Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
J. Antonakis, D. Day, B. Schyns (2012)
Leadership and individual differences: At the cusp of a renaissanceLeadership Quarterly, 23
J. Turner, R. Baker, Frank Kellner (2018)
Theoretical Literature Review: Tracing the Life Cycle of a Theory and Its Verified and Falsified StatementsHuman Resource Development Review, 17
M. Novicevic, J. Humphreys, I. Popoola, S. Poor, R. Gigliotti, B. Randolph-Seng (2017)
Collective leadership as institutional work: interpreting evidence from Mound BayouLeadership, 13
G. Edwards, S. Turnbull (2013)
A Cultural Approach to Evaluating Leadership DevelopmentAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 15
Tamara Friedrich, W. Vessey, Matthew Schuelke, M. Mumford, F. Yammarino, G. Ruark (2014)
Collectivistic leadership and George C. Marshall: A historiometric analysis of career eventsLeadership Quarterly, 25
E. Hoffman, R. Lord (2013)
A taxonomy of event-level dimensions: Implications for understanding leadership processes, behavior, and performanceLeadership Quarterly, 24
F. Kennedy, Brigid Carroll, Joline Francoeur (2013)
Mindset Not Skill SetAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 15
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 15
F. Fiedler (1976)
The leadership game: Matching the man to the situationOrganizational Dynamics, 4
R. House (1996)
Path-goal theory of leadership: Lessons, legacy, and a reformulated theoryLeadership Quarterly, 7
M. Glynn, R. Raffaelli (2010)
Uncovering Mechanisms of Theory Development in an Academic Field: Lessons from Leadership ResearchThe Academy of Management Annals, 4
Jamie Callahan, Manda Rosser (2007)
Pop Goes the Program: Using Popular Culture Artifacts to Educate LeadersAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 9
G. Ligon, J. Wallace, Holly Osburn (2011)
Experiential Development and Mentoring Processes for Leaders for InnovationAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 13
L. Ayiro (2009)
An Analysis of Emotional Intelligence and the Performance of Principals in Selected Schools in KenyaAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 11
Shamas-ur-rehman Toor, G. Ofori (2008)
Leadership for future construction industry: Agenda for authentic leadershipInternational Journal of Project Management, 26
R. McWhorter, S. Lynham, Dorothy Porter (2008)
Scenario Planning as Developing Leadership Capability and CapacityAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 10
Shelley Kirkpatick, E. Locke (1991)
Leadership: do traits matter?The Executive, 5
Journal of Management, 42
D. Day, Peter Gronn, E. Salas (2004)
Leadership capacity in teamsLeadership Quarterly, 15
Kim Nimon, M. Astakhova (2015)
Improving the Rigor of Quantitative HRD Research: Four Recommendations in Support of the General Hierarchy of EvidenceHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 26
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 14
Raymond Sparrowe, R. Liden (2005)
Two Routes to Influence: Integrating Leader-Member Exchange and Social Network PerspectivesAdministrative Science Quarterly, 50
Alma McCarthy (2014)
Leading During Uncertainty and Economic TurbulenceAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 16
Richard Steers, C. Sanchez-Runde, L. Nardon (2012)
Leadership in a global context: New directions in research and theory developmentJournal of World Business, 47
B. Shuck, A. Herd (2012)
Employee Engagement and LeadershipHuman Resource Development Review, 11
Alexandre Ardichvili, Kristina Dag, Steven Manderscheid (2016)
Leadership DevelopmentAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 18
Academy of Management Perspectives, 5
Alexandre Ardichvili, Steven Manderscheid (2008)
Emerging Practices in Leadership DevelopmentAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 10
P. Jordan, A. Troth (2002)
Emotional Intelligence and Conflict Resolution: Implications for Human Resource DevelopmentAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 4
Blair Browning (2007)
Leadership in Desperate Times: An Analysis of Endurance: Shackleton's Incredible Voyage through the Lens of Leadership TheoryAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 9
Afsaneh Bagheri, Z. Pihie (2011)
Entrepreneurial leadership: towards a model for learning and developmentHuman Resource Development International, 14
M. London, Jeffrey Polzer, Heather Omoregie (2005)
Interpersonal Congruence, Transactive Memory, and Feedback Processes: An Integrative Model of Group LearningHuman Resource Development Review, 4
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 15
T. Brown, M. McCracken, P. O’Kane (2011)
‘Don't forget to write’: how reflective learning journals can help to facilitate, assess and evaluate training transferHuman Resource Development International, 14
Helen Muyia, K. Kacirek (2009)
An Empirical Study of a Leadership Development Training Program and Its Impact on Emotional Intelligence Quotient (EQ) ScoresAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 11
