Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
H. Allen, W. Rogers (1997)
The consumer health plan value survey: round two.Health affairs, 16 4
J. Lefkovits, E. Plow, E. Topol (1995)
Platelet glycoprotein IIb/IIIa receptors in cardiovascular medicine.The New England journal of medicine, 332 23
M. Conrad, J. Umbreit, E. Moore, C. Uzel, M. Berry (1994)
Alternate iron transport pathway. Mobilferrin and integrin in K562 cells.The Journal of biological chemistry, 269 10
K. Warner, J. Slade, D. Sweanor (1997)
The emerging market for long-term nicotine maintenance.JAMA, 278 13
J. Staessen, G. Byttebier, F. Buntinx, H. Celis, Eoin O'Brien, R. Fagard (1997)
Antihypertensive treatment based on conventional or ambulatory blood pressure measurement. A randomized controlled trial. Ambulatory Blood Pressure Monitoring and Treatment of Hypertension Investigators.JAMA, 278 13
S. Borowsky, Margaret Davis, C. Goertz, N. Lurie (1997)
Are all health plans created equal? The physician's view.JAMA, 278 11
Epilog Investigators (1997)
Platelet glycoprotein IIb/IIIa receptor blockade and low-dose heparin during percutaneous coronary revascularization.The New England journal of medicine, 336 24
B. Kim, J. Phillips, J. Atherton (1976)
Actinobacillus suis in the horseVeterinary Record, 98
J. Kralewski, E. Rich, T. Bernhardt, B. Dowd, R. Feldman, C. Johnson (1998)
The organizational structure of medical group practices in a managed care environment.Health Care Management Review, 23
E. Levin, E. Westman, R. Stein, E. Carnahan, M. Sanchez, S. Herman, F. Behm, J. Rose (1994)
Nicotine skin patch treatment increases abstinence, decreases withdrawal symptoms, and attenuates rewarding effects of smoking.Journal of clinical psychopharmacology, 14 1
H. Allen, H. Darling, D. McNeill, F. Bastien (1994)
The Employee Health Care Value Survey: round one.Health affairs, 13 4
J. Killen, S. Fortmann, Laurie Davis, A. Varady (1997)
Nicotine patch and self-help video for cigarette smoking cessation.Journal of consulting and clinical psychology, 65 4
A. Amery, A. Distler, D. Ganten, C. Mancia, W. Meyer-Sabellek, E. O'Brien, T. Pickering (1990)
Consensus document on non-invasive ambulatory blood pressure monitoring. The Scientific Committee.Journal of hypertension. Supplement : official journal of the International Society of Hypertension, 8 6
D. Fischman, M. Savage (1997)
The platelet, the patient, and periprocedural infarction during percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty.JAMA, 278 6
J. Staessen, E. O’Brien, A. Amery, N. Atkins, P. Baumgart, P. Cort, J. Degaute, P. Dolenc, R. Gaudemaris, I. Enström, R. Fagard, P. Gosse, Steven Gourlay, H. Hayashi, Y. Imai, GaryD. James, T. Kawasaki, E. Kuschnir, I. Kuwajima, L. Lindholm, Li-sheng Liu, F. Macor, G. Mancia, B. McGrath, M. Middeke, J. Ming, Stefano Omboni, Kuniaka Otsuka, P. Palatini, G. Parati, C. Pieper, P. Verdecchia, P. Zachariah, Weizhong Zhang (1994)
Ambulatory blood pressure in normotensive and hypertensive subjects: results from an international databaseJournal of Hypertension, 12
N. Mair, C. Randall, G. Thomas, J. Harbourne, C. Mccrea, K. Cowl (1974)
Actinobacillus suis infection in pigs. A report of four outbreaks and two sporadic cases.Journal of comparative pathology, 84 1
A. Joseph, S. Norman, L. Ferry, A. Prochazka, E. Westman, B. Steele, Scott Sherman, Minot Cleveland, D. Antonuccio, Neil Hartman, P. McGovern (1996)
The safety of transdermal nicotine as an aid to smoking cessation in patients with cardiac disease.The New England journal of medicine, 335 24
W. Clark, D. Hollis, R. Weaver, P. Riley (1985)
Identification of unusual pathogenic gram-negative aerobic and facultatively anaerobic bacteria
E. Topol, J. Ferguson, H. Weisman, J. Tcheng, S. Ellis, N. Kleiman, R. Ivanhoe, Ann Wang, David Miller, K. Anderson, R. Califf (1997)
Long-term Protection From Myocardial Ischemic Events in a Randomized Trial of Brief Integrin β3 Blockade With Percutaneous Coronary InterventionJAMA, 278
K. Zarnke, B. Feagan, J. Mahon, R. Feldman (1997)
A randomized study comparing a patient-directed hypertension management strategy with usual office-based care.American journal of hypertension, 10 1
E. Karwatowska-Prokopczuk, E. Czarnowska, A. Berȩsewicz (1992)
Iron availability and free radical induced injury in the isolated ischaemic/reperfused rat heart.Cardiovascular research, 26 1
M. Conrad, J. Umbreit, R. Peterson, E. Moore, K. Harper (1993)
