Disentangling the Influences of Storm-Relative Flow and Horizontal Streamwise Vorticity on Low-Level Mesocyclones in Supercells
Disentangling the Influences of Storm-Relative Flow and Horizontal Streamwise Vorticity on...
Peters, John M.; Coffer, Brice E.; Parker, Matthew D.; Nowotarski, Christopher J.; Mulholland, Jake P.; Nixon, Cameron J.; Allen, John T.
2023-01-22 00:00:00
AbstractSufficient low-level storm-relative flow is a necessary ingredient for sustained supercell thunderstorms and is connected to supercell updraft width. Assuming a supercell exists, the role of low-level storm-relative flow in regulating supercells’ low-level mesocyclone intensity is less clear. One possibility considered in this article is that storm-relative flow controls mesocyclone and tornado width via its modulation of overall updraft extent. This hypothesis relies on a previously postulated positive correspondence between updraft width, mesocyclone width, and tornado width. An alternative hypothesis is that mesocyclone characteristics are primarily regulated by horizontal streamwise vorticity irrespective of storm-relative flow. A matrix of supercell simulations was analyzed to address the aforementioned hypotheses, wherein horizontal streamwise vorticity and storm-relative flow were independently varied. Among these simulations, mesocyclone width and intensity were strongly correlated with horizontal streamwise vorticity, and comparatively weakly correlated with storm-relative flow, supporting the second hypothesis. Accompanying theory and trajectory analysis offers the physical explanation that, when storm-relative flow is large and updrafts are wide, vertically tilted streamwise vorticity is projected over a wider area but with a lesser average magnitude than when these parameters are small. These factors partially offset one another, degrading the correspondence of storm-relative flow with updraft circulation and rotational velocity, which are the mesocyclone attributes most closely tied to tornadoes. These results refute the previously purported connections between updraft width, mesocyclone width, and tornado width, and emphasize horizontal streamwise vorticity as the primary control on low-level mesocyclones in sustained supercells.Significance StatementThe intensity of a supercell thunderstorm’s low-level rotation, known as the “mesocyclone,” is thought to influence tornado likelihood. Mesocyclone intensity depends on many environmental attributes that are often correlated with one another and difficult to disentangle. This study used a large body of numerical simulations to investigate the influence of the speed of low-level air entering a supercell (storm-relative flow), the horizontal spin of the ambient air entering the thunderstorm (streamwise vorticity), and the width of the storm’s updraft. Our results suggest that the rotation of the mesocyclone in supercells is primarily influenced by streamwise vorticity, with comparatively weaker connections to storm-relative flow and updraft width. These findings provide important clarification in our scientific understanding of how a storm’s environment influences the rate of rotation of its mesocyclone, and the associated tornado threat.
http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.pngJournal of the Atmospheric SciencesAmerican Meteorological Societyhttp://www.deepdyve.com/lp/american-meteorological-society/disentangling-the-influences-of-storm-relative-flow-and-horizontal-KwJPI9K6Iq
Disentangling the Influences of Storm-Relative Flow and Horizontal Streamwise Vorticity on Low-Level Mesocyclones in Supercells
AbstractSufficient low-level storm-relative flow is a necessary ingredient for sustained supercell thunderstorms and is connected to supercell updraft width. Assuming a supercell exists, the role of low-level storm-relative flow in regulating supercells’ low-level mesocyclone intensity is less clear. One possibility considered in this article is that storm-relative flow controls mesocyclone and tornado width via its modulation of overall updraft extent. This hypothesis relies on a previously postulated positive correspondence between updraft width, mesocyclone width, and tornado width. An alternative hypothesis is that mesocyclone characteristics are primarily regulated by horizontal streamwise vorticity irrespective of storm-relative flow. A matrix of supercell simulations was analyzed to address the aforementioned hypotheses, wherein horizontal streamwise vorticity and storm-relative flow were independently varied. Among these simulations, mesocyclone width and intensity were strongly correlated with horizontal streamwise vorticity, and comparatively weakly correlated with storm-relative flow, supporting the second hypothesis. Accompanying theory and trajectory analysis offers the physical explanation that, when storm-relative flow is large and updrafts are wide, vertically tilted streamwise vorticity is projected over a wider area but with a lesser average magnitude than when these parameters are small. These factors partially offset one another, degrading the correspondence of storm-relative flow with updraft circulation and rotational velocity, which are the mesocyclone attributes most closely tied to tornadoes. These results refute the previously purported connections between updraft width, mesocyclone width, and tornado width, and emphasize horizontal streamwise vorticity as the primary control on low-level mesocyclones in sustained supercells.Significance StatementThe intensity of a supercell thunderstorm’s low-level rotation, known as the “mesocyclone,” is thought to influence tornado likelihood. Mesocyclone intensity depends on many environmental attributes that are often correlated with one another and difficult to disentangle. This study used a large body of numerical simulations to investigate the influence of the speed of low-level air entering a supercell (storm-relative flow), the horizontal spin of the ambient air entering the thunderstorm (streamwise vorticity), and the width of the storm’s updraft. Our results suggest that the rotation of the mesocyclone in supercells is primarily influenced by streamwise vorticity, with comparatively weaker connections to storm-relative flow and updraft width. These findings provide important clarification in our scientific understanding of how a storm’s environment influences the rate of rotation of its mesocyclone, and the associated tornado threat.
