doi: 10.1093/eurheartj/ehac554pmid: 36254664
All correspondence relating to this article should be sent to [email protected] If you enjoyed a post-pandemic summer holiday during 2022, you may have become concerned by the intensity of the heatwave and the extreme temperatures across Europe. Those working in the health sector may have registered excessive numbers of patients seeking treatment for cardiovascular and respiratory ailments exacerbated by the hot weather. One physician who believes that the risk of environmental factors to our health is vastly under-stated is cardiologist Thomas Münzel MD, Chief of the Department of Cardiology at the University Medical Centre, Johannes Gutenberg University in Mainz, Germany. Prof. Münzel and his team have been focusing on environmental risk factors for cardiovascular disease (CVD) since 2011, initially in relation to aircraft noise and air pollution, and more recently in relation to excessive temperatures. With rising temperatures set to continue due to climate change, Prof. Münzel believes the threat of environmental factors on heart health is bigger than previously thought and needs to be highlighted. Over a series of articles in CardioPulse, he will explore the impact of rising temperatures on cardiovascular health and look at some possible solutions or mitigating actions (Figure 1). Figure 1 Open in new tabDownload slide Prof. Dr. Thomas Münzel. Prof. Münzel has showed how air pollution is much more dangerous than anticipated for health and currently surpasses tobacco smoking as a hazard for CVD. He also found that noise is a major risk factor as it stimulates stress in the brain, activates the sympathetic nervous system, and may trigger major adverse cardiovascular events. Concern about the effects of heatwaves and rising temperatures builds on this earlier work and shows how exceptionally hot weather and the issues that accompany it, exacerbates the problems. He says: ‘I’ve previously worked on the impact of noise and demonstrated how many deaths occur due to atmospheric pollution, but it’s not about one single factor, you often have a co-exposure of noise and air pollution, much of it traffic-related, and accompanying heat extremes.’ A heatwave is defined as an extended period of weather which exceeds expected conditions in a particular area relative to the time of year and persists for days or possibly weeks. The 2003 heatwave was memorable in Europe for its effects in London and Paris in particular. It is estimated to have caused in excess of 70 000 deaths across Europe. More recently, in 2022, the countries worst hit by the heatwave included the United Kingdom where temperatures of 40.2°C were recorded and Spain where the country’s Ministry of Health reported that 679 people had lost their lives in the first eight days (July 10–17) of the heatwave. Spain experienced two similarly severe heatwave events this year and in Portugal, dangerous forest fires broke out endangering life and adding to atmospheric pollution. Much of Southern Europe experienced extreme heat which scientists say is a result of the world’s changing climate. The effects of excess heat on the human body and the implications for cardiovascular health are many. Direct impacts include the following: dehydration, heat cramps, and heatstroke, resulting in fatalities attributable to respiratory, cardiovascular, or other chronic diseases. Indirect impacts include the transmission of water and food borne diseases, contamination of water supplies and in some cases damage to infrastructure through drought or wildfires. Heatwaves also put a strain on hospitals and health services. Physiological heat stress responses are necessary to limit a rise in core temperature and can affect people differently based on pre-existing medical conditions. Increased blood flow to the skin increases cardiac demand while decreasing the heart’s filling pressure. The heart is required to pump harder and faster, increasing oxygen demand. For people with pre-existing heart conditions, this response can lead to a mismatch between a high cardiac oxygen demand and a compromised cardiac oxygen delivery, resulting in cardiac ischaemia, infarction, and ultimately, cardiovascular collapse. Elevated cardiovascular strain from heat stress is a primary health concern during heat extremes for older adults in particular. All-cause cardiovascular illness is the primary cause of death during heatwaves, and as almost half a billion people are estimated to have CVD globally, any densely populated area affected by heat extremes will be at risk for increased cardiovascular-related mortality (Figure 2). Figure 2 Open in new tabDownload slide Burning fossil fuels contributes to air pollution. Whilst he is a cardiologist and not a climate change specialist, Prof. Münzel has taken up the challenge of raising awareness of the implications of heatwaves and rising temperatures amongst his colleagues and peers. He warns that the crisis is happening now, and action needs to be taken immediately. He says: ‘This year we’ve all seen how desert storms from the Sahara brought sand and dust from Africa to the Alps which covered the mountain range and caused the ice to melt and the temperature to rise. We also know that these desert storms are killing half a million people a year, adding to air pollution, and amplifying heatwaves. Many people with CVD are already greatly in danger because of increased heat and we will see more deaths amongst these patients from myocardial infarction and stroke.’ While environmental threats to health are well-documented, solutions are complex. Prof. Münzel says: ‘The problem lies with fossil fuel burning like oil, coal and gas and of course car emissions. If we stopped using them, it would both significantly decrease the temperature and pollution but that’s currently not straightforward or realistic. The problem is that people are dying at a rate of 5 million per year due to excess heat. Air pollution is killing around 8 million people each year.’ Importantly, most of the excess deaths are due to ischaemic heart disease and stroke but also caused by diabetes and arterial hypertension. These figures he points out are bigger than deaths caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. A study published in the Lancet showed that a mere 1°C increase in temperature was associated with CVD-related mortality across all considered diagnoses.1 The overall risk of CVD-related mortality increased by 2.1% specifically related to stroke and coronary heart disease. A 1°C, temperature rise was also associated with a significant increase in morbidity due to arrhythmias, cardiac arrest, and coronary heart disease. These findings strengthen the evidence that the rise in hot temperatures, in conjunction with an increase of older people in the population, may result in a significant rise in CVD. The Lancet review concluded that prevention measures are needed to lower the worldwide threat of the heat-related burden of CVD-related morbidity and death. The issue of air pollution which national governments worldwide are continuing to struggle with, is an important consideration in the heat debate. The World Health Organization has outlined how air pollution threatens health and contributes to millions of deaths a year. Excess heat and heatwaves add to pollution by increasing pollutants and their toxicity, as well as creating a stagnant layer of air above the ground. This increases emissions as people use air conditioning in cars and buildings, furthermore wild fires triggered by dry weather can add to pollution and contribute to a vicious circle. Sun and heat transform—and worsen—air pollution due to chemical reactions that cause ozone. Heatwaves and poor air quality often go hand-in-hand because lingering high pressure creates a stagnant environment, and a lack of rain means that pollutants remain in the air. By any standards, Prof. Münzel says, it all adds up to a major public health concern, the causes of which are beyond our prevention. ‘It’s too late to stop the sort of environmental damage that is causing some of these problems but not perhaps to mitigate some of the worst effects on cardiovascular health.’ Although solutions are complex and demanding, there is a lot of interest in this area which Prof. Münzel hopes can be translated into positive and immediate action. Some of the ways forward will be explored in a future article. Reference 1 Zhao Q , Guo Y, Ye T, Gasparrini A, Tong S, Overcenco A, et al. Global, regional, and national burden of mortality associated with non-optimal ambient temperatures from 2000 to 2019: a three-stage modelling study . Lancet Planet Health 2021 ; 5 : e415 – e425 . Google Scholar Crossref Search ADS PubMed WorldCat Author notes Conflict of interest: None declared. © The Author(s) 2022. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the European Society of Cardiology. All rights reserved. For permissions, please e-mail: [email protected] This article is published and distributed under the terms of the Oxford University Press, Standard Journals Publication Model (https://academic.oup.com/journals/pages/open_access/funder_policies/chorus/standard_publication_model) © The Author(s) 2022. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the European Society of Cardiology. All rights reserved. For permissions, please e-mail: [email protected]