Function of integrin in duodenal mucosal uptake of ironBlood, 81
To the Editor.—The central premise of the article by Dr Borowsky and colleagues1 —that physicians have a unique and valuable window into the quality of health plan performance—is compelling. Although the physician viewpoint has all but been forgotten in public debate over plan performance measurement, the authors have made a valuable initial empirical attempt to correct this omission. For example, it is important to recognize that physicians were highly critical of mental health care in all 3 evaluated plans and that this presents an immediate opportunity for improvement. However, the authors overreach their data when applying these measures to assign report card rankings to these plans. First, uncontrolled differences in plan type bias the results. The authors compared a staff model health maintenance organization (HMO) (plan 2) with 2 network model plans gatekeeper (plans 1 and 3, of which plan 3 had a primary care physician format). Previous work has traced differences in patient satisfaction between plans to plan type.2,3 These health plans may genuinely differ on the indicators used in this study, but this distinction could not be adequately controlled (statistically or otherwise) given the study design. The most likely explanation for the more positive perception of physicians in plan 2 toward managed care practices—a possibility raised but not investigated by the authors—is that physicians who choose to work in this setting have greater understanding of, and a more positive view toward, the same managed care practices than their colleagues in the 2 network model plans. A more credible comparison would have pitted each of these plans with similar types of plans or asked physicians who work with all 3 plans to compare them against each other. Second, the rate of attrition was problematic. Of the target plan 3 sample, 45% were lost either to initial difficulty in locating the physicians or because respondents asserted that they rated another plan because they did not know enough about plan 3. The attrition rate for plan 3 was large and was much greater than the rate for the other 2 samples, and undercut any claim that the final plan 3 sample was representative of the corresponding physician population. An unacknowledged urban-rural bias also confounds the comparison because plan 3 includes comparatively more rural physicians. These flaws render any conclusion about the relative performance of these 3 plans premature. Pioneering work often falls prey to this kind of overreach, but, as a result, it would be erroneous to link the reported differences in physician perceptions to actual differences in practices that promote or hinder the provision of high-quality care to patients. There is much to learn from physicians' perceptions of health plans, but only when the static introduced by preexisting attitudes can be sorted out successfully. Furthermore, to assert that the ability of physician satisfaction measures "to distinguish between plans stands in contrast to some surveys of consumer satisfaction that find small, if any, differences between plans" is unfounded. This study with its shortcomings is hardly sufficient to compare physician-supplied and patient/member-supplied data in differentiating plans. References 1. Borowsky SJDavis MKGoertz CLurie N Are all health plans created equal? the physician's view. JAMA. 1997;278917- 921Google ScholarCrossref 2. Allen Jr HMDarling HMcNeill DBastien F The employee health care value survey: round one. Health Aff (Millwood). 1994;13 (4) 25- 41Google ScholarCrossref 3. Allen Jr HMRogers WH The consumer health plan value survey: round two. Health Aff (Millwood). 1997;16 (4) 156- 166Google ScholarCrossref
JAMA – American Medical Association
Published: Jan 21, 1998
Read and print from thousands of top scholarly journals.
Already have an account? Log in
Bookmark this article. You can see your Bookmarks on your DeepDyve Library.
To save an article, log in first, or sign up for a DeepDyve account if you don’t already have one.
Copy and paste the desired citation format or use the link below to download a file formatted for EndNote
Access the full text.
Sign up today, get DeepDyve free for 14 days.
All DeepDyve websites use cookies to improve your online experience. They were placed on your computer when you launched this website. You can change your cookie settings through your browser.