Post-fire response of S235 steel plates considering different bolt hole-making processesAl Chamaa, Fadwa M.; El Ghor, Ahmad; Hantouche, Elie
2024 Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
doi: 10.1108/jsfe-04-2023-0023
This study aims at investigating the effect of bolt hole-making processes on the post-fire behavior of S235 steel plates.Design/methodology/approachA total of nine steel plates with a single bolt hole are tested. The single bolt holes are fabricated using three different hole-making processes: drilling, waterjet and plasma. Among the nine steel plates, three fabricated specimens are control specimens and are tested at ambient temperature. The six remaining steel plates with a single bolt hole are subjected to a complete heating-cooling cycle and then monotonically loaded until failure. The six fabricated specimens are first heated up to two different temperatures 800 and 925 °C, and then cooled back to the ambient prior to loading.FindingsThe results show that after being exposed to post-fire temperatures (800 and 925 °C), the maximum decrease in strength of the S235 steel plate was 6% (at 925 °C), 14% (at 925 °C) and 22% (at 800 °C) when compared to the results of ambient specimens for waterjet, drilled and plasma bolt holes, respectively. For post-fire temperature tests, drilled and waterjet bolt hole-making processes result in having approximately the same load-displacement response, and both have larger strength and ductility than those obtained using plasma cutting.Originality/valueThis study provides preliminary data to guide the steel designers and fabricators in choosing the most suitable hole-making process for fire applications and to quantify the post-fire reduction in capacity of S235 plates.
Behavior of Zn5Al hot-dip galvanized steel members under fire exposurePinger, Thomas; Firan, Mirabela; Mensinger, Martin
2024 Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
doi: 10.1108/jsfe-11-2023-0042
Based on the known positive effects of conventional hot-dip galvanizing under fire exposure and indicative results on zinc–aluminum coatings from smallscale tests, a series of tests were conducted on zinc-5% aluminum galvanized test specimens under fire loads to verify the previous positive findings under largescale boundary conditions.Design/methodology/approachThe emissivity of zinc-5% aluminum galvanized surfaces applied to steel specimens was determined experimentally under real fire loads and laboratory thermal loads in accordance with the normative specifications of the standard fire curve. Both large and smallscale specimens were used in this study. The steel grade and surface conditions of the specimens were varied for both test scenarios.FindingsLargescale tests on specimens with typical steel construction dimensions under fire loads showed that the surface emissivity of zinc-5% aluminum galvanized steel was significantly lower than that of the conventionally galvanized steel. Only minor influences from the weathering of the specimens and steel chemistry were observed. These results agree well with those obtained from smallscale tests. The design values of zinc-5% aluminum melt (Zn5Al) required for the structural fire design were proposed based on the obtained results.Originality/valueThe novel tests presented in this study are the first ones to study the behavior of zinc-5% aluminum galvanized largescale steel construction components under the influence of real fire exposure and their positive effect on the emissivity of steel components galvanized by this method. The results provide valuable insights and information on the behavior in the case of fire and the associated savings potential for steel construction.
Modelling intumescent coatings for the fire protection of structural systems: a reviewLucherini, Andrea; de Silva, Donatella
2024 Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
doi: 10.1108/jsfe-10-2023-0038
Intumescent coatings are nowadays a dominant passive system used to protect structural materials in case of fire. Due to their reactive swelling behaviour, intumescent coatings are particularly complex materials to be modelled and predicted, which can be extremely useful especially for performance-based fire safety designs. In addition, many parameters influence their performance, and this challenges the definition and quantification of their material properties. Several approaches and models of various complexities are proposed in the literature, and they are reviewed and analysed in a critical literature review.Design/methodology/approachAnalytical, finite-difference and finite-element methods for modelling intumescent coatings are compared, followed by the definition and quantification of the main physical, thermal, and optical properties of intumescent coatings: swelled thickness, thermal conductivity and resistance, density, specific heat capacity, and emissivity/absorptivity.FindingsThe study highlights the scarce consideration of key influencing factors on the material properties, and the tendency to simplify the problem into effective thermo-physical properties, such as effective thermal conductivity. As a conclusion, the literature review underlines the lack of homogenisation of modelling approaches and material properties, as well as the need for a universal modelling method that can generally simulate the performance of intumescent coatings, combine the large amount of published experimental data, and reliably produce fire-safe performance-based designs.Research limitations/implicationsDue to their limited applicability, high complexity and little comparability, the presented literature review does not focus on analysing and comparing different multi-component models, constituted of many model-specific input parameters. On the contrary, the presented literature review compares various approaches, models and thermo-physical properties which primarily focusses on solving the heat transfer problem through swelling intumescent systems.Originality/valueThe presented literature review analyses and discusses the various modelling approaches to describe and predict the behaviour of swelling intumescent coatings as fire protection for structural materials. Due to the vast variety of available commercial products and potential testing conditions, these data are rarely compared and combined to achieve an overall understanding on the response of intumescent coatings as fire protection measure. The study highlights the lack of information and homogenisation of various modelling approaches, and it underlines the research needs about several aspects related to the intumescent coating behaviour modelling, also providing some useful suggestions for future studies.
