Loading next page...
/lp/emerald-publishing/decision-research-correlates-directly-with-better-business-performance-7bYs7QdwbO
- Publisher
- Emerald Publishing
- Copyright
- Copyright © 2007 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
- ISSN
- 0263-4503
- DOI
- 10.1108/02634500710722399
- Publisher site
- See Article on Publisher Site
Abstract
Purpose – Proceeding from the widely accepted but relatively untested premise that the gathering of intelligence via market research is central to business success, this paper reports a study investigating the extent to which the type of research carried out influences the level of business performance. Design/methodology/approach – Just over 6,000 market research projects conducted by a sample of 68 companies in New Zealand were classified as mainly “decision” or “background research” the companies allocated to one of three categories according to the mix of those types in their total research programme, and their business performance rated on four criteria. Firm size and the market research budget were taken into account as potential confounding variables. ANOVA, MANOVA and factor analysis were applied to data gathered from responses to a questionnaire developed by Diamantopoulos and Souchon, appropriately modified to the specific conditions of this study. Findings – Companies carrying out mostly “decision research” rated themselves as performing generally better than those placing more emphasis on “background research” regardless of the size of the firm or the its market research budget. They scored highly on return‐on‐assets, return‐on‐sales and sales growth, and exhibited positive overall performance. The initial finding was strongly reinforced by factor analysis, 98 per cent of the variation in business performance being explained by the categorisation of a company's research as dominantly “decision” “background” or “mixed”. Practical implications – The evidence for the positive effect of “decision research” on business performance suggests deliberate repositioning of market research strategy towards “decision research” rather than the “background research” which is generally in favour. This will require a major shift in the marketing management mindset with respect to marketing intelligence. Originality/value – This is the first study to show a direct correlation between type of market research conducted and better business performance. It offers an improved conceptual framework for marketing intelligence and planning.
Journal
Marketing Intelligence & Planning – Emerald Publishing
Published: Feb 13, 2007
Keywords: Market research; Marketing intelligence; Market research methods; Performance measures
Recommended Articles
Loading...
References
-
Marketing ResearchAaker, D.; Kumar, V.; Day, G.
-
The long road to customer understandingArken, A.
-
The distribution marketing to competitive success: a literature reviewBaker, M.; Hart, S.; Black, C.; Abdel‐Mohsen, T.
-
The synergistic effect of market orientation and learning orientation on organizational performanceBaker, W.E.; Sinkula, J.M.
-
Hearing the Voice of the Market – Competitive Advantage through Creative Use of Market InformationBarabba, P.; Zaltman, G.
-
Meeting of the Minds – Creating the Market‐based EnterpriseBarabba, P.
-
The marketing manager's view of marketing researchBellenger, D.
-
The utilisation process: a conceptual framework and synthesis of empirical findingsBeyer, J.; Trice, H.
-
Market‐driving organizations: a frameworkCarrillat, F.A.; Jaramillo, F.; Locander, W.B.
-
Predecisional information acquisition: effects of task variable on suboptimal search strategiesConnolly, T.; Thom, B.
-
Implementing strategic missions: effective strategic, structural and tactical choicesCovin, J.; Selvin, D.; Achultz, R.
-
Information control and influence in emergent buying centersDawes, J.; Lee, D.; Dowling, G.
-
Learning about MarketsDay, G.
-
Continuous learning about marketsDay, G.
-
Learning about marketsDay, G.
-
Managerial representations of competitive positioningDay, G.; Nedungadi, P.
-
Factors affecting the use of market research information: a path analysisDeshpandé, R.; Zaltman, G.
-
A comparison of factors affecting researcher and manager perceptions of market research useDeshpandé, R.; Zaltman, G.
-
A comparison of factors affecting use of marketing information in consumer and industrial firmsDeshpandé, R.; Zaltman, G.
-
Measuring organisational performance in the absence of objective measures: the case of the privately‐held firm and conglomerate business unitDess, G.; Robinson, B.
-
Instrumental, conceptual and symbolic use of export information: an exploratory study of UK firmsDiamantopoulos, A.; Souchon, A.
-
Measuring export information use: scale development and validationDiamantopoulos, A.; Souchon, A.
-
Towards an understanding of cross‐national similarities and differences in export information utilisation: a perceptual mapping approachDiamantopoulos, A.; Souchon, A.; Durden, G.; Axinn, C.; Holzmüller, H.
-
The Practice of ManagementDrucker, P.
-
Information in organisations as signals and symbolFieldman, M.; March, J.
-
The role of organisational factors in the adoption and sophistication of database marketing in the UK financial services industryFletcher, K.; Wright, G.; Desai, C.
-
Conceptual issues of linkage in the assessment of organisational performanceFord, J.; Schellenberg, D.
-
Making marketing research accountableGandz, J.; Whipple, T.
-
The prevalence and usefulness of market research: an empirical investigation into ‘background’ versus ‘decision’ researchGaneshasundaram, R.; Henley, N.
-
Information needs for management decision‐makingGoodman, S.
-
Market orientation and service firm performance – a research agendaGray, B.; Hooley, G.
-
Developing a better measure of market orientationGray, B.; Matear, S.; Boshoff, C.; Matheson, P.
-
Business unit strategy, managerial characteristics, and business unit effectiveness at strategy implementationGupta, A.K.; Govindarajan, V.
-
Competing for the futureHamel, G.; Prahalad, C.K.
