Get 20M+ Full-Text Papers For Less Than $1.50/day. Start a 14-Day Trial for You or Your Team.

Learn More →

Fifteen Years' Experience with Gastric Resection for Duodenal Ulcer

Fifteen Years' Experience with Gastric Resection for Duodenal Ulcer Abstract Gastric surgery for duodenal ulcer began in 1884 when Rydygier, a Polish surgeon, performed a gastroenterostomy for benign obstruction of the stomach. Thereafter, other surgeons in Britain, Europe, and America followed suit, and thus began the surgical treatment of duodenal ulcer. Moynihan in England and W. J. Mayo in this country deserve great credit for making clear the indications for gastroenterostomy and developing the technique of the operation. It was often combined with excision of the ulcer and pyloroplasty, or excision and pyloroplasty only were used. Thus, it came about that during the first quarter of this century, the operation of gastroenterostomy became the most frequently performed gastric operation for duodenal ulcer. In the 1920's, Lorenz and Van Haberer in Europe were among the first to recognize that gastroenterostomy did not prevent hemorrhage and to realize also that ulcer symptoms frequently persisted or recurred, and all too frequently marginal ulcer References 1. Brooks, J. R., and Moore, F. D.: Duodenal Ulcer: The Present Status of Definitive Surgery; the Selection and Management of Patients Undergoing Operation , New England J. Med. 260:1018-1025 ( (May 14) )Crossref 2. 1069-1075 (May 21) 3. 1124-1130 (May 28) 1959. 4. Burdette, W. J., and Fitzpatrick, W. K.: Objective Evaluation of Vagotomy-Antrectomy for Duodenal Ulcer , Ann. Surg. 149:875 ( (June) ) 1959.Crossref 5. Coffey, R. J., and Lazaro, E. J.: Vagotomy, Hemigastrectomy and Gastroduodenostomy (Fin-(Finney-VonHaberer in the Treatment of Duodenal Ulcer , Ann. Surg. 141:862-871, 1955.Crossref 6. Colp, R.: Subtotal Gastrectomy With and Without Vagotomy for Duodenal and Gastrojejunal Ulcer , J.A.M.A. 162:1599-1602 ( (Dec. 29) ) 1956.Crossref 7. Crile, G., Jr.: Postoperative Mortality , A.M.A. Arch. Surg. 77:857-858 ( (Dec.) ) 1958.Crossref 8. Wallensten, S.: Reappraisal: Gastric Resection for Peptic Ulcer , Surgery 41:341-348, 1957. 9. Dragstedt, L. R.; Palmer, W. L.; Schafer, P. W., and Hodges, P. C.: Supradiaphragmatic Section of Vagus Nerves in Treatment of Duodenal and Gastric Ulcers , Gastroenterology 3:450-462, 1952. 10. Druckerman, L. J.; Weinstein, V. A.; Klingenstein, P., and Colp, R.: A Comparative Study of Subtotal Gastrectomy With and Without Infradiaphragmatic Vagotomy in the Surgical Therapy of Duodenal Ulcer , Ann. Surg. 136:211-216 ( (Aug.) ) 1952.Crossref 11. Edwards, L. W., and Herrington, J. L., Jr.: Vagotomy and Gastroenterostomy—Vagotomy and Conservative Gastrectomy , Ann. Surg. 137:873-883, 1953.Crossref 12. Gillespie, M. G.: Surgical Treatment of Peptic Ulcer , Minnesota Med. 27:707-711 ( (Sept.) ) 1944. 13. Harvey, H. D.; St. John, F. B., and Volk, H.: Peptic Ulcer: Late Follow-up Results After Partial Gastrectomy; Analysis of Failures , Ann. Surg. 138:680-688 ( (Nov.) ) 1953.Crossref 14. Hinton, J. W.: The Evaluation of End Results in Physiologic Versus Pathologic Operative Procedures for Chronic Duodenal Ulcer During the Past 2 Decades , Ann. Surg. 132:641-651, 1950.Crossref 15. Hoerr, S. O.: Evaluation of Vagotomy with Gastroenterostomy Performed for Chronic Duodenal Ulcer: Report Based on 5-Year Follow-up of 145 Patients , Surgery 38:149-157, 1955. 