione dell’abitare dopo il sisma. L’Aquila tra territorialità, emergenza e CASE
    Palma, F.; Calandra, L.
  • A Mogul who would rebuild New Orleans
    Rivlin, G.
  • Capitale, capitalismo, territorialità
    Turco, A.
  • Comparazione di due approcci GIS nello studio dei cambiamenti demografici del post sisma aquilano
    Valent, G.; Ferrarese, F.
  • Constructing Neoliberalism: opening salvo
    Wacquant, L.
  • Assessment of the regional landscape plan of Sardinia (Italy): a participatory-action-research case study type
    Zoppi, C.; Lai, S.