Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

An empirical approach to understanding the lower-middle and upper-middle income traps

An empirical approach to understanding the lower-middle and upper-middle income traps The purpose of this paper is to investigate the factors that are significant in contributing to the per capita income growth of countries that are experiencing or have experienced the lower-middle and upper-middle income traps.Design/methodology/approachThe study comprises 85 countries over the period 1960 to 2017 spanning across three income groups: lower-middle, upper-middle and high. A panel data structure was used to run a fixed effect and random effect estimation on three models of income groups. The Hausman specification test, which was used for further statistical fitness, confirmed the appropriateness of fixed effect over the random in explaining the estimation of factor variables.FindingsThe results show that unemployment is a pervasive problem that negatively affect countries at all income levels. Foreign direct investment and population of dependents are associated with economic progression of countries that have experienced or are experiencing the lower-middle income trap. Furthermore, rising income inequality and foreign aid assistance are detrimental to countries that have experienced or are experiencing the upper-middle income trap. Moreover, income inequality, disproportionate urban population and rising dependent population are damaging for high income countries that never experienced any of the middle-income traps. Conversely, openness to trade, inflation and exchange rate volatility had limited capacity in explaining growth dynamics.Research limitations/implicationsThis study could not incorporate geopolitical, demographic, geographical and other such exogenous factors, which could have episodes of influences on the economic development of countries. These were outside the study's realm of quantitative analysis.Originality/valueThis paper contributes to existing literature by providing an empirical cross-sectional comparative analysis of countries belonging to different income groups. The prevailing literature lacks such a cross-tabulated presentation of factors affecting countries that avoided the middle income trap and those that could not. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png International Journal of Development Issues Emerald Publishing

An empirical approach to understanding the lower-middle and upper-middle income traps

Download PDF
20 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/an-empirical-approach-to-understanding-the-lower-middle-and-upper-1nOPvFeBGs
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
1446-8956
DOI
10.1108/ijdi-09-2018-0138
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to investigate the factors that are significant in contributing to the per capita income growth of countries that are experiencing or have experienced the lower-middle and upper-middle income traps.Design/methodology/approachThe study comprises 85 countries over the period 1960 to 2017 spanning across three income groups: lower-middle, upper-middle and high. A panel data structure was used to run a fixed effect and random effect estimation on three models of income groups. The Hausman specification test, which was used for further statistical fitness, confirmed the appropriateness of fixed effect over the random in explaining the estimation of factor variables.FindingsThe results show that unemployment is a pervasive problem that negatively affect countries at all income levels. Foreign direct investment and population of dependents are associated with economic progression of countries that have experienced or are experiencing the lower-middle income trap. Furthermore, rising income inequality and foreign aid assistance are detrimental to countries that have experienced or are experiencing the upper-middle income trap. Moreover, income inequality, disproportionate urban population and rising dependent population are damaging for high income countries that never experienced any of the middle-income traps. Conversely, openness to trade, inflation and exchange rate volatility had limited capacity in explaining growth dynamics.Research limitations/implicationsThis study could not incorporate geopolitical, demographic, geographical and other such exogenous factors, which could have episodes of influences on the economic development of countries. These were outside the study's realm of quantitative analysis.Originality/valueThis paper contributes to existing literature by providing an empirical cross-sectional comparative analysis of countries belonging to different income groups. The prevailing literature lacks such a cross-tabulated presentation of factors affecting countries that avoided the middle income trap and those that could not.

Journal

International Journal of Development Issues – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jun 24, 2019

