Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

A critical review of patient satisfaction

A critical review of patient satisfaction Purpose – This paper aims to review the patient satisfaction literature, specifically meta‐analyses, which critically analyses its theory and use; then to present evidence for perceived service quality as a separate and more advanced construct. Design/methodology/approach – Papers that judiciously review the development and application of patient satisfaction were identified; along with studies addressing the conceptual and methodological deficiencies associated with the concept; and the current perceived service quality theory. Findings – Patient satisfaction has been extensively studied and considerable effort has gone into developing survey instruments to measure it. However, most reviews have been critical of its use, since there is rarely any theoretical or conceptual development of the patient satisfaction concept. The construct has little standardisation, low reliability and uncertain validity. It continues to be used interchangeably with, and as a proxy for, perceived service quality, which is a conceptually different and superior construct. Practical implications – The persistent use of patient satisfaction to evaluate the client's perception of the quality of a health service is seriously flawed. The key to solving this dilemma may be for the healthcare sector to focus on perceived health service quality by considering the specific concepts and models that can be found in the services marketing literature. This literature offers more advanced consumer theories which are better differentiated and tested than existing healthcare satisfaction models. Originality/value – The paper points out that there is an urgent need for differentiation and standardisation of satisfaction and service quality definitions and constructs, and argues for research to focus on measuring perceived health service quality. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Leadership in Health Services Emerald Publishing

A critical review of patient satisfaction

Liz Gill; Lesley White
Leadership in Health Services , Volume 22 (1): 12 – Feb 6, 2009
Download PDF
12 pages

Loading next page...
 
/lp/emerald-publishing/a-critical-review-of-patient-satisfaction-TzcGLiC8hF
Publisher
Emerald Publishing
Copyright
Copyright © 2009 Emerald Group Publishing Limited. All rights reserved.
ISSN
1751-1879
DOI
10.1108/17511870910927994
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Purpose – This paper aims to review the patient satisfaction literature, specifically meta‐analyses, which critically analyses its theory and use; then to present evidence for perceived service quality as a separate and more advanced construct. Design/methodology/approach – Papers that judiciously review the development and application of patient satisfaction were identified; along with studies addressing the conceptual and methodological deficiencies associated with the concept; and the current perceived service quality theory. Findings – Patient satisfaction has been extensively studied and considerable effort has gone into developing survey instruments to measure it. However, most reviews have been critical of its use, since there is rarely any theoretical or conceptual development of the patient satisfaction concept. The construct has little standardisation, low reliability and uncertain validity. It continues to be used interchangeably with, and as a proxy for, perceived service quality, which is a conceptually different and superior construct. Practical implications – The persistent use of patient satisfaction to evaluate the client's perception of the quality of a health service is seriously flawed. The key to solving this dilemma may be for the healthcare sector to focus on perceived health service quality by considering the specific concepts and models that can be found in the services marketing literature. This literature offers more advanced consumer theories which are better differentiated and tested than existing healthcare satisfaction models. Originality/value – The paper points out that there is an urgent need for differentiation and standardisation of satisfaction and service quality definitions and constructs, and argues for research to focus on measuring perceived health service quality.

Journal

Leadership in Health Services – Emerald Publishing

Published: Feb 6, 2009

Keywords: Patients; Health services; Quality management; Customer satisfaction; Australia

