Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Design morphology complexity and conceptual building project cost forecasting

Design morphology complexity and conceptual building project cost forecasting This research aims to develop conceptual phase building project cost forecasting models by exploring the relationship of existing plan shape complexity indices and general design morphology parameters with total construction cost.Design/methodology/approachPlan shape indices proposed to date by the literature for measuring building design complexity are critically reviewed. Building morphology is also dictated by town planning restrictions such as plot coverage ratio or number of storeys. This study analyses historical data collected from 49 residential building projects to develop multiple linear regression (MLR) and artificial neural network (ANN) models for forecasting construction cost. Existing plan shape coefficients are calculated to evaluate the geometrical complexity of sampled projects. Ten regression-based cost estimating equations are totally derived from stepwise backward and forward methods, and their predictive accuracy is contrasted: to performance levels reported in past studies and to ANN models developed in this research with multilayer perceptron architecture.FindingsAnalysis of plan shape indices revealed that 85.7% of examined past projects possess a high degree of design complexity, hence resulting in expensive initial decisions. This highlights the need for more effective early design stage decision-making by developing new building economic tools. The most accurate regression model, with a mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) of 19.2%, predicts the log of total cost from wall to floor index and total building envelope surface. Other explanatory variables resulting in MAPE values in the order of 20%–22% are total volume, volume above ground level, gross floor area below ground level, gross floor area per storey and total number of storeys. The overall MAPE of regression-based equations is 24.3% whilst ANN models are slightly more accurate with MAPE scores of 21.8% and 21.6% for one hidden and two hidden layers, respectively. The most accurate forecasting model in the research is the ANN with two hidden layers and the sigmoid activation function which predicts total building cost from total building volume (19.1%).Originality/valueThis paper introduces MLR-based and ANN-based conceptual construction cost forecasting models which are founded solely on building morphology design parameters and compare favourably with previous studies with an average predictive accuracy less than 25%. This paper is expected to be beneficial to both practitioners and academics in the built environment towards more effective cost planning of building projects. The methodology suggested can further be implemented in other countries provided that accurate and relevant data from historical projects are used. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Financial Management of Property and Construction Emerald Publishing

Design morphology complexity and conceptual building project cost forecasting

Download PDF
28 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/design-morphology-complexity-and-conceptual-building-project-cost-S5Q1TIW66Q
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1366-4387
eISSN
1366-4387
DOI
10.1108/jfmpc-04-2021-0027
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

This research aims to develop conceptual phase building project cost forecasting models by exploring the relationship of existing plan shape complexity indices and general design morphology parameters with total construction cost.Design/methodology/approachPlan shape indices proposed to date by the literature for measuring building design complexity are critically reviewed. Building morphology is also dictated by town planning restrictions such as plot coverage ratio or number of storeys. This study analyses historical data collected from 49 residential building projects to develop multiple linear regression (MLR) and artificial neural network (ANN) models for forecasting construction cost. Existing plan shape coefficients are calculated to evaluate the geometrical complexity of sampled projects. Ten regression-based cost estimating equations are totally derived from stepwise backward and forward methods, and their predictive accuracy is contrasted: to performance levels reported in past studies and to ANN models developed in this research with multilayer perceptron architecture.FindingsAnalysis of plan shape indices revealed that 85.7% of examined past projects possess a high degree of design complexity, hence resulting in expensive initial decisions. This highlights the need for more effective early design stage decision-making by developing new building economic tools. The most accurate regression model, with a mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) of 19.2%, predicts the log of total cost from wall to floor index and total building envelope surface. Other explanatory variables resulting in MAPE values in the order of 20%–22% are total volume, volume above ground level, gross floor area below ground level, gross floor area per storey and total number of storeys. The overall MAPE of regression-based equations is 24.3% whilst ANN models are slightly more accurate with MAPE scores of 21.8% and 21.6% for one hidden and two hidden layers, respectively. The most accurate forecasting model in the research is the ANN with two hidden layers and the sigmoid activation function which predicts total building cost from total building volume (19.1%).Originality/valueThis paper introduces MLR-based and ANN-based conceptual construction cost forecasting models which are founded solely on building morphology design parameters and compare favourably with previous studies with an average predictive accuracy less than 25%. This paper is expected to be beneficial to both practitioners and academics in the built environment towards more effective cost planning of building projects. The methodology suggested can further be implemented in other countries provided that accurate and relevant data from historical projects are used.