16. Horsley, G. W., and Barnes, W. C.: Twenty-five Years Experience with Bilroth I Gastric Resection , Ann. Surg. 145:758-769, 1957.Crossref 17. Johnson, H. D., and Orr, I. M.: Selective Surgery for Peptic Ulcer , Surg. Gynec. & Obst. 98:425-431, 1954. 18. LaBree, R. H., and Gillespie, M. G.: Adequate Subtotal Gastric Resection for Duodenal Ulcer , Arch. Surg. 59:750-757 ( (Sept.) ) 1949. 19. Lahey, F. H., and Marshall, S. I.: Surgical Treatment of Peptic Ulcer , New England J. Med. 246:115-123 ( (Jan. 24) ) 1952. 20. Lewisohn, R.: Changes in Surgical Treatment of Chronic Duodenal Ulcers During Past 50 Years , A.M.A. Arch. Surg. 77:61-74 ( (July) ) 1958. 21. McCaughan, J. J., Jr., and Bowers, R. F.: Favorable Postgastrectomy Results in Billroth II Patients with a Small Stoma , A.M.A. Arch. Surg. 77:837-843 ( (Dec.) ) 1958. 22. McDonald, O. G.; Gillespie, M. G., and LaBree, R. H.: Treatment of Duodenal Ulcer by Subtotal Gastric Resection , A.M.A. Arch. Surg. 67:444-450 ( (Sept.) ) 1953. 23. Milstein, B. B.: The Late Results of Partial Gastrectomy , Ann. Surg. 133:1-17, 1951.Crossref 24. Pallette, E. C., and Harrington, R. W.: Long-Term Results in Surgical Treatment of Peptic Ulcer , J.A.M.A. 168:20-24 ( (Sept. 6) ) 1958.Crossref 25. Palumbo, L. T.; Mazur, T. T., and Doyle, B. J.: Partial Gastrectomy for Duodenal Ulcer or Marginal Ulcer , Ann. Surg. 140:860-866, 1954.Crossref 26. Poth, E. J.: Rational Treatment of Duodenal Ulcer , Surg. Gynec. & Obst. 101:489-493, 1955. 27. Roth, J. L. A.; Becker, I.; Vine, S., and Bockus, H. L.: Results of Subtotal Gastric Resection (Billroth II Type) for Duodenal Ulcer , J.A.M.A. 161:794-800 ( (June 30) ) 1956. 28. Survey Committee, Ohio Chapter, American College of Surgery: Elective Operations Performed for Duodenal Ulcer with Their Mortality , Am. J. Surg. 96:365-368 ( (Sept.) ) 1958. 29. Walters, W.; Gray, H. K.; Priestley, J. T., and Counseller, V. S.: Annual Report on Surgery of the Stomach and Duodenum for 1942 , Proc. Staff Meet. Mayo Clin. 18:505-511 ( (Dec. 29) ) 1943. 30. Walters, W., and Chance, D. P.: Vagotomy as a Prophylactic and Curative Procedure in Peptic Ulcer , J.A.M.A. 153:993-997 ( (Nov. 14) ) 1953. 31. Wangensteen, O. H.: The Ulcer Problem , Canad. M.A.J. 53:309-331 ( (Oct.) ) 1945. 32. Wangensteen, O. H.; Varco, R. L.; Hay, L.; Walpole, S., and Froch, B.: Gastric Acidity Before and After Operative Procedure with Special Reference to the Role of the Pylorus and Antrum , Ann. Surg. 112:626-670, 1940. 33. Walters, W., and Mobley, J. E.: Five-to-10-Year Follow-Up of 162 Cases of Duodenal Ulcer Treated by Vagotomy With and Without Associated Gastric Operations , Ann. Surg. 145: 753-757, 1957. 34. Zollinger, R. M.: Evaluation of the Surgical Treatment of Intractable Duodenal Ulcer , A.M.A. Arch. Int. Med. 102:607-617 ( (Oct.) ) 1958. 35. Zollinger, R. M., and Williams, R. D.: Considerations in Surgical Treatment for Duodenal Ulcer , J.A.M.A. 160:367-373 ( (Feb. 4) ) 1956. http://www.deepdyve.com/assets/images/DeepDyve-Logo-lg.png Archives of Surgery American Medical Association

Fifteen Years' Experience with Gastric Resection for Duodenal Ulcer

Loading next page...
 