Journal
Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences
– American Meteorological Society
Published: Jan 22, 2023
Recommended Articles
Loading...
References
Some aspects of a severe, right-moving thunderstorm deduced from mesonetwork rawinsonde observations
Barnes, S. L.
On the environments of tornadic and nontornadic mesocyclones
Brooks, H. E.; Doswell, C. A.; Cooper, J.
The influence of lifting condensation level on low-level outflow and rotation in simulated supercell thunderstorms
Brown, M.; Nowotarski, C. J.
Airflow within a tornadic storm
Browning, K. A.; Landry, C. R.
A benchmark simulation for moist nonhydrostatic numerical models
Bryan, G. H.; Fritsch, J. M.
Predicting supercell motion using a new hodograph technique
Bunkers, M. J.; Klimowski, B. A.; Thompson, R. L.; Weisman, M. L.
An idealized physical model for the severe convective storm environmental sounding
Chavas, D. R.; Dawson, D. T.
Impacts of increasing low-level shear on supercells during the early evening transition
Coffer, B. E.; Parker, M. D.
Simulated supercells in nontornadic and tornadic VORTEX2 environments
Coffer, B. E.; Parker, M. D.
Comments on “The regulation of tornado intensity by updraft width.”
Coffer, B. E.; Markowski, P. M.
Is there a “tipping point” between simulated nontornadic and tornadic supercells in VORTEX2 environments?
Coffer, B. E.; Parker, M. D.
Volatility of tornadogenesis: An ensemble of simulated nontornadic and tornadic supercells in VORTEX2 environments
Coffer, B. E.; Parker, M. D.; Dahl, J. M. L.; Wicker, L. J.; Clark, A. J.
Using near-ground storm relative helicity in supercell tornado forecasting
Coffer, B. E.; Parker, M. D.; Thompson, R. L.; Smith, B. T.; Jewell, R. E.
Near-ground wind profiles of tornadic and nontornadic environments in the United States and Europe from ERA5 reanalyses
Coffer, B. E.; Taszarek, M.; Parker, M. D.
Insights into supercells and their environments from three decades of targeted radiosonde observations
Coniglio, M. C.; Parker, M. D.
SPC mesoscale analysis compared to field-project soundings: Implications for supercell environment studies
Coniglio, M. C.; Jewell, R. E.
Imported and storm-generated near-ground vertical vorticity in a simulated supercell
Dahl, J. M.; Parker, M. D.; Wicker, L. J.
The dependence of core radius on swirl ratio in a tornado simulator
Davies-Jones, R. P.
Streamwise vorticity: The origin of updraft rotation in supercell storms
Davies-Jones, R. P.
Can a descending rain curtain in a supercell instigate tornadogenesis barotropically?
Davies-Jones, R. P.
A review of supercell and tornado dynamics
Davies-Jones, R. P.
Roles of streamwise and transverse partial-vorticity components in steady inviscid isentropic supercell-like flows
Davies-Jones, R. P.