D. Linden, Keri Pekaar, A. Bakker, J. Schermer, P. Vernon, C. Dunkel, K. Petrides (2017)
Overlap Between the General Factor of Personality and Emotional Intelligence: A Meta-AnalysisPsychological Bulletin, 143
Organizational Science, 6
Human Resource Development Review, 11
Kirk Mensch, Tim Rahschulte (2008)
Military leader development and autonomous learning: Responding to the growing complexity of warfareHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 19
D. Muir (2014)
Mentoring and Leader Identity Development: A Case StudyHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 25
Nada Endrissat, Werner Müller, Stephanie Kaudela-Baum (2007)
En Route to an Empirically-Based Understanding of Authentic LeadershipEuropean Management Journal, 25
T. Cummings, Chailin Cummings (2014)
Appreciating Organization Development: A Comparative Essay on Divergent PerspectivesHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 25
R. House (1971)
A Path-Goal Theory of Leader EffectivenessAdministrative Science Quarterly, 16
Francesco Sofo, R. Yeo, J. Villafañe (2010)
Optimizing the Learning in Action Learning: Reflective Questions, Levels of Learning, and CoachingAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 12
Patricia O'Connell (2014)
A simplified framework for 21st century leader developmentLeadership Quarterly, 25
F. Yammarino, Shelley Dionne, Jae Chun, F. Dansereau (2005)
Leadership and levels of analysis: A state-of-the-science reviewLeadership Quarterly, 16
R. House (1999)
Weber and the neo-charismatic leadership paradigmLeadership Quarterly, 10
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 13
N. Clarke (2013)
Model of complexity leadership developmentHuman Resource Development International, 16
Lynn Harland (2003)
Using Personality Tests in Leadership Development: Test Format Effects and the Mitigating Impact of Explanations and Feedback.Human Resource Development Quarterly, 14
Peter Bolstorff (2002)
Supply Chain: A Framework for Expanding the Human Resource Development Professional’s Role in Technology ImplementationsAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 4
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 13
L. Godkin, S. Allcorn (2009)
Dependent Narcissism, Organizational Learning, and Human Resource DevelopmentHuman Resource Development Review, 8
Human Resource Development Review, 11
Kleio Akrivou, Hilary Bradbury-Huang (2011)
Executive catalysts: Predicting sustainable organizational performance amid complex demandsLeadership Quarterly, 22
Sergio Fernandez, Y. Cho, J. Perry (2010)
Exploring the link between integrated leadership and public sector performanceLeadership Quarterly, 21
Michael Wukitsch, Ryan Simmons, Mark Hutt (2013)
Rearticulating Values Through Applied Theories at Children’s Hospital ColoradoAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 15
Levi Nieminen, Ryan Smerek, L. Kotrba, D. Denison (2013)
What Does an Executive Coaching Intervention Add Beyond Facilitated Multisource Feedback? Effects on Leader Self-Ratings and Perceived EffectivenessHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 24
Randall Knapp (2010)
Collective (Team) Learning Process Models: A Conceptual ReviewHuman Resource Development Review, 9
Bret Crane, Christopher Hartwell (2018)
Developing Employees’ Mental Complexity: Transformational Leadership as a Catalyst in Employee DevelopmentHuman Resource Development Review, 17
Richard Egan, M. Turner, D. Blackman (2017)
Leadership and Employee Work Passion: Propositions for Future Empirical InvestigationsHuman Resource Development Review, 16
K. Petrides, R. Pita, F. Kokkinaki (2007)
The location of trait emotional intelligence in personality factor space.British journal of psychology, 98 Pt 2
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 14
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 15
Idriss Djibo, Katie Desiderio, Noriece Price (2010)
Examining the Role of Perceived Leader Behavior on Temporary Employees' Organizational Commitment and Citizenship Behavior.Human Resource Development Quarterly, 21
Ji Song, Judith Kolb, U. Lee, H. Kim (2012)
Role of transformational leadership in effective organizational knowledge creation practices: Mediating effects of employees' work engagementHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 23
Sunyoung Park, Shinhee Jeong, Soebin Jang, S. Yoon, D. Lim (2018)
Critical Review of Global Leadership Literature: Toward an Integrative Global Leadership FrameworkHuman Resource Development Review, 17
Lila Carden, Jamie Callahan (2007)
Creating leaders or loyalists? conflicting identities in a leadership development programmeHuman Resource Development International, 10
Bella Lien, Richard Hung, G. McLean (2007)
Organizational Learning as an Organization Development Intervention in Six High- Technology Firms in Taiwan: An Exploratory Case StudyHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 18
M. Eberly, Michael Johnson, Morela Hernandez, B. Avolio (2013)
An integrative process model of leadership: examining loci, mechanisms, and event cycles.The American psychologist, 68 6