Journal

Journal of Financial Management of Property and Construction – Emerald Publishing

Published: Sep 21, 2022

Keywords: Construction cost estimation; Design stage; Regression modelling; Neural networks

References

  • Regularization neural network for construction cost estimation
    Adeli, H.; Wu, M.
  • The accuracy of pre-tender building cost estimates in Australia
    Aibinu, A.A.; Pasco, T.
  • Modelling the relationship of architectural and structural design variables for estimating substructure cost of duplexes
    Ajator, U.O.; Ugochukwu, S.; Ogunsina, O.
  • Analysis of factors influencing project cost estimating practice
    Akintoye, A.
  • Artificial neural networks incorporating cost significant items towards enhancing estimation for (life-cycle) costing of construction projects
    Alqahtani, A.; Whyte, A.
  • Uses of a length/breadth index and a plan shape ratio
    Banks, D.G.
  • The influence of the building shape on the costs of its construction
    Belniak, S.; Lesniak, A.; Plebankiewicz, E.; Zima, K.
  • A framework for cost exploration and strategic cost planning in design
    Brandon, P.S.
  • On the issue of plan shape complexity: plan shape indices revisited
    Chau, K.W.
  • Cost control during the pre-contract stage of a building project – an introduction
    Cunningham, T.
  • Development of neural networks to predict total construction cost
    Emsley, M.W.; Lowe, D.J.; Duff, A.R.; Harding, A.; Hickson, A.
  • A neural network approach for early cost estimation of structural systems of buildings
    Günaydin, H.M.; Doğan, S.Z.
  • An expert system for conceptual design of buildings
    Haber, D.; Karshenas, S.
  • Neural network model for parametric cost estimation of highway projects
    Hegazy, T.; Ayed, A.
  • Effect of changes in layout shape on unit construction cost of residential buildings
    Ibrahim, A.D.
  • ANN based approach for estimation of construction costs of sports fields
    Juszczyk, M.; Leśniak, A.; Zima, K.
  • Predesign cost estimating method for multistory buildings
    Karshenas, S.
  • A hybrid conceptual cost estimating model for large building projects
    Kim, H.-J.; Seo, Y.-C.; Hyun, C.-T.
  • Predicting construction cost using multiple regression techniques
    Lowe, D.J.; Emsley, M.W.; Harding, A.
  • Some examples of the use of regression analysis as an estimating tool
    McCaffer, R.
  • Early cost estimating for road construction projects using multiple regression techniques
    Mahamid, I.
  • An artificial neural network approach for cost estimation of engineering services
    Matel, E.; Vahdatikhaki, F.; Hosseinyalamdary, S.; Evers, T.; Voordijk, H.
  • RICS new rules of measurement 1: order of cost estimating and cost planning for capital building works
  • Cost implications of building design plans: a literature review analysis
    Safiki, A.; Solikin, M.; NurSahid, M.
  • The accuracy of construction price forecasts
    Skitmore, M.; Stradling, S.; Tuohy, A.; Mkwezalamba, H.
  • Conceptual cost estimation of building projects with regression analysis and neural networks
    Sönmez, R.
  • A critique of mechanical and electrical services cost planning: existing methods and published information
    Swaffield, L.M.; Pasquire, C.L.
  • Construction cost and building height
    Tan, W.
  • Analysis of the building shape erected in Krakow and its impact on construction costs
    Zima, K.; Plebankiewicz, E.
  • Accuracy in estimating, occasional paper No. 27
    Ashworth, A.; Skitmore, R.M.
  • Predesign cost estimation function for buildings
    Kouskoulas, V.; Koehn, E.