Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

All-natural versus organic: are the labels equivalent in consumers’ minds?

All-natural versus organic: are the labels equivalent in consumers’ minds? This paper aims to investigate inferences consumers make about organic and all-natural labeled products in both food and non-food contexts using the health halo effect as a theoretical foundation.Design/methodology/approachThis paper uses three experiments to test the effects of organic and all-natural labeling across three product types, food, personal hygiene and household cleaning, while controlling for environmental attitudes.FindingsThe results of the experiments in the context of food, personal hygiene and household cleaning products suggest that both organic and all-natural labeling produce halo effects. Distinct findings are presented across the three product types.Research limitations/implicationsFindings indicate that consumers may make unwarranted inferences about both organic and all-natural labeled products and demonstrates that the health halo effect is a potentially robust phenomenon, pervasive across a diverse array of products. This research used a crowdsourcing platform for sample recruitment. Future research should validate the results of these experiments with other sample types.Practical implicationsThis research suggests that consumers may make similar unwarranted inferences for diverse products bearing organic and all-natural labels. These inferences are particularly intriguing given the differing regulatory requirements for the labelsOriginality/valueOrganic and all-natural labels are ubiquitous in both food and non-food products. However, research on either label primarily exists in a food context and has not directly compared the labels. Understanding the inferences consumers make based on the labels across product types is imperative for both marketing and public policy. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Journal of Consumer Marketing Emerald Publishing

All-natural versus organic: are the labels equivalent in consumers’ minds?

Download PDF
11 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/all-natural-versus-organic-are-the-labels-equivalent-in-consumers-1aW4xe81zx
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
© Emerald Publishing Limited
ISSN
0736-3761
DOI
10.1108/jcm-05-2018-2664
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

This paper aims to investigate inferences consumers make about organic and all-natural labeled products in both food and non-food contexts using the health halo effect as a theoretical foundation.Design/methodology/approachThis paper uses three experiments to test the effects of organic and all-natural labeling across three product types, food, personal hygiene and household cleaning, while controlling for environmental attitudes.FindingsThe results of the experiments in the context of food, personal hygiene and household cleaning products suggest that both organic and all-natural labeling produce halo effects. Distinct findings are presented across the three product types.Research limitations/implicationsFindings indicate that consumers may make unwarranted inferences about both organic and all-natural labeled products and demonstrates that the health halo effect is a potentially robust phenomenon, pervasive across a diverse array of products. This research used a crowdsourcing platform for sample recruitment. Future research should validate the results of these experiments with other sample types.Practical implicationsThis research suggests that consumers may make similar unwarranted inferences for diverse products bearing organic and all-natural labels. These inferences are particularly intriguing given the differing regulatory requirements for the labelsOriginality/valueOrganic and all-natural labels are ubiquitous in both food and non-food products. However, research on either label primarily exists in a food context and has not directly compared the labels. Understanding the inferences consumers make based on the labels across product types is imperative for both marketing and public policy.

Journal

Journal of Consumer Marketing – Emerald Publishing

Published: Jun 18, 2019

Keywords: Eco-label; Environmental appeal; Health halo effect; Natural label; Organic label; Product health appeal