Invented forces in supercell models
Davies-Jones, R. P.
Theory of parcel vorticity evolution in supercell-like flows
Davies-Jones, R. P.
The 8 June 1995 Mclean, Texas, storm. Part II: Cyclic tornado formation, maintenance, and dissipation
Dowell, D. C.; Bluestein, H. B.
The influence of helicity on numerically simulated convective storms
Droegemeier, K. K.; Lazarus, S. M.; Davies-Jones, R.
A compressible model for the simulation of moist mountain waves
Durran, D. R.; Klemp, J. B.
The relative importance of updraft and cold pool characteristics in supercell tornadogenesis using highly idealized simulations
Fischer, J.; Dahl, J. M. L.
Transition of near-ground vorticity dynamics during tornadogenesis
Fischer, J.; Dahl, J. M. L.
The influence of ground-relative flow and friction on near-surface storm-relative helicity
Flournoy, M. D.; Rasmussen, E. N.
Low-level updraft intensification in response to environmental wind profiles
Goldacker, N. A.; Parker, M. D.
Effects of low-level wind profile on outflow position and near-surface vertical vorticity in simulated supercell thunderstorms
Guarriello, F.; Nowotarski, C. J.; Epifanio, C. C.
Dynamics of tornadic thunderstorms
Klemp, J. B.
Simulations of right- and left-moving storms produced through storm splitting
Klemp, J. B.; Wilhelmson, R. B.
The structure, energetics, and propagation of rotating convective storms. Part II: Helicity and storm stabilization
Lilly, D. K.
The dynamical coupling of convective updrafts, down-drafts, and cold pools in simulated supercell thunderstorms
Marion, G. R.; Trapp, R. J.
Using overshooting top area to discriminate potential for large, intense tornadoes
Marion, G. R.; Trapp, R. J.; Nesbitt, S. W.
The influence of environmental low-level shear and cold pools on tornadogenesis: Insights from idealized simulations
Markowski, P. M.; Richardson, Y. P.
Large sensitivity of near-surface vertical vorticity development to heat sink location in idealized simulations of supercell-like storms
Markowski, P. M.; Richardson, Y. P.
Direct surface thermodynamic observations within the rear-flank downdrafts of nontornadic and tornadic supercells
Markowski, P. M.; Straka, J. M.; Rasmussen, E. N.
Characteristics of vertical wind profiles near supercells obtained from the Rapid Update Cycle
Markowski, P. M.; Hannon, C.; Frame, J.; Lancaster, E.; Pietrycha, A.; Edwards, R.; Thompson, R. L.
Buoyancy and shear characteristics of hurricane-tornado environments
McCaul, E. W.
An analytic description of the structure and evolution of growing deep cumulus updrafts
Morrison, H.
Theoretical expressions for the ascent rate of moist convective thermals
Morrison, H.; Peters, J. M.
Impact of cloud microphysics on the development of trailing stratiform precipitation in a simulated squall line: Comparison of one- and two-moment schemes
Morrison, H.; Thompson, G.; Tatarskii, V.
Thermal chains and entrainment in cumulus updrafts: Part I: Theoretical description
Morrison, H.; Peters, J. M.; Hannah, W. M.; Varble, A. C.; Giangrande, S. E.
Simultaneous dual-Doppler and mobile mesonet observations of streamwise vorticity currents in three supercells
Murdzek, S. S.; Markowski, P. M.; Richardson, Y. P.
Convective initiation in an idealized cloud model using an updraft nudging technique
Naylor, J.; Gilmore, M. S.
Classifying proximity soundings with self-organizing maps toward improving supercell and tornado forecasting
Nowotarski, C. J.; Jensen, A. A.
Evolution of a long-track violent tornado within a simulated supercell
Orf, L.; Wilhelmson, R.; Lee, B.; Finley, C.; Houston, A.
Composite VORTEX2 supercell environments from near-storm soundings
Parker, M. D.
Production of near-surface vertical vorticity by idealized downdrafts
Parker, M. D.; Dahl, J. M. L.
The role of vertical wind shear in modulating maximum supercell updraft velocities
Peters, J. M.; Nowotarski, C.; Morrison, H.