Post-earthquake fire performance of the gusset plate moment connectionKetabdari, Hesam; Saedi Daryan, Amir; Hassani, Nemat; Safi, Mohammad
2024 Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
doi: 10.1108/jsfe-08-2023-0031
In this paper, the seismic behavior of the gusset plate moment connection (GPMC) exposed to the post-earthquake fire (PEF) is investigated.Design/methodology/approachFor this purpose, for the sake of verification, first, a numerical model is built using ABAQUS software and then exposed to earthquakes and high temperatures. Afterward, the effects of a series of parameters, such as gusset plate thickness, gap width, steel grade, vertical load value and presence of the stiffeners, are evaluated on the behavior of the connection in the PEF conditions.FindingsBased on the results obtained from the parametric study, all parameters effectively played a role against the seismic loads, although, when exposed to fire, it was found that the vertical load value and presence of the stiffener revealed a great contribution and the other parameters could not significantly affect the connection performance. Finally, to develop the modeling and further study the performance of the connection, the 4 and 8-story frames are subjected to 11 accelerograms and 3 different fire scenarios. The findings demonstrate that high temperatures impose rotations on the structure, such that the story drifts were changed compared to the post-earthquake drift values.Originality/valueThe obtained results can be used by engineers to design the GPMC for the combined action of earthquake and fire.
The effects of pre-loading on structural behavior of reinforced concrete beams under fire condition: a reviewSuhaimi, Aminuddin; Ibrahim, Izni Syahrizal; Ab Kadir, Mariyana Aida
2024 Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
doi: 10.1108/jsfe-11-2023-0041
This review paper seeks to enhance knowledge of how pre-loading affects reinforced concrete (RC) beams under fire. It investigates key factors like deflection and load capacity to understand pre-loading's role in replicating RC beams' actual responses to fire, aiming to improve fire testing protocols and structural fire engineering design.Design/methodology/approachThis review systematically aggregates data from existing literature on the fire response of RC beams, comparing scenarios with (WP) and without pre-loading (WOP). Through statistical tools like the two-tailed t-test and Mann–Whitney U-test, it assesses deflection extremes. The study further examines structural responses, including flexural and shear behavior, ultimate load capacity, post-yield behavior, stiffness degradation and failure modes. The approach concludes with a statistical forecast of ideal pre-load levels to elevate experimental precision and enhance fire safety standards.FindingsThe review concludes that pre-loading profoundly affects the fire response of RC beams, suggesting a 35%–65% structural capacity range for realistic simulations. The review also recommended the initial crack load as an alternative metric for determining the pre-loading impact. Crucially, it highlights that pre-loading not only influences the fire response but also significantly alters the overall structural behavior of the RC beams.Originality/valueThe review advances structural fire engineering with an in-depth analysis of pre-loading's impact on RC beams during fire exposure, establishing a validated pre-load range through thorough statistical analysis and examination of previous research. It refines experimental methodologies and structural design accuracy, ultimately bolstering fire safety protocols.