-
Exploring market driving: a case study of De Beers in ChinaHarris, L.C.; Cai, Y.K.
-
The contribution of marketing to competitive successHart, S.
-
How strategy‐making processes can make a differenceHart, S.; Banbury, C.
-
Marketing research activity and company performance: evidence from manufacturing industryHart, S.; Diamantopoulos, A.
-
The market research contribution to new product failure and successHill, P.
-
How managers see marketing researchHolbert, N.
-
Marketing lessons from UL's high flying companiesHooley, G.; Lynch, J.
-
The untapped markets for marketing researchHooley, G.; West, C.
-
Management accounting (and other), lessons from the JapaneseHowell, R.; Sakurai, M.
-
Market orientation: antecedents and consequencesJaworski, B.J.; Kohli, A.K.
-
Market‐driven versus driving marketsJaworski, B.J.; Kohli, A.K.; Sahay, A.
-
The balanced scorecard‐measures that drive performanceKaplan, R.S.; Norton, D.P.
-
Has marketing failed or was it never really tried?King, S.
-
Market orientation: the construct, research propositions and managerial implicationsKohli, A.; Jaworski, B.
-
From market driven to market drivingKumar, N.; Scheer, L.; Kotler, P.
-
Evaluation and the use of marketing research by decision‐makers: a behavioural simulationLee, H.; Acito, F.; Day, R.L.
-
Marketing Research and AnalysisLehman, D.
-
The impact of market knowledge competence on new product advantage: conceptualisation and empirical examinationLi, T.; Calantone, R.
-
Information technology and firm performance: linking with environmental, strategic and managerial contextsLi, M.; Ye, R.
-
Factors affecting the use of information in the evaluation of marketing communications productivityLow, G.S.; Mohr, J.J.
-
Contemporary Marketing ResearchMcDaniel, C.; Gates, R.
-
Market intelligence dissemination across functional boundariesMaltz, E.; Kohli, A.
-
A model of marketing knowledge use within firmsMenon, A.; Varadarajan, R.
-
Organisational market information processes: cultural antecedents and new product outcomesMoorman, C.
-
Relationship between providers and users of market research: the dynamics of trust within and between organisationsMoorman, C.; Zaltman, G.; Deshpandé, R.
-
The effect of market orientation on business profitabilityNarver, J.; Slater, S.
-
Market orientation and alternative strategic orientations: a longitudinal assessment of performance implicationsNoble, C.H.; Sinha, R.K.; Kumar, A.
-
Marketing Decision Making: Analytic Framework and CasesO'Dell, W.; Rupell, A.; Trent, R.; Kehoe, W.
-
The impact of grand strategy and planning formality on financial performancePearce, J.; Robbins, D.; Robinson, R.
-
Marketing ResearchPeterson, R.A.
-
Market information and firm performanceRaju, J.; Roy, A.
-
Relationship of strategic planning to financial performanceRhyne, L.
-
Export performance and market orientation: establishing an empirical linkRose, G.; Shoham, A.
-
Marketing information: a competitive analysisSarvary, M.; Parker, P.
-
The use of marketing research in engineering companies: empirical evidence from the USA and the UKSchlegelmilch, B.; Therevil, S.
-
Marketing research in medium‐sized UK and US firmsSchlegelmilch, B.; Boyle, K.; Therevil, S.
-
How to make research more actionableSchmalensee, D.H.; Lesh, A.D.
-
Market information processing and organizational learningSinkula, J.M.
-
Market orientation, customer value, and superior performanceSlater, S.F.; Narver, J.C.
-
Information Search Style and Business Performance in Dynamic and Stable Environments: An Exploratory StudySlater, S.F.; Narver, J.C.
-
The positive effect of market orientation on business profitability: a balanced replicationSlater, S.F.; Narver, J.C.
-
Use and non‐use of export information: some preliminary insights into antecedents and impact of export performanceSouchon, A.; Diamantopoulos, A.
-
The Marketing Research GuideStevens, R.; Wrenn, B.; Ruddick, M.; Sherwood, P.
-
An analysis of the market share – profitability relationshipSzymanski, D.; Bharadwaj, S.; Varadarajan, P.
-
Strategic sensemaking and organizational performance: linkages among scanning, interpretation, action, and outcomesThomas, J.B.; Clark, S.M.; Gioia, D.A.
-
Export market information use, organizational knowledge, and firm performance: a conceptual frameworkToften, K.; Olsen, S.O.
-
Generating new product ideas: an initial investigation of the role of market information and organizational characteristicsTroy, L.; Szymanski, D.; Varadarajan, R.
-
Using information to enhance competitive advantage – the marketing optionsTurner, P.
-
Marketing planning in NZ: a survey of practice and performancevan der Walt, N.; Lyonski, S.; Queree, B.; Harper, J.; Hales, S.
-
Strategic information management: targeting information for organisational performanceWeitzel, J.
-
Market situation interpretation and response: the role of cognitive style, organizational culture, and information useWhite, C.; Varadarajan, R.; Dacin, P.
-
The integration of marketing problem‐solving modes and marketing management support systemsWierenga, B.; van Bruggen, G.
-
Export information use in small and medium‐sized industrial companies: an application of Diamantopoulos' and Souchon's scaleWilliams, J.E.
-
What makes marketing more effective?Wyner, G.
-
The importance of personal trust in the use of researchZaltman, G.; Moorman, C.
-
Exploring Marketing ResearchZikmund, W.
@Phil_Robichaud
@deepthiw
@JoseServera