Josefina Baltodano, S. Carlson, L. Jackson, Wanda Mitchell (2012)
Networking to Leadership in Higher EducationAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 14
K. Blakeley, M. Higgs (2014)
Responsible leadership development – crucible experiences and power relationships in a global professional services firmHuman Resource Development International, 17
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 16
S. Horwitz (2005)
The Compositional Impact of Team Diversity on Performance: Theoretical ConsiderationsHuman Resource Development Review, 4
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 16
D. Vredenburgh, Rita Shea-VanFossen (2010)
Human Nature, Organizational Politics, and Human Resource DevelopmentHuman Resource Development Review, 9
Admiistrative Science Quarterly, 22
Mary Uhl‐Bien, Russ Marion (2009)
Complexity Leadership in Bureaucratic Forms of Organizing: A Meso ModelLeadership Quarterly, 20
M. Marquardt, Ng Seng, H. Goodson (2010)
Team Development via Action LearningAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 12
Jamie Callahan, J. Whitener, Jennifer Sandlin (2007)
The Art of Creating Leaders: Popular Culture Artifacts as Pathways for DevelopmentAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 9
Barba Martín, Klodiana Kolomitro, Tony Lam (2014)
Training MethodsHuman Resource Development Review, 13
Mirlenda Noelliste (2013)
Integrity: An Intrapersonal PerspectiveHuman Resource Development Review, 12
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 15
Jennifer Wenson (2010)
After-coaching leadership skills and their impact on direct reports: recommendations for organizationsHuman Resource Development International, 13
Michelle Bligh, Jeffrey Kohles, Rajnandini Pillai (2011)
Romancing leadership: Past, present, and future ☆Leadership Quarterly, 22
G. McLean, Baiyin Yang, M. Kuo, A. Tolbert, C. Larkin (2005)
Development and initial validation of an instrument measuring managerial coaching skillHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 16
Reid Bates, Hsin-Chih Chen (2004)
Human resource development value orientations: a construct validation studyHuman Resource Development International, 7
S. Turnbull, G. Edwards (2005)
Leadership Development for Organizational Change in a New U.K. UniversityAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 7
B. Bass (1985)
LEADERSHIP AND PERFORMANCE BEYOND EXPECTATIONS
O. Tkachenko, Alexandre Ardichvili (2017)
Cultural-Historical Activity Theory’s Relevance to HRD: A Review and ApplicationHuman Resource Development Review, 16
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 14
N. Contractor, Leslie DeChurch, Jay Carson, Dorothy Carter, Brian Keegan (2012)
The topology of collective leadershipLeadership Quarterly, 23
Human Resource Development Quarterly, 26
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 18
D. Knippenberg, S. Sitkin (2013)
A Critical Assessment of Charismatic—Transformational Leadership Research: Back to the Drawing Board?The Academy of Management Annals, 7
Doris Collins (2002)
Performance-Level Evaluation Methods Used in Management Development Studies from 1986 to 2000Human Resource Development Review, 1
E. Drodge, Steven Murphy (2002)
Interrogating Emotions in Police LeadershipHuman Resource Development Review, 1
D. Denison, R. Hooijberg, R. Quinn (1995)
Paradox and Performance: Toward a Theory of Behavioral Complexity in Managerial LeadershipOrganization Science, 6
R. House, T. Mitchell (1975)
PATH-GOAL THEORY OF LEADERSHIP, 3
R. Arvey, C. Dhanaraj, Mansour Javidan, Zhi-Xue Zhang (2015)
Are there unique leadership models in Asia? Exploring uncharted territoryLeadership Quarterly, 26
R. Hooijberg, James Hunt, George Dodge (1997)
Leadership Complexity and Development of the leaderplex ModelJournal of Management, 23
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 12
Denise Cumberland, Meera Alagaraja, B. Shuck, Sharon Kerrick (2018)
Organizational Social Capital: Ties Between HRD, Employee Voice, and CEOsHuman Resource Development Review, 17
Lynna Ausburn, Floyd Ausburn (2014)
Technical Perspectives on Theory in Screen-Based Virtual Reality EnvironmentsAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 16
Human Resource Development Review, 13
P. Balkundi, M. Kilduff (2005)
The ties that lead: A social network approach to leadershipLeadership Quarterly, 17
G. Edwards, Doris Schedlitzki, J. Ward, M. Wood (2015)
Exploring Critical Perspectives of Toxic and Bad Leadership Through FilmAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 17
D. Knippenberg, M. Hogg (2003)
A SOCIAL IDENTITY MODEL OF LEADERSHIP EFFECTIVENESS IN ORGANIZATIONSResearch in Organizational Behavior, 25
Shelley Dionne, Alka Gupta, K. Sotak, Kristie Shirreffs, Andra Serban, C. Hao, Dong Kim, F. Yammarino (2014)
A 25-year perspective on levels of analysis in leadership researchLeadership Quarterly, 25
N. Hiller, Leslie DeChurch, Toshio Murase, Daniel Doty (2011)
Searching for Outcomes of Leadership: A 25-Year ReviewJournal of Management, 37
