BackgroundAlthough the determinates of paranasal sinus development and sinusitis are not well defined, a candidate factor is blockage of the choana.HypothesisMaxillary sinuses ipsilateral to unilateral choanal atresia are comparatively small and have more evidence of sinusitis than do the contralateral sinuses.DesignRetrospective.SettingChildren's hospitals.PatientsSixteen nonsyndomic children with isolated unilateral congenital choanal atresia.Main Outcome MeasuresDetermination of maxillary sinus volumes and mucoperiosteal thickening on preoperative computed tomograms.ResultsMaxillary sinuses ipsilateral to unilateral choanal atresia have slightly larger volumes than, and mucoperiosteal thickening that is similar to, the contralateral sinuses.ConclusionThese data suggest that maxillary sinus development and sinusitis are independent of posterior nasal ventilation and drainage.OBSTRUCTION of sinonasal drainage and ventilation is a well-accepted contributor to paranasal sinusitis.Such a situation exists in children with choanal atresia. In 1927, Grovereported a case of unilateral choanal atresia, about the 180th at the time, and noted that:the free ventilation of the nose is one of the most potent factors in the prevention of sinus disease and in the cure of an early existing sinus infection. As no air current is possible [through the nose with unilateral choanal atresia], it must become apparent that the sinuses on the side of a choanal atresia are particularly susceptible to infection.Proetzemphasized, in 1941, the importance of sinus ventilation and drainage, noting that "it is generally agreed that stagnation of mucus in the closed side is apt to result ultimately in sinus disease." Later, Friday et aland then Waldput choanal atresia at the top of the list of mechanical obstructions predisposing to sinusitis.Because ventilation of the middle ear contributes to temporal bone pneumatization, nasal ventilation may be important in the development of the paranasal sinuses.Extensive paranasal sinus and mastoid development indicate sinus and middle ear health during a person's growth period.Conversely, growth of the maxillary sinuses is adversely affected by severe sinus infection. This compromised growth is exhibited by the small paranasal sinuses of patients with cystic fibrosis.Interestingly, Kim et alreported that children who meet the criteria for chronic sinusitis, but who do not have cystic fibrosis, have maxillary sinus development that is comparable to that of normal subjects.In children with unilateral choanal atresia, ipsilateral anterior nasal discharge is a presenting symptom.These children are frequently treated for months for presumptive sinusitis before the choanal atresia is recognized. Because nasal breathing is absent on the side of the atresia, poor gas exchange, leading to a lower partial pressure of oxygen and improved environment for bacterial growth, would be expected.The combination of abnormal mucociliary flow, pooling of secretions, and poor nasal ventilation would seem to predispose these children, in particular, to sinusitis on the atretic side.With this background understanding, we hypothesize that children with unilateral choanal atresia have abnormal mucociliary flow, relatively poor ventilation, and smaller sinuses and sinusitis on the atretic side. However, we were surprised and intrigued to encounter a child with unilateral choanal atresia and well-developed, aerated maxillary sinuses. Was this one case a fluke? Unilateral choanal atresia may be considered an experiment of nature, providing an opportunity to explore the relationship of nasal obstruction and sinusitis in children.SUBJECTS AND METHODSSTUDY POPULATIONThe medical records of all children with unilateral choanal atresia were requested from the 3 children's hospitals in Atlanta, Ga, and from a private otolaryngology practice in Memphis, Tenn. Approval of the Clinical Research Coordinating Committee was obtained from the one institution that required such approval. Excluded from the study were patients with bilateral atresia or anterior nasal piriform aperture stenosis and patients with any other congenital anomaly or syndrome. Also excluded were children whose initial preoperative computed tomographic (CT) scan was unavailable or did not include the posterior choanae and maxillary sinuses.The initial preoperative noncontrast axial sinus CT scans of 15 children and the coronal CT scan of 1 child were available for study. Each sinus was tomographically sectioned at regular parallel intervals ranging from 1 to 5 mm. The identity of each patient and the side of the atresia were known and concealed by the first author (P.M.B.) using opaque adhesive tape so that the reviewing author (N.W.T.) could view the scans without bias. Using an x-ray film review box for illumination, the bony contours of all maxillary sinus sections (caudal to cranial extent) were traced onto paper by the reviewing author. Similarly, the area of mucosal thickening (soft tissue density) within each maxillary sinus