Numerical analysis of fire-exposed reinforced concrete sections for assessing post-heating axial and flexural capacityGaikwad, Mahesh; Singh, Suvir; Gopalakrishnan, N.; Bhargava, Pradeep; Chourasia, Ajay
2024 Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
doi: 10.1108/jsfe-10-2023-0039
This study investigates the impact of the fire decay phase on structural damage using the sectional analysis method. The primary objective of this work is to forecast the non-dimensional capacity parameters for the axial and flexural load-carrying capacity of reinforced concrete (RC) sections for heating and the subsequent post-heating phase (decay phase) of the fire.Design/methodology/approachThe sectional analysis method is used to determine the moment and axial capacities. The findings of sectional analysis and heat transfer for the heating stage are initially validated, and the analysis subsequently proceeds to determine the load capacity during the fire’s heating and decay phases by appropriately incorporating non-dimensional sectional and material parameters. The numerical analysis includes four fire curves with different cooling rates and steel percentages.FindingsThe study’s findings indicate that the rate at which the cooling process occurs after undergoing heating substantially impacts the axial and flexural capacity. The maximum degradation in axial and flexural capacity occurred in the range of 15–20% for cooling rates of 3 °C/min and 5 °C/min as compared to the capacity obtained at 120 min of heating for all steel percentages. As the fire cooling rate reduced to 1 °C/min, the highest deterioration in axial and flexural capacity reached 48–50% and 42–46%, respectively, in the post-heating stage.Research limitations/implicationsThe established non-dimensional parameters for axial and flexural capacity are limited to the analysed section in the study owing to the thermal profile, however, this can be modified depending on the section geometry and fire scenario.Practical implicationsThe study primarily focusses on the degradation of axial and flexural capacity at various time intervals during the entire fire exposure, including heating and cooling. The findings obtained showed that following the completion of the fire’s heating phase, the structural capacity continued to decrease over the subsequent post-heating period. It is recommended that structural members' fire resistance designs encompass both the heating and cooling phases of a fire. Since the capacity degradation varies with fire duration, the conventional method is inadequate to design the load capacity for appropriate fire safety. Therefore, it is essential to adopt a performance-based approach while designing structural elements' capacity for the desired fire resistance rating. The proposed technique of using non-dimensional parameters will effectively support predicting the load capacity for required fire resistance.Originality/valueThe fire-resistant requirements for reinforced concrete structures are generally established based on standard fire exposure conditions, which account for the fire growth phase. However, it is important to note that concrete structures can experience internal damage over time during the decay phase of fires, which can be quantitatively determined using the proposed non-dimensional parameter approach.
Impact of the variability of material constitutive models on the thermal response of reinforced concrete wallsKaraki, Ghada; Hawileh, Rami A.; Naser, M.Z.
2024 Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
doi: 10.1108/jsfe-06-2023-0027
This study examines the effect of temperature-dependent material models for normal-strength (NSC) and high-strength concrete (HSC) on the thermal analysis of reinforced concrete (RC) walls.Design/methodology/approachThe study performs an one-at-a-time (OAT) sensitivity analysis to assess the impact of variables defining the constitutive and parametric fire models on the wall's thermal response. Moreover, it extends the sensitivity analysis to a variance-based analysis to assess the effect of constitutive model type, fire model type and constitutive model uncertainty on the RC wall's thermal response variance. The study determines the wall’s thermal behaviour reliability considering the different constitutive models and their uncertainty.FindingsIt is found that the impact of the variability in concrete’s conductivity is determined by its temperature-dependent model, which differs for NSC and HSC. Therefore, more testing and improving material modelling are needed. Furthermore, the heating rate of the fire scenario is the dominant factor in deciding fire-resistance performance because it is a causal factor for spalling in HSC walls. And finally the reliability of wall's performance decreased sharply for HSC walls due to the expected spalling of the concrete and loss of cross-section integrity.Originality/valueLimited studies in the current open literature quantified the impact of constitutive models on the behaviour of RC walls. No studies have examined the effect of material models' uncertainty on wall’s response reliability under fire. Furthermore, the study's results contribute to the ongoing attempts to shape performance-based structural fire engineering.