References

  • Developing service quality in mental health services
    Bell, L.
  • Perception and use of the results of patient satisfaction surveys by care providers in a French teaching hospital
    Boyer, L.; François, P.; Doutre, E.; Weil, G.; Labarere, J.
  • Some new thoughts on conceptualizing perceived service quality: a hierarchical approach
    Brady, M.K.; Cronin, J.J.J.
  • Where are the patients in the quality of health care?
    Brown, C.
  • Health care quality: incorporating consumer perspectives
    Cleary, P.; Edgman‐Levitan, S.
  • Patients' perceptions of service quality dimensions: an empirical examination of health care in New Zealand
    Clemes, M.D.; Ozanne, L.K.; Laurensen, W.L.
  • Seeing the wood for the trees: defining the forgotten concept of patient dissatisfaction in the light of patient satisfaction research
    Coyle, J.; Williams, B.
  • Assessing the effects of quality, value, and customer satisfaction on consumer behavioral intentions in service environments
    Cronin, J.J.J.; Brady, M.K.; Hult, G.T.M.
  • The measurement of satisfaction with healthcare: implications for practice from a systematic review of the literature
    Crowe, R.; Gage, H.; Hampson, S.; Hart, J.; Kimber, A.; Storey, L.; Thomas, H.
  • A measure of service quality for retail stores
    Dabholkar, P.A.; Thorpe, D.I.; Rentz, J.Q.
  • A hierarchical model of health service quality: scale development and investigation of an integrated model
    Dagger, T.S.; Sweeney, J.C.; Johnson, L.W.
  • The definition of quality and approaches to its assessment
    Donabedian, A.
  • Problems in the conceptual framework of patient satisfaction research: an empirical exploration
    Fitzpatrick, R.; Hopkins, A.
  • A different approach to sociodemographic predictors of satisfaction with health care
    Fox, J.G.; Storms, D.M.
  • A cross‐industry comparison of customer satisfaction
    Gilbert, G.R.; Veloutsou, C.
  • Measuring customer satisfaction in the fast food industry: a cross‐national approach
    Gilbert, G.R.; Veloutsou, C.; Goode, M.M.H.; Moutinho, L.
  • Development and validation of an in‐patient satisfaction questionnaire
    Gonzalez, N.; Quintana, J.M.; Bilbao, A.; Escobar, A.; Aizpuru, F.; Thompson, A.; Esteban, C.; Sebastian, J.A.S.; de la Sierra, E.
  • Consumer satisfaction and perceived quality: complimentary or divergent constructs
    Gotlieb, J.B.; Grewal, D.; Brown, S.W.
  • Components and predictors of patient satisfaction
    Hardy, G.; West, M.; Hill, F.
  • Review of Patient Satisfaction Measures
    Hawthorne, G.
  • Patient satisfaction with anaesthesia care: what is patient satisfaction, how should it be measured, and what is the evidence for assuring high patient satisfaction
    Heidegger, T.; Saal, D.; Nuebling, M.
  • Satisfaction
    Hill, R.
  • The new public management in the 1980s: variations on a theme
    Hood, C.
  • Scale for the measurement of attitudes towards physicians and primary medical care
    Hulka, B.; Zyzanski, S.; Cassel, J.; Thompson, S.
  • Empathy: towards a conceptual framework for health professionals
    Irving, P.; Dickson, D.
  • Service quality in health care
    Kenagy, J.W.; Berwick, D.M.; Shore, M.F.
  • The silent customers: measuring customer satisfaction in nursing homes
    Kleinsorge, I.K.; Koenig, H.F.
  • Assessment of client/patient satisfaction: development of a general scale
    Larsen, D.L.; Attkisson, C.C.; Hargreaves, W.A.; Nguyen, T.D.
  • Impact of deficient healthcare service quality
    Lee, P.‐M.; Khong, P.; Ghista, D.N.
  • The patient as the pivot point for quality in health care delivery
    Lengnick‐Hall, C.A.
  • Methodological issues in patient satisfaction surveys
    Lin, B.; Kelly, E.
  • Toward a theory of patient satisfaction
    Linder‐Pelz, S.
  • Patient judgments of hospital quality: report of a pilot study
    Meterko, M.; Nelson, E.C.; Rubin, H.R.; Batalden, P.; Berwick, D.M.; Hays, R.D.; Ware, J.E. Jr
  • Assessment of patient satisfaction: development and refinement of a service evaluation questionnaire
    Nguyen, T.D.; Attkisson, C.C.; Stegner, B.L.
  • Commentary – patient satisfaction: what is the point?
    O'Connor, S.J.; Shewchuk, R.
  • Perceptual gaps in understanding patient expectations for health care service quality
    O'Connor, S.J.; Trinh, H.Q.
  • The great gap
    O'Connor, S.J.; Shewchuk, R.M.; Carney, L.W.
  • Perceptual gaps in understanding patient expectations for health care service quality
    O'Connor, S.J.; Trinh, H.Q.; Shewchuck, R.M.
  • Measurement and evaluation of satisfaction processes in retail settings
    Oliver, R.L.
  • Processing of the satisfaction response in consumption: a suggested framework and research propositions
    Oliver, R.L.
  • Satisfaction: A Behavioral Perspective on the Consumer
    Oliver, R.L.
  • A conceptual model of service quality and its implications for future research
    Parasuraman, A.; Zeithaml, V.A.; Berry, L.L.
  • SERVQUAL: a multiple‐item scale for measuring consumer perceptions of service quality
    Parasuraman, A.; Zeithaml, V.A.; Berry, L.L.
  • Patient satisfaction in primary health care: a literature review and analysis
    Pascoe, G.C.
  • Service quality in public services as a segmentation variable
    Sanchez‐Perez, M.; Sanchez‐Fernandez, R.; Marin‐Carrillo, G.M.; Gazquez‐Abad, J.C.
  • Factors that influence cancer patients' overall perceptions of the quality of care
    Sandoval, G.A.; Brown, A.D.; Sullivan, T.; Green, E.
  • How valid and reliable are patient satisfaction data? An analysis of 195 studies
    Sitzia, J.
  • Perceptions of the quality of health services
    Sofaer, S.; Firminger, K.
  • The patient satisfaction process: moving toward a comprehensive model
    Strasser, S.; Aharony, L.; Greenberger, D.
  • Distinguishing service quality from patient satisfaction in developing health care marketing strategies
    Taylor, S.A.
  • Attitudes toward patient expertise in chronic illness
    Thorne, S.E.; Ternulf Nyhlin, K.; Paterson, B.L.
  • Unpacking the concept of patient satisfaction: a feminist analysis
    Turris, S.A.
  • Patient satisfaction measurement: current issues and implications
    Urden, K.D.
  • The quality of care and patient satisfaction: a review of measuring instruments
    van Campen, C.; Sixma, H.; Friele, R.D.; Kerssens, J.J.; Peters, L.
  • Dimensions of patient attitudes regarding doctors and medical care services
    Ware, J.E. Jr; Snyder, M.K.
  • Defining and measuring patient satisfaction with medical care
    Ware, J.E.; Snyder, M.K.; Wright, W.R.; Davies, A.R.
  • Patient‐reported service quality on a medicine unit
    Weingart, S.N.; Pagovich, O.; Sands, D.Z.; Li, J.M.; Aronson, M.D.; Davis, R.B.; Phillips, R.S.; Bates, D.W.
  • Patient satisfaction: a valid concept?
    Williams, B.
  • A Critical Review of Customer Satisfaction
    Yi, Y.