/lp/american-medical-association/fifteen-years-experience-with-gastric-resection-for-duodenal-ulcer-Oa2JPysa56

References (39)

Publisher
American Medical Association
Copyright
Copyright © 1960 American Medical Association. All Rights Reserved.
ISSN
0004-0010
eISSN
1538-3644
DOI
10.1001/archsurg.1960.01300060055013
Publisher site
See Article on Publisher Site

Abstract

Abstract Gastric surgery for duodenal ulcer began in 1884 when Rydygier, a Polish surgeon, performed a gastroenterostomy for benign obstruction of the stomach. Thereafter, other surgeons in Britain, Europe, and America followed suit, and thus began the surgical treatment of duodenal ulcer. Moynihan in England and W. J. Mayo in this country deserve great credit for making clear the indications for gastroenterostomy and developing the technique of the operation. It was often combined with excision of the ulcer and pyloroplasty, or excision and pyloroplasty only were used. Thus, it came about that during the first quarter of this century, the operation of gastroenterostomy became the most frequently performed gastric operation for duodenal ulcer. In the 1920's, Lorenz and Van Haberer in Europe were among the first to recognize that gastroenterostomy did not prevent hemorrhage and to realize also that ulcer symptoms frequently persisted or recurred, and all too frequently marginal ulcer References 1. Brooks, J. R., and Moore, F. D.: Duodenal Ulcer: The Present Status of Definitive Surgery; the Selection and Management of Patients Undergoing Operation , New England J. Med. 260:1018-1025 ( (May 14) )Crossref 2. 1069-1075 (May 21) 3. 1124-1130 (May 28) 1959. 4. Burdette, W. J., and Fitzpatrick, W. K.: Objective Evaluation of Vagotomy-Antrectomy for Duodenal Ulcer , Ann. Surg. 149:875 ( (June) ) 1959.Crossref 5. Coffey, R. J., and Lazaro, E. J.: Vagotomy, Hemigastrectomy and Gastroduodenostomy (Fin-(Finney-VonHaberer in the Treatment of Duodenal Ulcer , Ann. Surg. 141:862-871, 1955.Crossref 6. Colp, R.: Subtotal Gastrectomy With and Without Vagotomy for Duodenal and Gastrojejunal Ulcer , J.A.M.A. 162:1599-1602 ( (Dec. 29) ) 1956.Crossref 7. Crile, G., Jr.: Postoperative Mortality , A.M.A. Arch. Surg. 77:857-858 ( (Dec.) ) 1958.Crossref 8. Wallensten, S.: Reappraisal: Gastric Resection for Peptic Ulcer , Surgery 41:341-348, 1957. 9. Dragstedt, L. R.; Palmer, W. L.; Schafer, P. W., and Hodges, P. C.: Supradiaphragmatic Section of Vagus Nerves in Treatment of Duodenal and Gastric Ulcers , Gastroenterology 3:450-462, 1952. 10. Druckerman, L. J.; Weinstein, V. A.; Klingenstein, P., and Colp, R.: A Comparative Study of Subtotal Gastrectomy With and Without Infradiaphragmatic Vagotomy in the Surgical Therapy of Duodenal Ulcer , Ann. Surg. 136:211-216 ( (Aug.) ) 1952.Crossref 11. Edwards, L. W., and Herrington, J. L., Jr.: Vagotomy and Gastroenterostomy—Vagotomy and Conservative Gastrectomy , Ann. Surg. 137:873-883, 1953.Crossref 12. Gillespie, M. G.: Surgical Treatment of Peptic Ulcer , Minnesota Med. 27:707-711 ( (Sept.) ) 1944. 13. Harvey, H. D.; St. John, F. B., and Volk, H.: Peptic Ulcer: Late Follow-up Results After Partial Gastrectomy; Analysis of Failures , Ann. Surg. 138:680-688 ( (Nov.) ) 1953.Crossref 14. Hinton, J. W.: The Evaluation of End Results in Physiologic Versus Pathologic Operative Procedures for Chronic Duodenal Ulcer During the Past 2 Decades , Ann. Surg. 132:641-651, 1950.Crossref 15. Hoerr, S. O.: Evaluation of Vagotomy with Gastroenterostomy Performed for Chronic Duodenal Ulcer: Report Based on 5-Year Follow-up of 145 Patients , Surgery 38:149-157, 1955. 