Thermal chains and entrainment in cumulus updrafts: Part II: Simulations
Peters, J. M.; Morrison, H.; Hannah, W. M.; Varble, A. C.; Giangrande, S. E.
A formula for the maximum vertical velocity in supercell updrafts
Peters, J. M.; Morrison, H.; Nowotarski, C. J.; Mulholland, J. P.; Thompson, R. L.
Are supercells resistant to entrainment because of their rotation?
Peters, J. M.; Nowotarski, C. J.; Mullendore, G.
The influences of effective inflow layer streamwise vorticity and storm-relative flow on supercell updraft properties
Peters, J. M.; Nowotarski, C. J.; Mulholland, J. P.
The influence of shear on deep convection initiation. Part I: Theory
Peters, J. M.; Morrison, H.; Nelson, T. C.; Marquis, J. N.; Mulholland, J. P.; Nowotarski, C. J.
The influence of shear on deep convection initiation. Part II: Simulations
Peters, J. M.; Morrison, H.; Nelson, T. C.; Marquis, J. N.; Mulholland, J. P.; Nowotarski, C. J.
Generalized lapse rate formulas for use in entraining cape calculations
Peters, J. M.; Mulholland, J. P.; Chavas, D. R.
On the rotation and propagation of simulated supercell thunderstorms
Rotunno, R.; Klemp, J. B.
Comparing observations and simulations of the streamwise vorticity current and the forward-flank convergence boundary in a supercell storm
Schueth, A.; Weiss, C.; Dahl, J. M. L.
Observed relationship between tornado intensity and pretornadic mesocyclone characteristics
Sessa, M. F.; Trapp, R. J.
VORTEX2 observations of a low-level mesocyclone with multiple internal rear-flank downdraft momentum surges in the 18 May 2010 Dumas, Texas, Supercell
Skinner, P. S.; Weiss, C. C.; French, M. M.; Bluestein, H. B.; Markowski, P. M.; Richardson, Y. P.
Convective modes for significant severe thunderstorms in the contiguous United States. Part I: Storm classification and climatology
Smith, B. T.; Thompson, R. L.; Grams, J. S.; Broyles, C.; Brooks, H. E.
Severe convective storms across Europe and the United States. Part II: ERA5 environments associated with lightning, large hail, severe wind, and tornadoes
Taszarek, M.; Allen, J. T.; Púcik, T.; Hoogewind, K. A.; Brooks, H. E.
Eta model storm-relative winds associated with tornadic and nontornadic supercells
Thompson, R. L.
Close proximity soundings within supercell environments obtained from the Rapid Update Cycle
Thompson, R. L.; Edwards, R.; Hart, J. A.; Elmore, K. L.; Markowski, P.
Effective storm-relative helicity and bulk shear in supercell thunderstorm environments
Thompson, R. L.; Mead, C. M.; Edwards, R.
Convective modes for significant severe thunderstorms in the contiguous United States. Part II: Supercell and QLCS tornado environments
Thompson, R. L.; Smith, B. T.; Grams, J. S.; Dean, A. R.; Broyles, C.
The regulation of tornado intensity by updraft width
Trapp, R. J.; Marion, G. R.; Nesbitt, S. W.
Reply to “Comments on ‘The regulation of tornado intensity by updraft width.’”
Trapp, R. J.; Marion, G. R.; Nesbitt, S. W.
Impact of variations in upper-level shear on simulated supercells
Warren, R. A.; Richter, H.; Ramsay, H. A.; Siems, S. T.; Manton, M. J.
Simulation and analysis of tornado development and decay within a three-dimensional supercell thunderstorm
Wicker, L. J.; Wilhelmson, R. B.
The second Verification of the Origins of Rotation in Tornadoes Experiment: VORTEX2
Wurman, J.; Dowell, D.; Richardson, Y.; Markowski, P.; Rasmussen, E.; Burgess, D.; Wicker, L.; Bluestein, H. B.
To get new article updates from a journal on your personalized homepage, please log in first, or sign up for a DeepDyve account if you don’t already have one.
All DeepDyve websites use cookies to improve your online experience. They were placed on your computer when you launched this website. You can change your cookie settings through your browser.