was traced to compare aerated with nonaerated maxillary sinus volumes.DETERMINATIONS OF MAXILLARY SINUS VOLUMESThe volume of each maxillary sinus was calculated using a technique described by Cavalieri, who was a contemporary and disciple of Galileo. Each maxillary sinus volume was approximated by calculating the area of each individually traced CT section using a planimeter (Keuffel & Esser Co, Germany). Correction for magnification (ie, correction for linear compression of each CT image) was accomplished by measuring the actual number of centimeters represented by the centimeter reference on the CT scan. Thus, the volume of each maxillary sinus was calculated according to the following formula: (linear correction)2×(centimeters between sections)×(sum of the object's areas).Similarly, the volume of each maxillary sinus containing soft tissue density (rather than air) was calculated. The aerated volume of the sinus was determined by subtracting the soft tissue–containing volume from the bony outline of the maxillary sinus.STATISTICSThe paired ttest was used to compare the mean of the volumes of the maxillary sinuses ipsilateral to the choanal atresia with the mean of the volumes of the maxillary sinuses contralateral to the atresia. The 1-tailed Pvalue was used to reject the null hypothesis (that the mean of the differences of the pairs is different from 0).RESULTSSixteen children, aged 1 month to 17 years, with isolated unilateral choanal atresia were identified. Twelve children were female and 4 were male, similar to the 2:1 ratio reported by Brown.Nine patients had right-sided atresia and 7 had left-sided atresia.A wide range of maxillary sinus volumes was noted (Figure 1). The mean maxillary sinus volume ipsilateral to the choanal atresia was 4.84 mL, compared with 4.48 mL for the contralateral side. The sinuses ipsilateral to the atresia were, on average, larger than the contralateral sinuses (P<.06). Symmetry of maxillary sinus size was apparent (r=0.97; P<.001).Volumes of maxillary sinus pneumatization of 16 patients (12 girls and 4 boys) with choanal atresia (right-sided in 9 and left-sided in 7). The number beside each data point indicates patient age (in years) at the time computed tomographic scans were performed.The volumes of the soft tissue (presumably mucoperiosteal thickening) in the maxillary sinuses appeared symmetrical: 6 patients had more soft tissue in the sinus ipsilateral to the atresia; 5 patients had more soft tissue in the sinus contralateral to the atresia; and 5 patients had complete opacification of both maxillary sinuses; ie, sinusitis as assessed by the preoperative CT scans was unrelated to the unilateral choanal atresia.COMMENTClassically, chronic sinusitis in children is associated with both local and systemic contributing factors. Systemic factors include upper respiratory tract infections, both allergic and nonallergic rhinitis, immunodeficiency states, primary ciliary dyskinesia, cystic fibrosis, Down syndrome, inhalant pollutants, and aspirin sensitivity. The list of local factors includes dental infections, cleft palate, and swimming, but mostly items related to nasal obstruction: adenoid hypertrophy or infection, foreign bodies, tumors, polyps, septal deviation, and choanal atresia.All of these conditions presumably interfere with normal nasal ventilation and sinonasal mucociliary flow and lead to obstruction of the osteomeatal unit.Lifelong, persistent, severe paranasal sinusitis is thought to be represented radiographically by nonaerated sinuses that are smaller than usual. The nonaerated (ie, opaque) sinus is attributed to stagnated mucus or pus or to thickened mucoperiosteum. Proetzsuggested that "the failure of some sinuses to develop may be on a kindred basis [to Wittmaack's contention that inflammatory middle ear disease limits mastoid pneumatization]." However, Ritterstated, "For unknown reasons, during growth the maxillary sinuses may cease development and produce a sinus lumen of less than normal size."Notwithstanding the consensus of conventional wisdom, sinusitis is not universal in children with choanal atresia. Proetzobserved that newborns with bilateral choanal atresia do not have clinical infection of the maxillary sinuses. Stewart's1931 report included the radiographs of 3 patients with unilateral choanal atresia: "The air sinuses on both sides of the skull were found to be well developed." Mehta,in describing an adult with unilateral choanal atresia, reported near-symmetrical, aerated, pneumatized maxillary sinuses. Similarly, Mittermaierillustrated a case of unilateral choanal atresia and stated in the study's figure legend, "The sinuses are normally developed." Klossek et aland Diner et alrecently described 2 small series of patients (numbering 6 and 11, respectively) with unilateral choanal atresia: no sinusitis!As Proetzsuggested:A difference apparently exists between the behavior of a nasal mucosa deprived of air after breathing has been established, and one in which, through congenital posterior closure, no