References

  • Do biodegradable labels lead to an eco-safety halo effect?
    Amos, C.; Allred, A.; Zhang, L.
  • Natural labeling and consumers’ sentimental pastoral notion
    Amos, C.; Pentina, I.; Hawkins, T.G.; Davis, N.
  • Are some comparative nutrition claims misleading? The role of nutrition knowledge, ad claim type and disclosure conditions
    Andrews, J.C.; Burton, S.; Netemeyer, R.G.
  • Moralities in food and health research
    Askegaard, S.; Ordabayeva, N.; Chandon, P.; Cheung, T.; Chytkova, Z.; Cornil, Y.; Corus, C.; Edell, J.A.; Mathras, D.; Junghans, A.F.; Kristensen, D.B.; Mikkonen, I.; Miller, E.G.; Sayarh, N.; Werle, C.
  • Mapping the values driving organic food choice: Germany vs the UK
    Baker, S.; Thompson, K.E.; Engelken, J.; Huntley, K.
  • What is a label worth? Defining the alternatives to organic for US wool producers
    Bernard, J.C.; Hustvedt, G.; Carroll, K.A.
  • It’s only natural: the mediating impact of consumers’ attribute inferences on the relationships between product claims, perceived product healthfulness, and purchase intentions
    Berry, C.; Burton, S.; Howlett, E.
  • Consumer awareness of organic products in Spain: an application of multinominal logit models
    Briz, T.; Ward, R.W.
  • Billion dollar baby: local foods and US grocery
    Campbell, J.M.; Fairhurst, A.
  • The best eco-friendly laundry detergents of 2017
    Chan, J.
  • The biasing health halos of fast-food restaurant health claims: lower calorie estimates and higher side-dish consumption intentions
    Chandon, P.; Wansink, B.
  • The American omnivore’s dilemma: who constructs ‘organic’ food?
    Chrzan, J.
  • Consumer associations with the ‘all natural’ food label
    Dominick, S.R.; Fullerton, C.; Widmar, N.J.O.; Wang, H.
  • Is less always more? The effects of low-fat labeling and caloric information on food intake, calorie estimates, taste preference, and health attributions
    Ebneter, D.S.; Latner, J.D.; Nigg, C.R.
  • Decision making process of community organic food consumers: an exploratory study
    Essoussi, L.H.; Zahaf, M.
  • FDA Basics-What is the meaning of ‘natural’ on the label of food?
  • Can consumers interpret nutrition information in the presence of a health claim? A laboratory investigation
    Ford, G.T.; Hastak, M.; Mitra, A.; Ringold, D.J.
  • Jim Gaffigan: King Baby
    Gaffigan, J.
  • Planning and conducting experimental advertising research and questionnaire design
    Geuens, M.; Pelsmacker, P.D.
  • Crowdsourcing consumer research
    Goodman, J.K.; Paolacci, G.
  • Factors that influence parental food purchases for children: implications for dietary health
    Hughner, R.S.; Maher, J.K.
  • The hazy world of ‘organic’ products
    Jalonick, M.C.
  • Consumer purchase intention for organic personal care products
    Kim, H.Y.; Chung, J.-E.
  • Making healthful food choices: the influence of health claims and nutrition information on consumers’ evaluations of packaged food products and restaurant menu items
    Kozup, J.C.; Creyer, E.H.; Burton, S.
  • Organic consumers’ profile and their willingness to pay (wtp) for selected organic food products in Greece
    Krystallis, A.; Fotopoulos, C.; Zotos, Y.
  • You taste what you see: do organic labels bias taste perceptions?
    Lee, W.J.; Shimizu, M.; Kniffin, K.M.; Wansink, B.
  • Why do people like natural? Instrumental and ideational bases for the naturalness preference?
    Li, M.; Chapman, G.B.
  • Double standard: the role of environmental consciousness in green product usage
    Lin, Y.-C.; Chang, C.A.
  • A natural experiment: using immersive technologies to study the impact of all‐natural labeling on perceived food quality, nutritional content, and liking
    Liu, R.; Hooker, N.H.; Parsidis, E.; Simons, C.T.
  • Who buys oddly shaped food and why? Impacts of food shape abnormality and organic labeling on purchase intentions
    Loebnitz, N.; Schuitema, G.; Grunert, K.G.
  • The effect of naturalness claims on perceptions of food product naturalness in the point of purchase
    Lunardo, R.; Saintives, C.
  • Strategic green marketing
    McDaniel, S.W.; Rylander, D.H.
  • Tea tree oil (Melaleuca alternifolia) safety
  • Evolving paradigm for environmental sensitivity in marketing programs: a synthesis of theory and practice
    Menon, A.; Menon, A.; Chowdhury, J.; Jankovich, J.
  • Mother natural: motivations and associations for consuming natural foods
    Moscato, E.M.; Machin, J.E.
  • Factors influencing consumers’ willingness to pay for organic fruits and vegetables: empirical evidence from a consumer survey in India
    Nandi, R.; Bokelmann, W.; Gowdru, N.V.; Dias, G.
  • Food health claims–What consumers understand
    Nocella, G.; Kennedy, O.
  • Natural” claims in food advertising: policy implications of filling the regulatory void with consumer class action lawsuits
    Petty, R.D.
  • An investigation of the effects of environmental claims in promotional messages for clothing brands
    Phau, I.; Ong, D.
  • Determinants of regular and occasional consumers’ intentions to buy organic food
    Pino, G.; Peluso, A.M.; Guido, G.
  • Does nutrition information contribute to grocery shoppers’ willingness to pay?
    Ran, T.; Yue, C.; Rihn, A.
  • The differentiation of biodegradable and non-biodegradable dissolved organic matter in wastewaters using fluorescence spectroscopy
    Reynolds, D.M.
  • Estimations of consumer demand for local beef
    Ridley, W.; Devadoss, S.; Shook, S.R.
  • Consumer attitudes and behaviour to organic foods in Ireland
    Roddy, G.; Cowan, C.A.; Hutchinson, G.
  • The impact of health claims on consumer search and product evaluation outcomes: results from FDA experimental data
    Roe, B.; Levy, A.S.; Derby, B.M.
  • LOHAS forum attracts fortune 500 companies
    Roos, G.
  • The meaning of ‘natural’: process more important than content
    Rozin, P.
  • Naturalness judgments by lay Americans: process dominates content in judgments of food or water acceptability and naturalness
    Rozin, P.
  • Preference for natural: instrumental and ideational/moral motivations, and the contrast between foods and medicines
    Rozin, P.; Spranca, M.; Krieger, Z.; Neuhaus, R.; Surillo, D.; Swerdlin, A.; Wood, K.
  • When good deeds leave a bad taste. negative inferences from ethical food claims
    Schuldt, J.P.; Hannahan, M.
  • The ‘organic’ path to obesity? Organic claims influence calorie judgments and exercise recommendations
    Schuldt, J.P.; Schwarz, N.
  • The ‘fair trade’ effect: health halos from social ethics claims
    Schuldt, J.P.; Muller, D.; Schwarz, N.
  • US consumers think natural is greener than organic, says survey
    Scott-Thomas, C.
  • An eco-label effect in the built environment: performance and comfort effects of labeling a light source environmentally friendly
    Sörqvist, P.; Haga, A.; Holmgren, M.; Hansla, A.
  • The green halo: mechanisms and limits of the eco-label effect
    Sörqvist, P.; Haga, A.; Langeborg, L.; Holmgren, M.; Wallinder, M.; Nöstl, A.; Seager, P.B.; Marsh, J.E.
  • The role of perceived variability and the health halo effect in nutritional inference and consumption: nutritional inference
    Sundar, A.; Kardes, F.R.
  • Consumer decision making regarding a ‘green’ everyday product
    Thøgersen, J.; Jørgensen, A.-K.; Sandager, S.
  • Natural food and the pastoral: a sentimental notion?
    Thompson, D.B.
  • Allowed mulches on organic farms and the future of biodegradable mulch
  • Consumer perceptions of nutrition and health claims
    van Trijp, H.C.M.; van der Lans, I.A.
  • Can ‘low-fat’ nutrition labels lead to obesity?
    Wansink, B.; Chandon, P.
  • Mythbusting 101: organic farming>conventional agriculture
    Wilcox, C.