16. Horsley, G. W., and Barnes, W. C.: Twenty-five Years Experience with Bilroth I Gastric Resection , Ann. Surg. 145:758-769, 1957.Crossref 17. Johnson, H. D., and Orr, I. M.: Selective Surgery for Peptic Ulcer , Surg. Gynec. & Obst. 98:425-431, 1954. 18. LaBree, R. H., and Gillespie, M. G.: Adequate Subtotal Gastric Resection for Duodenal Ulcer , Arch. Surg. 59:750-757 ( (Sept.) ) 1949. 19. Lahey, F. H., and Marshall, S. I.: Surgical Treatment of Peptic Ulcer , New England J. Med. 246:115-123 ( (Jan. 24) ) 1952. 20. Lewisohn, R.: Changes in Surgical Treatment of Chronic Duodenal Ulcers During Past 50 Years , A.M.A. Arch. Surg. 77:61-74 ( (July) ) 1958. 21. McCaughan, J. J., Jr., and Bowers, R. F.: Favorable Postgastrectomy Results in Billroth II Patients with a Small Stoma , A.M.A. Arch. Surg. 77:837-843 ( (Dec.) ) 1958. 22. McDonald, O. G.; Gillespie, M. G., and LaBree, R. H.: Treatment of Duodenal Ulcer by Subtotal Gastric Resection , A.M.A. Arch. Surg. 67:444-450 ( (Sept.) ) 1953. 23. Milstein, B. B.: The Late Results of Partial Gastrectomy , Ann. Surg. 133:1-17, 1951.Crossref 24. Pallette, E. C., and Harrington, R. W.: Long-Term Results in Surgical Treatment of Peptic Ulcer , J.A.M.A. 168:20-24 ( (Sept. 6) ) 1958.Crossref 25. Palumbo, L. T.; Mazur, T. T., and Doyle, B. J.: Partial Gastrectomy for Duodenal Ulcer or Marginal Ulcer , Ann. Surg. 140:860-866, 1954.Crossref 26. Poth, E. J.: Rational Treatment of Duodenal Ulcer , Surg. Gynec. & Obst. 101:489-493, 1955. 27. Roth, J. L. A.; Becker, I.; Vine, S., and Bockus, H. L.: Results of Subtotal Gastric Resection (Billroth II Type) for Duodenal Ulcer , J.A.M.A. 161:794-800 ( (June 30) ) 1956. 28. Survey Committee, Ohio Chapter, American College of Surgery: Elective Operations Performed for Duodenal Ulcer with Their Mortality , Am. J. Surg. 96:365-368 ( (Sept.) ) 1958. 29. Walters, W.; Gray, H. K.; Priestley, J. T., and Counseller, V. S.: Annual Report on Surgery of the Stomach and Duodenum for 1942 , Proc. Staff Meet. Mayo Clin. 18:505-511 ( (Dec. 29) ) 1943. 30. Walters, W., and Chance, D. P.: Vagotomy as a Prophylactic and Curative Procedure in Peptic Ulcer , J.A.M.A. 153:993-997 ( (Nov. 14) ) 1953. 31. Wangensteen, O. H.: The Ulcer Problem , Canad. M.A.J. 53:309-331 ( (Oct.) ) 1945. 32. Wangensteen, O. H.; Varco, R. L.; Hay, L.; Walpole, S., and Froch, B.: Gastric Acidity Before and After Operative Procedure with Special Reference to the Role of the Pylorus and Antrum , Ann. Surg. 112:626-670, 1940. 33. Walters, W., and Mobley, J. E.: Five-to-10-Year Follow-Up of 162 Cases of Duodenal Ulcer Treated by Vagotomy With and Without Associated Gastric Operations , Ann. Surg. 145: 753-757, 1957. 34. Zollinger, R. M.: Evaluation of the Surgical Treatment of Intractable Duodenal Ulcer , A.M.A. Arch. Int. Med. 102:607-617 ( (Oct.) ) 1958. 35. Zollinger, R. M., and Williams, R. D.: Considerations in Surgical Treatment for Duodenal Ulcer , J.A.M.A. 160:367-373 ( (Feb. 4) ) 1956.

Journal

Archives of SurgeryAmerican Medical Association

Published: Dec 1, 1960

There are no references for this article.