breathing has ever taken place. In the latter condition normal, healthy tissues are often found in the nasal fossae. . . .There are several potential explanations for our findings of maxillary sinus symmetry in children with unilateral choanal atresia, including (1) stagnation of sinonasal mucus per se does not limit development of the maxillary sinuses; (2) absence of nasal ventilation alone does not result in chronic sinusitis or limit paranasal sinus pneumatization; (3) the blocked choana decreases the risk of viral and other pathogens getting into the nose; and (4) our findings, and those of other investigators, are flukes (statistically, this seems unlikely).CONCLUSIONSThat children with congenital unilateral choanal atresia manifest healthy, well-developed paranasal sinuses bilaterally is surprising and incongruous with the time-honored teachings that nasal ventilation and drainage are necessary for sinus health. The explanation for this unexpected finding is unknown, and may be a fertile investigative tract for improved understanding of paranasal sinusitis.JPDudleyParanasal sinus infections.In: Ballenger JJ, Snow JB Jr, eds. Otorhinolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery.15th ed. Baltimore, Md: Williams & Wilkins; 1996:163-172.JTJohnsonInfections.In: Cummings CW, ed. Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery.Vol 1. 2nd ed. St Louis, Mo: Mosby–Year Book Inc; 1986:929-940.JMGwaltney JrJGJonesDWKennedyMedical management of sinusitis: educational goals and management guidelines: the International Conference on Sinus Disease.Ann Otol Laryngol Otol Suppl.1995;167:22-30.DMehtaAtlas of Endoscopic Sinonasal Surgery.Philadelphia, Pa: Lea & Febiger; 1993.DSParsonsERWaldOtitis media and sinusitis: similar diseases.Otolaryngol Clin North Am.1996;29:11-25.AWProetzEssays on the Applied Physiology of the Nose.St Louis, Mo: Annals Publishing Co; 1941.AReimerCvon MecklenburgNGToremalmThe mucociliary activity of the upper respiratory tract, III: a functional and morphologic study on human and animal material with special reference to maxillary sinus diseases.Acta Otolaryngol Suppl Stockh.1978;356:1-20.HStammbergerMHawkeEssentials of Endoscopic Sinus Surgery.St Louis, Mo: Mosby–Year Book Inc; 1993.OEVan AlyeaNasal Sinuses: An Anatomic and Clinical Consideration.2nd ed. Baltimore, Md: Williams & Wilkins; 1951.ERWaldRhinitis and acute and chronic sinusitis.In: Pediatric Otolaryngology.Vol 1. Philadelphia, Pa: WB Saunders Co; 1996:843-858.MEWigandEndoscopic Surgery of the Paranasal Sinuses and Anterior Skull Base.Suttgart, Germany: Georg Thieme Verlag; 1990.WEGroveChoanal atresia and sinus infection.Arch Otolaryngol.1927;6:237-241.GAFriday JrPFiremanASukanichMLSteinbergSinusitis.In: Naspitz CK, Tinkelman DG, eds. Childhood Rhinitis and Sinusitis: Pathophysiology and Treatment.New York, NY: Marcel Dekker Inc; 1990:193-215.AFrengGrowth in width of the dental arches after partial extirpation of the mid-palatal suture in man.Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg.1978;12:267-272.AFrengCongenital choanal atresia.Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg.1978;12:261-265.NWToddMastoid pneumatization in patients with unilateral aural atresia.Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol.1994;251:196-198.HJKimEMFriedmanMSulekNODuncanCMcCluggageParanasal sinus development in chronic sinusitis, cystic fibrosis, and normal comparison population: a computerized tomography correlation study.Am J Rhinol.1997;11:275-281.GRothmanRAWoodRMNaclerioUnilateral choanal atresia masquerading as chronic sinusitis.Pediatrics.1994;94:941-944.OEBrownChoanal atresia.In: Schaefer SD, ed. Rhinology and Sinus Disease: A Problem-Oriented Approach.St Louis, Mo: Mosby–Year Book Inc; 1998:78-83.AGungorJPCoreyPediatric sinusitis.In: McCaffrey TV, ed. Rhinologic Diagnosis and Treatment.New York, NY: Thieme-Stratton Inc; 1997:382-405.FNRitterThe Paranasal Sinuses: Anatomy and Surgical Technique.St Louis, Mo: Mosby–Year Book Inc; 1978.JPStewartCongenital atresia of the posterior nares.Arch Otolaryngol.1931;13:570-583.RMittermaierOtorhinolaryngologic Radiology: A Radiologic Atlas of Ear, Nose and Throat Diseases.New York, NY: Grune & Stratton Inc; 1970.JMKlossekJCFerriePJFourcroyCDesmonsFBasso-BrusaJPFontanelUnilateral choanal atresia and paranasal sinus growth [in French].Ann Otolaryngol Chir Cervicofac.1996;113:392-396.PADinerJAndrieu-GuitrancourtDDehesdinUnilateral congenital choanal atresia and maxillary sinus development.J Maxillofac Surg.1986;14:285-288.Accepted for publication July 16, 1999.Presented as a poster at the 14th Annual Meeting of the American Society of Pediatric Otolaryngology and the Third Biannual Meeting of the Interamerican Association of Pediatric Otolaryngology, Palm Desert, Calif, April 28-30, 1999.Reprints: N. Wendell Todd, MD, Department of Otolaryngology, Emory University School of Medicine, 1365 Clifton Rd NE, Atlanta, GA 30322.
JAMA Otolaryngology - Head & Neck Surgery – American Medical Association
Published: Feb 1, 2000