Keywords: Panel data analysis; Economic development; Middle income trap

References

  • Caught in the Middle? The economics of Middle‐income traps
    Agénor, P.R.
  • Middle-income growth traps
    Agénor, P.R.; Canuto, O.
  • A model of growth through creative destruction
    Aghion, P.; Howitt, P.
  • Pro-poor to inclusive growth: Asian prescriptions
    Ali, I.
  • Inclusive growth toward a prosperous Asia: policy implications (No. 97)
    Ali, I.; Zhuang, J.
  • Project execution capability, organizational know-how and conglomerate corporate growth in late industrialization
    Amsden, A.H.; Hikino, T.
  • The case against infant-industry tariff protection
    Baldwin, R.E.
  • Demographic change and economic growth in asia
    Bloom, D.E.; Finlay, J.E.
  • Implications of population ageing for economic growth
    Bloom, D.E.; Canning, D.; Fink, G.
  • Human population growth and the demographic transition
    Bongaarts, J.
  • Politics and the effectiveness of foreign aid
    Boone, P.
  • Foreign aid, institutions, and governance in Sub-Saharan Africa
    Bräutigam, D.A.; Knack, S.
  • Demography and growth: a unified treatment of overlapping generations
    Bruce, N.; Turnovsky, S.J.
  • Transitioning from low-income growth to high-income growth: is there a Middle-income trap?
    Bulman, D.; Eden, M.; Nguyen, H.
  • Aid, policies, and growth
    Burnside, C.; Dollar, D.
  • On the empirics of foreign aid and growth
    Dalgaard, C.J.; Hansen, H.; Tarp, F.
  • New ways of looking at old issues: inequality and growth
    Deininger, K.; Squire, L.
  • The middle-income trap: more
    Doner, R.F.; Schneider, B.R.
  • When fast-growing economies slow down: international evidence and implications for China
    Eichengreen, B.; Park, D.; Shin, K.
  • The Middle-income trap and upgrading along global value chains
    Engel, J.; Taglioni, D.
  • A discussion about the possible effect of Middle income trap on large scale firms’ selection of competitive strategy
    Eryılmaz, F.; Eryılmaz, M.E.
  • The rise and fall of Brazilian inequality: 1981-2004
    Ferreira, F.H.; Leite, P.G.; Litchfield, J.A.
  • Does trade cause growth?
    Frankel, J.A.; Romer, D.H.
  • The Middle-income trap turns ten
    Gill, I.S.; Kharas, H.
  • The Middle-income trap: definitions, theories and countries concerned – a literature survey
    Glawe, L.; Wagner, H.
  • Urbanization with and without industrialization
    Gollin, D.; Jedwab, R.; Vollrath, D.
  • Searching for aid threshold effects
    Gomanee, K.; Morrissey, O.
  • Late industrialisation, urbanisation and the Middle-income trap: an analytical approach and the case of Vietnam
    Gore, C.
  • Fixed and random effects in stochastic frontier models
    Greene, W.
  • Growth accelerations
    Hausmann, R.; Pritchett, L.; Rodrik, D.
  • Determinants of economic growth: a varying-coefficient path identification approach
    He, Q.; Xu, B.
  • Can China escape the middle-income trap?
    Huang, Y.
  • What does the Lewis turning point mean for China? A computable general equilibrium analysis
    Huang, Y.; Jiang, T.
  • Can low-income countries afford basic social security?
  • Tigers trapped: tracing the Middle-income trap through the East and Southeast Asian experience
    Kanchoochat, V.; Intarakumnerd, P.
  • Foreign aid and long‐run economic growth: empirical evidence for a panel of developing countries
    Karras, G.
  • Can Asian developing countries stuck in a ‘middle income trap’ learn from South Korea’s
    Kasenda, D.
  • Economic consequences of population change in the third world
    Kelley, A.C.
  • Aggregate population and economic growth correlations: the role of the components of demographic change
    Kelley, A.C.; Schmidt, R.M.
  • Economic growth and unemployment: an empirical analysis
    Kreishan, F.M.
  • Economic growth and income inequality
    Kuznets, S.
  • The interface between globalization, trade and development: theoretical issues for international business studies
    Lévy, B.
  • The social impact of globalization in the developing countries
    Lee, E.; Vivarelli, M.
  • The fragile foundations of the Asian century
    Lee, J.S.
  • Unlimited labour: further notes
    Lewis, W.A.
  • Beyond catch-up – can a new innovation policy help China overcome the Middle income trap?
    Liu, X.; Schwaag Serger, S.; Tagscherer, U.; Chang, A.Y.
  • A contribution to the empirics of economic growth
    Mankiw, N.G.; Romer, D.; Weil, D.N.
  • The turning point in the Japanese economy
    Minami, R.
  • Avoiding the Middle-income trap: renovating industrial policy formulation in Vietnam
    Ohno, K.
  • Examining the economic growth and the Middle-income trap from the perspective of the Middle class
    Ozturk, A.
  • Escaping the Middle-income trap: innovate or perish
    Paus, E.
  • Survival of the fittest: an evolutionary approach to an export-led model of growth
    Prašnikar, J.; Redek, T.; Drenkovska, M.
  • Aid and growth: What does the cross-country evidence really show?
    Rajan, R.G.; Subramanian, A.
  • On the existence of a Middle income trap
    Robertson, P.E.; Ye, L.
  • The stages of economic growth
    Rostow, W.W.
  • The standardized world income inequality database
    Solt, F.
  • How to escape the Middle income trap: international evidence from a binary dependent variable model
    Tuğcu, C.T.
  • The political economy of the Middle-income trap: implications for potential growth
    Wang, Y.
  • Economic growth, structural change, and search unemployment
    Zagler, M.
  • Poverty, inequality, and inclusive growth in Asia
    Zhuang, J.; Ali, I.
  • The World Bank Atlas method - detailed methodology – world bank data help desk