Human Resource Development Review, 13
Alina Waite (2014)
Leadership's influence on innovation and sustainability: A review of the literature and implications for HRDEuropean Journal of Training and Development, 38
Jeremy Meuser, W. Gardner, Jessica Dinh, Jinyu Hu, R. Liden, R. Lord (2016)
A Network Analysis of Leadership TheoryJournal of Management, 42
M. Mumford, Carter Gibson (2011)
Developing Leadership for Creative EffortsAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 13
L. White, G. Currie, A. Lockett (2016)
Pluralized leadership in complex organizations: Exploring the cross network effects between formal and informal leadership relationsLeadership Quarterly, 27
K. Parry, P. Sinha (2005)
Researching the Trainability of Transformational Organizational LeadershipHuman Resource Development International, 8
Marilyn Byrd (2007)
Educating and Developing Leaders of Racially Diverse Organizations.Human Resource Development Quarterly, 18
A. Margaryan, B. Collis, Andy Cooke (2004)
Activity-based blended learningHuman Resource Development International, 7
Ethan Waples, Tamara Friedrich, Paul Shelton (2011)
Closing Comments on ‘Leading for Innovation’Advances in Developing Human Resources, 13
Catherine McCauley-Smith, Sharon Williams, A. Gillon, A. Braganza, C. Ward (2013)
Individual Leader to Interdependent LeadershipAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 15
Dave Keller (2007)
Leading on Top of the World: Lessons from Into Thin AirAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 9
W. Gardner, Kevin Lowe, Todd Moss, Kevin Mahoney, C. Cogliser (2010)
Scholarly leadership of the study of leadership: A review of The Leadership Quarterly's second decade, 2000-2009.Leadership Quarterly, 21
Florina Trapero, Verónica Lozada (2010)
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE RELATIONSHIP OF INTEGRITY AND LEADERSHIP STYLES ACCORDING TO THE MODEL OF BERNARD BASSEstudios Gerenciales, 26
Human Resource Development Review, 17
Z. Rhea (2013)
Alien tutelage: on generalizability and contextualization in leadership developmentHuman Resource Development International, 16
Human Resource Development Review, 14
Craig Polsfuss, Alexandre Ardichvili (2008)
Three Principles Psychology: Applications in Leadership Development and CoachingAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 10
Peter Richardson, D. Denton (2005)
How to create a high‐performance teamHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 16
J. Collins (2012)
Identity MattersHuman Resource Development Review, 11
Marie Carasco-Saul, Woocheol Kim, T. Kim (2015)
Leadership and Employee EngagementHuman Resource Development Review, 14
Morela Hernandez, M. Eberly, B. Avolio, Michael Johnson (2011)
The loci and mechanisms of leadership: Exploring a more comprehensive view of leadership theoryLeadership Quarterly, 22
B. Avolio, R. Reichard, S. Hannah, Fred Walumbwa, A. Chan (2009)
A meta-analytic review of leadership impact research: Experimental and quasi-experimental studiesLeadership Quarterly, 20
G. Thomas, Robin Martin, R. Riggio (2013)
Leading groups: Leadership as a group processGroup Processes & Intergroup Relations, 16
R. Lord (1977)
Functional leadership behavior: Measurement and relation to social power and leadership perceptions.Administrative Science Quarterly, 22
G. Edwards, S. Turnbull (2013)
Special Issue on New Paradigms in Evaluating Leadership DevelopmentAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 15
J. Gilley, M. Morris, Alina Waite, Tabitha Coates, Abigail Veliquette (2010)
Integrated Theoretical Model for Building Effective TeamsAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 12
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 10
Norma D’Annunzio-Green, Helen Francis (2005)
Human resource development and the psychological contract: Great expectations or false hopes?Human Resource Development International, 8
Hye-Shin Kim, Soyeon Shim (2003)
Gender-based approach to the understanding of leadership roles among retail managersHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 14
J. Antonakis, R. House (2014)
Instrumental leadership: Measurement and extension of transformational–transactional leadership theoryLeadership Quarterly, 25
Denise Bonebright, Anitra Cottledge, P. Lonnquist (2012)
Developing Women Leaders on CampusAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 14
Karen Longman, Shawna Lafreniere (2012)
Moving Beyond the Stained Glass CeilingAdvances in Developing Human Resources, 14
M. Mendenhall, B. Reiche, A. Bird, J. Osland, J. Osland (2012)
DEFINING THE 'GLOBAL' IN GLOBAL LEADERSHIPJournal of World Business, 47
Paul Nesbit (2012)
The Role of Self-Reflection, Emotional Management of Feedback, and Self-Regulation Processes in Self-Directed Leadership DevelopmentHuman Resource Development Review, 11
E. Raes, E. Kyndt, Stefan Decuyper, P. Bossche, F. Dochy (2015)
An Exploratory Study of Group Development and Team LearningHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 26
P. Dorfman, Mansour Javidan, P. Hanges, Ali Dastmalchian, R. House (2012)