Estimating the elastic modulus of concrete under moderately elevated temperatures via impulse excitation techniqueCoelho, Tulio; Diniz, Sofia Maria Carrato; Rodrigues, Francisco
2024 Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
doi: 10.1108/jsfe-02-2024-0004
To evaluate the temperature-dependency of the Young’s and shear moduli of concrete after exposure to moderately elevated temperatures using the non-destructive impulse excitation technique (IET).Design/methodology/approachThe study involved heating the concrete up to 225 °C and measuring the dynamic Young’s and shear moduli using the non-destructive technique of impulse excitation, which measures the natural vibration frequency from a mechanical impulse received by an acoustic sensor. The effects of temperature on the dynamic Young’s and shear moduli were analysed and the importance of the spatial variability of the measured values was also verified.FindingsThe study found that even moderately elevated temperatures (below 225 °C) resulted in a significant permanent reduction in the Young’s modulus of concrete (reduction in the range of 23%–36% for the maximum temperature considered in this research) as well as a modest and permanent reduction in the shear modulus of around 6%. It was also observed that spatial variability of the mechanical properties of concrete plays an important role in the measured values; higher dispersion of the results was found for the values of the Young’s and shear moduli of concrete measured along the height of the beam. The non-destructive test method used in this study was found to be extremely useful in the investigation of heat-related damage in concrete structures for its ease of use, low time consumption and accuracy. The results were consistent with the published literature.Originality/valueThis study provides important insights into the temperature-dependent behaviour of the dynamic Young’s and shear moduli of concrete and highlights the significance of proper consideration of the spatial variability of the measured values. The use of a non-destructive test method for continuous acoustic testing during heating and cooling proved to be effective, and the findings contribute to the fields of materials science and civil engineering in understanding the effects of elevated temperatures on concrete properties. The findings confirm that IET can be easily used to gather important information in the condition assessment and rehabilitation of concrete structures after a fire event. Further studies to foster the application of this technique to real structures are suggested.
Combined effects of corrosion and fire on load-carrying response of hot-rolled steel reinforcementTariq, Faraz
2024 Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
doi: 10.1108/jsfe-09-2023-0034
Although separate studies on the influence of corrosion and fire exposure on the constitutive relationship of concrete and steel have been done, there is still a gap in knowledge on the influence of corrosion-temperature superimposition as nonlinear phenomenon. The current study is focused to investigate the response of hot-rolled steel bars subjected to corrosion-temperature superimposition.Design/methodology/approachUsing the accelerated corrosion-impressed-current technique, hot-rolled specimens with different levels of corrosion were obtained. The hot-rolled rebars were first corroded to target levels such as (6, 12, 18, 24, 30 and 36%) and subsequently subjected to target temperatures (250 °C, 400 °C, 550 °C, 800 °C and 950 °C), before tensile tests were carried out to evaluate the residual mechanical response.FindingsThe outcomes showed a significant decline in the parameters governing the mechanical properties of steel reinforcement due to the combined damage due to corrosion and fire. Corroded reinforcement still showed ductile failure after exposure to fire. Moreover, the combined loss of load-bearing characteristics due to corrosion and fire has little influence on the modulus of elasticity. The outcomes of this investigation provide a theoretical database for the assessment of aged structural elements exposed to combination after exposure to fire.Originality/valueThe information concerning structural material's response to corrosion-temperature combined damage is still limited. The cover of the reinforcement is designed to safeguard the reinforcing bars from foreign agencies but is often damaged and spalled off due to corrosion, rendering the reinforcing bars directly exposed. The study aims at the experimental production of fire conditions in a corrosion-damaged infrastructure to cover the aforementioned research gap. The effects of corrosion being superimposed by exposure to elevated temperatures on key parameters affecting mechanical behavior were examined.HighlightsInfluence of corrosion-temperature superimposition on the mechanical properties of hot-rolled rebars.Influence of corrosion-temperature superimposition on the macro and microstructure properties of hot-rolled rebars.Influence of corrosion-temperature superimposition on stress-strain curves of hot-rolled rebars.Influence of corrosion-temperature superimposition on tensile strength, modulus of elasticity and elongation of hot-rolled rebars.