GLOBE: A twenty year journey into the intriguing world of culture and leadershipJournal of World Business, 47
This paper aims to identify the life-cycle of leadership theory from both the human resource development (HRD) and the organizational/leadership literature while providing a contrast between the two bodies of literature. The current research identifies which theories are being represented within the HRD literature, followed by a review of current directions in the leadership fields, primarily from literature in the organizational and leadership fields. By identifying these two bodies of leadership theories, the following research question will be answered: How current are the leadership theories provided in the literature of HRD compared to research that is reported from other external leadership fields?Design/methodology/approachThis paper examines how leadership theories are represented in the HRD literature. Data for the current article provide a preview of leadership theories that are used to inform HRD scholars and scholar–practitioners for a period of 15 years (2000-2015) in the four Academy of Human Resource Development (AHRD) publications (Advances in Developing Human Resources; Human Resource Development International; Human Resource Development Quarterly; and Human Resource Development Review). The four journals within the AHRD were reviewed to identify which leadership theories were being researched and used to inform members of HRD. The search terms for the current study included “leadership AND theory,” “team AND leadership,” “leadership AND development” and “team AND development.” Studies that presented a leadership theory and either described or defined the theory were coded for the current study. Within this body of literature, there were a total of 74 leadership theories identified (some repeating), among those there were a total of 20 unique leadership theories. The literature external of HRD was identified using the ScienceDirect database for 10 years (2007-2017) with the topics limited to “topics–leadership.” Once the HRD and organizational/leadership literature are presented, a comparison between the two literature streams will be provided, highlighting any deficiencies within either body of literature and recommendations for future research efforts for the field of HRD.FindingsThis examination of leadership theory study within HRD and other fields highlights the deficiencies within either body of literature and offers recommendations for future research efforts for the field of HRD. In line with the trend in leadership research, HRD should call for more longitudinal and multi-level research efforts to be conducted as opposed to cross-sectional studies.Research limitations/implicationsThe current study is limited in the literature that was used to collect/code data. Also, the time frame for the HRD literature ended in 2015 due to the long duration required to review articles and to code the data. Secondary data were obtained from organizational/leadership literature and are more current because they are more recent. Overall, even with an end date of 2015 for the HRD literature, the HRD field has not changed too much during this time and the authors recognize some minor changes, but the research findings are still relevant and the leadership deficits presented are still realized.Practical implicationsThe field of HRD is behind when it comes to leadership theories. This paper identifies this in an effort to aid researchers, students and practitioners to look beyond the leadership theories presented in the HRD literature for more relevant and current leadership theories. This paper highlighted a number of newer and current leadership theories and trends for scholars and scholar-practitioners to begin to focus on; however, this list is only a snapshot and is bounded by the data collected for the current paper.Originality/valueThis paper is original in that it is both critical of leadership research within the HRD literature while also providing new directions for the field. The snapshot of where the field of HRD is compared to the leadership and organizational fields becomes apparent with multiple future directions for research.
European Journal of Training and Development – Emerald Publishing
Published: Oct 29, 2018
Keywords: Leadership; Collective theories; Global theories; Leadership theories; New theories; Traditional theories
Read and print from thousands of top scholarly journals.
Already have an account? Log in
Bookmark this article. You can see your Bookmarks on your DeepDyve Library.
To save an article, log in first, or sign up for a DeepDyve account if you don’t already have one.
Copy and paste the desired citation format or use the link below to download a file formatted for EndNote
Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
All DeepDyve websites use cookies to improve your online experience. They were placed on your computer when you launched this website. You can change your cookie settings through your browser.